Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get critical illness cover?

68 replies

Rainraingoaway10 · 08/07/2023 09:25

Looking at updating our life insurance policies.

unsurprisingly the financial advisor is touting the need for critically illness cover too, but it’s a really expensive extra payment per month

is it common for people with kids to have this coverage? My job has v good sick leave policy

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bussteward · 08/07/2023 13:00

We have it. It’s expensive due to family health history but given that very history it feels very likely I’ll get ill. At which point it will be needed. Yes it’s a boring spend, like buildings and contents insurance, but one of those “hope you never need it but glad you have it if you do need it” things.

Missgemini · 08/07/2023 12:55

Maraudingmarauders · 08/07/2023 11:48

We were warned by our IFA against going for some of the cheaper policies - not worth the paper they are written on was his description. We went for L&G in the end. Not had to use them (thankfully) so no idea if worth the extra money but we had recommendations we trust.

I think the aim is to go with a reputable company. The actual quote you get depends on your circumstances of course.
I am also with L&G and only pay £15 a month for life insurance and critical illness of almost £250k.

The £150 a month quote sounds excessive to me personally. Do shop around OP.

Maraudingmarauders · 08/07/2023 11:48

We were warned by our IFA against going for some of the cheaper policies - not worth the paper they are written on was his description. We went for L&G in the end. Not had to use them (thankfully) so no idea if worth the extra money but we had recommendations we trust.

PinkiOcelot · 08/07/2023 11:08

I wouldn’t bother. We had it and they refused our claim. Policy said something like unable to perform your job rather than any job - in the small print.

Took 9 years, financial ombudsman etc. They agreed DH couldn’t work because they way paying out on our waiver of contribution.

MumblesParty · 08/07/2023 11:00

I'm a single parent so I have cover, because if I couldn’t earn then once my 6 months sick pay ended, I’d have nothing.

Having said that, these policies are not as wonderful as they say they are. My friend’s husband had critical illness cover. He was diagnosed with a malignant brain tumour. Because he was young and otherwise healthy, he lived for 5 years, during which time my friend couldn’t work due to looking after him. The policy refused to pay out, repeatedly, and my friend didn’t actually get the money till after he’d died. She has 4 kids and it was a real struggle for her during that time.

honeylulu · 08/07/2023 10:53

I only got it last year (I was 48). Should have got it earlier really. We were advised to get it when we bought our first house. I think I was 29/30 but quickly became pregnant with first child and mortgage and nursery fees left nothing spare! I've had no serious health issues in between which was very lucky. I feel like I took a gamble saving on the premiums for those years. I think I pay £45 per month for £50k cover which I think is expensive but it covers almost all conditions which a lot of policies don't (even suicide triggered by mental illness or addiction issues, not that I'm planning to to that way!). We have paid off mortgage so 50k is enough to keep us afloat for a while to downsize if needed. I also have 25k cover as an add on to my husbands work policy though it covers less conditions. Ive got seperate life cover which pays out for death and terminal illness (£200k) and the premoium is much lower £10 a month. I feel that's about right for me/us as i also have 6 months full pay and another 6 months half pay if sick and death in service cover for 3 x salary. I did find it quite challenging working out what i did need and which levels of cover were best. It's a very individual thing depending on your circumstances.

fireflyloo · 08/07/2023 10:47

I just checked it's actually £28 for both. £9 life and £18 for critical illness. It's with vitality.

EsmeSusanOgg · 08/07/2023 10:45

I cannot get critical illness cover, only life insurance - which I have.

But I am in the union, who do provide cover regardless.

HouseIsOnFire · 08/07/2023 10:44

Can you get a anything via work? That seems extortionate!

Granted, my industry does do benefits well, but I only pay £11 pm for a £125k CI payment, surely shouldn't be costing 100 pm!

fireflyloo · 08/07/2023 10:43

I have life insurance and critical illness insurance that covers me and 1dc and pay £48 combined with a great policy.

chohiad · 08/07/2023 10:40

@lemonyellows that's why we have income protection too

lemonyellows · 08/07/2023 10:39

The problem I see is that they don't do a critical illness mortgage cover. We were quoted £85 per month for £40k lump sum. That wouldn't pay off the new mortgage we are getting. We are in 50s so assume why but still, it's expensive for not that much return.

Howdoesitworkagain · 08/07/2023 10:39

ZiriForEver · 08/07/2023 10:10

It's so expensive because combination of how high the risk is and how much money for how long time they would have to pay.

In financial sense is long serious illness worse then death for the family. The ill one doesn't work, but eats, lives, needs space, needs care and might need some home adjustments.

Not quite - Critical Illness is a lump sum, so they don’t have to keep paying out over a long period of time. I think you’re thinking of income protection, which continues to pay out if you can’t work due to ill health.

Howdoesitworkagain · 08/07/2023 10:37

CuriouslyDifferent · 08/07/2023 09:34

Had it. They refused to pay.

I was unable to work for 4 months due to shocking Nhs treatment, but they wanted evidence of me trying to get work, when I was drugged up and out of it most of the time due to pain meds.

That wasn’t a Critical Illness policy then. CI policies pay out a lump sum based on a diagnosis of a critical illness and usually surviving for a particular amount of time (and it’s quite a high bar that you have to meet in terms of how serious the illness is). It’s not related to your ability to work. What you’ve described sounds more like income protection.

mauricemossmylove · 08/07/2023 10:33

I'm also a civil servant. Took out critical illness cover when I was a single mum, cost £15 per month. It paid out 50 grand when I got MS.

JustAnotherRandom · 08/07/2023 10:32

CuriouslyDifferent · 08/07/2023 09:34

Had it. They refused to pay.

I was unable to work for 4 months due to shocking Nhs treatment, but they wanted evidence of me trying to get work, when I was drugged up and out of it most of the time due to pain meds.

Bastards. So sorry

chohiad · 08/07/2023 10:30

@Echio speak for yourself, I intend to live forever Grin but yes it made sense in my head before posting ha.

M0rT · 08/07/2023 10:28

I got cancer and was out of work for two years. My job has excellent sick cover but it is not indefinite.
I'm back in work full-time mainly because I am not cancer free and expect to become too ill to work again and don't know how long that will last before I die so want to maximise my entitlement to sick pay etc for that period of time.
If I had critical illness I would have cleared the mortgage and be able to work part time now.
I'm early 40's.
I recommend it to everyone.

Merrygoraand · 08/07/2023 10:22

Our 160k cover (not decreasing) life insurance and critical illness for myself and DP is £130 p/m. First insurers quoted refused to cover due to my family history.

Wonder if you might be able to get the quote down at all. Your mortgage advisor will want the business, so benchmark and see what you can get yourself. Then ask him/her to match.

We aren't a high income family at all, so it's a lot to pay each month...but then that's why it's so important for us to have it. I personally wouldn't count sickness policy at work as a good enough cover.

jackstini · 08/07/2023 10:17

That seems expensive so I would shop around

We only have life cover until the youngest DC is 21, rather then unending

If you still can't afford both, I would do critical illness over life insurance. You are far more likely that one of you will get a critical illness before retiring than die

Batalax · 08/07/2023 10:16

My mortgage was paid off when I had cancer even though it was caught at an early stage.
It’s one of the things that you have to work out if it’s worth the risk to you.

Echio · 08/07/2023 10:14

chohiad · 08/07/2023 09:32

Yes, because you're statistically more likely to get ill than you are to die. I have critical illness, and income protection on top of our life cover. (DH can only get CI and life due to his job).

Hahahaha!!! I know you don't mean it this way but... no! You are 100% guaranteed to die. You might not get ill (if you die by some kind of one-off-freak thing that involves no illness period).

But I do know what you mean- you're more likely to need cover for illness because you're more likely to get ill during the period of your mortgage than you are to die during it.

PauliesWalnuts · 08/07/2023 10:14

I pay £95pm for 20 years of joint life and CI cover to the end of my mortgage for a payment of £100k.

For me the CI was more important than the life cover as I have no dependents. But at the time I had a poor occupational sick pay policy, and don’t have any family - there would be nobody to ask for help, either financially or practically. I wanted the reassurance that the mortgage would be paid, and could pay a cleaner, or nurse, or whoever, to come in and help.

There is a lot of cancer in my family and it’s always terminal - I have nobody left. I also have PCOS which bumped the premium up as well as family history.

If/when I get cancer, I need to be able to put every effort into getting better, not worrying about money.

And if I don’t get ill I’ve paid out £24k over twenty years which I won’t get back, but I’ll still be alive, and when your mum died at 53, your dad at 63 and your sibling at 47, then that’s an achievement in my family.

PyjamasToMyLeft · 08/07/2023 10:12

If you have a low mortgage and good sick pay, you might be better off shopping round for a lower level of cover that covers more conditions.

Being ill long- term, or the knock-on effects of aggressive treatment is expensive - maybe going part time, retiring early, maybe your partner going part time to support you, costs of getting to hospital appointments, maybe can’t get train to work anymore, need more help around the home or move to somewhere better suited to (even just to move somewhere where you have a drive vs having to walk from parking the car up the road). If you can afford to give yourself some extra protection that’s sensible in my view. We certainly can’t rely on support from the state.

Coffeetree · 08/07/2023 10:11

Eyesopenwideawake · 08/07/2023 09:32

I'm (many!) years out of the world of insurance but there (used to be) several cheaper and less 'sexy' policies that were more appropriate than CIC for young families - Family Income Benefit, a type of decreasing life cover that pays an income rather than a lump sum on death, and Permanent Health Insurance which covers up to 75% of your income if you are unable to work for medical reasons.

Maybe have a chat with a fee based IFA who can advise you without the pressure of commision?

Thank you, this is really helpful!