Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men’s Asylum seeker accommodation next to school

569 replies

chibcha · 07/07/2023 22:36

I feel quite ashamed by how I feel but want to know if it warranted.

There has been an announcement that a 500 men’s asylum seeker accommodation is going ahead against councils decision (it was overruled on a national scale). This is Stafford btw

It will be butted up to (no gap) to my DCs school and opposite a nursery. It’s not because they are asylum seekers that concerns me. It’s the fact it’a 500 men unit, with many with no known history / criminal records/ mental state.

I work over an hour away and currently my daughter who is 12 walks to the bus etc, she also does after school clubs then walks home alone. Most parents at the school are talking about moving their kids but in reality and logistically that’s not going to happen.

I genuinely feel scared for her safety. AIBU?
Its the location of it that’s wrong and the fact the council stated issues and concerns so refused it but got overruled by the government…

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Maireas · 09/07/2023 14:05

Gooniesnecersaydie · 09/07/2023 12:01

Not sure about that.

It is of course absolutely the case that women and girls will suffer. But the criminal gangs are predominantly targeting boys for criminal exploitation.

Both sexes are paying a price here.

Yes, but I'm sure that you can see that women and girls are more vulnerable for obvious reasons.

Bubblyb00b · 09/07/2023 14:02

I haven't seen any of these facilities as I live in Central London (we have our own problems here) but are these people just hang about all day on the street? Are these facilities not secure? I thought our glorious government is worried these pesky asylum seekers will escape and is keeping them behind high walls?

I would wait and see what is happening, if it is a problem I would complain, report it to the police and if things get really bad - move my kid to another school. You also have to keep in mind that it will probably take a couple of years for the facility to be up and running, and a lot can change in this time.

Also, for the people saying "why they are all man" - yes, a lot probably come to earn money for their families (which is a terrible crime, I know); but you have to keep in mind how dangerous the journey is - a lot of females and kids just don't make it. Sad reality but young men are the fittest and survive what weaker mums and kids would not.

Westcoastwoman · 09/07/2023 13:53

Zipidydodah · 09/07/2023 11:30

FFS. I understand MN is predominately left wing but I can’t work out whether people are being deliberately disingenuous or are just stupid.

Do posters really believe that the immigration crisis currently engulfing the whole of Europe is due to “Tory mismanagement”
and “Brexit.”
Are the Tories in power in France where there are migrant riots almost every year? Where vast areas of Paris and Calais are now essentially slums?
Are they in power in Germany where women can no longer take part in street parties or celebrations for fear of sexual assault? Do you think it’s now not happening because the media don’t bother to report it anymore?
Or Scandinavia where their whole society and culture is having to change to ‘accommodate’ the delight that is the misogynistic culture of the African / middle eastern men that dominate the migrant population.
Did Greece brexit too then as small boat crossing to their islands have increased over 400% in the last 5 years?

Or could it be, just maybe, that the spread of information across the world due to the invention and then increasing accessibility of the internet means that millions of people would like to leave their countries that are generally rife with endemic corruption and war (usually in the name of some religion or other but actually about power and money) for Europe/western society. Because these countries are actually pretty good as the world goes.

By the mid-2022, all around the world there were:

  • 32.5 million refugees and
  • 53.2 million internally displaced persons (due to conflict and violence).

They can’t all move to western counties.

People are going to have to do the hard stuff that every westernised countries people did in the past. Fight, overthrow, vote, protest until their own country ‘develops’ and takes on the values they want and be part of the economic development of their own country.

This is not a “Tory issue” 🤦‍♀️

Brilliant post that sums it all up. 👏👏

Anxioys · 09/07/2023 13:35

Of course it's a terrible idea. I have never understood the appetite for accepting asylum permanently from countries with social values towards women that are so different from our own. What's the upside for the UK in that?

Paul2023 · 09/07/2023 13:28

The difference with Ukraine refugees is that we know who they are, they were approved before they were permitted to enter the UK.

Id imagine alot of them would like to return home once it’s safe too.

Gooniesnecersaydie · 09/07/2023 12:21

JamSandle · 09/07/2023 12:07

It's also been stark to see Ukrainian people stay and fight the Russians while the women and children have been sent away.

Surely that's the right way round?

Yes. But Ukrainian refugees are already well supported to enter the UK under the Ukrainian sponsorship scheme aming others. Ukrainian nationals displaced by the war aren't asylum seekers in the UK.

JamSandle · 09/07/2023 12:07

It's also been stark to see Ukrainian people stay and fight the Russians while the women and children have been sent away.

Surely that's the right way round?

lollipoprainbow · 09/07/2023 12:06

Brilliant post @Zipidydodah

Gooniesnecersaydie · 09/07/2023 12:01

Maireas · 09/07/2023 11:48

I think you are spot on, @Zipidydodah .
Also, @JamSandle - it is women and girls who will pay the price.

Not sure about that.

It is of course absolutely the case that women and girls will suffer. But the criminal gangs are predominantly targeting boys for criminal exploitation.

Both sexes are paying a price here.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/07/2023 11:59

Superb post, Zipidydodah

It's true the various "sides" try to make this a party political issue, just as they do with anything where there's a chance of a vote, but to suggest that's all it is scampers along the margins of the surreal

For me it's an area that needs proper adult conversations, but good luck with that when the subject's so emotive and offers so many chances for mudslinging

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 09/07/2023 11:58

It’s clear that with Labour, you will get open borders, that’s what they believe in.

Something to look forward to.

Maireas · 09/07/2023 11:48

I think you are spot on, @Zipidydodah .
Also, @JamSandle - it is women and girls who will pay the price.

JamSandle · 09/07/2023 11:46

Zipidydodah · 09/07/2023 11:30

FFS. I understand MN is predominately left wing but I can’t work out whether people are being deliberately disingenuous or are just stupid.

Do posters really believe that the immigration crisis currently engulfing the whole of Europe is due to “Tory mismanagement”
and “Brexit.”
Are the Tories in power in France where there are migrant riots almost every year? Where vast areas of Paris and Calais are now essentially slums?
Are they in power in Germany where women can no longer take part in street parties or celebrations for fear of sexual assault? Do you think it’s now not happening because the media don’t bother to report it anymore?
Or Scandinavia where their whole society and culture is having to change to ‘accommodate’ the delight that is the misogynistic culture of the African / middle eastern men that dominate the migrant population.
Did Greece brexit too then as small boat crossing to their islands have increased over 400% in the last 5 years?

Or could it be, just maybe, that the spread of information across the world due to the invention and then increasing accessibility of the internet means that millions of people would like to leave their countries that are generally rife with endemic corruption and war (usually in the name of some religion or other but actually about power and money) for Europe/western society. Because these countries are actually pretty good as the world goes.

By the mid-2022, all around the world there were:

  • 32.5 million refugees and
  • 53.2 million internally displaced persons (due to conflict and violence).

They can’t all move to western counties.

People are going to have to do the hard stuff that every westernised countries people did in the past. Fight, overthrow, vote, protest until their own country ‘develops’ and takes on the values they want and be part of the economic development of their own country.

This is not a “Tory issue” 🤦‍♀️

I love everything about your post.

All this is doing is contributing to the sinking of the UK, which is already struggling.

And women and girls as they so often are will be the first casualties. But nobody really cares.

Swrigh1234 · 09/07/2023 11:38

Zipidydodah · 09/07/2023 11:30

FFS. I understand MN is predominately left wing but I can’t work out whether people are being deliberately disingenuous or are just stupid.

Do posters really believe that the immigration crisis currently engulfing the whole of Europe is due to “Tory mismanagement”
and “Brexit.”
Are the Tories in power in France where there are migrant riots almost every year? Where vast areas of Paris and Calais are now essentially slums?
Are they in power in Germany where women can no longer take part in street parties or celebrations for fear of sexual assault? Do you think it’s now not happening because the media don’t bother to report it anymore?
Or Scandinavia where their whole society and culture is having to change to ‘accommodate’ the delight that is the misogynistic culture of the African / middle eastern men that dominate the migrant population.
Did Greece brexit too then as small boat crossing to their islands have increased over 400% in the last 5 years?

Or could it be, just maybe, that the spread of information across the world due to the invention and then increasing accessibility of the internet means that millions of people would like to leave their countries that are generally rife with endemic corruption and war (usually in the name of some religion or other but actually about power and money) for Europe/western society. Because these countries are actually pretty good as the world goes.

By the mid-2022, all around the world there were:

  • 32.5 million refugees and
  • 53.2 million internally displaced persons (due to conflict and violence).

They can’t all move to western counties.

People are going to have to do the hard stuff that every westernised countries people did in the past. Fight, overthrow, vote, protest until their own country ‘develops’ and takes on the values they want and be part of the economic development of their own country.

This is not a “Tory issue” 🤦‍♀️

I agree that the left likes to make this a party political issue because, well, because they usually have no ideas of their own.

But the Tories have lied to the public. It’s clear that with Labour, you will get open borders, that’s what they believe in. The Tories, though, have lied that they would control immigration and have done the exact opposite. It’s completely within the government’s power to lower these numbers. They just don’t want to.

I think it’s very important that we acknowledge this. Our government DOES NOT want to control the borders. They want mass immigration to show economic growth even through GDP per capita drops and everyone already here gets poorer. And they want to do this because they have failed the economy through corruption. Borrowing and printing money to funnel it to their cronies.

Zipidydodah · 09/07/2023 11:30

FFS. I understand MN is predominately left wing but I can’t work out whether people are being deliberately disingenuous or are just stupid.

Do posters really believe that the immigration crisis currently engulfing the whole of Europe is due to “Tory mismanagement”
and “Brexit.”
Are the Tories in power in France where there are migrant riots almost every year? Where vast areas of Paris and Calais are now essentially slums?
Are they in power in Germany where women can no longer take part in street parties or celebrations for fear of sexual assault? Do you think it’s now not happening because the media don’t bother to report it anymore?
Or Scandinavia where their whole society and culture is having to change to ‘accommodate’ the delight that is the misogynistic culture of the African / middle eastern men that dominate the migrant population.
Did Greece brexit too then as small boat crossing to their islands have increased over 400% in the last 5 years?

Or could it be, just maybe, that the spread of information across the world due to the invention and then increasing accessibility of the internet means that millions of people would like to leave their countries that are generally rife with endemic corruption and war (usually in the name of some religion or other but actually about power and money) for Europe/western society. Because these countries are actually pretty good as the world goes.

By the mid-2022, all around the world there were:

  • 32.5 million refugees and
  • 53.2 million internally displaced persons (due to conflict and violence).

They can’t all move to western counties.

People are going to have to do the hard stuff that every westernised countries people did in the past. Fight, overthrow, vote, protest until their own country ‘develops’ and takes on the values they want and be part of the economic development of their own country.

This is not a “Tory issue” 🤦‍♀️

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/07/2023 11:30

On the subject of the centre being "250 yrads from a police station", just how high do folk suppose the chances are of the police leaping into action if an offence - even a very serious one - is reported among this particular demographic?

It's sometimes as if nothing at all was learned from Rotherham et al

DontBeAPrickDarren · 09/07/2023 10:55

LlynTegid · 09/07/2023 10:43

I would guess such a building use would not happen in Suella Braverman's constituency.

The Stafford MP is a Tory. There is interim and dispersal accommodation in every single local authority in England.

LlynTegid · 09/07/2023 10:43

I would guess such a building use would not happen in Suella Braverman's constituency.

Gooniesnecersaydie · 09/07/2023 10:42

Swrigh1234 · 09/07/2023 10:36

People here are incredibly naive. They just regurgitate whatever soundbite they last read on Twitter.

As bad as it is, the risk of death in these boats is tiny compared to the chance of earning more money in the black economy here. And specifically in the country. It used to be lorries across the channel but that route costs more because there is a higher chance of getting caught so smugglers charge a lot more for more intricate ways of getting people through the tunnel.

They would ordinarily not get travel visas to come here and disappear because they would need to show travel history, have a steady income back in their countries, or show that they have tourist visa sponsorship from someone here. Some come here and disappear that way. Many more do this via the student visa route, but that costs so much more in visa fees, having to pay a bogus college to sign on to a course etc. So paying a smuggler to cross in a boat is the cheapest way.

Once they get here, it is almost impossible to deport. Because of government policy to top up our cheap labour force to massage GDP figures and because it is expensive to get into a legal battle with human rights lawyers. It is also incredibly easy for migrants to get into the black economy.

It used to be the case that migrants wanted to disappear into the black economy, because there was at least some risk of deportation if they got caught. But now since there is no risk of that, it makes more financial sense to live in the hotels for free, go out and work - carwashes, warehouses, takeaways, restaurants, manual labour. Live for free and earn money makes a lot more sense. Someone else will usually send money back home on their behalf using money transfer services.

The rights and wrongs of what they do aside, the majority are NOT asylum seekers.

Yep. The amount of money being sent to Albania from organised crime in the UK is astonishing. And British children are also being criminally exploited to make this money.

DontBeAPrickDarren · 09/07/2023 10:40

BathroomOnTheRight · 09/07/2023 10:07

Not RTFT, only OP's post and reply, but won't the asylum seekers be locked up anyway? In the country I'm in, they're in detention, it's like a mini jail. They are not allowed to leave the property unless under armed guard. It's not like they could harm the kids because they can't leave the facility.

No. These are people awaiting asylum decisions, so not detained. Those whose application has been refused or are being deported may be held in detention centres.

Swrigh1234 · 09/07/2023 10:36

People here are incredibly naive. They just regurgitate whatever soundbite they last read on Twitter.

As bad as it is, the risk of death in these boats is tiny compared to the chance of earning more money in the black economy here. And specifically in the country. It used to be lorries across the channel but that route costs more because there is a higher chance of getting caught so smugglers charge a lot more for more intricate ways of getting people through the tunnel.

They would ordinarily not get travel visas to come here and disappear because they would need to show travel history, have a steady income back in their countries, or show that they have tourist visa sponsorship from someone here. Some come here and disappear that way. Many more do this via the student visa route, but that costs so much more in visa fees, having to pay a bogus college to sign on to a course etc. So paying a smuggler to cross in a boat is the cheapest way.

Once they get here, it is almost impossible to deport. Because of government policy to top up our cheap labour force to massage GDP figures and because it is expensive to get into a legal battle with human rights lawyers. It is also incredibly easy for migrants to get into the black economy.

It used to be the case that migrants wanted to disappear into the black economy, because there was at least some risk of deportation if they got caught. But now since there is no risk of that, it makes more financial sense to live in the hotels for free, go out and work - carwashes, warehouses, takeaways, restaurants, manual labour. Live for free and earn money makes a lot more sense. Someone else will usually send money back home on their behalf using money transfer services.

The rights and wrongs of what they do aside, the majority are NOT asylum seekers.

Gooniesnecersaydie · 09/07/2023 10:26

Boomboom22 · 09/07/2023 10:07

I'm starting to see why people don't have an issue. Many posters seem to think these are desperate people fleeing for their lives who just ran. Rather than a fully planned for months using wider family savings and paying people traffickers. It seems many people have misunderstood why the claims might be agreed. That's why the smugglers run the business, teach them what to say to be approved and part of why they come! Even a legal bod upthread explained the attitude of the lawyers for this, they know the documents are destroyed so proof is lost. Some of the help given is how to make your story good enough to meet our asylum requirements.

And the smugglers are often bringing people in specifically to engage in crime. Drug production and dealing usually. Which very often involves the criminal exploitation of British children.

BathroomOnTheRight · 09/07/2023 10:25

Gytgyt · 09/07/2023 10:11

What Country are you in?

Australia.

Gytgyt · 09/07/2023 10:11

BathroomOnTheRight · 09/07/2023 10:07

Not RTFT, only OP's post and reply, but won't the asylum seekers be locked up anyway? In the country I'm in, they're in detention, it's like a mini jail. They are not allowed to leave the property unless under armed guard. It's not like they could harm the kids because they can't leave the facility.

What Country are you in?

Boomboom22 · 09/07/2023 10:11

BathroomOnTheRight · 09/07/2023 10:07

Not RTFT, only OP's post and reply, but won't the asylum seekers be locked up anyway? In the country I'm in, they're in detention, it's like a mini jail. They are not allowed to leave the property unless under armed guard. It's not like they could harm the kids because they can't leave the facility.

Exactly why they want to come here and not other places. Our innocent until found guilty assumptions make it very difficult to justify locking people up even when it might seem sensible as they might not be who they say they are.
Anyone recall the 20 somethings claiming to be teens? Unaccompanied sent to Foster carers and schools. Quite a few issues there in both the care system and the schools for men who deliberately lie, hopefully to get quals rather than access to kids.