Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unfair on DC to adopt?

186 replies

RedCarrots · 08/07/2023 10:41

Two DC (one is just at primary, one about to go). Oldest struggles a bit socially, and is bit behind, can get overwhelmed (though he is also very happy). Younger one seems to totally unfazed by anything.

I am late 30s. I have been thinking about having a 3rd baby. I love kids, and I love being a mum. I also work full time and we are lucky enough to have help.

I know very much in my heart that my desire to have a 3rd baby isn't reliant on them being biologically mine and I'm thinking about adopting. I don't want to be pregnant. And I would happily have a child, not looking to adopt a baby.

I know I have more love to give (cheeesy!) and our home feels pretty happy and functional (most of the time!)

The only thing holding me back is my other kids, my oldest one specifically. Is it an unfair thing to put upon him? He may well have ASD (or at least his old nursery thought he might) - we are doing all we can to support in that area - he is very happy and loves school, has friends, but he does definitely struggle with change and we have had to adopt some techniques to help me around that.

Am I being totally unfair to him that now he's settled at school - we could change his whole life by bringing in another child who will need so much of our focus?

OP posts:
Mischance · 10/07/2023 09:35

I am not "making up crap" - I am very glad that your adoption has worked well - it is heartening to hear. But that does not mane that every person explaining the possible problems is making it up.

I have personal experience of this, having supported a close relative and close friend through very difficult times in relation to adoption. In one case the adoption fell through (mainly because SSD neither explained up front what the problems were nor provided proper support to deal with these) and in the other the child is now an adult in prison after SSD was not clear about the extent of brain damage suffered, and no statutory service would help throughout the whole childhood. And it was not for want of trying believe me. Some Mumsnetters will know only too well the state of CAMHS.

The first family went through hell, and found themselves blamed for the child's problems and their self-confidence destroyed - the child had sadly been in several failed adoptions, was understandably a very angry child, who made serious accusations about the adoptive father as a means of expressing their anger. This married couple were shattered and themselves damaged by the whole process.

The second family are hanging on in there with their support to their now adult adopted child in prison, but they have been through hell and are still in an impossible situation and are themselves in danger - I will not explain in detail, as it is outing.

By all means tell us the happy stories - it is wonderful to hear these - but do not accuse those whose experience has been the opposite of making up crap. I have no reason to make all this up. I want the OP to go into this with her eyes open.

Simonjt · 10/07/2023 09:17

We have an eight year old a toddler we adopted just over a year ago. Our eight year old isn’t a grenade, damaged and doesn’t have behavioural problems.

OP you would be best to post on the adoption board, there you will find people who actually know what they’re talking about, rather than people making up crap for the sake of it.

Nousername4now · 10/07/2023 08:28

MagpieSong · 10/07/2023 07:11

This is highly offensive. There are children out there who are left with severe trauma from their experiences. We’re talking about severe neglect where children’s muscles have never developed properly because they were left in a cot or car seat, children who have drunk toilet water, never learnt to speak because they’ve never been properly engaged with,
never known when the next meal is coming and constantly worry about food. Or severe abuse where they live in constant fear. Children who’ve seen a parent stab another parent, children who do the school run and bath their siblings because a parent is too drunk or high to manage, children who have brain damage forever because their mum drank alcohol while they were pregnant. Very often, these children would have died or come to serious harm had they not been removed.

As an adoptee, yes, adoption itself is a trauma, but sometimes it’s a necessary one. The courts decide that. So, yes, it’s not always what the parents want - even if a previous child in their care has died. Often parents have complex problems and have also had horrific experiences, they simply can’t care for their children (at least at that point in their lives). Some of them do fight in court, they do love their children, but the issues they’ve got needs sorting first because there’s a long road to removing a child, they’ve got chances to engage and change. It doesn’t mean it’s not a heartbreaking situation for the birth parents and we can’t have empathy for them too, but the reality is, children have to come first. Children died in the pandemic (and have died outside the pandemic too) because action was not taken to remove them. It’s not about the parents not wanting to parent in the majority of cases, it’s about them not comprehending what they need to do to safely parent and give a child a safe home where they can grow.

I'm not reading all of that, I read the first sentence and couldn't be bothered to read the rest, if you are offended on a fact based on what is documented in people's life then that is your problem not mine, nothing was stated to offend anyone. I'm an adopted person btw and I also have 2 children who are adopted by their father.

MagpieSong · 10/07/2023 07:11

Nousername4now · 09/07/2023 13:04

Some parents actually do their best to get there children back but unfortunately because social services have the power and courts most likely go in favour with the wooden handles social the child /children gets adopted..
So many cases have been documented about how children/babies being forced into adoption

This is highly offensive. There are children out there who are left with severe trauma from their experiences. We’re talking about severe neglect where children’s muscles have never developed properly because they were left in a cot or car seat, children who have drunk toilet water, never learnt to speak because they’ve never been properly engaged with,
never known when the next meal is coming and constantly worry about food. Or severe abuse where they live in constant fear. Children who’ve seen a parent stab another parent, children who do the school run and bath their siblings because a parent is too drunk or high to manage, children who have brain damage forever because their mum drank alcohol while they were pregnant. Very often, these children would have died or come to serious harm had they not been removed.

As an adoptee, yes, adoption itself is a trauma, but sometimes it’s a necessary one. The courts decide that. So, yes, it’s not always what the parents want - even if a previous child in their care has died. Often parents have complex problems and have also had horrific experiences, they simply can’t care for their children (at least at that point in their lives). Some of them do fight in court, they do love their children, but the issues they’ve got needs sorting first because there’s a long road to removing a child, they’ve got chances to engage and change. It doesn’t mean it’s not a heartbreaking situation for the birth parents and we can’t have empathy for them too, but the reality is, children have to come first. Children died in the pandemic (and have died outside the pandemic too) because action was not taken to remove them. It’s not about the parents not wanting to parent in the majority of cases, it’s about them not comprehending what they need to do to safely parent and give a child a safe home where they can grow.

KinderCat · 10/07/2023 04:13

@RedCarrots

Lots of posts really against the idea so thought I at a view that may be more neutral (hopefully) or least give my experience.

I am a teacher and have been for a decade, worked in education prior to this as well and have also recently adopted a little boy at 10 months (now 2).

Lots of people have suggested attending the information evenings if they run near you and I 100% agree with this as it is really helpful. We did a group one and a 1:1 whilst deciding and it really outlined the process to us far more clearly which is probably key as there are quite a few regional differences. Also second going to adoption board for responses.

In case it helps, our experience:
You do have to take quite a while off, but my husband only took off 10 months and I only had the standard 2 weeks plus an extra one for half term. SS were fine with this.

Training and assessment is one major consideration as this is lengthy and can be quite a lot emotionally as well just to the level of things you go through and the things you learn about. Some people do back out during this stage as it the level of need and/or trauma can be eye opening. But you do meet other adopters who become a support network. Adopters came in shapes and sizes including people with existing children who had done it before. They are great to give you realistic views on it.

Our little boy himself is very different to what a lot of posts seem to suggest. Yes he has his own background but this is where lots of people seem to be ignoring that you will work with SS to find the right match for you. You will set out how much need you can support and age and they will check they agree. You will look at profiles that will anonymously outline known and potential risks/needs etc and they will have several matching meetings to check you really can meet these realistically before agreeing to even proceed. We looked at 7 other profiles prior to our sons all with different needs, backgrounds and ages and it is so ranged . Lots of people wait longer and see more profiles so it can take quite a while. Whole process for us took over a year to train and be matched to give you and idea. You have to be 100% honest with yourself and SS about what you can support, even it seems quite pragmatic or even cold to do so as it has to be fair to the child.

You do need to consider contact as well. You adopt a child but you may well also be adopting their contact agreement. This could mean meeting up with family or siblings for that child several times a year.

SS will also being coming to visit a lot after placement to observe and check and you need to consider the impact that may have on your children day to day.

Outside of my son, I have worked with and come across a lot of children who are fostered or adopted in my job and there is such a range of "need" or effects of adoption. Some children absolutely have noticeable attachment or development issues, some have absolutely no noticeable traits at all as it were.

It will absolutely be a massive change there is no avoiding that and I do think wait a little to give your two existing children a chance to settle into their schools more fully perhaps. But only you can decide if they will cope with the change in the future but I do really think your best information is contact with your adoption provider and seeing now it works in your region and their view about it all. They may well put you in contact with an adopter to speak to and ask these questions to who can be realistic.

Good luck OP with whatever you decide.

Ted27 · 10/07/2023 01:23

@FelicityFlops

would you care to expand on that remark?.

FelicityFlops · 10/07/2023 00:39

My uncle and aunt sadly had a couple of miscarriages and then adopted.
They were super parents, but got 3 "un" super children.
One of my oldest schoolfriends also adopted. The results were not "good".
Provenance, perhaps?

Edinlassy · 10/07/2023 00:26

As an adoptive mum I find the comments of “get a puppy” absolutely disgusting.

op, I adopted my child 9 years ago when he was age 3. At the time I had a 6 year old child you has dyspraxia and add. The process is long and challenging for good reason. For them to get to know you to find the absolute best match for you and your family. There is also a rule that your adopted child must be (in my time) 3 years younger than your last bio child so they follow the natural order. I also know 5 people who adopted kids under 1 so it’s not unheard of. I just hate all the negative comments and anti adoption comments. It’s not easy and it’s a whole new challenge to raising a bio child but you know what, I have the most amazing 12 year old lad who has slotted into our family from day 1. We made it work. I just feel this has been such a negative thread from alot
of people who have not actually adopted. Whatever you decide good luck to you all

Ted27 · 10/07/2023 00:08

@determinedtomakethiswork

firstly, not every adopted child has severe behavioural difficulties, mine doesnt, I know plenty of others who don’t
secondly, as I said upthread, everyone is new to adoption at some point. We all have to go on our own personal journey, researching, questioning, challenging ourselves.
at this point there will be many things about adoption the op does not know. I dont see a problem with that

determinedtomakethiswork · 09/07/2023 23:55

To be honest, I don't think you have any idea what it would be like for you and your children to introduce someone with very severe behavioural difficulties into your home. And of course having other siblings is not always the best thing for adopted children. Anyone with such difficulties deserves full attention from the parents. This is what your own both children deserve as well.

babbscrabbs · 09/07/2023 23:19

Ted27 · 09/07/2023 21:21

@babbscrabbs

My first foster placement has just moved in. I'm 58

Oh wow ok, maybe there will be time then! Thanks

ohfook · 09/07/2023 22:38

I'm not an adopter but it's something I was seriously considering. Our local authority runs information evenings where lots of people involved come to speak and answer questions. The one I went to had some adopters, an adult adoptee, a birth mum, the person who was in charge of the foster to adopt bit and a person who worked trying to place older children and sibling groups.

It was so informative and turned many of the views/judgments I'd previously had on their head - especially when it came to birth parents and adopting an older child.

One of the adopters spoke about her child's bio mum and how she'd gone into it thinking how could someone ever do X to a child but by the time she knew the full picture, wished she could've adopted mum too to just give her some love and nurturing.

Ultimately after attending the meeting I decided that while it's still something I see in my future, now is not the right time in terms of the age and needs of my existing children. Anyway, if your local authority runs similar events, I'd highly recommend you attend.

Anothermother3 · 09/07/2023 21:47

I’m not sure if this is right for you or not. My eldest has asd and I think fostering would be very destabilising due to the change and lack of permanency. I think if you are in a position where you are approved then at least the preparation could be clear and it would be a certainty. Not sure if that makes sense. My eldest finds having 2 siblings a bit overwhelming at times but I do think that there are huge benefits - not least the ability to manage the unpredictable even if it’s not his first choice.

Isitsixoclockalready · 09/07/2023 21:24

Mojoj · 08/07/2023 11:00

Wow, no wonder there are so many kids in the foster care system desperately waiting for their own family. Yes, kids in care can have a range of issues but with the right support and a loving family behind them, they can succeed. To the OP, I would say, yes the adoption process can be arduous but that is to make sure you and your partner are the right people to adopt. Most people can have kids, only a select few can adopt. I would at least do some more research, speak to SW and then decide. Good luck.

True - my parents adopted my sister when I was 5 and my brother was 4. My sister did have a tough start in life and it was relatively tough for my parents for a couple of years but I don't remember my brother or I being second place to my sister at any point. My parents never regretted it and we never resented it. Clearly it isn't for everyone but the first few posts were so dismissive that I felt compelled to weigh in with a balance.

Ted27 · 09/07/2023 21:21

@babbscrabbs

My first foster placement has just moved in. I'm 58

Ted27 · 09/07/2023 21:19

@Mischance

We can only offer our own views and experience and my own is that using 'damage' in relation to a medical condition like brain damage is very different to describing a child as 'damaged'
For me that conjures up a whole different image of our children which is not helpful, particularly when discussions involve non adopters.
If someone has an accident, breaks their neck and becomes a wheelchair user, we would not describe that person as broken, because they have a broken neck.
I think my son would he horrified if he was to hear me describe him as damaged. He isn't, but he does have specific issues as a result of his early years.
Yes I agree that prospective adopters should have a balanced view but that includes hearing that that adoption can be a very positive experience.
My own experience has not been without challenges, at times he has brought me to my knees, but we hung in, worked through it and its paid off.
Prospective adopters also need to hear that even when they experience problems, they can come out the other side.
They also need to hear that alongside all the issues and problems, there is also ordinary life.
Adoption isn't necessarily one long disaster.

babbscrabbs · 09/07/2023 21:13

Phineyj · 09/07/2023 16:04

When we applied to adopt it was made very clear that one of us would be required to give up work completely for a year. It is also a big assumption that childcare or school would actually work for an adopted child. Rates of emotionally based school avoidance are high in the UK. You'd have to at least entertain the possibility that you'd never get back to work.

EBSA is also high among autistic children so at some point OP may find herself having a child at home regardless. Also nanny might move on. I wouldn't do it.

I'd love to adopt or foster, but have two ND children and it wouldn't be fair on them - sadly by the time they're old enough to need me less I'll be too old to foster or adopt.

ASimpleLobsterHat · 09/07/2023 21:04

DH's family did this and it did not go well. The scars that the biological children bear from it have torn the family apart. One sibling doesn't speak to the parents any more and has strained relationships with the other siblings. The adopted child doesn't have any contact with any of the family any more.

Nordicrain · 09/07/2023 20:16

That people don’t go into it on a whim is the alternative, surely.

Mischance · 09/07/2023 20:08

I am truly sorry that the word "damaged" has caused offence; but in the adoption situations that I have experience of it is the appropriate word. Several had brain damage from in utero drug or alcohol use; and others had serious attachment problems and we know that this is often associated with damage to the parts of the brain which fail to fully develop in the absence of early bonding.

It is a harsh word, but I do not think it is inappropriate.

It is lovely to hear the success stories, but there are sadly also many serious failures that are not reflected in the adoption breakdown figures - behind these there are many families where they have soldiered on so that technically the adoption has not broken down; but families have been split, marriages broken and lives have been seriously affected in a negative way by the adoption.

It is important that the OP hears both sides of the story and is clear that healthy tiny babies are not placed for adoption any more.

TMess · 09/07/2023 19:47

I wouldn’t. When I was 10 my parents adopted an 8yo and a 12yo. Obviously as an adult I fully understand that they needed to be prioritized in a way that I didn’t, and I definitely don’t hold resentment towards my parents, but it was hard and hurtful as a child to feel pushed out in my own family. All of my older biological siblings had their own lives at that point and didn’t care, but I didn’t, and suddenly I lost all my parents’ attention.

Ted27 · 09/07/2023 19:29

@amispeakingintongues

When children are taken into care a plan is made for them, according to their needs. That may include returning to the birth family.
Many factors go into deciding whether child should be fostered or adopted.
When children are first removed, it may be an emergency and they will literally go where there is a bed available - that could be foster carer or a residential unit, with no consideration given to the family dynamics because there just isn't time. So initially they may move round a bit. My son was with the same family for 3 years before he came to me.
My new foster son has had two FC placements and has been in residential care for over two years. That is a lot of stability for a child and they have done a lot of work with him. He is now ready to live back in a family environment and bless his heart he just wants a mum. We have had a month of transition meetings (much longer than my adopted son had) to see if we all agree its what we want.
To be honest Friday was one of the worst days of my life, he was heartbroken to leave his carers and I couldn't help with that grief. We are much better today and I am confident it's going to work out.
There are of course no guarantees but as long as I am happy for him to be here, the local authority will not just randomly decide to move him elsewhere. A settled, stable placement benefits everyone. As far as I'm concerned he is already my family, I'm his mum now.
Sadly some children do bounce around the system. Children's social care is underfunded, in residential care the quality of staff can be poor.
My son's sibling is in residential care and has been in at least 8 placements in the last 6 years. It seems to me that everytime there was a problem they just moved him on without anyone tacking the problems, which not surprising have just got worse.
Adoption and fostering can be very successful for many children but I would be first in the queue to say the system also leaves a lot to be desired.

@maybebalancing

I agree with everything you said

maybebalancing · 09/07/2023 19:00

@Ted27 I agree that total placement breakdown seems to run around 3%.
But any placement that may involve residential care, regular police involvement, violence in home are not successful placements in my view and they run at a much higher rate.
Adoption can work really well, around a 1/3 of cases report no significant issues at all.
But it seems important that everyone understands the potential for complications.
The lack of proper record keeping doesn't help in this area either.

amispeakingintongues · 09/07/2023 18:27

Ted27 · 09/07/2023 18:23

@amispeakingintongues

Being fostered can provide a child with a loving permanent home.
My adopted son is grown and flying the nest soon.
On Friday our foster child moved in. He will be just as loved and nurtured as my adopted son. The plan is that he will stay here until adulthood

Brilliant to hear.

I keep hearing about kids floating around the foster system though, what guarantees they get to stay with you permanently ? And how is that any different from the adoption process? If you don't mind me asking.

Ted27 · 09/07/2023 18:23

@amispeakingintongues

Being fostered can provide a child with a loving permanent home.
My adopted son is grown and flying the nest soon.
On Friday our foster child moved in. He will be just as loved and nurtured as my adopted son. The plan is that he will stay here until adulthood