Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men’s Asylum seeker accommodation next to school

569 replies

chibcha · 07/07/2023 22:36

I feel quite ashamed by how I feel but want to know if it warranted.

There has been an announcement that a 500 men’s asylum seeker accommodation is going ahead against councils decision (it was overruled on a national scale). This is Stafford btw

It will be butted up to (no gap) to my DCs school and opposite a nursery. It’s not because they are asylum seekers that concerns me. It’s the fact it’a 500 men unit, with many with no known history / criminal records/ mental state.

I work over an hour away and currently my daughter who is 12 walks to the bus etc, she also does after school clubs then walks home alone. Most parents at the school are talking about moving their kids but in reality and logistically that’s not going to happen.

I genuinely feel scared for her safety. AIBU?
Its the location of it that’s wrong and the fact the council stated issues and concerns so refused it but got overruled by the government…

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
KarmaStar · 08/07/2023 09:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

VisionsOfSplendour · 08/07/2023 09:54

DisquietintheRanks · 08/07/2023 09:48

So how does that differ from having a bog standard housing estate right next to your child's school?

Hmm, I don't know what could possibly be different between asylum seekers squashed in unsuitable accomodation not allowed to do anything with no money and homeowners/tenants in a new housing estate

That's quite the puzzler

redreal · 08/07/2023 09:52

I live near Bassingbourn and about a decade ago the locals were called nimbys, racists and bigots for expressing concern about the arrival of 300 libyans to train at Bassingbourn barracks.
You can guess the rest.....

www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-cambridgeshire-32687137.amp

DisquietintheRanks · 08/07/2023 09:48

toffeeappleglow · 07/07/2023 23:32

You are not being unreasonable. Like it or not, there's no way of knowing which of these men will be a threat, but with 500 men and no way to ascertain possible criminal backgrounds or other problems, it's inevitable that some of them aren't safe around anyone, but especially not children.

So how does that differ from having a bog standard housing estate right next to your child's school?

Emmamoo89 · 08/07/2023 09:47

Yanbu

Feckedupbundle · 08/07/2023 09:46

A hotel near our nearest town did this. Men only accomodation. There were problems with groups of men cat calling and harassing girls,and some boys. It was hushed up in general.
The same hotel is still being used,but for women and children only. Zero problems since then.
I'd be liasing with other parents to escort them to school and back.

VisionsOfSplendour · 08/07/2023 09:45

PriamFarrl · 07/07/2023 23:09

My town has asylum seekers housed in a hotel in the town centre. I’ve only ever seen about 3 people and I go past regularly. Over certainly not seen gangs of men hanging around.

What does that prove? My brother works in a place where there is an asylum hotel and there most definitely are groups of young men who have nothing to do hanging around the streets, intimidating women and children and generally being anti social

Just because you haven't seen it doesn't mean it isn't happening and isnt a very valid concern

tennesseewhiskey1 · 08/07/2023 09:38

Sorry op but I would worry too - I would move my child but that’s me. 500 men that you have no idea backgrounds of?

Nevermind31 · 08/07/2023 09:36

miniegg3 · 08/07/2023 00:39

I wanted to add that many are from a culture that don't respect women, especially western woman.. but assumed I'd have everyone jump down my throat 🫣

I’m not saying that that is the case for all male asylum seekers. And many men from this country don’t treat women well either, but it was my anecdotal experience. It wasn’t nice.

pickledandpuzzled · 08/07/2023 09:25

It may well be mixed accommodation in principle, but the proportion of women and children arriving is extremely small in comparison to the men

Lwrenagain · 08/07/2023 08:51

@chibcha I'd also hate 500 men living near my DC school. Culture completely aside, 1 in 30 men have a predisposition for children.
So IDC where these men are from, I care that there is a huge number of them, if you see what I'm saying?!

But saying that, I have worked in care my whole adult life and alot of the peadophiles I've worked with, which is many, sadly, with some form on learning difficulties or ND have been housed very close to schools.
One child sex offender I worked with had a bedroom overlooking a playground of juniors, absolutely disgusting that it was even allowed. His learning disability was as a mild as a korma and boiled rice, he really didn't need a support plan in place. He had full independence and just lucked out where he was homed. It was awful.
There are risks to children everywhere that parents have no idea about.
The system is flawed when it comes to child safety, (I once attended a meeting where a sex offender had been exposing himself and masturbating in his window to the child in the house opposite, this man's social worker had wanted the child to be given some responsibility for "teasing" him, as he was a vulnerable adult. I'm genuinely not fabricating/lying/exaggerating this in any way, it was about 18 years ago.)

Unfortunately when it comes to the safety of children, we're governed by people that couldn't give less of a fuck and were all surrounded by risks we're unaware of.

If nothing else, you know with 500 men there will be a risk and I'm hopeful that you will be able to work with other school parents to carpool etc?

Whilst it's wonderful we're helping asylum seekers, it's less wonderful we're not considering the risks posed by men. As others pointed out, women just don't carry the same threat.

DontBeAPrickDarren · 08/07/2023 08:46

Just to reiterate:

  • there’s a planning condition that there can be no more than 481 residents - so that won’t be bunking them up two or three to a room as has happened elsewhere.
  • it is mixed use - so single men, women and families. The proposed layout of the building is such that areas can be restricted to certain groups.
  • the local council refused planning permission and opposed it on appeal. Reports suggest Serco had exceptional (expensive) legal representation. That fact this whole thing is profit driven and about who has the most money to throw around is repulsive in itself.
  • local MP is fucking useless and couldn’t point to Stafford on a map.
BadgerFacedCoo · 08/07/2023 08:43

EducatingArti · 08/07/2023 08:08

Not my experience at all. I've been in my local homeless hostel for men, many times. My experience is that the men are extremely anxious and shy. Before COVID we used to visit with buffet food and chat to them. Only a few would come and chat, others would stick their head round the door, then disappear very quickly. They are used to being treated as invisible or rejected and insulted so are very wary of others ( even a majority women group with an average age of over 60).
We used to leave the food out so that they could come and help themselves once we had left.

I've never been in a men's a hostel as part of a group of mostly over 60 women.

Maybe that's why our experiences differ.

Boomboom22 · 08/07/2023 08:43

Gytgyt · 08/07/2023 08:27

I think this is wrong though. You can't assume that these people aren't in real danger or living in sheer poverty they probably are living in poverty. Who told you they have paid thousands to seek asylum?

How do you think they pay? It's not free to get on a smugglers boat! Do you seriously think they just group together and get on a dinghy? Do you ever even listen to the news?

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/07/2023 08:42

We have an asylum seekers hotel with only men in it on the edge of our village & other than some issues with them wondering country lanes in the dark & nearly being run over, we’ve had no problems but a lot of effort has been put in by local charities & ppl in the village to support them. I can understand why the OP is concerned. It’s about 5 x more than we have and unless there is a concerted effort to put help & support in they’ll be bored & tbf with the community on edge even if they’re hanging about not doing anything, the mere fact they’re hanging about will cause tensions.

inamarina · 08/07/2023 08:38

BadgerFacedCoo · 08/07/2023 07:27

I've never worked asylum but I've worked homeless shelters.

Large groups of men housed like this is awful. I've walked through prisons and felt safe. The hostels and shelters were awful.

Large groups of bored angry men are terrifying.

Some very naive posters shouting racism here.

This.
People asking OP if she would have the same issue with other men living in her town seem so faux naive to me.
I‘d assume there is a difference between 500 single men with not much to do, all living together in a crowded environment or 500 men spread throughout the community, many with partners/ families, jobs etc.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 08/07/2023 08:33

The issue isn't that OP is racist.

It's her double standards - she's happy to welcome migrants to the UK but she's not happy to have them near her or her children.

Tiredmum100 · 08/07/2023 08:29

Beautiful3 · 08/07/2023 07:37

500 men with unknown backgrounds, from cultures where girls are seen as lower status and be married. Most of those countries have high sex crimes against children and women. These men are going to be unemployed and hanging around. My cousin lives in Liverpool, they've had big problems with them grooming local teen girls. There's been fighting and protests from the locals. It's shocking how the government tells us to accommodate, without caring what happens to our children.

Exactly. All the people shouting the op must be racist and needs to show compassion, are living in cookoo land. Would they want 500 men living next door to them..and I mean 500 men of any race or religion. No. Of course they wouldn't. 500 men will cause problems. Even if it's a lot of noise! Nor to mention the stats on male violence towards women. (ONS for reference). I live in a poorer class working area. We have only 2 really good hotels in the area. One has just been closed to house asylum seekers. So that means a loss of jobs. People's weddings cancelled. But hey, who cares. These people can no longer pay their bills, support their families etc, and we're already in a cost of living crisis. I guess someone will be along to say that we are selfish for having weddings in hotels when so many people have nothing, and we should give up everything to help others. But the people who already live here just don't matter. Not to the government anyway. Local businesses have been advertising to those who have lost their jobs to get in touch with them. I know of some people who were recently housed in an empty nursing home. That, to me, makes far more sense. We have plenty of empty buildings where I live that could be made safe and house people. And ffwi I believe they should be a mixture of men, women and children.

JudgeRudy · 08/07/2023 08:28

Ponoka7 · 08/07/2023 08:00

The issue is that in some cultures girls from 13 are seen as women. White women/girls are seen as fair game. As once was in our society. Read the thread on the most inappropriate thing to happen, the men in the 70/80's wasn't pedophiles, the attitudes around teen girls was different. It's a mind set. There doesn't seem to be any education going on in these centers. They've brushed over the issues in Knowsley. The police went into denial. Stayed with that, but then admitted that they did have to speak to some men about sexually harassing children and then moved the men. Ask African women about African men, most women's first sexual encounter is as a child/adult man and the men don't face consequences. There can be cultural differences at play in regards to attitudes towards women.

I'm aware of cultural differences so effectively what you are saying is it's the fact that they're asylum seekers (of a different culture) rather than a group of men that is the issue. I don't think OP implied that.
My thoughts are that you shouldn't label a group of people potential sex offenders without good reason.
I'm imagining the children of this school picking up on their parents' alarm and forming negative views of 'foreigners' in general. This can't be a good thing.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/07/2023 08:28

I'll be honest, it would concern me too. An army base(or anything similar)would as well, even if the risk reduces slightly since most of them would be working /otherwise engaged during school hours and drop off/pick up times.

It's a men issue, not an asylum seeking issue.

Yea2023 · 08/07/2023 08:28

MichelleScarn · 08/07/2023 08:12

@Yea2023 confusion then! I assumed the 'they're more likely to be victims of crime' meant here because the poster was talking about perceived behaviour here towards young females.

Maybe the confusion is on my part?

TBF, some will become victims here because having 500 unrelated men with nothing to do from different cultures, languages, backgrounds n shit conditions is a recipe for disaster.
I’ve heard strangers crammed into room shares - not great when some/most will have some trauma.

But that’s the govt fault and not OP’s problem. And I’m not unconvinced they aren’t doing this on purpose to create a bigger issue.

Gytgyt · 08/07/2023 08:27

Boomboom22 · 08/07/2023 08:13

It's not racist to say 500 aimless young men cause trouble.
It's not racist to point out these are men who can afford to pay thousands to people traffickers to come here illegally so not likely they are fleeing for their lives they believe they will have a better life here, still happy to do that illegally.
The people who really do need asylum cannot afford to pay thousands and we are busy justifying the men who have so don't pay attention to those who may need help.
Judges stymie the home office in every policy they try to put in place so the people smugglers and economic migrants think we all do want them here and won't be able to do anything anyway.

I think this is wrong though. You can't assume that these people aren't in real danger or living in sheer poverty they probably are living in poverty. Who told you they have paid thousands to seek asylum?

Panteranoir · 08/07/2023 08:25

miniegg3 · 08/07/2023 00:39

I wanted to add that many are from a culture that don't respect women, especially western woman.. but assumed I'd have everyone jump down my throat 🫣

Not at all miniegg3 you are entitled to your opinion just like everyone else.

Wasn't it Liverpool where the little girl (think she was about 14?) filmed an asylum seeker pestering her for sex while she was on her way to school? He said 'I don't care' when she told him her age.

500 bored men all in one place next to young girls is not a good idea. Certainly when they are from parts of the world which are very culturally different and women are regarded as less than human, mere baby making machines whose value lies only in their chastity (and western women are considered whores for not covering up and doing things like being out without a male guardian) you're bound to get more than a frisson of tension.

Mumsnet is always fiercely pro mass immigration on one hand, but on the other hand never take into account the effect of having significant numbers of people arriving with a very different stance on the rights of women. It will alter our political landscape and the world isn't a great place for women as it is.

I have to admit I laughed out loud at Simon Reeve the travel presenter. I think it was his documentary about Greece, where he saw a boatload of illegal migrants on camera and he couldn't wait to play the good Samaritan (they were well dressed, had mobile phones and could clearly afford to pay people smugglers). Shortly after first seeing them land, the film crew put the women immigrants in the car and were driving them to the local town and the car was stopped by a group of very aggressive male immigrants who didn't give a shit that the film crew were trying to assist, just that women are not allowed to be with men they don't know in case they are defiled by the presence of western men.

He just had no clue what he was dealing with. He had no clue about just how alien our western culture is and how unwelcome. It's well worth a watch to see how woefully lacking in understanding many westerners are when the try to 'help'.

A lot of men in that unit will literally hate our liberal way of life and consider women less than. We're all too busy wallowing in be kind, and guilt over empire to take a step back and say, actually there is value in our liberalism in the UK, there is value in the forward march of women's rights and that needs protection.

Pim Fortuyn believed in protecting the liberal culture of the Netherlands and he literally died for believing in those freedoms. In France, women are being physically assaulted for not covering up. I think it was last summer a lady was punched in the face for wearing a mini skirt. Look at the events in Cologne a few years ago. I nearly cried listening to one sexual assault survivor from that night talking about the many many hands all over her body grabbing her, tearing her clothes off. Dozens of men trying to grope her. In all of those men, not one tried to stop the assault, because to them it was completely justified, she was just a blond western whore out in public. So she deserved it. I wonder is Angela Merkel stopped for one second to consider the safety of the average German women when she gave out a free pass to a over million migrants. I wonder how many people will actually stop and listen to the testimony of those women, the very real victims of ill thought through migration policy.

I doubt the people clamouring for mass immigration stop for a second to think about being kind to women and certainly not to a bunch of teenage girls in Stafford. You can't get woke points for worrying about women's rights or protecting liberal culture. Nobody is going to give you a follow on Twitter for that.

There is value in migration. It isn't a dirty word. However is does need to be properly managed to ensure there isn't a major impact on the culture of the UK. At some stage the cognitive dissonance needs to stop, people need to stop yelling racism and actually have a sane and sensible conversation around migration and the very real impact of it. Obviously in this case putting 500 men next to a school, that simply has not happened.

Gytgyt · 08/07/2023 08:23

@kirbykirby imagine the uproar... I think the Richmond folk would definitely complain about it.

I'm going to be honest I wouldn't like it and I won't lie the fact thay is men would make me feel uneasy too. I do agree they have to go some where but there's lots of land waste all over the country its not really acceptable next to a school.

@Swrigh1234 you hit the nail on the head.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 08/07/2023 08:21

I think YABU. On the basis that in the uk there is such a low conviction rate doe sex crimes so there are 500 men with unknown histories within the vicinity of every school anyway.

I'd wait and see. If their behaviour is in any way intimidating or threatening then fine to consider moving her.