Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help me work out if my nanny is doing a good job

58 replies

pleppapligg · 07/07/2023 19:05

She's my first nanny and it's her first nanny job. We have a an agreement on what her duties and responsibilities are.

She takes care of my kids and I feel they're safe with her. I'm just not sure if she's doing enough play time / creative stuff with them when she's at home.

They're 15 months and 3 and a half.

My kids have a lot of toys and I know it's annoying to keep them organised, but you have to do it if you want them to get the most out of the toys. I've bought some really cool wooden ones with animals and poles you need to stick into holes etc and my 15 month old loves playing with it.

Somehow at the end of the each day they're all messed up and I don't think the kids get the most of playing with their toys. Play dough also keeps drying up and I keep buying more. I'm trying to teach my kids to tidy up after playing and encourage the nanny to also teach them to do the same. But it doesn't look like she tries to care about it at all and half of the time, she says the kids can't play with stuff because it's a mess. Even though I tidy it all up and sort it every weekend. By Monday it's all a mess and can't be played with properly again.

She also never takes them out in the garden. My garden has everything - slide / swing / trampoline etc etc. it's an even level and perfectly safe. I have asked her to take them out, but she just doesn't do it on her own accord.

She mostly sits in the living room with them. My mum is visiting at the moment and has seen her on her phone playing games / texting. I've seen her use her phone quite a bit, but I've not told her she isn't allowed to. I don't mind occasionally. She has taken calls before while the 15 month old was crying and I did pull her up on it gently.

Anyway, my main issue is that I don't feel like she is doing much developmental / educational play stuff with them. There's also not much structure to the day. I am around, as I wfh ( she knew that before she took the role ). So I do see some of the time what's going on.

Also, the other day she got my 15 month old up from a nap and he had done a poo. Rather than changing him, she sat him in his high chair and gave him his lunch. She only changed him after. I think that's really gross. ( I only realised after it happened what had happened ).

It's her first nanny job but she has a lot of experience in child care.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thehop · 07/07/2023 22:37

She's a bit crap.

also, she should be making play dough fresh each day with the children. It's really cheap and easy.

Sheselectric88 · 07/07/2023 22:34

I used to be a nanny when I was a young woman. As a nanny you are expected to look after children just as a parent would but also add in structured and educational activities. A nanny should do all child laundry, cooking, cleaning, tidying and also wash/bathe the children if required. They should also have a daily routine including outings to groups and activities and outside play. Inside play should be done with the children modelling language, turn taking etc… this should include messy play, reading and educational activities. I’m not a fan of modern toys but I’d play with them if required, I prefer to use things like pots and pans or the recycling to build things. As a nanny I’d expect a kitty so I could pay for outside activities but also buy art supplies and games etc that would be my responsibility to go shop for and it would be made into an outing with the children.

For my families I also tidied up the non child related home and did bits of cleaning, walked the dogs and cooked some adult meals. This was while the children napped and was an added extra I offered if I had time. I also replaced and repaired child clothing (using kitty money). At no point was I sat on my phone. That is unacceptable. I’d eat with the dc and take a break while they napped.

Op if you want to stick with this nanny, I’d invest in a week with a properly qualified experienced nanny to train her. It will cost you double but it will be worth it.

Trying2understand · 07/07/2023 22:33

I believe you've posted before about this. I really don't think it will get better. She sounds apathetic at best. Time to move on I think.

moneymatr · 07/07/2023 22:00

Yes you need a new nanny. I would expect a structure to the day. So example- outing in the morning playgroup/ park/ swimming/ farm etc followed by lunch. Naps if required otherwise a quiet play period- books/jigsaws/ puzzles. Followed by craft or baking activities. Then garden play. Then end the day with free play but management of toys during play so it's not a dumpsite. Then tea and maybe end with a educational tv show. I would want to see opportunities for development within play - linking to eyfs.
And I would absolutely expect nappies to be changed fairly promptly.

TheOccupier · 07/07/2023 21:28

pleppapligg · 07/07/2023 19:05

She's my first nanny and it's her first nanny job. We have a an agreement on what her duties and responsibilities are.

She takes care of my kids and I feel they're safe with her. I'm just not sure if she's doing enough play time / creative stuff with them when she's at home.

They're 15 months and 3 and a half.

My kids have a lot of toys and I know it's annoying to keep them organised, but you have to do it if you want them to get the most out of the toys. I've bought some really cool wooden ones with animals and poles you need to stick into holes etc and my 15 month old loves playing with it.

Somehow at the end of the each day they're all messed up and I don't think the kids get the most of playing with their toys. Play dough also keeps drying up and I keep buying more. I'm trying to teach my kids to tidy up after playing and encourage the nanny to also teach them to do the same. But it doesn't look like she tries to care about it at all and half of the time, she says the kids can't play with stuff because it's a mess. Even though I tidy it all up and sort it every weekend. By Monday it's all a mess and can't be played with properly again.

She also never takes them out in the garden. My garden has everything - slide / swing / trampoline etc etc. it's an even level and perfectly safe. I have asked her to take them out, but she just doesn't do it on her own accord.

She mostly sits in the living room with them. My mum is visiting at the moment and has seen her on her phone playing games / texting. I've seen her use her phone quite a bit, but I've not told her she isn't allowed to. I don't mind occasionally. She has taken calls before while the 15 month old was crying and I did pull her up on it gently.

Anyway, my main issue is that I don't feel like she is doing much developmental / educational play stuff with them. There's also not much structure to the day. I am around, as I wfh ( she knew that before she took the role ). So I do see some of the time what's going on.

Also, the other day she got my 15 month old up from a nap and he had done a poo. Rather than changing him, she sat him in his high chair and gave him his lunch. She only changed him after. I think that's really gross. ( I only realised after it happened what had happened ).

It's her first nanny job but she has a lot of experience in child care.

Sorry but none of this is acceptable, and I think you know it or you wouldn't have posted. I did a better job than this as a 15yo babysitter. What you describe is borderline neglectful/cruel, and with children too young to tell you what's gone on in your absence, you shouldn't take the risk. Get rid of this woman ASAP.

Gagaandgag · 07/07/2023 21:20

Talk to her about all this and write down a list of expectations together?

pimlicopubber · 07/07/2023 21:18

I would ignore the playdoh, however, the nappy incident alone would make me angry.
I'd expect a nanny to change my child's nappy right after they'd done a poo, as I would, unless there is a very good reason not to do so.

Rainbowqueeen · 07/07/2023 21:10

I would not be happy with this.

I think you need to talk to her about structuring her day to include the things you want. I’d be asking that she spent one hour a day minimum in the garden with them, tidied up all toys (with them so they learn) read to them for a certain amount of time per day and do a craft or music activity with them once a day.

Id also raise the nappy changing. Play dough I would let go as long as the rest improved

waterrat · 07/07/2023 21:01

Op it would be a total No from me that she sits on her phone .

And not taking them into the garden but letting them sit around indoors ???

Op raise your standards they would be better of at nursery or with a child minder with other kids and adults paying proper attention

cyncope · 07/07/2023 21:01

She's new to the role, so she needs some training/managing.

Sit down with her and have a review.

Tell her what you are happy about, and also give her some targets.
That could be:

  • ensuring play dough and toys are all put away correctly
  • plan and carry out a couple of developmentally appropriate activities every week
  • taking them out to play in the garden every day when it isn't raining
Have a follow up meeting in 6 weeks or so to see if she's been able to meet them.

Changing nappies promptly as soon as they're soiled and not using her phone during work time (or keeping phone use to half an hour during lunch time) are basics but you should tell her your expectations and give her a chance to improve.

applepuff · 07/07/2023 21:00

@Thoughtful2355 most jobs outside of min wage don't limit or time phone use, they just trust that their employees have enough discretion to know when occasional phone use is OK and when it's not

Thoughtful2355 · 07/07/2023 20:53

ALSO id be giving a time only thing for phones like no using phones unless in an emergency. She wouldnt be able to be on her phone at most other jobs so this is no different.

Thoughtful2355 · 07/07/2023 20:51

No i would not be happy with this at all BUT i would talk to her first have a meeting, at the end of the day you are her manager, her Boss and so you need to have a talk with her about what changes you expect, be very honest and if she still fails to do at least a good job then you need to let her go.

FheridanSox · 07/07/2023 20:40

Why are you ignoring all the comments asking why you’ve posted again? You got plenty of good advice last time.

applepuff · 07/07/2023 20:39

Nurseries have a high teacher to student ratio (1:13, which in practice usually means 1:26 because the assistant teacher may be there to focus on 1 or 2 kids with higher needs). Looking after 13 to 26 children well is a different skillset to looking after 1. You can be great at the latter but not the former, and vice versa.

Wimbo · 07/07/2023 20:36

Ok, so you’re paying market rate for someone whose first job it is as a nanny?

If you’re a professional woman who needs a nanny you can surely have an adult to adult (employer to employee) conversation about your expectations. If that is not met then you need to find another.

The rest is just hand-wringing and I’m wondering why you haven’t addressed these points at the the time - as you would at any workplace. This isn’t someone being annoying about a spreadsheet, it’s your children.

Get on it and just give her the feedback. You need to woman up.

ttcat37 · 07/07/2023 20:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What makes you think she doesn’t want to be a mother?
Have you got an issue with mothers who also have jobs to earn to money?

SayHi · 07/07/2023 20:35

Anyway, my main issue is that I don't feel like she is doing much developmental / educational play stuff with them. There's also not much structure to the day.

You’ve got your priorities messed up.
This should be the last issue that you have with her.

She doesn’t sound the best nanny but you don’t sound the best either tbh if you think educational play is more important than all of the other things you’ve listed.

If you’re not comfortable with her then get a new nanny.

WaltzingWaters · 07/07/2023 20:34

I spent 14 years as a nanny. General tasks included tidying away /organising toys, keeping kids areas clean and tidy, kids laundry, and prepping kids meals. Thought you should really have discussed expectations before she started, but maybe arrange an informal review to go over the role again. Keep it light and say what you are pleased with as well.

the nappy thing is bad, as long as you’re certain he didn’t poop whilst having lunch. I wouldn’t interrupt lunch to change him (unless a poonami!), but I would certainly have changed him before starting lunch if he’d already done it.

And being on her phone lots isn’t okay. Maybe say there’s 30 mins or so downtime whilst baby is napping and the older child is having quiet time where they can use their phone, but besides that it’s only for emergencies.

pleppapligg · 07/07/2023 20:27

Wimbo · 07/07/2023 20:26

You’re likely paying under market rate and are now realising the difference in quality between someone used to a nursery setting with a manager and other people vs having sole responsibility as a nanny. Big difference.

I'm not paying under market rate

OP posts:
Wimbo · 07/07/2023 20:26

You’re likely paying under market rate and are now realising the difference in quality between someone used to a nursery setting with a manager and other people vs having sole responsibility as a nanny. Big difference.

TinyTeacher · 07/07/2023 20:22

It sounds like you don't trust her, so it won't work out.

Looking at her phone really isn't great. But does she get a proper break to allow her to do those things? I'm guessing tho older one doesn't nap?

It sounds like you need to sit down with her and have a non-judgemental chat about what you want and if she's happy to agree to that. My nanny takes my boys out to a planned activity each morning. They walk each way so it's nap time when they get back. I give her a free reign in the afternoon - they go in the garden or to the playground if the weather is nice, I otherwise yes they do potter about the playroom.

As far as tidying goes.... It depends on your kids! Some make more mayhem than others.... when our nanny started i said it would be nice to come back to roughly the same tidiness as when I left. So the playroom isn't amazing as it usually doesn't start that way! But it's pretty good.

Playdough drying out happens quickly at this time of year. Wrap it in slightly damp kitchen roll in its lot over night with the lid on and it's usually fine by morning. Drop of veg oil once a year. We've had ours for 7 years over 3 kids....

Complicated wooden toys will get messy. That might mean the nanny doesn't want to play with them. That's not a hill I would die on, personally. Our nanny doesn't do exactly what I would do with my boys each day - she does more messy play than I would and less reading. Whether you are ok with that depends on how many days she has them/how long the days are. Ours does 2 days so it doesn't bother me at all.

pleppapligg · 07/07/2023 20:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You're not getting a rise out of me with that comment. I know that's what you want.

OP posts:
Efficaciou5 · 07/07/2023 20:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

smartiesnskittles · 07/07/2023 20:13

Forget educational play, she's barely doing the basics. And those poor kids must be so bored.

New nanny needed.

In the meantime, a few rules. Dirty nappies changed immediately, and always check before mealtimes and leaving the house.

An outing a day. Park, playgroups, walk to shops etc. Fresh air and garden play daily, whatever the weather, but dressed appropriately for the weather.

A few activities are set up for the children daily. Teach them how to play and tidy. Eg. Train track set up and then all playing together developing language etc. Then tidy up together ready for meal/outdoors etc. obviously their attention won't stick, but aim for a bit of concentration. End of the day tidy up, perhaps with a song.

And If she's not making her own play dough, what sort of nanny is she?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread