Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unfair on DC to adopt?

186 replies

RedCarrots · 08/07/2023 10:41

Two DC (one is just at primary, one about to go). Oldest struggles a bit socially, and is bit behind, can get overwhelmed (though he is also very happy). Younger one seems to totally unfazed by anything.

I am late 30s. I have been thinking about having a 3rd baby. I love kids, and I love being a mum. I also work full time and we are lucky enough to have help.

I know very much in my heart that my desire to have a 3rd baby isn't reliant on them being biologically mine and I'm thinking about adopting. I don't want to be pregnant. And I would happily have a child, not looking to adopt a baby.

I know I have more love to give (cheeesy!) and our home feels pretty happy and functional (most of the time!)

The only thing holding me back is my other kids, my oldest one specifically. Is it an unfair thing to put upon him? He may well have ASD (or at least his old nursery thought he might) - we are doing all we can to support in that area - he is very happy and loves school, has friends, but he does definitely struggle with change and we have had to adopt some techniques to help me around that.

Am I being totally unfair to him that now he's settled at school - we could change his whole life by bringing in another child who will need so much of our focus?

OP posts:
amispeakingintongues · 09/07/2023 18:16

Nordicrain · 09/07/2023 15:42

Wow, a 25% failure rate. That's shocking. And exactly why people need to remove the rose tinted glasses from adoption. That must be incredibly traumatising for kids who have already lost their families once. Please don't do this OP unless you are 100% sure you can do it. You can't just hand them back (well you can, evidently).

What is the alternative then? They just in the foster system instead with no chance whatsoever of finding a loving forever home?

Children need a chance, especially those children dealt a shit start in life.

amispeakingintongues · 09/07/2023 18:13

I can't believe all the people on here quick to say it wouldn't be a good idea.

Adoption is hard but always incredibly rewarding, and i'd assume you'd accepted that part before writing this post. If this is truly on your heart then I think it definitely should be explored with your family. Have you asked your children how they feel about it yet? Have you asked your partner? I would suggest that being your first step.

Good luck. Adoption is something i'd love to do in future too (also have two kids) x

Ted27 · 09/07/2023 18:05

@Nordicrain

most reports I read suggest as @maybebalancing does that the ‘disruption’ is nearer 3%. That would fit with my experiences amongst my adoptive friends.
I’d also add that disruption is a compex area. The two families I know where the child has returned to foster care appear to have much better relationships with their children.
Sadly some children find family life very diffucult. Both my friends retain parental responsibilty and see their children regularly and on special occasions and maintain contact in between

maybebalancing · 09/07/2023 17:02

Although there are no official UK statistics – local authorities and adoption agencies often don’t keep track once adoption orders are signed and children leave their care – it’s believed that around three per cent of UK adoptions end in breakdown. (For context, 3,570 children were adopted from care last year ending 31 March: three percent of that would be about 107 children.) Many more come close but teeter along on the very edge. Research by Adoption UK suggests about a third of adoptions encounter no significant problems, a third encounter problems but manage to resolve them, while the final third have challenges that are severe and ongoing. The most in-depth research into adoption breakdown, carried out by Bristol University, found that cases typically involved a significant degree of child-to-parent violence, running away and serious criminal behaviour
This is 2020 magazine article that seems to tie in pretty well with what I experienced while working in this area.

Nordicrain · 09/07/2023 16:14

Ted27 · 09/07/2023 16:09

@Nordicrain

What is the source of that 25% number.

@GiraffeLaSophie I'm a single adopter, I had 13 months of work and went back 22 hours a week. If I could have afforded it I would have had at least another 6 months off. Working 4 short days was just about workable for me, at times it was very difficult and I struggled to work at all. If I'd had more than one child I don't think I could have stayed in work.
Most adopters do return to work, but often one will go part time.

Adopters also use nurseries for the same reasons other parents do, to facilitate working and yes because children can do very well in nursery settings. Depending on the number of children and the level of need, some families may have over parent at home.

PP above worked in this area and said approx 25% fail.

Ted27 · 09/07/2023 16:09

@Nordicrain

What is the source of that 25% number.

@GiraffeLaSophie I'm a single adopter, I had 13 months of work and went back 22 hours a week. If I could have afforded it I would have had at least another 6 months off. Working 4 short days was just about workable for me, at times it was very difficult and I struggled to work at all. If I'd had more than one child I don't think I could have stayed in work.
Most adopters do return to work, but often one will go part time.

Adopters also use nurseries for the same reasons other parents do, to facilitate working and yes because children can do very well in nursery settings. Depending on the number of children and the level of need, some families may have over parent at home.

Phineyj · 09/07/2023 16:04

When we applied to adopt it was made very clear that one of us would be required to give up work completely for a year. It is also a big assumption that childcare or school would actually work for an adopted child. Rates of emotionally based school avoidance are high in the UK. You'd have to at least entertain the possibility that you'd never get back to work.

GiraffeLaSophie · 09/07/2023 15:53

Mirabai · 09/07/2023 11:26

A whole year eh, well that should do it.

Is it standard for one half of a couple to give up work post adoption, at least for a while, as adoption leave is obviously not sufficient?

Not trying to make a point, genuinely interested. I know an adopted child who was in nursery, but I don’t know how old they were when the family adopted them or how many hours the parents worked.

Nordicrain · 09/07/2023 15:42

Wow, a 25% failure rate. That's shocking. And exactly why people need to remove the rose tinted glasses from adoption. That must be incredibly traumatising for kids who have already lost their families once. Please don't do this OP unless you are 100% sure you can do it. You can't just hand them back (well you can, evidently).

saoirse31 · 09/07/2023 15:39

saoirse31 · 09/07/2023 15:38

I'm not sure I agree with this tbh. I think it may be more likely that social services will prioritise children being adopted r fostered.

And it maybe for very good child helping reasons

saoirse31 · 09/07/2023 15:38

FernStoneRain · 09/07/2023 13:34

Social services would do their best to match you with a child you could cope with. That's their job.

The nanny would have more time for the adopted child if the older two are in school by then. Though the risk of her leaving would worry me. Adopted children need consistency.

Of course you can work and be an adopter. You just need some flexibility, lots of support, an understanding boss etc.

If you really want it and can make changes according to a child's evolving needs I think it's possible. We all have to change when becoming a parent. By the time you get to child number 3 you know this and are good at it.

I'm not sure I agree with this tbh. I think it may be more likely that social services will prioritise children being adopted r fostered.

saoirse31 · 09/07/2023 15:37

I think you sound lovely op, and a potential great adoptive parent. However, from my experience seeing people who adopted r fostered kids, there is a huge impact on existing children in your family. Only you can know if your children can deal with this but it is something to consider.

Ted27 · 09/07/2023 15:33

@Mischance

I too have lots of valuable experience to offer the op.
Which is a more balanced view. Personally I object to the term 'damaged' in relation to adopted children.
My son is not damaged, yes he has problems, yes we have had many difficulties along the road but he is not damaged.
I know many adopted families who have very successful families. We are not all destined for disaster.
Prospective adopters need a balanced picture.
If @RedCarrots continues to ask questions, takes on board advice and the range of experience, does the research and applies at the right time for their family there is no obvious reason why they could not adopt.
Plenty of people with birth children adopt, many adoptive families have more than one child with additional needs

FernStoneRain · 09/07/2023 13:34

Social services would do their best to match you with a child you could cope with. That's their job.

The nanny would have more time for the adopted child if the older two are in school by then. Though the risk of her leaving would worry me. Adopted children need consistency.

Of course you can work and be an adopter. You just need some flexibility, lots of support, an understanding boss etc.

If you really want it and can make changes according to a child's evolving needs I think it's possible. We all have to change when becoming a parent. By the time you get to child number 3 you know this and are good at it.

ConsuelaHammock · 09/07/2023 13:09

I wouldn’t. Could you cope with a child with additional needs? It takes a very strong person to adopt nowadays. They’re rarely babies and they come with so much baggage. I couldn’t do it.

Nousername4now · 09/07/2023 13:06

@RedCarrots From what I read in your post I don't think its suitable right now for you to adopt a child, maybe when the children are older you can think about it.

Nousername4now · 09/07/2023 13:05

Wooden handles was a mistake 🤣

Nousername4now · 09/07/2023 13:04

Some parents actually do their best to get there children back but unfortunately because social services have the power and courts most likely go in favour with the wooden handles social the child /children gets adopted..
So many cases have been documented about how children/babies being forced into adoption

Ihadenough22 · 09/07/2023 13:02

I think that you like the idea of adopting a child but the reality of doing this will be far different than you imagine. The days of getting a new born baby with adoption are long gone. Your going to go through a lot of questions, background checks ect ect with social services.
Then if your allowed to adopt a child their is a high chance that they will a lot of additional needs and not all of these will be apparent at the start.
You said that you have a nanny, can take a year off and can work from home down the line but that won't work for your family.

You can't work from home and be their for 3 kids at the same time. Nor can you expect your nanny to deal with your child who looks like they have asd and then take on another child who could have any number of issues. What happens then if your nanny decides to leave you? Your nanny's own circumstances could change and they may need to do this.

One of my friends has a child with asd. Their were non verbal when diagnosed as asd. My friend has spent hours doing speech exercises and other things to help them out both physically and mentally. She has been to doctors, speech therapists, occupational therapist, physiological services ect for appointments. Her child is now in the early stages of secondary school and is doing well considering their own circumstances.
My friend had planned to try for a 3rd child but she told me it would be unfair on X who has asd and her older child as well.

My advice to you is to start pushing for an NHS diagnosis for your child's ASD as this will help you access additional service. It could also enable you to get extra benefits that you can use for your child's additional needs. My friend who's child has ASD told me that early diagnosis and extra help early on can make a big difference to an asd child.

In your situation I would not be looking to adopt another child because your ASD child will need a lot of your time and effort as they get older in order to have the best outcome possible for them.

It not fair on your other child also that they become last on the list if you have an asd child and other child who needs a lot of help/support.

maybebalancing · 09/07/2023 12:56

I should add you do have positives as well OP.
You have experience around dc and dc with additional support issues.
You are proactively choosing this method of increasing your family.
I didn't want to be all negative.

Mischance · 09/07/2023 12:55

There are many people on here who have experience of the huge challenges that adopters face in the current absence of proper services for damaged children.

I do not think it is helpful to describe them as "doom merchants", They are people with important knowledge that the OP needs to hear and to take into account.

Excited101 · 09/07/2023 12:54

This wouldn’t be in your current children’s best interests, at all. If you are happy to actively make their lives more difficult then go ahead.

adoption can be fantastic but more often than people realise when they spout off ‘just adopt!’ It’s not. These are often highly damaged children who take an awful lot more attention than can be imagined. To the detriment of everyone else in the family. Fine to some extent when it’s the parents who made the choice, but absolutely not for any other children.

aside from the fact that this would be massively unfair to your nanny.

Adoptionisok · 09/07/2023 12:49

Hello Carrots,
HRTWT. We adopted an older child who had been to hell and back. We don’t have BC, but that was an option ie. as far as we know, we could have BC.
In our case, we firmly felt there were enough kids on the planet and didn’t want to contribute to any more. BUT we did want to be parents. Sounds very sanctimonious but there we are. It was a perfectly legitimate reason as far as SS were concerned and people adopt for a myriad reasons. You, OP, genuinely feel you want to give a child a home and that is extremely commendable. Having a BC with additional needs has probably given you some insight into caring for a child who needs extra help (although an adopted child may have very different needs) The adoption process is a gruelling one and the whole family will be assessed regarding suitability.
Our DC is now an adult, and although struggles with aspects of life, is a loving caring person. It hasn’t always been easy but definitely worth it.
Good luck with whatever you decide.

maybebalancing · 09/07/2023 12:40

Many adoption situations not my.

maybebalancing · 09/07/2023 12:37

In a past life I worked in this area specifically choosing possible adoptive parents for dc.

I would have several concerns about your situation OP.

The impact on your current dc, always a concern but significantly heightened because of the dc with SN which are likely to both need more attention and time themselves and also already leave less time for any NT dc in the family.
This situation would only be exacerbated by adding another dc with additional needs into the family.

It seems as though day to day practical care is outsourced which isn't ideal in my adoption situations particularly for younger dc. Because of your family structure you would be looking at adopting a young dc currently.

Adoption can work really well but also has quite a high failure rate thought to be up to 25 percent so placement assessment should be pretty rigorous for everybody's sake.