Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for feeling a little bit envious?

36 replies

Embelline · 08/07/2023 09:02

I’ve changed a few details as I know my sister is on here but I’m feeling really jealous of her new relationship. I’m REALLY happy for her, but it doesn’t change the envy.

quixk summary: I broke up with DH after finding out he had cheated, I briefly got together with my best friend who is male but it didn’t go well, and now DH and I are trying to make things for work (we have a three year old DS). It’s going well, but I think it’s fair to say I’m not misty eyed with the romance of it all.

Dsis had a failed marriage, then stayed happily single for a while before getting together with her childhood friend (male) which to be honest wasn’t a surprise to anyone, they were made for each other. They hadn’t been in touch the whole time like me and my best friend, so that side of it was a surprise, but had a very intense bond as children and literally just clicked back together and are in the midst of a bit of a whirlwind romance now.

I’m thrilled for her genuinely but I also have this gnawing jealousy. It all seems like she’s getting her (well deserved) happy ending and it’s making me look at my situation and think “is this mine?” I can’t work out if I’m envious of the new thrill of a new relationship or if I’m envious it’s actually worked out with her friend where it failed with mine. Which would be awful if that’s the case because as I say, I’m trying to make things work with DH and it’s actually going really well.

We are going on a family holiday this year with dsis and her partner and Our parents and I’m kind of dreading it. She’s excited about it and excited about life in general and I’m just finding that I’m taking a step back and avoiding her a bit :(

AIBU to feel this way? Someone tell me to give my head a wobble.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PowerBMI · 09/07/2023 06:53

A shared history isn’t a reason to stay together.

You say you love your husband. Do you though? or do you just have a shared history means you have some feeling for him. And it’s easier to get back with him rather than go through all the upheaval of divorce.

If you had always been in love with him, you wouldn’t have got with your best friend would you? You wouldn’t have risked such an important friendship when you were in love with someone else. You wouldn’t have have done that to your best friend.

I suspect your feelings aren’t really jealousy. I suspect it’s making you think about your relationship and you aren’t happy in that relationship. You are trying to make it work, because it seems to make sense. But it’s not really working for you is it?

I wouldn’t bet on their honeymoon period ending to make you feel better. Sometimes it doesn’t. He may look at her he does forever. He may open doors and hold her hand forever. Some people do. You can’t sit and wait for their excitement and happiness to die down so you feel better.

My exhs grandparents whole marriage was a honeymoon period. He adored her. Even in their later years he looked at her like she was a goddess sent to bless him. They even died within days of eachother. Once she was gone he gave up. If your sister and her Dp end up like this, what will you do to make yourself feel better?

Fillyourshoes · 09/07/2023 06:33

JeandeServiette · 09/07/2023 05:33

Your subconscious is telling you that "making a go of things" with your cheating spouse isn't the way to be happy.

It's not a choice between the existing spouse and a childhood friend, either, FWIW.

Good point

JeandeServiette · 09/07/2023 05:33

Your subconscious is telling you that "making a go of things" with your cheating spouse isn't the way to be happy.

It's not a choice between the existing spouse and a childhood friend, either, FWIW.

Fillyourshoes · 09/07/2023 05:28

Why?

because surely your family know that your DH betrayed you and their niece / granddaughter very very badly and very recently.

Surely your dh feels somewhat sheepish

will your sister be bringing her children too if she has any?

Embelline · 08/07/2023 21:03

Fillyourshoes · 08/07/2023 15:23

This holiday has all the makings of something very unpleasant and tense

Because of my feelings of envy? Or because of what happened with DH? I'm not worried about the latter.

OP posts:
Embelline · 08/07/2023 20:43

No not my brother. Doubt he'd be on Mumsnet. But that's all I'll say on that.

Anyway, thank you for those who have given advice, you're probably right. I think I kind of said in my post that I am questioning things and I'm not sure if it's because I'm envious, or it's the fact that I'm envious that's opening my eyes if you see what I mean.

I don't want to go into details about the affair/what my family think etc as that's not what the thread is about and not why I'm dreading the holiday. I'm just dreading constantly comparing us to them.

Yes we did have a honeymoon period, and I know realistically that that is what they are in right this moment but I see how they are together and it makes me feel sad. They're just so made for each other and I'm almost sad for her that they didn't realise sooner, even though we're all happy they've finally realised now. Have you ever just been around a perfect couple and felt a bit wistful? And before anyone suggests it I'm not secretly hankering after her partner, it's not anything like that.

Making her happiness about me is Selfish I know. Which is why I'm ranting on here and not to anyone in real like because I can see I don't come out of the rant covered in glory.

A poster asked what was going on with me and DH and why I gave him another chance - we've been together a long time, I love him, we have history and a child together and I wanted to. I might be naive and maybe I'll regret it but I think I would regret it more if I just washed my hands of the whole thing.

I guess I just wanted to hear that it's a normal way to feel.

OP posts:
Fillyourshoes · 08/07/2023 15:43

Superfood · 08/07/2023 15:41

I presume you think your sister won't recognise herself because she's actually your brother.

In any case, don't try to stay married to someone who cheated on you. Basic error.

ah yes, a brother

Superfood · 08/07/2023 15:41

I presume you think your sister won't recognise herself because she's actually your brother.

In any case, don't try to stay married to someone who cheated on you. Basic error.

Fillyourshoes · 08/07/2023 15:38

Would I be right in thinking that you are still panging for your school friend lover?

Fillyourshoes · 08/07/2023 15:25

Did you not a honeymoon period with your DH

i recall mine all to well. The passion, the fact that you want to be with them so much and when you’re not, you’re counting down the days. The sex!

and then it evolves with time. Hopefully into an enduring and supportive and solid relationship.

Fillyourshoes · 08/07/2023 15:23

This holiday has all the makings of something very unpleasant and tense

Embelline · 08/07/2023 15:01

Sorry, long day.
I got back with DH because I wanted to, I love him, we have a lot of history, we have a child.

Posters who have said it’s probably more about me and my life are probably spot on, it hasn’t turned out how I thought it would and I am a bit of an old romantic at heart. I guess I really believed in the happy ever after.

I think it stems from seeing how much he clearly adores her, the way he looks at her, the small things he does like holding doors open and holding hands etc which we don’t really do anymore. But we have been together a lot longer and I do appreciate that it all dies down eventually.

I do need to give my head a wobble!

And again, I’m very confident that the situation will not be recognisable to my sister from this post but I can’t say why, as then it WILL be obvious!

OP posts:
Embelline · 08/07/2023 09:49

I am coming back in just on my way out so will catch up properly when I’m in thanks for all the replies

OP posts:
Togiveandtoreceive · 08/07/2023 09:45

Op are you coming back?

noglow · 08/07/2023 09:43

Embelline · 08/07/2023 09:04

I have changed a fair few, don’t worry. I switch around details whenever I post as well just incase.

I'd still work out it was me if all the best friend childhood friend holiday stuff is accurate

mondaytosunday · 08/07/2023 09:41

Natural to feel a bit envious, but come on, she's been through a divorce and now has found happiness, do you think she might have been jealous of your relationship during that time? Maybe. Did she not want to see you then? And don't you think you can find happiness again too? Seems sad that you can't separate your sisters happiness from your own circumstances.

Pinkdelight3 · 08/07/2023 09:38

it’s making me look at my situation and think “is this mine?”

Surely it's all about this and not really about your DSIS at all. You believe (rightly no doubt) that you're worth more than a DH who cheated on you. Your sister's current happiness may be shining more of a light on that than you'd like, but it's really all to do with you and DH, so you have to commit to the long-term goal of believing that making it work is the right thing to do for you (not just for your DC) and so there's nothing to jealous of because this is what you want, or else accept that you're never going to feel that way and that anything like your sister's situation is going to make yours feel inadequate. Either way isn't easy and I'm sorry DH has let you down like this, but it's him and your marriage that you need to focus on as the issue, not your sister at all. You can only be glad for her.

happyfoot · 08/07/2023 09:25

I suspect your jealousy about your sister is really about your own doubts about your decision to get back with your husband who cheated on you. Jealousy usually comes from a place of hurt and fear about an aspect of our own lives. Eg if your husband hadnt cheated and you were wildly happy, you wouldnt give her relationship a second thought.

Dont get distracted by her circumstances, thats a red herring, instead, have a look at whats really underneath this feeling and what it might be indicating to you about your own decisions.

pilates · 08/07/2023 09:21

Maybe you are feeling like this towards your sister as you are feeling insecure in your relationship. Are you having doubts that you can make it work?

WimpoleHat · 08/07/2023 09:19

I think it’s natural to feel a bit jealous - human nature unless you’re an incredibly selfless and generous type. So accept it and own that it’s not your finest hour and try not to
let it spoil your holiday or your relationship with your sister. Think about it this way - would you want her to be with an arse and unhappy? Of course not. So this is about you and how you feel about your own relationship. You’re getting some new fresh insight into you and how you feel about your own situation. And that’s ultimately going to be helpful to you.

Hotterthanhades · 08/07/2023 09:18

I think envy can be a useful emotion as it makes you see what is missing from your life. It shows us what we really want in life.

I don’t think this is about your sister. This isn’t because you resent her. It’s about what’s missing in your life.

life hasn’t turned out the way you want. Are you sure you want to try again with your husband?

Togiveandtoreceive · 08/07/2023 09:13

Presumably your family know about your husband’s affair?

how long have you been giving it a second go

not sure how happy I’d feel about someone joining that I know hurt my daughter / sister and granddaughter/niece so badly

Caravanvirgin · 08/07/2023 09:11

I wonder if this jealousy cause is really your poor relationship with your DH. What is going on there? He cheated and then you split up and now you’re back together. Why have you decided to give it another go?

Createausername1970 · 08/07/2023 09:11

You aren't being unreasonable. I think everyone has moments of questioning their own situation in comparison to others.

You are dealing with the aftermath of your DH cheating. This is a big thing and I respect you for giving it another go, many wouldn't. I wouldn't get too hung up on your sister's apparent happily ever after situation. Many relationships start this way, but it will tone down after a while.

Be happy for your sister, give your head a very gentle wobble, and look after yourself and concentrate on what you want.

Embelline · 08/07/2023 09:10

Tbh that’s my fault, I should have declined the holiday but our parents are getting older )obviously! Everyone does!) and dad isn’t in brilliant health and I guess I kind of thought it would be a nice thing for us all to be together.

OP posts: