Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unfair on DC to adopt?

186 replies

RedCarrots · 08/07/2023 10:41

Two DC (one is just at primary, one about to go). Oldest struggles a bit socially, and is bit behind, can get overwhelmed (though he is also very happy). Younger one seems to totally unfazed by anything.

I am late 30s. I have been thinking about having a 3rd baby. I love kids, and I love being a mum. I also work full time and we are lucky enough to have help.

I know very much in my heart that my desire to have a 3rd baby isn't reliant on them being biologically mine and I'm thinking about adopting. I don't want to be pregnant. And I would happily have a child, not looking to adopt a baby.

I know I have more love to give (cheeesy!) and our home feels pretty happy and functional (most of the time!)

The only thing holding me back is my other kids, my oldest one specifically. Is it an unfair thing to put upon him? He may well have ASD (or at least his old nursery thought he might) - we are doing all we can to support in that area - he is very happy and loves school, has friends, but he does definitely struggle with change and we have had to adopt some techniques to help me around that.

Am I being totally unfair to him that now he's settled at school - we could change his whole life by bringing in another child who will need so much of our focus?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fuckssaaaaake · 27/09/2023 23:50

I know this is quite an old post, but gosh I'm shocked at the negativity. I was adopted and my parents had 3 kids already, I am a very happy and normal (ish) person, I know my siblings love me the same as they do each other. Just wanted to add some positivity to this. I know not all situations are the same but so many are commenting with zero experience of this so thought I would add with a real life scenario

caringcarer · 27/09/2023 23:46

Everyone is being very negative but the reality is there are lots of DC who due to no fault of their own need a good home. I foster a DC who had a terrible start in life and it took time and patience but he deserves a chance for a good life just like other DC get. If you can offer a good home for a DC please do it OP. My youngest DS wasn't thrilled at first but now has offered to look after FS after he gets back from a sports holiday for 2 days whilst we go on holiday on our own.

amispeakingintongues · 27/09/2023 23:17

This. So much BS on this thread from people who have no idea.

sunshinemode · 27/09/2023 19:27

Omg I am so shocked by replies and negativity about adoption. I was an adoption social worker for 8 years and all sorts of families adopt. The assessing social should help you to think about if adoption is right for your family. Lots of families with children adopt and are very happy. Sometimes it doesn't work out but that could happen with a birth child too.

Ted27 · 26/09/2023 16:57

@KingsHeath53

I'm glad you had such a wonderful experience with your siblings but I really don't know where to start with your post.

The vast majority of adopted children have experienced abuse and neglect, they carry trauma which can have a huge impact on others in the family. Adoption is not something to be taken lightly, particularly when there are birth children.
Nor should adopted children be seen as a 'gift'
Of course there are families where there are both birth and adopted children and it works. But the op is absolutely right to consider the impact of a traumatised child with additional needs on their existing children.

KingsHeath53 · 26/09/2023 13:25

I'm so late to the party here but for any child having a sibling (whether biological or not) is a wonderful gift. My youngest sibling is 11 years younger than me, I definitely didn't want a baby in the family, and they were the best thing that ever happened to our family, bringing together me, my other sibling and parents together in loving them and caring for them. You would be giving your child another child to love, and to love them... obviously do whatever works for your family but worrying that having another sibling will be bad for your other kids is I feel not something you need to worry about

Nousername4now · 11/07/2023 07:09

MagpieSong · 10/07/2023 22:58

Of course it’s offensive, to adopters as well as adoptees. I assume having not read it, you didn’t see I’m also an adoptee. You’re calling adoption ‘forced adoption’. As an adoptee, you should realise that’s hardly a realistic rounded view of today’s adoption and wasn’t in the late 80s/early 90s either. If you compare your children being adopted by one parent, but they’re your birth children, that’s really not the same thing as a child being removed from both birth parents due to lack of a safe environment and placed with a different family. Yes, it’s a heated topic, but writing it off as forced adoption where birth parents fight to get them back but can’t simply isn’t the full picture. As I said, birth parents deserve empathy, but the child must come first. I’ll always love my birth parents and I understand why things were complex for them. Is adoption itself traumatic? Yes. But sometimes that trauma is the better option.

Like I mentioned of course it isn't offensive what I mentioned, you are now twisting my words stating I mentioned all adoption is forced adoption, which i didn't, please just stop and I stand by what I commented , have a nice day I will no longer go back and forth with you

MagpieSong · 10/07/2023 22:58

Nousername4now · 10/07/2023 08:28

I'm not reading all of that, I read the first sentence and couldn't be bothered to read the rest, if you are offended on a fact based on what is documented in people's life then that is your problem not mine, nothing was stated to offend anyone. I'm an adopted person btw and I also have 2 children who are adopted by their father.

Of course it’s offensive, to adopters as well as adoptees. I assume having not read it, you didn’t see I’m also an adoptee. You’re calling adoption ‘forced adoption’. As an adoptee, you should realise that’s hardly a realistic rounded view of today’s adoption and wasn’t in the late 80s/early 90s either. If you compare your children being adopted by one parent, but they’re your birth children, that’s really not the same thing as a child being removed from both birth parents due to lack of a safe environment and placed with a different family. Yes, it’s a heated topic, but writing it off as forced adoption where birth parents fight to get them back but can’t simply isn’t the full picture. As I said, birth parents deserve empathy, but the child must come first. I’ll always love my birth parents and I understand why things were complex for them. Is adoption itself traumatic? Yes. But sometimes that trauma is the better option.

Yoyonono · 10/07/2023 20:43

I say that as a single parent of a school refuser who has been plunged into poverty as a result

Yoyonono · 10/07/2023 20:41

I'm not anti adoption at all. Of course any child can be a school refuser or need a lot of appointments. Like an undiagnosed ASD child who has just had a massive life change may do...

Birth child or adopted child, either way best to be financially, emotionally etc. prepared and have a plan for what happens if they have any SEND or issues.

Mischance · 10/07/2023 18:26

So, if we don’t think children should be left with harmful parents, and we think they’re too damaged as a population for family life, what do we do with these little people who are literally just trying to survive in the best way they can.

This is a very good and highly relevant question. In my view they should have the opportunity of being adopted and having a normal family life, but ........ the prospective adopters should have every possible bit of information about that child - they should have the potential problems spelt out very clearly - and above all else they should have proper ongoing support throughout the whole time the child is with them - therapies and any other needs should be met. Adopters should not be left to sink or swim.

Unfortunately our public services are so depleted that it is rare that this is forthcoming.

Phineyj · 10/07/2023 17:43

Let's be honest here. If a birth child needs lots of appointments and school refuses, what tends to happen is the mum loses their job and/or marriage.

I have seen it time and time again.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/07/2023 15:54

I think adopters are often unprepared for the extent to which life changes post adoption, and just how much their priorities need to change. Talking openly about those considerations is important but when that’s presented as a “gotcha” or in a tone to dissuade someone from considering adoption it’s inappropriate and unfair.

And that’s how I read @Yoyonono comment particularly when followed with “focus on your own children” gem. The implication being of course you would do it for your “own” children but it’s an imposition to do it for an adopted (ie not your “own” child), when in fact any parent needs to consider that their child will have various appointments, may not cope with school etc.

The OP has a child with possible neurodivergence and so will have assessments and appointments for them, they aren’t coming to this with no parenting experience to draw on.

maybebalancing · 10/07/2023 15:32

But OP is at the start of this journey and not the end so surely highlighting some of the issues she needs to consider makes sense?

I have also come across some adoptive families who for different reasons have been very unprepared for the reality of the situation that they ended up in.

I hold the local authority responsible not the individual family but it was the prospective adoptive child who had the biggest fallout from this followed by the prospective parents.

As a social worker I'd like to think things are always done thoroughly but sometimes they just aren't.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/07/2023 14:41

Believe me, if you’re planning to adopt you’ll have thought through every possibility many times by the end of the process. In my circle it’s been bio parents of children with disabilities who have struggled to make the necessary adjustments because no thought was given to the possibility that their child might need more. Adoptive parents have usually developed a number of contingency plans for such an event.

maybebalancing · 10/07/2023 14:22

This is a valid point but as a parent of adopted dc you are much more likely to run into these types of issues so it makes sense to have thought about them.
It doesn't mean you will but surely thinking things through is sensible.

Simonjt · 10/07/2023 13:58

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/07/2023 11:16

How will you manage work if the child you adopt needs to attend a lot of appointments or is a school refuser or struggles to get or maintain a school place?

What do people do if their birth child needs to attend a lot of appointments or is a school refuser? These are issues parents should ask however they come to parenting, they’re hardly unique to adoptive parents.

Apparently birth children don’t have appointments, school refuse or struggle to attend.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/07/2023 11:16

How will you manage work if the child you adopt needs to attend a lot of appointments or is a school refuser or struggles to get or maintain a school place?

What do people do if their birth child needs to attend a lot of appointments or is a school refuser? These are issues parents should ask however they come to parenting, they’re hardly unique to adoptive parents.

Yoyonono · 10/07/2023 11:05

How will you manage work if the child you adopt needs to attend a lot of appointments or is a school refuser or struggles to get or maintain a school place?

I would concentrate on your two children for now, and then revisit in a few years. And I would pursue the ASD diagnosis and get support in place for your older child, things might be Ok now but can always change

Mangogogogo · 10/07/2023 10:57

Op you need to speak to people who have actually adopted. I know a few people who’ve adopted into a birth family and also a friend who was the adopted child in a birth family.

it’s a fantastic thing to do and while it takes another level of parenting you really cannot take the words of people who have no idea about adopting and just trot out the ‘all adopted kids are broken beyond repair’ line.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/07/2023 10:52

If find the level of cognitive dissonance when talking about adoption very interesting.

When a child is killed by parents or caregivers there is naturally an outcry - what were services doing, why did no one act to save that child. Very often there are questions about why the child wasn’t removed from its parents and how many people would have loved the opportunity to care for that little one.

Talk about adopting children in care though and it’s talk about how damaged, disrupted and chaotic they are, how they’ll ruin your life, harm any birth children and be a never ending source of pain.

So, if we don’t think children should be left with harmful parents, and we think they’re too damaged as a population for family life, what do we do with these little people who are literally just trying to survive in the best way they can.

Adoption is a wonderful way of creating or completing a family. Yes there are challenges, and there’s limited support out there, but my kids make me proud every single day, they’ve overcome more adversity in their short lives than most adults have in a life time. Yet according to many posters here they are too damaged, too difficult, too disruptive.

I do know that left with their birth family they’d be dead by now, I do know that remaining in the care system would have been disastrous for them, I do know that they have flourished in our family.

My career has taken a hit, life is more complex and more challenging but I wouldn’t change it for the world.

Maybe folk talking about damaged, chaotic children could remember they’re talking about children - the same children who are lamented and mourned when they aren’t protected or removed. Star Hobson, Arthur Labinjo-Hughes and all those precious children who tragically lost their lives would have needed new families, and would have shown the impact of their early mistreatment in all kinds of ways. It’s easy to talk in abstracts but these are real children needing real care not damaged goods.

Mischance · 10/07/2023 10:20

No one is saying you’re making up crap - they are - see previous poster.
I am shocked at the anti adoption stance on here. - it is not an anti adoption stance, but my experiences have ALL been negative ones. I have not listed them all.

As I keep repeating it is very heartening to hear the good stories, but that does not mean the negative ones should be ignored, or those posting their bad experiences should be slated and accused of lying or being anti adoption.

I have seen people go into this process with wonderful kindly intentions and find themselves in some very difficult situations with no help on offer.

steppemum · 10/07/2023 10:11

I am shocked at the anti adoption stance on here.

Yes adoption is not easy, and small babies are rare, but on the other hand I know quite a lot of adopted children, and they had all been in foster care since birth, and adopted at anything between 8 months and 2.5 years. So far less trauma based than the PP would have you believe.
All those adoptions are successful. Not entirely issue or probelm free, but certainly manageable, and not that different to dealing with BC with issues or problems.

I only know of one child (out of about 14 adopted kids I know) who was really hard. She was fostered from birth and then fostered into adoption from 8 months.
It turns out that she has severe and multiple learning issues, ASD, ADHD, learning difficulties and some other things.
The parents' biggest issue was that for the first 4 years no-one would listen to them saying that there is a problem as all problems were put down to attachment disorder.

A number of these adopters had BC, or had a previously adopted child as an older sibling.

If you went down this route now, it is likely to be 2 years or more before you were able to adopt. And then you would only be allowed to adopt a child 2 years younger than your youngest BC.

If you and your partner are serious about it, why not start with an information evening at your local council.

But please go over to the adoption board on here and get some opinions from those who have done it.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/07/2023 10:05

By all means tell us the happy stories - it is wonderful to hear these - but do not accuse those whose experience has been the opposite of making up crap. I have no reason to make all this up. I want the OP to go into this with her eyes open.

No one is saying you’re making up crap, but balance is important in discussions about adoption. Just because my kids are doing well doesn’t mean every child will, just because your experience is negative doesn’t mean everyone’s will be.

What I do know is that describing children as damaged, as a grenade dropped into lives, as inevitably having severe behavioural issues etc does nothing to promote reasoned decision making, because it tars every child with the same brush. Some will really struggle to overcome their early experiences (and sadly some may never get there), but others will thrive with the care, love and support of attuned parents (and professional support).

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/07/2023 10:00

To be honest, I don't think you have any idea what it would be like for you and your children to introduce someone with very severe behavioural difficulties into your home

I adopted two children, neither has severe behavioural problems, in the many adopted families I know all but one are doing really well, with no major issues. My children aren’t damaged - they are impacted by their early experiences but aren’t remotely damaged. They aren’t grenades either - they’ve turned my life on it’s head, but having kids does that.

OP you’ve had lots of information given, some of it accurate and useful, some of it well meaning but off the mark and some of it batshit crazy. That’s always the case with adoption though - it tends to bring out the best and worst in people.

The thing that I’d be thinking about is the use of a nanny. Adopted children come with very disrupted attachments and it can be very tricky for them to develop a secure attachment pattern, over a period of years in most cases. You and/or your partner would need to take primary responsibility for care giving to support attachment- some adopted children don’t cope with childcare and while a nanny sounds like an ideal solution, it could cause a lot of confusion for the child.

In many ways you sound like a good prospect for adoption, but you really need to understand any adopted child wouldn’t just slot in to your current family, work and childcare arrangements - and think about how much flexibility you have and how willing you are to change things to accommodate a child’s needs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread