Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unfair on DC to adopt?

186 replies

RedCarrots · 08/07/2023 10:41

Two DC (one is just at primary, one about to go). Oldest struggles a bit socially, and is bit behind, can get overwhelmed (though he is also very happy). Younger one seems to totally unfazed by anything.

I am late 30s. I have been thinking about having a 3rd baby. I love kids, and I love being a mum. I also work full time and we are lucky enough to have help.

I know very much in my heart that my desire to have a 3rd baby isn't reliant on them being biologically mine and I'm thinking about adopting. I don't want to be pregnant. And I would happily have a child, not looking to adopt a baby.

I know I have more love to give (cheeesy!) and our home feels pretty happy and functional (most of the time!)

The only thing holding me back is my other kids, my oldest one specifically. Is it an unfair thing to put upon him? He may well have ASD (or at least his old nursery thought he might) - we are doing all we can to support in that area - he is very happy and loves school, has friends, but he does definitely struggle with change and we have had to adopt some techniques to help me around that.

Am I being totally unfair to him that now he's settled at school - we could change his whole life by bringing in another child who will need so much of our focus?

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 09/07/2023 09:32

Mojoj · 08/07/2023 11:00

Wow, no wonder there are so many kids in the foster care system desperately waiting for their own family. Yes, kids in care can have a range of issues but with the right support and a loving family behind them, they can succeed. To the OP, I would say, yes the adoption process can be arduous but that is to make sure you and your partner are the right people to adopt. Most people can have kids, only a select few can adopt. I would at least do some more research, speak to SW and then decide. Good luck.

The bit where you said ‘the right support’ is crucial. Sadly, very few adopters get the right support for the child they adopt. The number of adoptions that break down as a result is far too high.
Adopting a child because you ‘love’ kids / would make a great parent / want another baby is by far the worst reason to do so.

tenbob · 09/07/2023 09:32

I have a colleague who has adopted 2 children alongside their one birth child and they’ve made it work well BUT

They are totally on the ball with professional help. When an issue has appeared, the immediately look to find a therapist/doctor/expert who can help. Some of it comes via SS and the NHS, and some of it is paid for privately

The thing that jumps out at me is that your DS nursery flagged a potentially ASD issue which you haven’t followed up, and in a later post, you say you’ll ‘wait and see’ whether he needs additional support.

I don’t think your lack of proactivity to find suitable support for your DS sounds very compatible with having an adopted child that needs someone on the ball and looking out for their interests, let alone your existing children having you looking out for what additional support they will need when their lives get impacted by the arrival of a new (and potentially troubled) sibling

Even reading the adoption boards, successful adopters seem to have a similar mindset, and it’s not the naive attitude that a bit of love and a family will solve all the problems

SilkTrees · 09/07/2023 09:26

Scienceadvisory · 08/07/2023 11:47

There are practical considerations like can you afford to live off statutory adoption pay for a year? What if the child has higher needs and one of you needs to give up work altogether. How will you balance the needs of a traumatised child, a child with suspected asd and your youngest?

There is an adoption board here that may help you.

Exactly this. Repost on the adoption board, OP -- it has a lot of wise, knowledgeable posters, some of whom have adopted with birth children, or adopted multiple children on different occasions.

caringcarer · 09/07/2023 09:23

I foster a child. I'd love to adopt him as he's lived with me since he was 5 and now 17. I can't because his Dad refuses to allow adoption. In the UK you can only adopt a child up to 18 years. My children have grown used to my foster son over time and now treat him as a younger brother.

timetorefresh · 09/07/2023 09:20

Yes. Adoption is not a smooth process. I know several people who's lives have been ripped apart by it

Weal · 09/07/2023 09:06

I absolutely understand that the child would most likely have profound emotional and behavioural challenges, and that the process is gruelling. I do have my eyes open to all of that - but I do agree that it might not be in best interest for DS immediately

^Op you are right to say that the process can be gruelling. Some children will adapt and settle into their adoptive families, others will never settle and will need intensive support throughout their childhood and life due to the impact of their early life experiences. How would you feel about giving up work completely if your adoptive child needs greater support, can’t find a suitable school, is removed from childcare etc? this is the reality for some parents/adoptive parents. How would you feel if the child has needs that start to impact on your other children eg they feel scared/can’t sleep/ don’t get time with you 1-2-1?

That’s a big thing to bring in to your family when you have young children and already have a child potentially who might need additional support to thrive.

years ago on some training I remember being told that there is a greater chance of adoption breakdown where children go into families who have biological children also. I suppose because if you have other children the impact of any behavioural issues might be greater as you have to balance the needs of all the children.

You say you want to adopt to offer a child a home who needs one rather than have another biological child. Why can’t you do that through fostering? I know you said you wouldn’t want to, but if that was your main reason then fostering is just as, if not more, helpful than adopting.

timetogetlost · 09/07/2023 09:01

You don't sound naive at all and are right to point out that getting a cat or dog is a ridiculous thing to say. Good luck with your research. The world does need more people like you.

TeenDivided · 09/07/2023 08:57

You can take a years adoption leave, same as for maternity.

Note, I am not saying adoption would be right for the OP or not, but working people to adopt, as do those with birth children.

bluebird3 · 09/07/2023 08:47

I think working full time might be a problem with adoption. The child will likely need additional support and need you available during the day to some extent or after school at least. I think you'd need to consider if you can afford to not work or work much less at least the first few years after adopting.

JMSA · 09/07/2023 08:36

I mean this kindly OP, but I'm not sure you'd be going into it for the right reasons. Adopting out of broodiness is probably not a good idea.

user1477391263 · 09/07/2023 08:25

What about volunteering in something child-related, in some way?

RedCarrots · 09/07/2023 08:12

Thanks for all the comments and advice.

I would take a year long adoption leave (paid as per my work policy) and our nanny is trained and knowledgeable about SEN and behavioural issues.

This thread has been really helpful in making me think further about DS and timing.

But suggestions about getting a puppy etc -doesnt feel v helpful - I'm not considering this because I want some cute little thing to look after. I'm considering it because I want to give a child a secure, happy, home and to support them as best we can. It's not comparable to a puppy. And I don't want to test anything by fostering. WE are looking to have a 3rd child, v different from fostering.

I have definitely listened though particularly in relation to DC. Perhaps I will wait until end of primary.

OP posts:
UnbeatenMum · 08/07/2023 18:46

We are in exactly this position except that we didn't know our biological child was autistic until quite a long time after we adopted. Our mentor through the adoption agency also had an autistic birth child and I know of other families in similar situations through other online groups. So it's not totally unheard of and we certainly don't regret it, although it's not easy at times. I have taken a career break and our age gaps are quite big, which I think helps. But I would generally assume that an adopted child will also have some level of additional needs.

CopperSeahorses · 08/07/2023 16:32

Why would fostering be any easier than adopting, I guess the idea is that you can walk away if things don't pan out but you don't go into fostering to 'try before you buy. The needs of a child in foster care are just as great as those of the child who needs adoption and you need to be fully committed to it.

1983Louise · 08/07/2023 15:37

Please don't do it, you're very lucky to have your children, why spoil it. I know you're coming from a good place but many children in care have massive emotional problems. We adopted a four month.old baby, thought there would be no problems as she was so young, how naive where we. I love her very much and we have a great relationship now but we went through some very difficult years x

Stompythedinosaur · 08/07/2023 15:33

Yes, I think it would be unfair to do that.

Cucucucu · 08/07/2023 15:28

Most children with autism gave siblings and benefit from it so no I don’t think you are being unfair . I think you want a child just like any other person ,. Go for it

Spendonsend · 08/07/2023 15:28

I would think very carefully about the impact on your potential adopted child and whether this is the right set up for them

they might find it hard when people say stuff like "bilogical child has aunties so an so eyes' or hard dealing with an autistic sibling when they perhaps have their own attachment things to work on.

There might be someone who you are the right family for but its not just your existing children to consider, its your new child too.

Dacadactyl · 08/07/2023 15:27

In your shoes I wouldn't do it.

If I were to adopt, my biological children would have to have grown up first. We have spoken about it as a couple and would still be young enough to do it when ours were grown. But the older mine get, the less I want to adopt.

mathanxiety · 08/07/2023 15:25

I agree with Mirabai and dottiedodah

Get a puppy.

TeenDivided · 08/07/2023 15:24

@determinedtomakethiswork
We adopted 16 years ago.

mathanxiety · 08/07/2023 15:20

You say you work full time but you have help?

What sort of help?

A nanny? A nanny who is qualified and willing to deal with the issues of a child whose birth family has met the very high bar that set in motion their child's removal?

A grandparent? A nursery?

determinedtomakethiswork · 08/07/2023 15:08

TeenDivided · 08/07/2023 11:06

I'm an adopter and my DC although they have issues and needs are not really recognisable from the descriptions above.

Suggest you post in the Adoption board for a rounded view.

How long ago did you adopt your children?

AxolotlEars · 08/07/2023 14:56

I won't share our story but I have been involved in fostering and adoption for years. I would advise against it. The needs of an adopted child are absolutely enormous. Throw in working full time and the needs of existing special kids and it's pretty overwhelming. I would say, based on my own experience, that kids on the ASD pathway need more support as they get older.

Having said all that I think adoption is a beautiful thing. Those who go into it, while sometimes feeling prepared initially, haven't lived it and are sometimes taken by surprise by the brutality of the life.

Mumtothreegirlies · 08/07/2023 14:47

RedCarrots · 08/07/2023 11:45

OK - yes, so I do agree that waiting is a good idea to see how DS gets on as he gets older.

Just a few points though - I am not looking to adopt a baby, I absolutely understand that the child would most likely have profound emotional and behavioural challenges, and that the process is gruelling. I do have my eyes open to all of that - but I do agree that it might not be in best interest for DS immediately.

I absolutely do not see any child as an accessory and I'm not sure where you picked that up @Mumtothreegirlies

I could have another baby myself, but just feel with so many older kids in need of homes - that I wanted to look at that instead. Of course we may not be a suitable family and i understand that.

But I just don’t get why you’re even considering adopting? I mean what would the child get out of it when you’re at work full time. An adopted child is likely to need a very prolonged settling in stage, and if you’re off out at work 5-6 days a week then how is that meant to work?.
there’s nothing romantic about adoption. My dad was adopted and it caused all sorts of issues in his life and his parents life. He hates his adopted sister too.
I see no reason for you to adopt whatsoever as you have enough on your plate with 2 little ones who already have you out at work, they don’t need what little time you have to give to them taken up by some child who’s likely to be very needy due to a shaky start in life.