Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Splitsavers always taking my reserved seat!!

153 replies

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 12:28

Is it just me but seems majority of time I get on a train, a person with a split saver ticket has taken my seat not realising that their ticket has only reserved a seat for 1 leg of their journey. Frustrated that people don’t check their reservations more thoroughly but also that the trains companies/sellers are allowing this confusion to roll on and on. Often spoils journey trying to sort the issue out

OP posts:
FragrantBumFluff · 08/07/2023 17:58

My heart always sinks when I see someone sat in my reserved seat on a packed train because I too feel awkward having to ask them to move. I always panic that I’ve got it wrong and it is actually their seat and I will look like an idiot, even if I’ve checked multiple times! That’s my anxiety though, it pops up in lots of situations that unfortunately can’t be avoided.

I had a really bad experience once on an overnight train abroad where some friends and I had a cabin reserved (so we could sleep!) and we boarded to find another group of English people asleep in there. It was so awkward having to wake them to ask them to move, and they refused anyway because another group of people were in their carriage, none of us spoke the language of the country we were passing through and the conductors didn’t have any English. So there was nothing we could do except sit in seats in one of the normal carriage all night, bright lights on, really uncomfortable seats - urgh. Didn’t even get our money back and I still rage thinking about those people a decade later!

But yeah anyway, it’s annoying but as long as people don’t get aggy about moving when you ask I don’t think there’s any more the train companies can do.

DdraigGoch · 08/07/2023 17:49

Lazylikeasundaymorning · 08/07/2023 14:33

It’s perfectly normal and sensible to sit in a seat that’s reserved further down the line when the train’s busy- loads of the time the person who made the reservation doesn’t show anyway. Are you suggesting that on a busy train people should stand rather than sit in a seat which is currently empty and may well be for the whole journey?

If the reservation screen says "Kings Cross to York" and "York to Newcastle" then it's usually fine to sit in the seat just after the train has left Kings Cross, so long as everyone has had the chance to find their seat. Be prepared to move at Newcastle - don't wait to be asked, be proactive: when you see someone heading your way checking the numbers you should ask "sorry, is 41 yours?"

Jumping in to someone else's seat as soon as you board is rude.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/07/2023 17:38

I definitely agree with that, IncomingTraffic - and if the train companies don't want to do that then they should invest in more train staff to come and check tickets constantly, moving on people who are in reserved seats.

I expect the train companies wouldn't want to do that either.

IncomingTraffic · 08/07/2023 17:32

It’s really bad customer experience design to intentionally create situations where passengers are likely to find someone else in their reserved seat and to have to ask them to move.

Train companies could entirely avoid this by pricing sensibly so that it’s not actually possible to save money by split ticketing. It’s absurd that it can cost you more to just book a ticket from one destination to another. You should never be able to book London to York and York to edinburgh on exactly the same train for less than just London to edinburgh on one ticket.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/07/2023 17:28

And if you are a split-saver and you know that your ticket has 'run out' for the seat you're in, go and find a non-reserved seat. Why can't they do that?

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/07/2023 17:27

There haven't been very many differing views to be fair. It's either agreeing with the OP's predicament or rudely telling her to suck it up, be an adult, etc. All of which require input from the OP which a) she doesn't want to give and b) she really shouldn't have to.

This isn't a new phenomenon. So many posts and messages about people not booking/taking other seats (planes and trains) and the person with the ticket being expect to move them or summon a member of staff to do it.

The onus is and always has been that if a seat is reserved and you didn't reserve it, you're not entitled to it and should get out of it without needing to be told.

I don't travel by train much but I can imagine it must be pretty heart-sinking when you get onto a busy train, get to your reserved seat, and find somebody sitting in it who doesn't immediately get up. I would hate that. I could ask them to move but, why would I have to do that when I have the reservation/ticket?

Sometimes, you just want to sit in your reserved seat, without preamble or fuss and I suspect that OP posted in search of solidarity. Just on the wrong board.

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 17:18

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/07/2023 16:26

Doesn't mean that anybody has to agree with the different opinions, EmeraldFox and I'm not sure that's considered particularly rude on AIBU which is the 'home of the bunfight'.

I don't think OP is being unreasonable. I also don't agree that she has to 'use her words' or any other vacuous demand that other posters insist on. OP paid for her seat, split-saver passenger didn't pay beyond that leg of the journey. Not rocket science, split-saver should get up and move.

Consider, not agree. If you have already made up your mind then why ask what others think, which is what AIBU is for?

I don't think many people would disagree that a person should get up and move when another person lets them know they have a reservation for that seat. It's vacating the seat before anyone turns up, or getting up as soon as anyone else comes along (who may or may not have a reservation) that is where the disagreement lies.

cloudsandream · 08/07/2023 16:56

OP your age is showing 😂

Theredcow · 08/07/2023 16:46

I booked a journey recently and saved a fortune with 3 splits so 3 seat changes. All the reserved seating was in 2 packed carriages so I moved further down the train where the carriages were unreserved and empty so had a table seat for the whole journey and didn't have to move.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/07/2023 16:26

Doesn't mean that anybody has to agree with the different opinions, EmeraldFox and I'm not sure that's considered particularly rude on AIBU which is the 'home of the bunfight'.

I don't think OP is being unreasonable. I also don't agree that she has to 'use her words' or any other vacuous demand that other posters insist on. OP paid for her seat, split-saver passenger didn't pay beyond that leg of the journey. Not rocket science, split-saver should get up and move.

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 16:24

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/07/2023 16:16

You could say that about any thread here. Having other people to ask doesn't mean that you can't go onto a chatboard and ask. I constantly remind myself of this when I look at the mostly, utter drivel posted, begging for responses.

It's considered rude to post in AIBU and then refuse to consider different opinions, instead insisting YANBU.

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 16:21

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/07/2023 16:04

I understand, OP. I think the posters telling you to be an 'adult' or whatever other terms they use to minimise this, are either not train travellers themselves or the type of cheeky timewaster that would behave like this.

That 'be an adult' door swings both ways. Split savers have the responsibility to check their own bookings and not to take advantage of seats they aren't entitled to. They want it cheap? Fine - have cheap seats but those have conditions so be an adult and comply. You have the ticket for that journey for that seat, you shouldn't need to say a damn thing.

All these posters who 'despair' sound extremely wet.

Thank you, it would be so nice to think I could just get on a train and sit in my reserved seat with no fuss. I thought it was just the split saver confusion issue but seems from this thread there is a minority of selfish people that would do it anyway despite how awkward they make anyone else feel

OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/07/2023 16:16

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 16:14

If you have a circle to ask then why ask us?

You could say that about any thread here. Having other people to ask doesn't mean that you can't go onto a chatboard and ask. I constantly remind myself of this when I look at the mostly, utter drivel posted, begging for responses.

EmeraldFox · 08/07/2023 16:14

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 16:12

I assume your quite happy that 56% of people would willow away and stand/ not sit in their chosen reserved seat and another good proportion feel very awkward about the whole thing because you’d jumped in it. Call it a personal insult to say I’m thankful that wouldn’t be considered acceptable behaviour in my circle

If you have a circle to ask then why ask us?

Talia99 · 08/07/2023 16:13

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 16:12

I assume your quite happy that 56% of people would willow away and stand/ not sit in their chosen reserved seat and another good proportion feel very awkward about the whole thing because you’d jumped in it. Call it a personal insult to say I’m thankful that wouldn’t be considered acceptable behaviour in my circle

😂

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 16:12

Talia99 · 08/07/2023 15:56

Agreed - socialising with people who promptly descend to personal insults when caught out telling porkies isn’t on my wish list either1

I assume your quite happy that 56% of people would willow away and stand/ not sit in their chosen reserved seat and another good proportion feel very awkward about the whole thing because you’d jumped in it. Call it a personal insult to say I’m thankful that wouldn’t be considered acceptable behaviour in my circle

OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/07/2023 16:04

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 14:22

My point is that this appears to be a perpetual mistake, shouldn’t either the booking process be making this clearer or people be taking more notice?

I understand, OP. I think the posters telling you to be an 'adult' or whatever other terms they use to minimise this, are either not train travellers themselves or the type of cheeky timewaster that would behave like this.

That 'be an adult' door swings both ways. Split savers have the responsibility to check their own bookings and not to take advantage of seats they aren't entitled to. They want it cheap? Fine - have cheap seats but those have conditions so be an adult and comply. You have the ticket for that journey for that seat, you shouldn't need to say a damn thing.

All these posters who 'despair' sound extremely wet.

LolaSmiles · 08/07/2023 16:00

I'd expect anyone with a split saver ticket to be aware that their seat was only reserved until a certain stop, then be ready with their things just before the station so that if the next passenger gets on they're ready to move quickly.

If nobody shows up then then they can stay there.

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 15:57

Bromptotoo · 08/07/2023 15:47

People in your reserved seat has been a thing as long as I've used long distance trains; nigh on 50 years. Peak trains out of (mostly) Kings Cross had multiple seats with a Reservation Tag on them but nobody in it by the time we passed through London's suburbs. People on business reserved seats on 2 or 3 trains, others, me amongst them sometimes, missed the damn thing.

I presume the indicator over the seat shows where it's reserved from and too? It certainly did when I used to get trains from Milton Keynes. Same as where people but their handbag or briefcase on a seat on a busy commuter train. You just need to ask, in an assertive but not aggressive style, to shift their bag, or in the OP's case, themselves!

As said earlier, if I got on at the next stop for some reason I would accept someone might have assumed the seat was unclaimed and wouldn’t think of them as rude. Just unacceptable to jump in the seat before its even left the original station

OP posts:
Talia99 · 08/07/2023 15:56

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 15:55

Well pop up a poll why don’t you? We can agree to disagree on what we both consider rude behaviour, just glad I don’t have to mix with people like you too often

Agreed - socialising with people who promptly descend to personal insults when caught out telling porkies isn’t on my wish list either1

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 15:55

Talia99 · 08/07/2023 15:49

The 74% relates to your original question which relates to the issue of split fares and people not realising the seat isn’t theirs and therefore arguing about it. I agree you are not unreasonable to think there needs to be a better system in place.

You have then decided to argue that anyone who ever sits in a reserved seat is ‘selfish’ and ‘rude’ even if they are prepared to move the second you say it’s your seat.

No one has voted on that because that wasn’t your question! Trying to say 74% of people agree with you on a completely new question that they may not even know has been raised unless they’ve read the thread in full is simply untrue.

Well pop up a poll why don’t you? We can agree to disagree on what we both consider rude behaviour, just glad I don’t have to mix with people like you too often

OP posts:
Talia99 · 08/07/2023 15:49

The 74% relates to your original question which relates to the issue of split fares and people not realising the seat isn’t theirs and therefore arguing about it. I agree you are not unreasonable to think there needs to be a better system in place.

You have then decided to argue that anyone who ever sits in a reserved seat is ‘selfish’ and ‘rude’ even if they are prepared to move the second you say it’s your seat.

No one has voted on that because that wasn’t your question! Trying to say 74% of people agree with you on a completely new question that they may not even know has been raised unless they’ve read the thread in full is simply untrue.

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 15:48

Talia99 · 08/07/2023 15:42

Please provide the link to the research. I would be interested to see sample size / how they eliminated bias (in some surveys only people who have an issue will respond) etc.

Also, I note you say this includes ‘people who would rather find another seat’. If I’m on a nearly empty train and have a reservation, I would probably take another seat rather than put the person in mine to the hassle of moving - there’s no point being disruptive ‘on principle’. It appears you disagree which is your right.

I was on a train once where a woman insisted on doing this. Multiple empty seats but she had to have ‘her seat’. Frankly it was a bit pathetic.

Why should she not be able to sit in the seat she had arranged? It’s not being pathetic, she’s gone to the effort of booking that seat, multiple reasons why she might have wanted that specific seat. Why was someone else sitting there if plenty of other empty seats?

search LNER - are you sitting comfortably, new research

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 08/07/2023 15:48

One of the issues with taking a different empty seat though, is that it may say "available" when you sit down, but on the app you can reserve a seat 5 mins before the train is due, so you may find your free seat gets reserved and then you need to move and find yourself bouncing around. That's why I do insist on my own booked seat even if there are seemingly plenty of free ones.

Bromptotoo · 08/07/2023 15:47

People in your reserved seat has been a thing as long as I've used long distance trains; nigh on 50 years. Peak trains out of (mostly) Kings Cross had multiple seats with a Reservation Tag on them but nobody in it by the time we passed through London's suburbs. People on business reserved seats on 2 or 3 trains, others, me amongst them sometimes, missed the damn thing.

I presume the indicator over the seat shows where it's reserved from and too? It certainly did when I used to get trains from Milton Keynes. Same as where people but their handbag or briefcase on a seat on a busy commuter train. You just need to ask, in an assertive but not aggressive style, to shift their bag, or in the OP's case, themselves!

Swipe left for the next trending thread