Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unfair on DC to adopt?

186 replies

RedCarrots · 08/07/2023 10:41

Two DC (one is just at primary, one about to go). Oldest struggles a bit socially, and is bit behind, can get overwhelmed (though he is also very happy). Younger one seems to totally unfazed by anything.

I am late 30s. I have been thinking about having a 3rd baby. I love kids, and I love being a mum. I also work full time and we are lucky enough to have help.

I know very much in my heart that my desire to have a 3rd baby isn't reliant on them being biologically mine and I'm thinking about adopting. I don't want to be pregnant. And I would happily have a child, not looking to adopt a baby.

I know I have more love to give (cheeesy!) and our home feels pretty happy and functional (most of the time!)

The only thing holding me back is my other kids, my oldest one specifically. Is it an unfair thing to put upon him? He may well have ASD (or at least his old nursery thought he might) - we are doing all we can to support in that area - he is very happy and loves school, has friends, but he does definitely struggle with change and we have had to adopt some techniques to help me around that.

Am I being totally unfair to him that now he's settled at school - we could change his whole life by bringing in another child who will need so much of our focus?

OP posts:
Mirabai · 08/07/2023 14:41

Apart from anything else - if you were a SAHM and nurturing your kids full time was your thing - adoption would make sense.

But it’s rather unfair to adopt a child, who will arrive needing to form a strong bond with new parents, potentially with issues around their early experiences, and then farm out their care to a nanny. You can’t force a nanny to read up on adoption issues and she is the one who will be at the coal face.

The whole idea seems to be based more around your biological urges rather than any of the children’s well-being.

dottiedodah · 08/07/2023 14:40

My Nan used to say "You will be taking on someone elses bundle of trouble ,when you adopt" Although this sounds unkind ,its very true sadly! I think the poor little mites would need to be adopted without siblings really.As it is not fair on them.Either your DC would be pushed out ,or adopted DC would be uncomfortable .Why not be pleased with what you have .Maybe a pup if you like dogs ?

Paperbagsaremine · 08/07/2023 14:38

TeenDivided · 08/07/2023 11:06

I'm an adopter and my DC although they have issues and needs are not really recognisable from the descriptions above.

Suggest you post in the Adoption board for a rounded view.

This, it's a lifelong commitment that needs to be made with your eyes WIDE open.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 08/07/2023 14:36

Remember that adopted children often come with trauma and additional needs- you sound very well equipped to meet those needs, but yes they likely will impact the other children. It's ok to explore and get approved and wait for the right fit child to come along, if ever, for your family. You could also consider being a foster mum if you have a spare room- if you take a Sen child you might get paid more I think too- this extra income would be positive for your family.

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 08/07/2023 14:22

I adopted with a birth child and it wasn't an easy ride. I feel phenomenally guilty towards my birth dd as my ad has severe behavioural issues which has massively impacted our entire family.

Adopted children aren't adopted due to parents not wanting them anymore, 99.9% are adopted because they've experienced trauma or abuse of some description, even those removed at birth will experience trauma. This means that a high % will need to be patented differently and will need additional support. On paper my ad had the best start that an adopted child could. She was removed at 2 hours old, had the same foster family until placed with me. However she is under a psychologist, goes to a special school, has various mental health issues and we need rest-bite on a monthly basis. Think very carefully as this has not only impacted me, but also my birth dd who has a very different and difficult life as a result of my decision to adopt. It's not a decision I'd make again given the option

Ladybug14 · 08/07/2023 14:10

AllIwantforChristmas22 · 08/07/2023 14:01

Maybe try fostering first?

personally I also think you have rose tinted glasses and should prioritise you children.

This

cocunut · 08/07/2023 14:07

thegreenlight · 08/07/2023 10:52

I’m a teacher who has taught a number of adopted children. Unfortunately the extent of neglect required to have a child removed from their family is so low that it is very unusual to have a child that doesn’t have major attachment issues, foetal alcohol syndrome or neo natal drug issues. Children like this deserve a loving home but it can have a massive, massive impact on the other children in the family. And the parents. I have seen marriages destroyed due to the stresses of raising troubled children.

if you are really set on this - why not try fostering first?

Fostering sounds like a brilliant idea for the OP.

AllIwantforChristmas22 · 08/07/2023 14:01

Maybe try fostering first?

personally I also think you have rose tinted glasses and should prioritise you children.

AtrociousCircumstance · 08/07/2023 13:55

Yes unfair. If you pursue it you will be putting your adult needs way above the well-being of your DC.

NuffSaidSam · 08/07/2023 13:52

You sound a bit idealistic. It would be catastrophically disruptive to your family and current children. Have a third baby if you want one. Then, in 15 years or so when all of yours are on their way to independence look into adopting an older child, it will be a fantastic to do and you'll then be in a position to give enough to the adopted child without harming your other children.

Catusrusty · 08/07/2023 13:46

MaPaSpa · 08/07/2023 11:52

Ditto. The anti adoption vibe is so awful. Having any new child biological or otherwise is an upheaval and change in dynamic.

OP if you and your partner think you can do it, do some research and speak to SS.

as other have said try fostering first of you are able but if you can do. Every child deserves a loving stable and committed home.

There is definitely a strong anti adoption vibe going on!

OP if you are going into it with your eyes open and understand it will be difficult and lengthy then that's a good start.

I know someone who had adopted a child who had had a terrible start, foetal alcohol syndrome etc. He is adored and adores his siblings who weren't adopted. However it was a long arduous road.

It isn't all doom and gloom. If you aren't right for the process, they won't continue with you anyway.

starrynight21 · 08/07/2023 13:38

Please don't do this. My mother did it, and like you she had two children already ( I was the younger one). Our adopted sister had many behavioural issues due to her history - and to be honest, her adoption was the worst thing that could have happened in our family. Mum may as well have thrown a bomb into our house. The relationships between all the other family members, changed for the worst and they never recovered.

It's a long time ago now, but the repercussions are still felt in our family dynamic. I wouldn't recommend this to anyone.

Mummyoflittledragon · 08/07/2023 13:25

No way would I consider this with dcs of these ages. Right now, you have little, relatively biddable children. Teen years can be very hard and you may not be able to cope with your dcs plus another child, who will need a lot of love and care.

Adopters - just one parent - are expected to take a year off work to allow for the child to settle in. If you’re still serious about this when your children are considerably older, maybe look again.

tara66 · 08/07/2023 13:07

You would be taking a big risk - your children may not thank you for it.

drpet49 · 08/07/2023 12:18

coconutpie · 08/07/2023 10:48

Yes, it would be unfair. Focus on your family, you would only be doing this for yourself and not in your family's best interests.

This. I wouldn’t adopt in your situation.

SayHi · 08/07/2023 12:18

I think if your family is contact now, bringing another person into the mix could ruin it.

The he’s child would also take most of your attention and affection which I wouldn’t want to inflict on my DCs.

Not the same scenario obviously but my sister had 2 dogs and had the perfect life with them.
Because they fit in so well and were so well behaved, went out for long walks every day, had loads of fuss etc she thought she could give a dog in need a really loving home.
So she went and got another one and it all went to shit basically, even her original dogs changed completely. And she regrets getting a third one when her life was so good as it was.
She eventually got rid of the new dog as it just wasn’t fair on him or the other dogs but it was heartbreaking and I can’t imagine how difficult it would be with a child.

If you and your DH both work FT then I can’t even see the point in adopting a child. I’m not sure it would even be possible as there will probably be a lot of additional things you need to do like meetings.

If you’ve got so much love to give have you thought about respite care?
It’s such a lovely thing to do but it won’t impact on your family life every day like a child living with you would.

Tiredtoday0 · 08/07/2023 12:12

The family that I know that have adopted have all had a wonderful experience. Their child is an absolute joy and was taken off the mother at birth I believe. I’m not undermining the experiences of this little one, but they are extremely happy and adored by the whole family.

I know this isn’t always the case, but they are thriving and their siblings love them.

I have an autistic child and they adore other children, so I would consider adopting. I would have to be careful of course, and it could be challenging, but that can happen with a birth child.

What I’m saying is just get advice from the professionals and take it from there 🙂

MolkosTeenageAngst · 08/07/2023 12:09

I don’t think it’s unreasonable to look into it. The adoption process is long and there is no guarantee your family will be suited for adoption. Panels take great care into trying to ensure that adopters and children are a good match, there will be lots to learn before they would even consider placing a child with you. If social workers and those approving you to adopt felt that it wouldn’t be possible to place a child with you considering your elder DSs needs they will tell you, and they will be far more qualified to do so than anybody here. There may or may not be a child out there who would be a good match for your family, lots of children in the adoptive system are traumatised and have complex emotional and behavioural difficulties but that isn’t always the case or that doesn’t mean that they can’t fit into a loving family.

Adoption is never easy or without complexities and difficulties but that doesn’t mean it couldn’t be successful and you will only be approved to adopt if the panel agree that your family could adopt successfully. You will only be matched with child if they are felt to be a good fit with your family and it’s felt the adoption could be successful. Don’t let people here scare you into thinking all children waiting for adoption will be a nightmare to parent or that there is no chance an adopted child could be compatible with your current family.

If it’s so,etching you genuinely feel you could commit to then your best course of action is to seek your local authority or an adoption agency and look to find out more information from them about whether this could be a feasible option for your family.

smartiecake · 08/07/2023 11:54

I have a son with autism. He is now a teenager. We have had so many issues over the years, and now sadly he has mental health issues and has been out of school for months. You don't know how your own child will be in the coming years. I would focus on having an ASD assessment for them and getting the right support in education. Typically kids with ASD find many education settings a challenge and stressful and particularly as they get older. My DH and I are exhausted with work and dealing with all DS's appointments and supporting him
He takes up all of our attention and time, he needs us to fully support him. He can't leave the house alone. I also felt like I would have liked a 3rd but it would never have worked, so instead we have a cat.
Your child may be happy and settled now but sadly things may well change as theh get older,and having another child who has their own issues and needs in your home would be hard on everyone, all the kids especially. It wouldn't be fair to any of them.

Nordicrain · 08/07/2023 11:54

Btw my brother is adopted so I am 100% in favour of adoption. I just think you have to be very realistic about it. Because it will be much worse for those poor kids to lose their families a second time.

Nordicrain · 08/07/2023 11:53

Oh and they got zero help from
social services. Luckily they could pay for support and therapy themselves, but she openly said she felt entirely abandoned. Originally she was meant to have the adoption leave but she couldn’t hack it and her husband ended up taking it.

MaPaSpa · 08/07/2023 11:52

Mojoj · 08/07/2023 11:00

Wow, no wonder there are so many kids in the foster care system desperately waiting for their own family. Yes, kids in care can have a range of issues but with the right support and a loving family behind them, they can succeed. To the OP, I would say, yes the adoption process can be arduous but that is to make sure you and your partner are the right people to adopt. Most people can have kids, only a select few can adopt. I would at least do some more research, speak to SW and then decide. Good luck.

Ditto. The anti adoption vibe is so awful. Having any new child biological or otherwise is an upheaval and change in dynamic.

OP if you and your partner think you can do it, do some research and speak to SS.

as other have said try fostering first of you are able but if you can do. Every child deserves a loving stable and committed home.

Nordicrain · 08/07/2023 11:51

I agree you sound a bit naive. Like you’ll just be handed a lovely little toddler eager to be showered with all your excess love.

Speak to people who have adopted for the uk. Everyone I know who has done it has had a really tough initial time because the fact is a child that is permanently removed from its parents in the uk has generally had a really shit time. A friend of mine adopted siblings, 3 and 5, removed for neglect. There were huge temper issues, violence, the youngest was affectionate hadn’t learnt to talk yet at 3, the oldest would let them touch or cuddle her at all for 6 months. They couldn’t even go near her for a while. They needed loads of support and therapy. They love their children of course, and are 100% a family, but she did say that in the first year there were definitely times she wished she hadn’t done it as it was so hard.

Scienceadvisory · 08/07/2023 11:50

Duchessofealing · 08/07/2023 11:20

Not posted under this user name for a long time, my children are adopted. The reality is there may be some difficult issues with an adopted child, BUT social services are trained to assess the family and won’t place a child with a family where it won’t work out. It’s a gruelling process to be approved, me and DH are now me and ex DH, which is heartbreaking. The whole household will be assessed. I think you are offering up a lovely thing but you all have to be fully committed and eyes open. I love my children dearly, but I don’t know if I would do it again if I’d known where we’d all end up.

But it's estimated that between 3 and 9% of adoptions fail in this country. So clearly they are placing children in families where it doesn't work out.

memyselfi · 08/07/2023 11:49

Can't you just count your blessings and concentrate on the children that are actually here ?
I honest get that urge, we are unable to have children, lots of IVF , lots of expense & heartbreak, but the broody feelings that give you that need for another child are essentially hormone driven and won't last forever.
I'm an adoptee myself and there's no way in hell I would adopt.
People seem to have a fairytale version of saving some poor unfortunate child and showering them with love and how wonderful they are going to feel doing this ' good deed'.
It's so not like that , it's messy and traumatic and hard. It'll will affect you family much longer than hormone driven daydreams.
There's a lot to be said for appreciating what you've got, don't put it all in jeopardy with this huge gamble.