Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if my GP gets paid for this?

132 replies

namechanger563 · 08/07/2023 14:11

I've received a text from my GP practice asking for my up to date height and weight measurements. Just to keep my record up to date it says.

I'm sure I read a few years ago the GP's get paid for every patient they do a height/weight check with. Is this still the case?

So is this text just a money making exercise or are they actually going to help anyone?

OP posts:
Sidge · 08/07/2023 21:32

@millymog11 you’re demonstrating that you really have no clue about primary care funding, patient registrations or NHS contract agreements. I’d stop posting now if I were you.

Flossiemoss · 08/07/2023 21:20

Alerts can be put on notes. The vast majority of people do not have an eating disorder. weight is an important piece of information for the vast majority of peoples healthcare.

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 20:40

Flossiemoss · 08/07/2023 20:27

This thread is like an argument to charge for healthcare. The amount of people who are outraged at being asked to engage with their own health never ceases to amaze . No wonder the nhs is struggling.

Asking some people with a history of EDs to weigh themselves without a good reason can be a risk to their health. There are risks and benefits to most things. I'm here and healthy today because I took responsibility for my own health. If more than a ballpark weight was genuinely needed I would access scales and provide it that day.

millymog11 · 08/07/2023 20:33

"We don’t get paid more for sending them messages. "
No, but sending them text messages is enough for them still to be "registered" patients in the eyes of the NHS and is enough to wade into any argument should the patient, in their absolute desperation (and in some cases fear for their life) try to change GP surgeries to actually get seen.

And don't tell me this elderly man should have gone and sat in A&E for hours and hours just to be criticised for not going to their GP.....

GP partnerships (because that is exactly what they are, private partnerships where key decisions are made by the GPs who are named as and are party to the partnership agreement of the practice) and are essentially private businesses run by the partners with very little more oversight than a commercial partnership in business out there. You yourself have cited the cost of keeping the lights on and the cost of employing a cleaner as an overhead which the GP partners have to worry themselves about.

If I ran a business and could continue to get guaranteed government funding by sending a book of contacts text messages I would be quite chuffed.

Flossiemoss · 08/07/2023 20:27

Endofroadinhs · 08/07/2023 18:39

@namechanger563 And this attitude is exactly why the NHS is struggling, people literally cannot be arsed and don’t think its their responsibility to provide very basic information which 95% have easy access to, and which will allow them to identify people who actually need to be seen. For god’s sakes try to work WITH your healthcare provider not find reasons to pick holes in them.

This thread is like an argument to charge for healthcare. The amount of people who are outraged at being asked to engage with their own health never ceases to amaze . No wonder the nhs is struggling.

FarmGirl78 · 08/07/2023 20:21

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/07/2023 19:35

Who doesn't have their own scales FFS? You can get a set for less than a tenner.

What a lame excuse to not weigh yourself.

@namechanger563 So what if the GP is requesting your weight? Confused I give them mine every few months, and blood pressure readings from the blood pressure monitor I got from Boots for £20.

I don't have my own scales. That's not an excuse to not give anyone my weight. I just don't have any. I don't want any to keep tripping over in my bathroom.

Most of the Patients I see are in their 80s and 90s. Plenty little old dears don't have scales. They don't have relatives living close by who can lend them theirs. They'd be too heavy to carry home from the shops. Some wouldn't have the mobility to stand upright independently while the weight registers. There's lots of reasons people need a face to face appointment so we can weight them. They aren't necessarily making excuses or trying to get out of it, they just need face to face.

MostlyBlueberryFlavoured · 08/07/2023 20:18

namechanger563 · 08/07/2023 20:03

I'm not happy about the surgery getting an extra payment per patient whose record they update with height/weight info. It's an automated link. No one is going to review this info and it will play no part in improving healthcare or outcomes for patients. Meanwhile, my DH has been unable to get a f2f since Covid. He has a recurring condition that they have neglected to treat, wasted weeks between raising requests online before email consultations that have been completely infective. He now faces surgery to remove necrotic tissue and infected bone that will leave him with hearing loss and significant facial scaring because of their lazy online diagnosis.

They get paid per patient and that should include keeping key data up to date. This shouldn't be an incentivised 'extra' piece of work they (the practice/group) get paid for.

Well, I'm sure your little tantrum will bring about major changes to the GP commissioning system 🙄.

Samaritans999 · 08/07/2023 20:18

namechanger563 · 08/07/2023 20:03

I'm not happy about the surgery getting an extra payment per patient whose record they update with height/weight info. It's an automated link. No one is going to review this info and it will play no part in improving healthcare or outcomes for patients. Meanwhile, my DH has been unable to get a f2f since Covid. He has a recurring condition that they have neglected to treat, wasted weeks between raising requests online before email consultations that have been completely infective. He now faces surgery to remove necrotic tissue and infected bone that will leave him with hearing loss and significant facial scaring because of their lazy online diagnosis.

They get paid per patient and that should include keeping key data up to date. This shouldn't be an incentivised 'extra' piece of work they (the practice/group) get paid for.

GP surgeries are private enterprises, they can charge what they like for their services.

Sidge · 08/07/2023 20:14

Its very obvious that the qualification for someone being "practices are paid on the basis of the number of patients on their list" could literally be increased by the number of people who have been automated contacted by what Sidge · Today 18:12 describes namely

umm no. They are paid an amount per person registered with them, whether we see them, or contact them or otherwise. We don’t get paid more for sending them messages. We do get paid more for providing services above and beyond the basic contract.

@millymog11 a practice gets paid something like £120 per annum for providing all care to a patient regardless of the amount of care they receive. They’re not going to be personally interested in losing an elderly (I.e. expensive in terms of care provided) patient to another surgery. (But of course that surgery sounds crap and should have seen that person).

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/07/2023 20:11

@namechanger563 Why do you think the GPs get paid for asking for your weight? First I have heard of this! Confused

millymog11 · 08/07/2023 20:05

"NHS England is responsible for paying GP Practices for their services. GP practices are paid on the basis of the number of patients on their list. This is obtained from the registered patient list held by NHS Digital on behalf of NHS England."
(taken from NHS England).

cptartapp · Today 18:15
"The 'GP's' don't get paid for it no. It goes in the practice pot to put the lights on and pay the staff from the cleaner upwards.
Don't cooperate by all means, but then don't complain when service provision doesn't meet your needs.
In an ideal word external reporting wouldn't be first choice, but desperate times...."

So, as GP practices are partnerships and not part of the NHS in the same way that hospitals are, they have autonomy on multiple key decisions which affect patients (eg where there surgeries are, how quickly you get an appointment if at all, the general availability of qualified doctors and the ease with which to be referred to a consultant eg for cancer (is the most recent example I have seen, and whether this money goes to keeping the lights on or whether it goes to the GP's salary.

Its very obvious that the qualification for someone being "practices are paid on the basis of the number of patients on their list" could literally be increased by the number of people who have been automated contacted by what Sidge · Today 18:12 describes namely
" large scale messages to either provide or request information. Eg smoking status, height and weight, let you know you can now book a flu jab, that your prescription has been done or your asthma review is due."

You have received a text via the above you are a patient on their books the funding flows through from the government. Its very slick. The fact that you might actually have a life limiting condition/disease/illness and actually need to see someone in person does not matter, you are on their books so that is enough.
This is why a recent example I came across happened. An elderly person I know who really really needed to see a GP as you describe could not get an appointment. They left it and left it because to get an in person appointment would have required the kind of tenacity I would expect to see from someone far younger. Eventually one of their younger relatives who had also tried to get them an in person appointment lost their rag and filled out forms to move this elderly patient to another surgery which happened to be over the border of the NHS trust boundary so the new GP surgery came under a different NHS trust and therefore different funding.
Only then was there any kind of notice taken, the original GP surgery got very shirtly and angry with the elderly patient for actually trying to do this because (i) I imagine it flagged up their statistics somewhere and, more importantly (ii) losing patients to another surgery hit their bottom line and they did not want to lose the money.
The man died shortly after of advanced cancer which might have been caught had he actually got an in person appointment when he first started complaining of symptoms.

And no this was not a social worker/care in the community case, he had relatives and neighbours who all tried to get in person appointments for him.

Its about the money and the money is assured if you are "on the books" i.e. you have received a text from the GP surgery.

By the way, on a personal level incase there is any doubt, of course I update all of my own information via patient access (there are other similar platforms used by various GP partnerships I understand, another decision they make on a practice by practice basis) and I always have done, healthcare and in particular GP surgeries are like high street banks in 2023, they are all shut and unless you are prepared to and able to run your life via a computer screen including anything to do with your physical body, then tough.

namechanger563 · 08/07/2023 20:03

I'm not happy about the surgery getting an extra payment per patient whose record they update with height/weight info. It's an automated link. No one is going to review this info and it will play no part in improving healthcare or outcomes for patients. Meanwhile, my DH has been unable to get a f2f since Covid. He has a recurring condition that they have neglected to treat, wasted weeks between raising requests online before email consultations that have been completely infective. He now faces surgery to remove necrotic tissue and infected bone that will leave him with hearing loss and significant facial scaring because of their lazy online diagnosis.

They get paid per patient and that should include keeping key data up to date. This shouldn't be an incentivised 'extra' piece of work they (the practice/group) get paid for.

OP posts:
LadyWithLapdog · 08/07/2023 19:55

I suspect people dutifully give their weight and height to a private insurance company and don’t see the irony in that.

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 19:38

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/07/2023 19:35

Who doesn't have their own scales FFS? You can get a set for less than a tenner.

What a lame excuse to not weigh yourself.

@namechanger563 So what if the GP is requesting your weight? Confused I give them mine every few months, and blood pressure readings from the blood pressure monitor I got from Boots for £20.

I purposely do not own any due to a history of AN.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/07/2023 19:35

FarmGirl78 · 08/07/2023 19:00

Because not all patients have their own scales. A lot lose weight if they're ill and have no idea how much they now weight.

It depends what exactly we need the weight for, but if the Patient says they haven't noticably changed weight recently then we'll usually accept a weight less than 3 months ago. Depending on the weight we might accept a few months longer (because a ballpark figure is enough if a Patient is nowhere near borderline weight). Some Patients don't have ANY weight recorded.

Who doesn't have their own scales FFS? You can get a set for less than a tenner.

What a lame excuse to not weigh yourself.

@namechanger563 So what if the GP is requesting your weight? Confused I give them mine every few months, and blood pressure readings from the blood pressure monitor I got from Boots for £20.

Sidge · 08/07/2023 19:20

Oh and now our local hospital won’t accept any referrals without a BMI. For ANY department. So be prepared for a height and weight check if you need a secondary care referral in some areas.

FarmGirl78 · 08/07/2023 19:00

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 18:54

@FarmGirl78
Why a f2f appointment? Why can't the patient let you know a weight over the phone when it's needed? How recent a weight do you need? Some people's weight could change in only a few months so it may need updating regardless.

Because not all patients have their own scales. A lot lose weight if they're ill and have no idea how much they now weight.

It depends what exactly we need the weight for, but if the Patient says they haven't noticably changed weight recently then we'll usually accept a weight less than 3 months ago. Depending on the weight we might accept a few months longer (because a ballpark figure is enough if a Patient is nowhere near borderline weight). Some Patients don't have ANY weight recorded.

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 18:54

@FarmGirl78
Why a f2f appointment? Why can't the patient let you know a weight over the phone when it's needed? How recent a weight do you need? Some people's weight could change in only a few months so it may need updating regardless.

FarmGirl78 · 08/07/2023 18:49

They don't get paid as such, and it's definitely not that the GP gets an extra chunk in his wage packet. At the very most it'll be that the surgery gets extra funding (for health promotion, extra staff etc) if they have more patients on their books who are obese, health risk, heart disease etc.

There are also many drugs which are weight or formula based, and calculated using height/weight etc so it's always very useful to have that up to date in your records. Very useful. I work in the community (not a surgery though) and we often have to check a surgeries records for an to date to calculate new prescriptions. If we don't have a weight its delays things until we can get the Patient in for a face to face appt.

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 18:47

MostlyBlueberryFlavoured · 08/07/2023 18:39

Deregister from your surgery, then.

Why should a person do this? I know when my weight is a concern, even without knowing the numbers (thing called a mirror) so I could book an appointment if I wanted help. If I needed to know my exact weight rather than a ballpark figure for a medication then I would find a scale, it's about balancing the risks!

Schlomp · 08/07/2023 18:42

MostlyBlueberryFlavoured · 08/07/2023 18:39

Deregister from your surgery, then.

I dont need to, thanks. I have a decent gp who has a very good understanding of all the complexities of EDs

MumblesParty · 08/07/2023 18:41

GP surgeries are required to collect data and offer health and chronic disease checks, and this attracts some NHS funding. These checks are usually coordinated by nurses and/or health care assistants. It may surprise people to learn that these people are PAID. Yes, believe it or not, staff working in GP surgeries get a wage. These wages are paid out of the money that GP surgeries get, and health checks are a part of this money. It does not, I repeat, does NOT go into the GP’s pocket. It baffles me that people think it does.

Endofroadinhs · 08/07/2023 18:39

@namechanger563 And this attitude is exactly why the NHS is struggling, people literally cannot be arsed and don’t think its their responsibility to provide very basic information which 95% have easy access to, and which will allow them to identify people who actually need to be seen. For god’s sakes try to work WITH your healthcare provider not find reasons to pick holes in them.

MostlyBlueberryFlavoured · 08/07/2023 18:39

Schlomp · 08/07/2023 18:14

This is a very ignorant viewpoint. Regular weighing is detrimental to those of us who have, or have had an eating disorder and could likely end up with us needing more medical intervention ultimately

Deregister from your surgery, then.

LadyWithLapdog · 08/07/2023 18:36

MumblesParty · 08/07/2023 18:30

Well they may have a machine in the waiting room, or you could go to a chemist. Or you could just not bother. It’s your life. The GP won’t lose any sleep if you’re walking around with high blood pressure.

Exactly. Cut your nose to spite your face. That’ll teach those GPs.