Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if my GP gets paid for this?

132 replies

namechanger563 · 08/07/2023 14:11

I've received a text from my GP practice asking for my up to date height and weight measurements. Just to keep my record up to date it says.

I'm sure I read a few years ago the GP's get paid for every patient they do a height/weight check with. Is this still the case?

So is this text just a money making exercise or are they actually going to help anyone?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mindyoursoul · 09/08/2023 08:05

They will be asking to see if you qualify to be referred for NHS digital weight management scheme which does come with extras reimbursements for GP practices. Trust me they don’t have time to be calling patients to update their records just for the hell of it. BMI is also required for MSK referrals now so if you recently had one you would be asked.

EmeraldFox · 15/07/2023 07:47

I bought a battery so now I have working scales. 9st 1, no shock or surprise, I knew I was about 9st without having weighed myself for almost a year. But now I'm thinking 8st 13 would be better. Guess I should call my surgery now and give them this very important information that I am right in the middle of the healthy weight range, seeing as they have been so concerned about my record saying 7st for the past three and a half years 🙄 .

birdsongismyfave · 10/07/2023 07:01

Seeline · 08/07/2023 15:15

Mine keeps texting me, asking me to supply my blood pressure! How the heck am I supposed to know that if they don't!

Some people have a blood pressure machine at home, or there's one in some GP waiting rooms. If you don't know it you don't know it though.

JackRosenberg · 09/07/2023 19:01

I've never owned a set of scales. I know what my dress size is, I know I'm slim and whenever I have been weighed over the years at smear tests etc it has confirmed what I can see, that my weight doesn't fluctuate much. Not owning scales, for me, has always been a function of having a healthy relationship with food and my body rather than the reverse.

And to the pp, yes my bathroom is also tiny. So small in fact that if you try to get past the shower to the toilet with a bulky coat on its a squeeze. But a lot of people on mumsnet tend to forget that not everyone lives the same way they do.

I have no objection to being weighed or being asked for my weight but if I have to give it myself it will be an estimate based on the last time I checked. I think that's fine in my case, but possibly not for everyone.

I've never taken my own blood pressure but I also have no cause to think its anything other than normal.

I think the thing about self reporting is its fine if its an additional nice to have, but it shouldn't be relied on in more serious medical situations, and I would assume it isn't. Some people may be checking their blood pressure and weight at home every three months but I suspect it's a very small percentage of the population. And as always those who are vulnerable or have chaotic home situations will be the ones least able to engage.

So I think its a balance. I think these texts are fine and its great if people can give the information but we need to be wary of becoming ever more remote in our approach to health care. Someone somewhere right now is no doubt looking at a way to replace GPs with AI chatbots I'm sure.

TroysMammy · 09/07/2023 08:23

A dramatic loss of weight could indicate cancer. People ring the GP because they have lost weight but don't know how much they have lost. They have made the call "because people have told me I have".

Having a recorded weight today on your GP records and a phone call to the surgery about weight loss 6 months down the line could be very important.

FarmGirl78 · 09/07/2023 00:19

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/07/2023 23:06

@FarmGirl78

Oh my days. 😆 'Little old dears.' Could you BE any more patronising?! The ladies I know in their 80s and 90s would give you a short shrift if they heard you calling them that!

And they are certainly capable of carrying a set of bloody bathroom scales back from the shops! Good grief! They're not carrying a bloody couch back! It's a set of bathroom scales. 😂 And suggesting many 'little old dears' can't stand up for long enough to weigh themselves. OMFG Shock😂

You managed a thoroughly daft and hilarious post, and yet still offensive. Quite an accomplishment! 😬

And why would you keep 'tripping over your bathroom scales?' Is your bathroom only a 2 X 2 feet wide or something? Confused

With respect, I said most of the Patients I see. I didn't say ALL THE PATIENTS THAT EXIST. You don't know my Patient cohort, you don't what what comorbidities they typically have, and you don't know why I'm making the judgements that I'm making. I gave answers to questions about a job I've been doing very well for nearly 25 years. Don't patronise me by assuming you know my Patient cohort better than I do. I'm not making it all up.....I'm telling you about factors I see every day of my working life.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/07/2023 23:06

FarmGirl78 · 08/07/2023 20:21

I don't have my own scales. That's not an excuse to not give anyone my weight. I just don't have any. I don't want any to keep tripping over in my bathroom.

Most of the Patients I see are in their 80s and 90s. Plenty little old dears don't have scales. They don't have relatives living close by who can lend them theirs. They'd be too heavy to carry home from the shops. Some wouldn't have the mobility to stand upright independently while the weight registers. There's lots of reasons people need a face to face appointment so we can weight them. They aren't necessarily making excuses or trying to get out of it, they just need face to face.

@FarmGirl78

Oh my days. 😆 'Little old dears.' Could you BE any more patronising?! The ladies I know in their 80s and 90s would give you a short shrift if they heard you calling them that!

And they are certainly capable of carrying a set of bloody bathroom scales back from the shops! Good grief! They're not carrying a bloody couch back! It's a set of bathroom scales. 😂 And suggesting many 'little old dears' can't stand up for long enough to weigh themselves. OMFG Shock😂

You managed a thoroughly daft and hilarious post, and yet still offensive. Quite an accomplishment! 😬

And why would you keep 'tripping over your bathroom scales?' Is your bathroom only a 2 X 2 feet wide or something? Confused

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/07/2023 23:06

Brunilde · 08/07/2023 23:02

Getting a bloody text message does not change your registration status with the GP. If you're registered they get paid no matter how many text messages you get.

I believe there are additional financial incentives for additional things they do. So what if one of those is collecting height and weight data. (don't know for sure if it is) Why do you think there are incentives for this? Do you think they would be getting paid for it if it wasn't important? They get paid for doing things that improve the service and health outcomes for patients. What kind of a nutter would be angry that GPs are incentivised to do things that will help patients? So whether they send a text out of the goodness of their hearts, or because they get paid, the outcome is the same. Helps patients.

Plenty of jobs have a bonus or incentive for good performance. Is it just the evil GPs that shouldn't get this?

This. ^ Unfathomable isn't it, that people are whinging and moaning and throwing their toys out of the pram because GASP - their GPs are trying to help them stay healthy. Those EVIL MONSTERS!!!!!! Shock

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/07/2023 23:05

Hbh17 · 08/07/2023 22:44

I'm absolutely fine with GPs being paid for the jobs that Government ask them to do, but you are under no obligation to reply. I haven't been to the GP for 20 years, so only gave them my mobile number when the Covid vaccine was being rolled out, as I didn't want to miss it. Now when I get silly texts about blood pressure or whatever, I just delete them. You are a free individual - you have choices, do what you like, respond or don't respond - it doesn't matter.

Fine... Don't give your blood pressure. But don't complain, and expect NHS help when you have some kind of condition or illness that results from high blood pressure - because you refuse to give it, because you CBA, because 'I'm a free spirit maaaaan?!' 🙄

Brunilde · 08/07/2023 23:02

Getting a bloody text message does not change your registration status with the GP. If you're registered they get paid no matter how many text messages you get.

I believe there are additional financial incentives for additional things they do. So what if one of those is collecting height and weight data. (don't know for sure if it is) Why do you think there are incentives for this? Do you think they would be getting paid for it if it wasn't important? They get paid for doing things that improve the service and health outcomes for patients. What kind of a nutter would be angry that GPs are incentivised to do things that will help patients? So whether they send a text out of the goodness of their hearts, or because they get paid, the outcome is the same. Helps patients.

Plenty of jobs have a bonus or incentive for good performance. Is it just the evil GPs that shouldn't get this?

Hbh17 · 08/07/2023 22:44

I'm absolutely fine with GPs being paid for the jobs that Government ask them to do, but you are under no obligation to reply. I haven't been to the GP for 20 years, so only gave them my mobile number when the Covid vaccine was being rolled out, as I didn't want to miss it. Now when I get silly texts about blood pressure or whatever, I just delete them. You are a free individual - you have choices, do what you like, respond or don't respond - it doesn't matter.

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 22:41

I certainly could never afford private healthcare 🤣

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 22:39

LadyWithLapdog · 08/07/2023 22:29

@EmeraldFox i don’t understand why you’re so angry and making a mountain out of a molehill. You know that private healthcare is an option (good luck with withholding info from private insurance companies), especially as you keep saying how you were away for 20 years. What was good about the healthcare system abroad?

I'm not angry at the system, just annoyed with posters suggesting I don't want to engage with my health just because I don't want to know my exact weight without good reason such as for a medication that requires it. I don't see why it matters otherwise, I'm around 9st at 5ft 5 so no reason for concern imo. My GP surgery doesn't care anyway as they still have me down as being 7st and haven't thought to follow that up. I'm only disappointed that I couldn't get help when I did need it.

Sidge · 08/07/2023 22:35

@LadyWithLapdog you’re right, I shouldn’t rise.

LadyWithLapdog · 08/07/2023 22:31

@Sidge you know how it is with fake news. Spew bullshit with conviction, draw in some gullibles with a chip on their shoulder, axe to grind etc, and off you go.

LadyWithLapdog · 08/07/2023 22:29

@EmeraldFox i don’t understand why you’re so angry and making a mountain out of a molehill. You know that private healthcare is an option (good luck with withholding info from private insurance companies), especially as you keep saying how you were away for 20 years. What was good about the healthcare system abroad?

Sidge · 08/07/2023 22:10

StarDolphins · 08/07/2023 21:45

🤣 why should anyone stop posting? Everyone has as much right to post here whether you think they’re ‘demonstrating’ enough knowledge or not. What an odd thing to say.

I meant they should stop posting about things which they obviously know nothing about with such conviction. Other posters might think the tripe that they’re posting is correct.

MumblesParty · 08/07/2023 22:00

StarDolphins · 08/07/2023 21:45

🤣 why should anyone stop posting? Everyone has as much right to post here whether you think they’re ‘demonstrating’ enough knowledge or not. What an odd thing to say.

Because it’s not a good idea to post incorrect information whilst implying that you know lots, when you don’t.

MumblesParty · 08/07/2023 21:58

Sidge · 08/07/2023 21:32

@millymog11 you’re demonstrating that you really have no clue about primary care funding, patient registrations or NHS contract agreements. I’d stop posting now if I were you.

Exactly. It’s astounding that someone can talk such utter rubbish with such conviction.

MumblesParty · 08/07/2023 21:56

Samaritans999 · 08/07/2023 20:18

GP surgeries are private enterprises, they can charge what they like for their services.

That’s simply not true

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 21:46

StarDolphins · 08/07/2023 21:39

I definitely don’t feel like anyone I know would answer yes to ‘do you feel like you’re getting the healthcare you deserve?

Maybe 10 years ago.

I certainly haven't, and they got 20+ years of funding for me when I wasn't even here, I was still on the books at the same surgery.

StarDolphins · 08/07/2023 21:45

Sidge · 08/07/2023 21:32

@millymog11 you’re demonstrating that you really have no clue about primary care funding, patient registrations or NHS contract agreements. I’d stop posting now if I were you.

🤣 why should anyone stop posting? Everyone has as much right to post here whether you think they’re ‘demonstrating’ enough knowledge or not. What an odd thing to say.

StarDolphins · 08/07/2023 21:39

Sidge · 08/07/2023 18:09

Invasive? Bloody hell you are a muppet. This is YOUR GP surgery, that YOU chose to register with, that hold YOUR medical records and are there to provide YOUR health care.

Yet they send a simple text asking you to update your record of height and weight and that’s invasive? Jesus. It’s not like they turned up on your doorstep demanding to come in and weigh you.

Honestly the general public is getting the healthcare they deserve. You’ll miss us when we’re gone.

I definitely don’t feel like anyone I know would answer yes to ‘do you feel like you’re getting the healthcare you deserve?

Maybe 10 years ago.

StarDolphins · 08/07/2023 21:35

MostlyBlueberryFlavoured · 08/07/2023 17:30

Jesus wept, why would you make a fuss about your GP surgery receiving funding? I despair.

I think people are irked because they generally can’t get to see a GO very easily or even at all. I know many people that can’t get to see one & have to send a photo. My neighbour being one of them that tried & tried & eventually a gp rang her & she now is mid treatment for cancer which has spread to her bones.

I am all for GP’s getting extra funding IF we could get to see them. Sort of, you scratch my back & I’ll scratch yours.

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 21:32

Flossiemoss · 08/07/2023 21:20

Alerts can be put on notes. The vast majority of people do not have an eating disorder. weight is an important piece of information for the vast majority of peoples healthcare.

My point was that not wanting non essential weigh ins doesn't mean you are not engaging with your health. It's more important to take responsibility for your own health imo, which is what I focus on.