Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers - are your 6-8 year olds this rude?

161 replies

WhaleBlue · 07/07/2023 21:49

I work in lots of different schools working with small groups of children aged between 6 & 8. More recently I’ve noticed the level of interrupting when I’m speaking, not listening to instructions and generally thinking what they have to say is far more important than what I have to stay really off putting.

I’ve been doing the same role for over 20 years and never had any real issues, but over recent months am becoming more frustrated with this. Is it just my area or is it the same across the UK?

God only knows how their class room teacher copes with about 30 of them at the same time.

This is also something that they have expressed an interest in which their parents are paying for.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 08/07/2023 09:26

I teach KS2 children, both whole class and small intervention groups. The kids in the intervention groups are far more chatty 9n their group than when in whole class, where they’re probably slightly intimidated by the couple of challenging children in there! One particular girl never speaks in whole class, but chatters away in our small group!

oobladay · 08/07/2023 09:26

It's very striking in the early years too. The last couple of years especially have been very challenging. Lots of children where we have huge concerns about their social skills and their ability to regulate their emotions. Lots of incidents of children being very physical towards each other in the pre school class. They are only little and still learning, but there has been a noticeable change in this area compared to previous cohorts.

I absolutely do believe that lockdowns had an impact on this and that children did engage with screens more than ever before and that this has been difficult for families to reduce. Parenting has changed greatly over the last few years.

lavenderlou · 08/07/2023 09:25

For context, my current class were pre-schoolers in the first lockdown and missed a term of Reception in the second lockdown so they did lose out on some of the "school-ready" routines. Our current year 4s missed part of Year 1 and Year 2 but they are by far our best-behaved, most respectful class. Cohorts can just vary.

LittleBrenda · 08/07/2023 09:25

It's having your needs satisfied instantly that's part of the problem. I can see myself doing it on my own ipad or phone. Switching from one thing to another. Everything is so immediate. Nobody has to wait for anything so they can't control their impulses.

And also a lack of attention from the adults in their lives. Some parents barely look up when their child approaches them at home time. Toddlers are playing on phones in their pushchairs instead of talking to their parent.

I was at a cricket match last weekend. There were games, play equipment and of course the cricket to look at. And so much space to run around. There were about thirty children and nearly all of them were given a screen to watch. Whereas when we were kids we would have played together, rolled down hills, invented games and probably had a brilliant time. They don't seem to be able to interact with each other.

lavenderlou · 08/07/2023 09:21

I teach this age range and my class this year has been particularly bad for interrupting, speaking over others, carrying on chatting when I've explained it's time to listen. They're much better now after a year of training but it's been far worse than previous years. Last year's classwere also chatty but picked up the "rules" quicker.

Mojitosaremyfavourite · 08/07/2023 09:19

Butteredtoast55 · 08/07/2023 08:12

@Herejusttocomment and @Mojitosaremyfavourite I know a couple of good supply teachers who bear this out, and am a headteacher so anecdotally heard and seen for myself that there are lots of issues with years 3 and 4 (about to move to 4 & 5).
They were reception and year 1 at the start of lockdown and it's like they've got stuck at that stage of interaction and development. We've worked really hard on addressing this but for some children it's still a real struggle, especially those who didn't come back in summer 2020 despite it being offered.
Having said that, the issues of declining listening skills, oracy, good manners and behaviour was noticeable pre-pandemic.
I deal with a gaming/internet/Tik Tok/social media related issue at least weekly and have never had as many parents asking for help with their children attacking them, swearing at them and refusing to do as requested.

This is interesting from a HT point of view. Thank you.

TheMoth · 08/07/2023 09:18

I've been teaching a long time. Yes, behaviour is worse, but it's easy to forget all those lovely, well behaved kids. Many of whom have experienced covid; parents on phones; full time working parents; lots of screen time. Yet, they can still behave appropriately. Which brings us back to parenting and circumstances.

If you're brought up in a house full of drama you don't know what's appropriate behaviour; you don't know that telling an adult to fuck off is inappropriate, because in your house that's normal.

I've lost count of the number of times 11 or 12 year olds have told me they don't like the way I'm looking at them, or they don't like my tone , or to stop screaming at them (can you take your coat off please?) And manners have died.

Child appears at my door.
"Pen. "
"Sorry?"
"Need a pen."
"Oh, you mean 'please may I borrow a pen. '
'Yeah. You got one or what?"

Mojitosaremyfavourite · 08/07/2023 09:16

Hardbackwriter · 08/07/2023 08:17

Current reception were toddlers in lock down, not babies

Yes they were toddlers. Exactly that: toddlers. Not children at school- who SHOULD have been at school.

I can guarantee toddlers then were no way as affected long term as the reception/ year one / year two children at that time of lockdown.

GuidingSpirit · 08/07/2023 09:09

We have exactly the same at Brownies. Less so at Rainbows at the minute. It's just awful. We have a year long waiting list but I'm actually considering dropping our group size from 24 to 16 because its so unmanageable, in the hope that being able to give a bit more attention to a smaller group will help improve things.

CrustyWingshield · 08/07/2023 09:06

MucozadeOnLucozade · 07/07/2023 23:47

There's a lot of other factors, both parents working and family structure and interaction so much less. Parents tired so kids shoved in front of tablets. Very sad times, but I fear this will only get worse.

This is a really important point people are overlooking. It is bloody hard when both parents have full time jobs.

During lockdown my employer - the public sector - expected me to WFH, teach my reception child and care for a one year old while churning out my usual workload. No reduced workload or furlough for me, partner also keyworker working out of the home, so all down to me. I could have put my kids in school and nursery, but a family member died from it, so I was scared and everyone was pumping out the 'we're all in this together' bullshit while loading the burden mainly onto working women. My one year old was probably the most neglected and he is behind developmentally, but does have ASD. I think I actually did well with my older child despite the workload. My kids went back for the last part of that year, so it was only a few months, but that was because i was a keyworker. Many didn't have that option, even some of my colleagues got refused due to WFH. Why is everyone assuming people dumped their kids in front of screens by choice or laziness? My situation wasn't unique.

We need to look at what parents are expected to do now compared to our parents. We have to feed healthy meals (not oven shite like my mum did with us), ferry our kids to lots of clubs and keep immaculate homes apparently, while both parents hold down careers and deal with the usual life admin. That's why we use ipads, but how is this different to being dumped in front of the telly like I was?

I do encourage my kids to play out and I agree there is less of that now, but parents do seem cautious about it. There are less community activities. My school always had discos and events like country dancing and other crap (with a bar!) that brought the community together. There seems to be fewer opportunities for that now.

Hangingtrousers · 08/07/2023 09:01

You can't deny that parents on their phone all the time must have had a big impact on kids development.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/07/2023 08:59

Hangingtrousers · 08/07/2023 08:51

@AngryGreasedSantaCatcus well how long have smart phones been around...

First iphone was 2007. So 16 years ago. And it took a while for the world to catch up and develop the usage we see today.

EsmeeMerlin · 08/07/2023 08:53

I am a TA in year 2 and our current year 2s are the worst year band in the whole school for behaviour issues. To the point that next year they are being put into 3 classes instead of 2 to make it more manageable for their teachers and support staff. Some children are Sen and we have more sen children in the school than ever before but collectively they all struggle to listen and concentrate. We also deal with rudeness numerous times daily. They struggle with friendships and just generally are not very emotionally mature for their age. I think it is partly down to the pandemic, they had their early years heavily impacted and it's those years that focus on listening, sitting on carpet etc. It's also sometimes down to shitty parenting. I have one girl who is the most obnoxious rude child I have ever met. You follow the behaviour policy and give her reminders that she will miss 5 minutes of her break time and she tells us she doesn't care, dad will give her what she wants when she gets home anyway and he does. She is being ruined by her parents who have never told her no a day in her life although fair play to mum who is now realising and is putting consequences in place. Consequently her behaviour in school is also now improving.

WonderingWanda · 08/07/2023 08:53

Smeeps · 08/07/2023 08:14

I’m in secondary and behaviour has got much tougher - especially in the playground and corridors. So much worse - I don’t think we really recognise we will be dealing with consequences for such a long time. I’d say even reception children have been affected and it won’t be until they finish school we stop seeing the impacts.

i know I’m not with your age ranges but it is definitely covid related. I’ve been a teacher for 12 years.

I agree with this. Our current y7 are the least secondary ready I have ever met. Nife kids displaying all the behaviours the op described, constant shouting out, answering back interrupting etc. They seem to have no impulse control and a constant need for attention.

Guiltridden12345 · 08/07/2023 08:53

WhaleBlue · 08/07/2023 08:30

I agree completely. I set boundaries and am firm from the outset. Some children look completely taken aback when I tell them they need to listen. Some even respond with ‘but I need to tell you something/ show you something.’ I respond ‘is it to do with the lesson?’ It never is, they want to tell me where they’re going on holiday or what they had for tea. It’s of course normal for children to want to chat and tell me something but I say to wait until the end of the lesson. Some look so upset!
The most frustrating for me is I’m trying to explain something and they constantly interrupt. If they waited a few more seconds they would have the answer to their question.
I do really enjoy my job, it’s just this low level disruption and interruption is becoming more and more apparent. It’s also not really fair on the handful of children who can listen and want to learn. It’s just something that seems to be worsening.
Anyway I’ll carry on with the polite reminders to listen and they can tell me all about their holiday or whatever at the end of the lesson.

I also think we’re in a period of endemic poor parenting. No boundaries, unlimited screens, ‘friend’ parents who say yes immediately to everything and provide immediate gratification. These kids don’t understand waiting, esp if they are also on screens too long where everything happens immediately. normal life rules then appear horrifically slow.

And don’t get me started on behaviour. It’s not just year 4. My child’s year 6 group are really quite horrid, very badly behaved, bitchy girls and fearless boys who take the piss out of older kids with no care. It feels very odd to someone in their mid 40s as the normal social rules just don’t seem to apply. And these kids were indulged toddlers - ‘kind hands’ after child punched another in the face - so I’m not sure it’s all covid or all screens or all parenting but the combination of all 3 is horrific. Poor teachers.

I still have screen time on my teen’s phone. Two hours a day and off at 8 until 8 the next morning when she leaves for school. she is thd only one. All of them on screens til late hours, they must be exhausted too. There are just no boundaries around, it’s no wonder they are all so feral.

Hangingtrousers · 08/07/2023 08:51

@AngryGreasedSantaCatcus well how long have smart phones been around...

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/07/2023 08:48

Hangingtrousers · 08/07/2023 08:45

I really think it's parents on phones and not giving kids attention.
These kids have had parents staring at their phones since birth... had to fight to get adult attention over WhatsApp and Instagram.

I know I'm guilty of it too with my own kids.

How do you explain the fact that it's across all year groups, and as one poster stated even in FE.

Hangingtrousers · 08/07/2023 08:45

I really think it's parents on phones and not giving kids attention.
These kids have had parents staring at their phones since birth... had to fight to get adult attention over WhatsApp and Instagram.

I know I'm guilty of it too with my own kids.

Guiltridden12345 · 08/07/2023 08:41

Herejusttocomment · 08/07/2023 07:53

Lol so it's not just the Y4 in our school.
They're a wild bunch who only seem to communicate with each other by shouting over one another. No amount of team games has changed this this year.
I'm hoping they'll settle a bit more next year, the Y5 and 6 teacher (small school so blended classes) won't stand for it, she's strict but fair and a really good teacher imo.

Our Yr 4 also wild. Real social problems and violence. A good few families have now left for private as so disruptive.

Catusrusty · 08/07/2023 08:41

electriclight · 08/07/2023 08:10

I work with a similar age group op and feel the same. Everyone I know who works with children agrees. I do think it is the legacy of covid but not just because the children missed so many opportunities for learning and socialisation, but because their parents are far more overprotective and indulgent. I have far more parents who work tirelessly to protect their child from any worry, difficulty or challenge. Experiences that were considered a normal part of growing up, persevering, learning resilience and so on are now routinely challenged by parents seeking to create a perfect world for their child. It upsets me to see children limited and stunted by their parents' inability to see them challenged in any way.

I think this is absolutely true electriclight

I do think parents have become more protective and indulgent anyway and Covid seems to have really exacerbated it.

Invisibleeye · 08/07/2023 08:31

I have found similar issues in FE. In 2021/22, we suddenly had an influx of kids who were just really immature.

We’d never really had major behaviour issues but all of a sudden I was being called “a pathetic fat bitch” for politely asking a group to be quiet in the corridors while I taught as we had to have the doors open for covid reasons (apparently I should have “shut the fucking door if [I] wanted quiet”). I wouldn’t have been shocked if I’d encountered it in a local comp (trust me I’ve worked in all of them!) but in FE it just wasn’t really heard of!

Same with kids falling out with each other - very year 9 dramatic mean girls type behaviour from kids in the equivalent of years 12/13. However, at the time that had been their last “normal” year of schooling so it made perfect sense they were stuck in the mode of year 9 drama - they’d not had the opportunity to really develop more.

We also had lots of kids shocked they weren’t going to be told the topics covered in their end of year exam in 2022. They’d been told for the GCSEs so it was completely foreign to them that they had to revise the entire syllabus (and according to them a “very unfair” way to do things!)

I can only imagine the same is true for all kids. In fact, I spoke to a secondary teacher who said the same about year 7s that year… just incredibly immature for their age.

Mygazpachoistoocold · 08/07/2023 08:31

When I volunteered to help out at Beavers I didn't realise how much time I would spend telling other people's children off.
Some of it I think is that the children don't actually want to be there. Their parents think it is a 'wholesome' activity so want them to go and as a club it's good value for money.
We go on walks, do den building, play team games, fishing, craft activities etc so there is plenty for them to do. Some of the children answer back a lot, refusing to be out of a game when they've been caught out, talk over people and they don't even know the others names despite it being a relatively small group.
I actually wonder if it's partially down to how much attention they get from their parents. If their parents are engrossed in devices themselves they don't interact with children as they used to or pull them up on their behaviour.

WhaleBlue · 08/07/2023 08:30

StellaF · 08/07/2023 08:15

I completely agree. I was finding that anytime a child was told “no” or challenged in the slightest way, even if you offered a more practical solution to something they were struggling with, you were apparently “bullying” them. I love being around children and young people but have increasingly found their inability to understand the human condition doesn’t support being “happy” ALL THE TIME incredibly sad and frustrating.

I agree completely. I set boundaries and am firm from the outset. Some children look completely taken aback when I tell them they need to listen. Some even respond with ‘but I need to tell you something/ show you something.’ I respond ‘is it to do with the lesson?’ It never is, they want to tell me where they’re going on holiday or what they had for tea. It’s of course normal for children to want to chat and tell me something but I say to wait until the end of the lesson. Some look so upset!
The most frustrating for me is I’m trying to explain something and they constantly interrupt. If they waited a few more seconds they would have the answer to their question.
I do really enjoy my job, it’s just this low level disruption and interruption is becoming more and more apparent. It’s also not really fair on the handful of children who can listen and want to learn. It’s just something that seems to be worsening.
Anyway I’ll carry on with the polite reminders to listen and they can tell me all about their holiday or whatever at the end of the lesson.

OP posts:
Herejusttocomment · 08/07/2023 08:26

@Mojitosaremyfavourite oh, there is definitely an effect on Reception age. Since the start of the school year, we basically had to teach each child how to play with each other, how to role play, how to take turns, skills that usually start to develop in toddlerhood. (I'm in a support role btw)

TheCrystalPalace · 08/07/2023 08:25

@Mojitosaremyfavourite Re:strikes, the classes closed are those whose teachers are striking. It is not the Head who "prioritises" chosen year groups to open.