Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend is RUDE and HARDWORK

63 replies

Timetoflower22 · 08/07/2023 14:09

Need a little advice. There's three of us in a group and one of our friends within the group is rude and unbelievably hard work.

We were supposed to all come over to mine for bbq and drinks and one of our friends came over early and the other friend was busy until 8pm so we decided to go to the pub with some people I know from my area.

My friend that came over doesn't know anyone who was at the pub but made a conscious effort to talk and interact with them. We told our other friend we were going to the pub and if she is happy to meet us there. She said yes. Anyway, she turned up and we were all having a few drinks enjoying ourselves and when she arrived we introduced her. She had a face like a slapped arse and didn't say hi or make any conscious effort to speak to anyone. She sat there in her phone the entire time, and the other girls she didn't know made an effort to include her and talk to her but they got nothing but one word answers back or a rude look.
After an hour she said she was going to go home as she wasn't aware we were planning on staying out and we said well that's not an issue we can go back to mine and have drinks and we can go back to the original plan. She said no thanks, and made a silly excuse up. She was SO rude to my other friends the entire time. Never once made any conversation and I've never seen someone sit there and look so miserable. The issue is, she's like it even with just us three together. Always so miserable and the only time she's happy is when she's doing something SHE wants to do. It's her way or no way sort of thing.

Me and my other friend apologised to 'my' friends and said sorry for her rudeness and they just couldn't believe she didn't once even try to initiate conversation with any of them (considering they are all lovely girls and really tried with her). Me and my other friend are at our wits end with it, she's constantly negative, miserable and rude when she's with us and we don't know what to say to her. She's been like this on and off for years and can be a very bitter person too.

Any advice would appreciated.

OP posts:
uncomfortablydumb53 · 08/07/2023 17:15

Surround yourself with radiators, not drains as the saying goes
If you come away from meeting her feeling worse, it's a sign she is not a friend
If you all feel the same, it's her not you
Personally I'd fade her out slowly and if she asks why tell her

Peachy2005 · 08/07/2023 17:08

Ditch her! Why on earth would you plan another holiday with her when she was a misery-guts on the last one?!

PinkArt · 08/07/2023 16:38

Look it sounds like your don't like her at all so I'd stop calling her a friend and let the relationship slide. I'm with her on the BBQ/ pub incident though. You invited her to a BBQ for three at your house and at the 11th hour changed that to a night in the pub with a lot of people she didn't know. I'd have tried to suck that up for an hour thinking we were going to head to yours soon but like her would probably have headed off when it became clear that plans had changed for the night.
Between the way she behaved in the pub and what you said about her texting herself screams social anxiety to me. She's trying to find ways of coping with a situation that makes her feel deeply uncomfortable. If she was a friend, I'd suggest ways to work with her on that's but you don't like her so for both your sales just let the 'friendship' go

CoffeeCantata · 08/07/2023 16:07

Oh dear - I would judge her as ignorant, rude and selfish.

I would have been mortified for my other friends to have some rude person turn up and snub them all.

I guess it's awkward because she is part of a threesome with your other (nicer) friend so it's not easy to unilaterally ditch her - I admit that makes if difficult. But in all other respects I'd not want her in my social life.

CovertImage · 08/07/2023 15:37

Surely she was annoyed because it was just supposed to be three of you having a barbecue. When she met you in the pub though you'd added several other people from your area to the group that neither of your friends know and weren't giving any sign that you were going to continue with your original plan until she mentioned it an hour later. I would also have been pissed off in this situation.

Doesn't excuse her other behaviour of course but I'm with her on this one.

threecupsofteaminimum · 08/07/2023 15:15

I think I she has issues and for some reason when she's in your company she feels able to express them freely regardless of how she comes across and makes you feel.

For one, I'd encourage her to perhaps explore why she does, then gently let her know how you feel, that you feel upset or whatever afterward having spent time with her, she can either accept it or maybe open up to you or sort he shit out and apologise etc, or let the friendship meet it's natural end.

midsomermurderess · 08/07/2023 14:49

I don’t understand why people put up with this sort of petulant, attention-seeking nonsense. You get nothing from this set up, and clearly she doesn’t, unless sulking gives her some kind of pleasure. You don’t need to stay in touch with people you don’t like. Tell her you’ve nothing in common anymore, that neither of you enjoy the others company. It might make her buck up her ideas. If not, you’re shot of her.

NoSquirrels · 08/07/2023 14:46

Timetoflower22 · 08/07/2023 14:31

Also, she's really difficult with booking a holiday. We want to go to Portugal next year, cheap and cheerful and she stated 'I don't want to spend my money on somewhere I don't want to go, why don't we consider going to Miami or New York?' And both me and my other friend have mortgages so we can just get up and book to go to America. Whereas she still lives at home. We said wells Europe is cheaper, where would you like to go and she said she doesn't want to go to Europe, because it's 'boring'. She doesn't compromise - EVER.

In which case you say, No problem if you don’t want to come on holiday with us next year then, Friend. Other friend and I will make plans for Europe.

M0rT · 08/07/2023 14:46

You can't fix her or make her confide in you if there are problems, you can only set your own boundaries.
If you and your friend with a mortgage want to book a holiday to Europe for next summer just pick what suits yourselves and invite her to that holiday if you would like her company. Don't get into negotiations about wether or not you can afford long haul etc
Equally don't do joint presents with someone who prioritises personal spending over gifts.
Just buy a present from yourself to your other friend.
I wouldn't pull her up on her behaviour at someone else's event where there will probably be alcohol.
In future either don't change plans you have made with her and don't try to include her with other friends if you know she will be rude.
Your friendship will probably fizzle out anyway as late twenties/early thirties is the time most peoples social circles shrink just because of time/money/kid pressures.
When you have less time and money for fun, you tend to want to spend it with the "bankers". Eg if Europe is too expensive for her to spend to not go where she wants, is it too expensive for you to spend with a sulker?

Anewuser · 08/07/2023 14:46

Ok, I’ll go with: she finds social interaction difficult and most time masks because she has ASD.

She wants things her way and can’t pretend when she isn’t happy with someone else’s choice.

She takes things literally and when you say ‘meet at the pub,” she thinks that’s fine as you’ll meet then immediately go back to yours for the bbq.

MCOut · 08/07/2023 14:46

Be honest with her about how her behaviour is affecting you. It’s clear that she is unhappy and your conversation should explore how she’s feeling, but it’s not fair for her to constantly be a drag on your time. If she doesn’t seem to be putting in any effort to work on how she’s feeling or she continues to be rude, then it’s completely fine to slowly withdraw.

Regarding the money, she’s allowed to be cheap if she wants to be. If you and your other friend have agreed to Europe then she just doesn’t have to go.

Gymnopedie · 08/07/2023 14:43

we see her with other friends and is happy as Larry.

She has other friends. Then you have no reason to feel guilty about letting her go.

ilovesooty · 08/07/2023 14:41

NoSquirrels · 08/07/2023 14:29

You’re not obliged to stay friends with someone you don’t actually like.

Exactly. If you no longer like her you can withdraw from the friendship. I think you should tell her why though.

Thebigblueballoon · 08/07/2023 14:39

I’d have one frank chat with her to see if she’d open up about what is bothering her. If there was no resolution I’d honestly back off from the friendship.

determinedtomakethiswork · 08/07/2023 14:37

I wonder how she think she comes across?

Timetoflower22 · 08/07/2023 14:36

Maddy70 · 08/07/2023 14:34

I'm unsure you invited her over for a bbq and then went with your other friends to the pub and said she could tag along....

We asked her originally if she's happy to meet us at the pub, we had all had plans before hand to come to mine, but she told us on the day she had a leaving do to attend, so we said in the meantime rather than waiting around we'd go to the pub and even asked her if she was happy to meet us there, if she didn't want to go we would've just gone back home and carried on with our normal plans. But she said that was fine and she'd happily meet us there

OP posts:
Tiqtaq · 08/07/2023 14:36

If I usually feel happy after I have seen a friend then I know that I'd like to continue the friendship.

If that's not the case then I don't persue the friendship.

Regarding the holiday, just tell her that your budget stretches to europe not America so you will be going to europe. If that's boring for her she can chose to go to America instead.

Maddy70 · 08/07/2023 14:34

I'm unsure you invited her over for a bbq and then went with your other friends to the pub and said she could tag along....

Timetoflower22 · 08/07/2023 14:34

ExtraOnions · 08/07/2023 14:31

Some people find it really hard when meeting a group of people they don’t know; you don’t know the dynamic, the history, the “politics”… sometimes easier to sit back and see things evolve around you.
Maybe you had all had a few drinks, and she hadn’t (I know it can be quite overwhelming to walk, sober, into a group that’s been drinking.
She wasn’t up for the pub, but didn’t want to stop you enjoying yourself, so left. Maybe she was hungry, and the BBQ wasn’t showing any signs of appearing.

TBH, sounds like she needs some different friends, who don’t apologise on her behalf

This originally was my thinking, I apologised to her and said we can leave if you want too, but she doesn't even make a conscious effort to even try. She was sober yes, but we weren't drunk, just merry. It was her facial expressions and one word answers that really caused a bit of a scene. It was obvious to everyone she didn't want to be there, which is fine but she never said anything to us

OP posts:
EmmaOvary · 08/07/2023 14:31

She sounds like a narcissistic bore. Bin her off.

ExtraOnions · 08/07/2023 14:31

Some people find it really hard when meeting a group of people they don’t know; you don’t know the dynamic, the history, the “politics”… sometimes easier to sit back and see things evolve around you.
Maybe you had all had a few drinks, and she hadn’t (I know it can be quite overwhelming to walk, sober, into a group that’s been drinking.
She wasn’t up for the pub, but didn’t want to stop you enjoying yourself, so left. Maybe she was hungry, and the BBQ wasn’t showing any signs of appearing.

TBH, sounds like she needs some different friends, who don’t apologise on her behalf

Timetoflower22 · 08/07/2023 14:31

Also, she's really difficult with booking a holiday. We want to go to Portugal next year, cheap and cheerful and she stated 'I don't want to spend my money on somewhere I don't want to go, why don't we consider going to Miami or New York?' And both me and my other friend have mortgages so we can just get up and book to go to America. Whereas she still lives at home. We said wells Europe is cheaper, where would you like to go and she said she doesn't want to go to Europe, because it's 'boring'. She doesn't compromise - EVER.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 08/07/2023 14:30

I do think she sounds very unhappy and socially anxious and her mental health is clearly not good. If she is a good friend who you value you might want to reach out and ask if she is struggling and point out that her behaviour is having a significant negative impact on you and others. It may be that she isn't fully aware of how destructive this is.

But ultimately foisting this kind of passive aggressive behaviour on your friends in unacceptable, regardless of what the justification is. This kind of "mood hoover" behaviour is very antisocial and controlling. If her MH is sufficiently bad that she can't cope with social settings that fair enough but she should gracefully remove herself from them, rather than seeking to ruin it for others.

You don't have to tolerate this and its time to read the riot act or withdraw.

OldBeller · 08/07/2023 14:30

Difficult one. I'm not sure what you can do if she's in your friendship group but I'd definitely start ignoring her if she complains.

Backstreets · 08/07/2023 14:29

Sounds like she’s got some issues only she can work through. I’d quietly withdraw.