Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Splitsavers always taking my reserved seat!!

153 replies

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 12:28

Is it just me but seems majority of time I get on a train, a person with a split saver ticket has taken my seat not realising that their ticket has only reserved a seat for 1 leg of their journey. Frustrated that people don’t check their reservations more thoroughly but also that the trains companies/sellers are allowing this confusion to roll on and on. Often spoils journey trying to sort the issue out

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Chatandtea · 09/07/2023 09:15

IhearyouClemFandango · 08/07/2023 22:19

Tbh when I booked a train the other day it didn’t make it obvious it was split, I only realised when checking that the tickets had gone in my wallet and panicked that I had got the wrong ones 😬

Yes it’s never pleasant for the person who has made the unwitting mistake either and makes me feel bad that I’ve been the one to highlight it, it’s just so awkward and embarrassing all round that reluctant to get the train now as it’s either that or me avoiding the issue and not claiming my reservation. It would be appreciated on all sides if the booking websites made the different/lack of seat reservations clearer to just avoid all this, perhaps also signs/announcements for those with split savers to double check their reservations

OP posts:
Chatandtea · 09/07/2023 08:58

willWillSmithsmith · 08/07/2023 21:58

I wasn’t referring to taking a seat at London when the digital reservation above the seat clearly shows London to York is reserved. I mean if someone gets on at London but the reserved seat is not until say an hour into the journey. Then I see no reason why someone can’t sit in the seat for an hour then vacate it if the person with the reservation shows up.

Yes of course that’s absolutely fine for them to sit in the seat until the reservation starts, I assume that’s the reason why they specify the periods of reservation. Best really if vacate the seat by the time train stops at that station, although forgivable if packed train and be ready to move before they have to ask, although they are still probably going to feel a bit rubbish that you’ve lost your seat to them.

OP posts:
Chatandtea · 09/07/2023 08:47

Sissynova · 08/07/2023 22:08

If this puts you off getting trains you really need to build up some resilience. People sit in the wrong seat all the time for a multitude of reasons, either because they haven’t reserved one, they read their ticket wrong, or no one was sat in the seat when they got on so they assumed the person sat elsewhere.

It’s not about resilience, I can tolerate it if unavoidable but I’m not going to stop thinking your a selfish twat if I arrive to my seat at my departing station and your already sitting in it (knowingly) or be annoyed at the booking websites when have whole split saver confusion to sort out. It will factor into my decision to use the trains or not.
If I get on at a following station and your sitting in my seat I’m going to expect a downside of that is that I may have to reclaim my seat as they reasonably assumed I hadn’t turned up and certainly no hard feelings towards that person. I’m actually quite a chilled person, forget to wave thanks to me while driving and I’m not seething all day, I’ll assume you thought was just another parked car etc. Having small children and working with the public there are many interactions I ‘confidently and resiliently’ negotiate each day thank you very much. Do you consider how much harder it must be for people who do actually have communication difficulties?

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 08/07/2023 23:59

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 20:04

For those worried unoccupied seats would be wasted for hours, LNER suggest in the above video that if 5 minutes after the train has departed a reserved unoccupied seat is empty (from the station reserved from) then you can sit there as long as willing to move if the person who has reserved the seat later turns up. I’ve said all the way through this seems fair enough but not taking someone’s seat with there being a fair chance they’ll have to ask you to move

Some operators change the displays at that point to read "available if unoccupied"

IhearyouClemFandango · 08/07/2023 22:19

Tbh when I booked a train the other day it didn’t make it obvious it was split, I only realised when checking that the tickets had gone in my wallet and panicked that I had got the wrong ones 😬

Sissynova · 08/07/2023 22:08

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 12:53

It’s just the confrontation isn’t pleasant, having to publicly point out they’re in the wrong, them gathering up their stuff and having to find another seat, it really puts me off using the trains, frustrated at them and the train companies. Surely this enduring situation can be sorted out somehow

If this puts you off getting trains you really need to build up some resilience. People sit in the wrong seat all the time for a multitude of reasons, either because they haven’t reserved one, they read their ticket wrong, or no one was sat in the seat when they got on so they assumed the person sat elsewhere.

willWillSmithsmith · 08/07/2023 21:58

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 13:58

I have to disagree, unless it looks unlikely the person will not be turning up e.g screen says booked London to York but the train left London 10 minutes ago. It makes a lot of people feel very awkward having to confront someone and why should they have to when they’ve made the effort to ensure they’ve booked themselves a seat

I wasn’t referring to taking a seat at London when the digital reservation above the seat clearly shows London to York is reserved. I mean if someone gets on at London but the reserved seat is not until say an hour into the journey. Then I see no reason why someone can’t sit in the seat for an hour then vacate it if the person with the reservation shows up.

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 20:18

cloudsandream · 08/07/2023 16:56

OP your age is showing 😂

and?? ………

OP posts:
Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 20:16

lieselotte · 08/07/2023 18:06

Thank you, it would be so nice to think I could just get on a train and sit in my reserved seat with no fuss. I thought it was just the split saver confusion issue but seems from this thread there is a minority of selfish people that would do it anyway despite how awkward they make anyone else feel

So if I get on a train, I am not allowed to sit in a reserved, but unused, seat in case someone is too scared to ask me to move.

That is ridiculous. How do some of you ever get anything done, if you are too worried to open your mouth to ask someone to do something.

Just with some consideration, lucky enough that most of people I know and work with are like this and makes life so much more pleasant

OP posts:
Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 20:12

Nordicrain · 08/07/2023 18:47

Which you acknowledge is an oversight rather than intentional. Although I actually struggle to believe it genuinely takes 15 mins of “confrontation” to get people to move every time.

i can see it’s annoying but I agree with others than in most cases simply saying “excuse me this is my seat” shouldn’t be an issue. I also would let jump out of my seat every stop in case someone has reserved it.

Yes it has taken 10-15 minutes because after the initial ‘I have this seat booked’ and them replying that they also do then usually wait for guard walk through to sort it out. I could suggest it may be due to them not checking their reservation properly, wouldn’t be awful if you starting bleating on about that and found you were in the wrong ( had made an oversight yourself) so personally don’t like to push it. It’s just always awkward all round and be nicer if didn’t happen at all

OP posts:
Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 20:07

Blossomtoes · 08/07/2023 18:53

Wow six pages of nasty snide little thieves coming up with increasingly rude and abrasive reasons why it's fine to steal something that belongs to someone else.

The seat belongs to the train company. 🤷‍♀️

sure a house renting belongs to a landlord but doesn’t mean is right for someone to come and squat there before you’ve decided to move in

OP posts:
Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 20:04

For those worried unoccupied seats would be wasted for hours, LNER suggest in the above video that if 5 minutes after the train has departed a reserved unoccupied seat is empty (from the station reserved from) then you can sit there as long as willing to move if the person who has reserved the seat later turns up. I’ve said all the way through this seems fair enough but not taking someone’s seat with there being a fair chance they’ll have to ask you to move

OP posts:
Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 19:53

Whataretheodds · 08/07/2023 19:02

Not at all, you'll see from my previous replies that I don't think that. But you're getting upset about people being inconsiderate when you yourself have pointed out that mostly they don't realise their reservation doesn't cover the second leg.

So you can provide the feedback or remain professionally offended with no practical effect.

I have said I feel a mixture of sympathy and frustration for the people unwittingly sitting in my seat, they wouldn’t be if they checked their reservation properly and had some curiosity as to why the screen did not display a reservation for their entire journey but I acknowledged it is a major system failure too. I really cannot imagine this hasn’t been previously highlighted to the train companies and is no doubt as daily headache for the conductors but of course I do plan to add to the feedback too. No excuse for the selfish people who knowingly jump into your reserved seat before the train has even pulled away!!

OP posts:
OP posts:
LadyAddle · 08/07/2023 19:24

@Chatandtea I'd be interested in the LNER research as well, if you can send a link - I can't find anything on their website. I'm with you on disliking having to evict people from my seat, btw, though I do it.
My bugbear is LNER renaming the quiet coach the "quieter" coach. Bah, what a cop out. I want a Totally Silent Coach but I'd have to buy my own train.

MzHz · 08/07/2023 19:04

Flapjacker48 · 08/07/2023 12:30

Buying split tickets is a way to get the cheapest fare possible, maybe you don't need to worry about costs.....

And dickish comment of the thread goes to…

Whataretheodds · 08/07/2023 19:02

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 15:22

And you implication? That I shouldn’t be able to occupy my reserved seat without having to rectify a faulty system?

Not at all, you'll see from my previous replies that I don't think that. But you're getting upset about people being inconsiderate when you yourself have pointed out that mostly they don't realise their reservation doesn't cover the second leg.

So you can provide the feedback or remain professionally offended with no practical effect.

Blossomtoes · 08/07/2023 18:53

Wow six pages of nasty snide little thieves coming up with increasingly rude and abrasive reasons why it's fine to steal something that belongs to someone else.

The seat belongs to the train company. 🤷‍♀️

Nordicrain · 08/07/2023 18:47

Chatandtea · 08/07/2023 14:16

Usually takes a good 10-15 minutes to sort out with the split savers as they appear to genuinely believe it’s their seat

Which you acknowledge is an oversight rather than intentional. Although I actually struggle to believe it genuinely takes 15 mins of “confrontation” to get people to move every time.

i can see it’s annoying but I agree with others than in most cases simply saying “excuse me this is my seat” shouldn’t be an issue. I also would let jump out of my seat every stop in case someone has reserved it.

marewindham · 08/07/2023 18:38

Wow six pages of nasty snide little thieves coming up with increasingly rude and abrasive reasons why it's fine to steal something that belongs to someone else.

Obviously nicking something that belongs to someone else is rude. Sit in a reserved seat only if it's clear it's unused (eg London-Edinburgh but you left London 5 mins ago), if the seat reservation is Leeds-Edinburgh then it's fine to sit there from London to Leeds to either get up when the train reaches Leeds (sit back down only if the train leaves without the rightful owner of the seat turning up), or at the very least look around and be ready to spring up if someone approaches and is clearly looking for that seat. There's a big difference between that, and people who spread all their stuff around and put earpods in, staring out the window, pretending not to notice people asking for their seat.

And sneering and saying "well the onus is on you to ask for your stolen seat back boo hoo if you find confronting thieves difficult" - jesus, is there a full moon or something?

Plenty of people are neurodivergent, deaf, have mental illness, have PTSD, or don't speak English. Or have just had bad experiences on trains and are afraid of potential confrontation. There are lots of reasons why someone can't physically ask for their seat.

And unfortunately you can't predict how people will react to being told they're in someone's seat. Some people are lovely and apologetic and move, some get verbally abusive, some just flatly refuse to move. There have been tons of threads here where the OP as asked someone to move from a reserved seat and the other person has become abusive or belligerent, even one thread where the seat-stealer spent the rest of the journey heckling and yelling about what a C word the OP was. (Probably mental illness at play there.) I've even had one man lie to me that he was travelling with another person who was in the toilet just to prevent me from sitting in the empty seat next to him because he didn't want a disabled person near him. Look at this very thread, posters are saying it's "pathetic" to want to sit in your reserved seat. How selfish and rude!

The point is, it's not "no big deal just tell them they're in your seat and ask them to move!" when you have no idea if the person is going to react by apologising and moving, or by punching you in the face. Since Covid the amount of violence and hostility and just generally the amount of feral, antisocial behaviour in this country has shot through the roof.

I'm disabled and can't stand without pain, but I also can't speak brilliantly due to aphasia after a stroke a couple of years ago. But according to Mumsnet stroke survivors should just be forced to stand because fuck 'em, right? Fuck anyone who can't fight for themselves.

The "I've got mine so fuck everyone else" mentality here is feral.

Jibo · 08/07/2023 18:20

I had no idea about this, OP. Never gave it a thought. In fact I've booked my boss a splitsave ticket to Edinburgh on Monday morning! Oops.

So, thank you for bringing it to my attention and YANBU to say that the train companies/ticket vendors should make it clearer.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 08/07/2023 18:08

lieselotte · 08/07/2023 18:06

Thank you, it would be so nice to think I could just get on a train and sit in my reserved seat with no fuss. I thought it was just the split saver confusion issue but seems from this thread there is a minority of selfish people that would do it anyway despite how awkward they make anyone else feel

So if I get on a train, I am not allowed to sit in a reserved, but unused, seat in case someone is too scared to ask me to move.

That is ridiculous. How do some of you ever get anything done, if you are too worried to open your mouth to ask someone to do something.

Why wouldn't you just move to an unreserved seat? Your sneering is really unpleasant, I wouldn't want to have to deal with mouthy, entitled passengers and that is what the risk is.

lieselotte · 08/07/2023 18:06

Thank you, it would be so nice to think I could just get on a train and sit in my reserved seat with no fuss. I thought it was just the split saver confusion issue but seems from this thread there is a minority of selfish people that would do it anyway despite how awkward they make anyone else feel

So if I get on a train, I am not allowed to sit in a reserved, but unused, seat in case someone is too scared to ask me to move.

That is ridiculous. How do some of you ever get anything done, if you are too worried to open your mouth to ask someone to do something.

lieselotte · 08/07/2023 18:03

I was on a train once where a woman insisted on doing this. Multiple empty seats but she had to have ‘her seat’. Frankly it was a bit pathetic

She might have booked it for a reason, though - like a window seat or a particular place in the carriage. Or because she thought if she sat somewhere else then she'd be moved on by the person whose seat it actually was.

lieselotte · 08/07/2023 18:01

AngeloMysterioso · 08/07/2023 12:35

Just… explain it’s your reserved seat and ask them to move?

This. I have done this - had a split ticket and sat in a reserved seat, hoping the person wouldn't get on at the next station. If they do, I move. No drama.

Of course, if they won't move, they are CFs and that's when you call the guard to tell them to shift their entitled bottoms.

Swipe left for the next trending thread