Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the majority of women would leave their DH/DP

460 replies

NoLeaveIt · 07/07/2023 23:47

…. If they could have the same standard of living and home without them.

I’m interested to see what proportion of MNetters are actually happy with their lives with their partners rather than just trapped by practicalities of life and finances.

OP posts:
RatatouilleAndFeta · 08/07/2023 18:18

Yep can't vote on the app

ThisIsntDanicaBritannica · 08/07/2023 16:45

If I won the lottery tomorrow, I'd still stay with dh. He's not perfect, in the past he's been a right bell end, but he has proved to be a keeper and a great support to me. Plus he makes an amazing fried egg sandwich!

JamieFrasersfurrysporran · 08/07/2023 16:45

JorisBonson · 07/07/2023 23:52

Fats? Days!! 😄

I did wonder 🤣

Qilin · 08/07/2023 16:42

NoLeaveIt · 08/07/2023 00:10

40% are voting YANBU but all the comments support YABU

I posted but not voted as on the app, and voting isn't possible on the app.

Qilin · 08/07/2023 16:39

No. Been married to dh almost 25 years now, together for 33 years, with a 21y daughter. Very happy with our life together.

My life would be much poorer without dh in it, and I don't mean financially.

gwenneh · 08/07/2023 16:32

Blossomtoes · 08/07/2023 12:08

this is only because DH enabled me to do that by doing half of everything and taking a step back in his career when the kids were small.

I think that’s as much of a myth as a SAHP facilitating a high earners’s career. My bloke was away Monday to Friday and did nothing so we had a cleaner. My highflying stepson has an equally highflying wife and he’s frequently away for weeks at a time. Her career is being enabled by her mum, her MiL and a twice weekly cleaner.

Not a myth, DH did the same for me. We definitely had no cleaner, no family nearby, and no one else barring each other. We juggled a lot while I went back to school, but the end result is that we both earn relatively equal salaries now and are quite comfortable. I don't think it's terribly unusual; I only did it myself after another friend of mine did the same, which is what inspired the thought in the first place.

FFSCarrieBradshaw · 08/07/2023 16:13

leftshark · 08/07/2023 05:25

@TMess a genuine question. I love my partner very much, but I really wouldn’t give up my flat to live in a tent with him. Can you tell me a bit more about your relationship and why you would say this? I’m interested as my partner and I are talking about cohabiting; he has a house and a 6 year old and I have my own flat; i love them both but if the options were to be by myself in my flat or with him in a tent I 100% know I would of course choose my flat. But there have been a decent amount of posters who seem to think their husband/partner is their best friend and one and only, so perhaps I’m wrong?

@leftshark I will tell you a fact, and undoubtedly, loads of posters will come on to tell me I'm wrong.

BUT I would absolutely and in no way EVER have a relationship with a man with a young child. It's just a no-go for so many reasons.

Primarily, why is a man with a young child single?

As you've seen from this thread, women stay in relationships that are less than ideal because it's easier than going it alone. So he was either such a shit father that it was easier for his ex to be a single mother, or, he was reproductively careless.

Neither one of those shouts 'great potential partner'.

Stay in your flat. Do not blend your good life with this man. Don't.

My husband is a brilliant person I would rather live in a tent with him than anywhere, we've been together for over 20 years and we get each other. Our relationship isn't difficult, it's easy.

I'd rather be single than with a 'complicated' partner. Single life is great. Don't give that up for anything less than a person that enhances your life, that makes you better than you are alone.

Couples are great when they really work. BUT it's not some kind of Platonic ideal. It's not necessarily something to strive for.

If you find 'That' person and they're steady and calm and share your values, and humour and intellect, amazing, you've won one of life's lotteries.

If not, hey, I would rather be by myself for eternity than be with someone who didn't really understand me. Because when you couple-up, particularly if you are an independent woman, you are giving something away. Make sure it's worth it.

Purplepeaches123 · 08/07/2023 15:25

Yea2023 · 08/07/2023 10:48

I’ve never understood this, like when ppl say ‘he’s out for the night/weekend I can eat, watch do what I want’?

what?

what do you normally do?

I agree. We wouldn’t have lasted this long in that sort of relationship!

TMess · 08/07/2023 15:06

leftshark · 08/07/2023 05:25

@TMess a genuine question. I love my partner very much, but I really wouldn’t give up my flat to live in a tent with him. Can you tell me a bit more about your relationship and why you would say this? I’m interested as my partner and I are talking about cohabiting; he has a house and a 6 year old and I have my own flat; i love them both but if the options were to be by myself in my flat or with him in a tent I 100% know I would of course choose my flat. But there have been a decent amount of posters who seem to think their husband/partner is their best friend and one and only, so perhaps I’m wrong?

It’s so hard to explain the inner workings of a relationship, but I basically just mean that if the choice were anything (nice house, or any house, for example) vs being together I’d choose being together. We’ve been through some difficult situations especially in the earlier years of our marriage (death of a child, loss of jobs etc) and we’ve always become tighter as a unit through it. I’d sooner lose a limb than be without him, and I realize that all sounds very dramatic lol but it’s genuinely how I feel.

alabamathunderpussy · 08/07/2023 14:58

I would. But he would not have the same standard. I care for him a lot so for that reason i wouldnt do it to him. If he left me for a happier life, i would not he sad.

Starseeking · 08/07/2023 14:35

If you'd have asked me this question 2.5 years ago, I would have said yes, because I was in the process of leaving my then DP.

Even though we weren't married, it still took me about a year to leave once I'd made the decision, due to how much our lives were intertwined after 6 years together (at that tie).

We had two DC, plus he had a NR DC, a mortgaged house, shared car with loan attached, a joint account and joint bills. I was financially independent, and earned a large salary more than double my EXDP's so I could have left at any time, but it took careful planning to do so.

The whole process of unravelling our lives together was so exhausting that personally I think things have to have got really awful in the relationship before a number of women will leave, especially if they have DC. With me I knew it was the end of the relationship it was when my ex started being emotionally abusive towards me in front of my then 3 and 4 year old DC.

If life is just about bearable in a relationship which isn't really working, I suspect a lot of women just put up with it, in the same way a lot of men stay in ok relationships until they've found someone they feel is better for them to pair up with.

Thepeopleversuswork · 08/07/2023 14:34

I earn three times what my OH does so this wouldn't apply. I would never stay with someone purely for financial reasons and in fact this situation scares me so much that I avoid men who earn more than me and would never marry.

Being financially entangled with someone is my worst fear tbh.

morejumpingfrogs · 08/07/2023 14:22

badluckorbadvibes · 07/07/2023 23:51

I could have the same standard of living without him. I quite like him though.

Came in here to say this!

IknowYouButIdontLikeYou · 08/07/2023 14:12

Been married for 43 years (AC). Financially struggling at the moment, but the mortgage was paid off years ago. I can't imagine life without my husband, he's looked after me for the past 2 years.

FFSCarrieBradshaw · 08/07/2023 14:10

I don't think people do change, not that much. I do possibly think that women overlook that they've married an absolute arse when children are small, because unless they're actively abusive, and they're just low-grade shitty blokes, I guess it's easier to keep on keeping on. Then when the children are independent peoples, the scales may fall from the eyes and you realise you've pegged yourself to an utter tosser. I get it.

I had a very brief first marriage (5 years), we lived outside the UK, when I got to 29 I realised I actively wanted children, I also realised 'not with this wanker though' and that was the push I needed to leave. I could have stayed and had children with him, it would have been the 'safe' option, I understand why and how women do it. So you'll get no judgement from me.

BUT I'd now be a woman that hates her husband and is just staying because I stayed, and now it's too difficult to go.

BabyDubsEverywhere · 08/07/2023 13:54

If I left tomorrow I'd be in the same position I am today - we don't have a pot to piss in. Half of nothing would still be nothing.

But, I wouldn't leave DH for all the money in the world. He lives and breathes for me and our DC and I feel both lucky and proud to say he's mine and I'm his.

Springbecamethesummer · 08/07/2023 13:49

It's good to see so many happy with their partners, it's interesting to see how many couples split after a big lottery win.

Milk2SugarsAndAShotOfYourFinestValium · 08/07/2023 13:42

User135644 · 08/07/2023 13:25

You wonder why all these women get married in tge first place. Or is it just a business transaction?

I think as @LadyOutside and @Hopelessromatic have demonstrated with their posts - things and people change. It's why - despite being happily married myself - I could absolutely be convinced many women would leave if it were easy. Marriages aren't guaranteed to last even if they start with mad passionate love. I don't think that's even a particularly cynical way to think.

NoLeaveIt · 08/07/2023 13:30

User135644 · 08/07/2023 13:25

You wonder why all these women get married in tge first place. Or is it just a business transaction?

Probably the vast majority got married for love (as do men). That doesn’t mean they are obligated to stay in a shitty marriage for life if it doesn’t turn out well

OP posts:
LadyOutside · 08/07/2023 13:29

Up to around age 35 I adored my DH and couldn’t imagine life without him.

Now at 45 I fantasise about seeing his dead body and look forward to living alone one day.

Most women I know in their 40s say they would prefer to be without their husband now. I think there’s a lot of reasons for this.

For me, my DH literally changed personality when he got anxiety/depression. He is now angry, argumentative and doesn’t appreciate anything I’ve done for him. I don’t know if the anxiety/depression made his true self come out or if it changed his brain some way (it was very severe catatonic depression).

He’s recovered now but our relationship hasn’t. I’m still here because I don’t want to disrupt the DC in their exam years and he refuses to leave the house.

Friends the same age have all got their own stories of why they are just tolerating their husbands now. We all agree it changed around 15 years after marriage.

User135644 · 08/07/2023 13:25

You wonder why all these women get married in tge first place. Or is it just a business transaction?

Cosycover · 08/07/2023 12:47

Nah I wouldn't.
But I do know many who absolutely would. Which is a shame.

FFSCarrieBradshaw · 08/07/2023 12:45

PS @denpark, it's quite easy to tag...

FFSCarrieBradshaw · 08/07/2023 12:44

denpark · 08/07/2023 02:16

I can't tag the CarrieBradshaw poster but, no, it's actually not one friendship group. It's people that I've met over the years via school/university/work/random baby groups/my own family etc etc. pretty much every couple has split.

Not sure why but I reckon people are realising that the do not have to stick it out and that women manage perfectly well on their own. I think it's a bit of a culture shift.

The only thing that all of the women that I know have in common is that they've all got degrees and post-grads/doctorates. Not sure if that makes a difference but that's the only common factor! Not all have children.

Ok @denpark, gosh, not sure how to unpack that comment but...

Guess what? Women my age also know quite well that we do not need a man, I'm the daughter of a second-wave feminist, I was a Greenham Common with my mother, I don't need lessons from a 30-odd year old thank you.

And if every woman you know has a degree, you need to widen your social circle, frankly.

If there is a culture-shift, it's that men have got shitter, not that women have got wiser. And I think that at your age you have hit a perfect shit-storm of men, xenniel men are the absolute worst I think.

KinderCat · 08/07/2023 12:39

I can't imagine leaving mine no. Hasn't always been smooth sailing but he is my rock when all is said and done and my life is better for his presence in all ways which I also say as the main earner.
Aware this is a bit soppy sounding though 😅