Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men’s Asylum seeker accommodation next to school

569 replies

chibcha · 07/07/2023 22:36

I feel quite ashamed by how I feel but want to know if it warranted.

There has been an announcement that a 500 men’s asylum seeker accommodation is going ahead against councils decision (it was overruled on a national scale). This is Stafford btw

It will be butted up to (no gap) to my DCs school and opposite a nursery. It’s not because they are asylum seekers that concerns me. It’s the fact it’a 500 men unit, with many with no known history / criminal records/ mental state.

I work over an hour away and currently my daughter who is 12 walks to the bus etc, she also does after school clubs then walks home alone. Most parents at the school are talking about moving their kids but in reality and logistically that’s not going to happen.

I genuinely feel scared for her safety. AIBU?
Its the location of it that’s wrong and the fact the council stated issues and concerns so refused it but got overruled by the government…

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Sunsetandsunrise · 08/07/2023 08:17

RafaistheKingofClay · 07/07/2023 23:41

The idea that the left/liberals are responsible for this when it’s happened under the watch of the most right wing government in living memory and is a direct result of the Home Office’s hostile environment policy is genuinely hilarious.

You can complain to your MP but it probably won’t get you anywhere. When it comes to the next election just remember that it was the Tories that ground processing of asylum seekers to a halt and meant that the only way many can get in was by crossing in a small boat.

This

Goldfoot · 08/07/2023 08:17

Goldfoot · 08/07/2023 07:59

😆 Do you know how much work the Army puts into keeping the men under control and what the penalties are for causing trouble in the community?

It is absolutely recognised by the Army that large groups of men cause harm and loads of work is done to prevent it. Even then it still happens a lot, plus often their wives and children live on the garrison with them.

Plus those men are kept occupied. The Army knows very well what happens when large groups of men have nothing to do, this is why all the nonsense work is created.

Boomboom22 · 08/07/2023 08:13

It's not racist to say 500 aimless young men cause trouble.
It's not racist to point out these are men who can afford to pay thousands to people traffickers to come here illegally so not likely they are fleeing for their lives they believe they will have a better life here, still happy to do that illegally.
The people who really do need asylum cannot afford to pay thousands and we are busy justifying the men who have so don't pay attention to those who may need help.
Judges stymie the home office in every policy they try to put in place so the people smugglers and economic migrants think we all do want them here and won't be able to do anything anyway.

Mapples · 08/07/2023 08:13

I'd hate this too, sadly speaking out about it will get you labelled a bigot and whatever else. 500 young men without any background checks probably bored shitless in close confines from cultures with varying views on women and girls is a recipe for disaster.

MichelleScarn · 08/07/2023 08:12

@Yea2023 confusion then! I assumed the 'they're more likely to be victims of crime' meant here because the poster was talking about perceived behaviour here towards young females.

EducatingArti · 08/07/2023 08:08

BadgerFacedCoo · 08/07/2023 07:27

I've never worked asylum but I've worked homeless shelters.

Large groups of men housed like this is awful. I've walked through prisons and felt safe. The hostels and shelters were awful.

Large groups of bored angry men are terrifying.

Some very naive posters shouting racism here.

Not my experience at all. I've been in my local homeless hostel for men, many times. My experience is that the men are extremely anxious and shy. Before COVID we used to visit with buffet food and chat to them. Only a few would come and chat, others would stick their head round the door, then disappear very quickly. They are used to being treated as invisible or rejected and insulted so are very wary of others ( even a majority women group with an average age of over 60).
We used to leave the food out so that they could come and help themselves once we had left.

Yea2023 · 08/07/2023 08:06

No @MichelleScarn you asked what crimes they may be victims of, I assumed you mean what crimes they are fleeing?

they are prob at risk of exploitation in the U.K. (esp considering HO have lost children and have housed as young as 9 solo in hotels).

I cannot think of any situation where 500 men just lingering with nothing to do, no money etc wouldn’t cause an issue. Govt policy needs to change.

Megifer · 08/07/2023 08:03

SunSurfSand · 08/07/2023 07:55

My fancy private school was located across from army barracks.

I don't remember anyone having any issues at all.

It might not be as bad as you think OP

A true head scratcher 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Ponoka7 · 08/07/2023 08:00

JudgeRudy · 07/07/2023 23:12

Hmm, I'm going to stick my neck out and say that it's OK. Statistically, let's say there are some 'dangerous' men in there - unless they are known paedophiles, children shouldn't be any more at risk than anyone else so being next to a school shouldn't influence.
I think if you don't feel your kids are able to recognise/avoid/report 'trouble' then you need to pick them up.
If these same people were eg next to a church or in your culture de sac would they be any more or less of risk?

The issue is that in some cultures girls from 13 are seen as women. White women/girls are seen as fair game. As once was in our society. Read the thread on the most inappropriate thing to happen, the men in the 70/80's wasn't pedophiles, the attitudes around teen girls was different. It's a mind set. There doesn't seem to be any education going on in these centers. They've brushed over the issues in Knowsley. The police went into denial. Stayed with that, but then admitted that they did have to speak to some men about sexually harassing children and then moved the men. Ask African women about African men, most women's first sexual encounter is as a child/adult man and the men don't face consequences. There can be cultural differences at play in regards to attitudes towards women.

Goldfoot · 08/07/2023 07:59

SunSurfSand · 08/07/2023 07:55

My fancy private school was located across from army barracks.

I don't remember anyone having any issues at all.

It might not be as bad as you think OP

😆 Do you know how much work the Army puts into keeping the men under control and what the penalties are for causing trouble in the community?

It is absolutely recognised by the Army that large groups of men cause harm and loads of work is done to prevent it. Even then it still happens a lot, plus often their wives and children live on the garrison with them.

SunSurfSand · 08/07/2023 07:55

My fancy private school was located across from army barracks.

I don't remember anyone having any issues at all.

It might not be as bad as you think OP

Goldfoot · 08/07/2023 07:54

pickledandpuzzled · 08/07/2023 07:49

Part of the problem with this is the lack of community.

We've developed a society where men's basest instincts are curbed by community. Their worst behaviour has to be kept under wraps for fear of censure.

When there is no community, there's no censure, and bad behaviour spirals.

500 people forced into close contact is not the same as community.
We need to be supporting such developments by building community in them- organising leaders, locals connected to the culture to help mentor them. Can't be done on a shoestring.

Yes, but you can't really have proper community without women and children.

What are the reasons no women are coming? In every other humanitarian crisis, women and children tend to be evacuated first, while the men stay to fight/work. Apologies if I should know, but why is this so different? Where are the women and children? (I know there are some, but where are the rest?)

Megifer · 08/07/2023 07:54

Sorry to answer your op if it was my DD, based on my experiences personally and otherwise, there's simply not a chance she'd be going anywhere on her own for a long time.

If she has no choice it might be worth looking into some self defence classes or showing her how to hold her key in her knuckles, carry a mini deodorant spray in her pocket to spray in eyes, get a tracking app on her phone, make sure she knows to shout "fire" instead of help etc.

MichelleScarn · 08/07/2023 07:53

Yea2023 · 08/07/2023 07:36

I think some of the Eastern African men have been or are at danger of being forced/kidnapped into the army. the youth may be escaping becoming child soldiers.

For some others they may be facing persecution for being gay, political views (having/not having them), rejecting local religion or just wanting to escape war/conflict.

So basically victims of state or local militia perpetrators.

Either way, this isn’t the OPs concern, the govt needs to sort the Home Office so it is functional again to avoid these situations.

At risk of this in the UK in the temp accommodation?!

pickledandpuzzled · 08/07/2023 07:49

Part of the problem with this is the lack of community.

We've developed a society where men's basest instincts are curbed by community. Their worst behaviour has to be kept under wraps for fear of censure.

When there is no community, there's no censure, and bad behaviour spirals.

500 people forced into close contact is not the same as community.
We need to be supporting such developments by building community in them- organising leaders, locals connected to the culture to help mentor them. Can't be done on a shoestring.

JMSA · 08/07/2023 07:46

YANBU.

Megifer · 08/07/2023 07:45

I was very much a "be kind, they are vulnerable, they won't do any harm, everyone is a racist" until a local hotel was used as temp accommodation, its now permanent pretty much as its been about 3 years. So I was a true NIMBY and I feel very embarrassed now at some of the arguments id had with friends and family.

After about 2 weeks of the first intake I was followed on my way home past the hotel from a night out and called at to see if id like "a good time" (a taxi driver pulled up and they just sauntered back into the hotel not a care in the world), a friends DS had his phone and trainers robbed by a group of around 7 of them, there's constant reports of burglary on the community Facebook and there are often groups of 15-20 of them just hanging around the local shops.

Its really intimidating op. I'm sorry you're in this position

Goldfoot · 08/07/2023 07:43

The idea that this is all caused by liberals is ridiculous. We've had a right wing government that's getting more right wing by the minute for 13 years.

This is caused by the right wing government pretending to be "hard" on immigration by ignoring it, allowing backlogs to build up, putting no facilities or systems in place. When we did have liberals in charge it simply wasn't a problem in the way it is now.

How is it even possible to suggest "liberals" are to blame for this when we've had a very right wing government for over a decade? How does that make any sense, liberals have had literally no power in this country for years.

Beautiful3 · 08/07/2023 07:37

500 men with unknown backgrounds, from cultures where girls are seen as lower status and be married. Most of those countries have high sex crimes against children and women. These men are going to be unemployed and hanging around. My cousin lives in Liverpool, they've had big problems with them grooming local teen girls. There's been fighting and protests from the locals. It's shocking how the government tells us to accommodate, without caring what happens to our children.

Yea2023 · 08/07/2023 07:36

MichelleScarn · 08/07/2023 06:32

@LauraNicolaides what crimes are they likely going to be victims of? Who are the perpetrators to be?

I think some of the Eastern African men have been or are at danger of being forced/kidnapped into the army. the youth may be escaping becoming child soldiers.

For some others they may be facing persecution for being gay, political views (having/not having them), rejecting local religion or just wanting to escape war/conflict.

So basically victims of state or local militia perpetrators.

Either way, this isn’t the OPs concern, the govt needs to sort the Home Office so it is functional again to avoid these situations.

Goldfoot · 08/07/2023 07:30

500 men in one building sounds awful for all concerned. 500 men with nothing to do all day, miserable for them and a disaster for the community.

Government must get these things turned around quicker. If they are economic migrants, they want to work. We need people to work...Sort their cases out much quicker and if they're entitled to stay let them work.

Yea2023 · 08/07/2023 07:29

Thehippowife · 08/07/2023 03:13

It’s ok to have concern for your child’s welfare and safety against the unknown. It’s not racist or elitist to think that 500 unvetted people, most likely with trauma and mh, could pose a risk to children in some capacity. sometimes horrible things happen as we saw in France. Why are people so quick to shout down Op simply for being worried for her child.

What happened re asylum seekers in France?

I wouldn’t like it, regardless of where the men are from.

OP have you had a chat with the school? would they not be able to formally object on safeguarding grounds?

General number of asylum seekers haven’t increased, method of travel has.

This is a Tory made crisis, from which they are siphoning £££ and providing a bogey man for their base, who tend to believe it’s the fault of Labour/liberals.

BadgerFacedCoo · 08/07/2023 07:27

I've never worked asylum but I've worked homeless shelters.

Large groups of men housed like this is awful. I've walked through prisons and felt safe. The hostels and shelters were awful.

Large groups of bored angry men are terrifying.

Some very naive posters shouting racism here.

LakieLady · 08/07/2023 07:26

If "bullying woke liberals" "dominate" this country @JaneyGee , how do you explain the fact that we've had Tories in charge for 13 years?

The right has managed to shift the Overton window so far that having compassion for people in desperate straits has been reduced to being "woke". This country is becoming less tolerant and more brutal by the day.

Goldfoot · 08/07/2023 07:25

kirbykirby · 07/07/2023 23:03

They should house them in places like Hampstead and Richmond where the locals are relatively well off and council tax could be raised a lot in order to fund accommodation and services for them. Most people in these areas are liberal so there should be lots of support for increased taxes to pay for humanitarian help and increased house building. Instead they get dumped in poor working class areas.

Yes. Ordinary people get accused of NIMBYism but these things never are built in the backyards of wealthy, influential people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread