Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 year old so rude and disrespectful to me

61 replies

Cantlastsixweeksofthis · 07/07/2023 19:02

Is this normal?

Dd is speaking to me rudely, for example if I bring toast, she’ll almost shout ‘I wanted cereal!’ Today she said ‘You’re doing everything wrong!’ Or she’ll say ‘I said not like that!’ It’s getting embarrassing in public and I have to admit I get angry at her as rudeness is my pet peeve, she sounds bratty and spoilt. She’s a lovely, fun, smart girl, but not when she is like this.
Can’t help wondering what I’m doing wrong and how to deal with this?

OP posts:
Sensibletrousers · 07/07/2023 20:55

I have one DS who is Autistic and another who has ADHD. They both have good manners and are never rude to people. There are two main reasons:

  1. We model manners to each other and to them. We talk to them nicely, say please and thank you to them and each other in front of them, and have explicitly explained since they were tiny that “this family speaks kindly to each other” and then demonstrate it daily.
  2. Zero tolerance for rudeness and disrespect. Any rudeness would be met with “we do not talk to each other like that in this house” and they are told how they should have said things. We also apologise to them if we lose our cool or go too far, and expect the same respect in return.

Basically you have to show them how to behave by your behaviour, don’t be hypocritical (“do as I say, not as I do” is ridiculous and undermines your own efforts), practice mutual respect, and as others have said, have boundaries/ consequences and stick to them.

Gytgyt · 07/07/2023 20:53

Surprisedbysummer · 07/07/2023 20:47

As a teacher, I have noticed that polite, respectful children have polite respectful parents. Children model their behaviour on their parents. Shouty, rude children tend to have shouty rude parents.
The term,'Punishment', is so loved by a section of MN. Schools don't use the term anymore but talk about behaviour management. That is your goal OP, to encourage polite behaviour from your daughter by modelling polite respectful interaction in your dealings with your daughter. Honestly, it works.

How patronising. Nobody likes a know it all!

kyliekoo · 07/07/2023 20:51

I really hate the "who has she learnt this from?" or "she's mimicking you" comments. This is such complete nonsense, and overt mother shaming.

Kids aren't born polite, gentle little souls. We teach them to be that. My toddler used to bite others. It was a phase, he got over it. He certainly didn't learn that from me biting him!

Don't worry, OP. It's her age - she's seeing what she can get away with. Just stop engaging with her when she speaks like that, and she'll soon stop. I often use the phrase, "Let me know when you're ready to speak to me politely," then ignore them until they do.

Surprisedbysummer · 07/07/2023 20:47

As a teacher, I have noticed that polite, respectful children have polite respectful parents. Children model their behaviour on their parents. Shouty, rude children tend to have shouty rude parents.
The term,'Punishment', is so loved by a section of MN. Schools don't use the term anymore but talk about behaviour management. That is your goal OP, to encourage polite behaviour from your daughter by modelling polite respectful interaction in your dealings with your daughter. Honestly, it works.

Easterbunny23 · 07/07/2023 20:43

When he’s calm @Aquamarine1029 yes, I do. There’s no use in talking to him before the red mist has cleared. He’ll say sorry mummy and is very down on himself.

But once the red mist descends next time, it’ll happen again.

EvilElsa · 07/07/2023 20:42

I always said I wouldn't be doing anything if I was spoken to like that. 5 isn't too little to understand you speak nicely if you want something and you don't demand, shout or call names. You say please and thank you or you don't get what you want until you do. If you refuse you get nothing. If we are at a café or soft play and you behave that way we leave. No more fun. No shouting needed, just instruction and action if needed. I definitely wouldn't ignore someone talking to me like shit, children need to learn right from wrong. They can't go around speaking rudely to people and expecting them all to turn a blind eye and ignore it or give in to demands.

Saschka · 07/07/2023 20:42

My pet peeve is shouting repeatedly 'I'm thirsty,' as a demand. Instead of saying 'Please may I have a drink?' we've made it clear he needs to actually ask.

Oh god yes, infuriating! We reply “Are you darling? You should get yourself a drink then” until he cracks and rephrases it as a polite request.

Aquamarine1029 · 07/07/2023 20:32

Easterbunny23 · 07/07/2023 20:26

It’s so hard! Both my kids are rude sometimes and I’m at a loss.

My 4 year old is very very volatile, and when he’s lost his temper, he’ll shout awful things at me, like “you are stupid”. He doesn’t do it when he’s calm, it’s when he’s really lost it, but I have no idea how to handle it.

Do you not tell him to never, ever speak like that to you, or anyone, ever again? You don't make him face consequences for such awful behaviour?

Rinkydinkydoodle · 07/07/2023 20:31

what @WiddlinDiddlin said is a good approach.

Skelpit lugs were de rigeur in my childhood too but not a parenting style we emulate nowadays thank God.

‘Did you know it’s considered rude/cheeky to say/do whatever’ was our warning. Then if they spoke to us (or more rarely, others) rudely again we did what this post said. ‘You can make your lunch yourself then’ or ‘you can speak nicely or we can go home.’ Got to actually follow through and do it though! Can be embarrassing but it does work.

I agree it’s important to explain (as often as need be, in a measured way at a calm moment) why it is we don’t speak to one another unpleasantly. The consequences etc.

FWIW I’ve got two well-mannered children. The younger has always had a tendency to be cheekier than the elder, but only in private, and mainly now when she’s tired or not getting her own way. I do remember she was particularly defiant at four, I used to get some very interesting nursery reports. However, we worked on it. Now, as soon as I say ‘actually, you do it,’ or ‘the way you’re talking makes me think you’re too tired to go out with your mate later’ or ‘would you speak to your teacher like that?’ she stops it. She’s probably getting slightly lippier again now she’s a tween so there are definitely phases, maybe it’s transitional as they edge towards independence. Testing the boundaries. A bit of verbal rebellion is natural kid-ness of course, they’re not robots, but overall she’s a notably well-mannered lass and it’s been commented on in school/ friends’ houses. She also definitely knows where the line is at home.

I am not a strict parent overall and let a lot go (probably compensating for my own childhood) but I’ve seen a few of DCs friends who were jaw-droppingly cheeky at five still be so cheeky at ten and fifteen it’s tough to watch. Their parents tended to be the sort to ignore as well, so I haven’t any anecdotal proof they just grow out of it alone (unfortunately).

Easterbunny23 · 07/07/2023 20:26

It’s so hard! Both my kids are rude sometimes and I’m at a loss.

My 4 year old is very very volatile, and when he’s lost his temper, he’ll shout awful things at me, like “you are stupid”. He doesn’t do it when he’s calm, it’s when he’s really lost it, but I have no idea how to handle it.

itsgettingweird · 07/07/2023 20:23

Agree with snack size. Give her the option is ask nicely or have what you have brought her.

If you give her the option and she continues just say you won't be spoken to like that and walk away.

Yes - it's likely she'll escalate the behaviour at first to see if you mean it. So mean it!

If you are out and she says anything rude then tell her she has a chance to ask you nicely or you'll be going home.

Then follow through.

The trick is to practice your most bored voice and speak in that tone as it's often monotonous and therefore they understand they aren't getting a reaction.

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/07/2023 20:18

I used humour on whining. It might work with this behaviour, "I'm sorry I don't speak 'rude' I can't understand you" with ever increasing bafflement. When she speaks nicely, "thank goodness I can hear you now, what did you need lovely?". Takes some of the heat out of it.

SnackSizeRaisin · 07/07/2023 20:15

Cantlastsixweeksofthis · 07/07/2023 19:02

Is this normal?

Dd is speaking to me rudely, for example if I bring toast, she’ll almost shout ‘I wanted cereal!’ Today she said ‘You’re doing everything wrong!’ Or she’ll say ‘I said not like that!’ It’s getting embarrassing in public and I have to admit I get angry at her as rudeness is my pet peeve, she sounds bratty and spoilt. She’s a lovely, fun, smart girl, but not when she is like this.
Can’t help wondering what I’m doing wrong and how to deal with this?

I think it can be normal. Don't get angry though - remain firm but calm and insist on a more polite tone. Always make it a choice that she can ask politely or...(go home, not get any cereal, whatever the logical consequence is). Frame the request as "I would like you to speak more politely please. Would you like to ask for cereal politely, or stick with toast?" Calmly follow through and then move on. If you get angry it can turn into a stand off where no one can back down. And don't get personal or shame your daughter.

Aquamarine1029 · 07/07/2023 20:13

Of course you don't ignore behaviour like this from a five year old. Fucking hell, it's no wonder there are so many horribly behaved children when so many posters encourage you to ignore her.

This type of rudeness needs an immediate and very firm response.

Darkdiamond · 07/07/2023 20:11

I used to teach 5 years olds in a private school. Many of the parents were very wealthy and seemed to have a habit of allowing their children to speak to them like absolute garbage. Sometimes my mouth would be hanging open because of the scenes I saw. The parents often came to me worried that maybe their child needed to see a psychologist as their behaviour was so challenging at home. I used to think, stop letting them speak to you like something on their shoe for a start! I cannot imagine ever speaking to my mother like that at 5, and ever doing it again!

Cantlastsixweeksofthis · 07/07/2023 20:10

Yes I can’t ignore it, some behaviours I can, but with this it’s something I really don’t like at all.

OP posts:
EsmeSusanOgg · 07/07/2023 20:02

This seems to be a phase 4 and 5 year olds go through. We correct. But politely. If we lose our rag, it just makes DS do it more.

My pet peeve is shouting repeatedly 'I'm thirsty,' as a demand. Instead of saying 'Please may I have a drink?' we've made it clear he needs to actually ask.

But, his friends are all either going through/ have gone through this recently.

They're testing a boundary. Don't let them cross it, but also don't get visibly angry - it'll just make it worse.

Faradalla · 07/07/2023 20:02

Absolutely do not ignore it! What dreadful advice. My daughter is 5 as well and this evening she was trying it on. I didn't think twice about telling her not to speak to me like that. Enforce your boundaries calmly and confidently. Children are always searching for the boundaries and it's actually what they want, deep down (and need). She needs to learn that rudeness doesn't get her anywhere.

Twillow · 07/07/2023 20:00

It is pretty normal for some youngsters to have a 'testing the limits' phase like this - show her what the limits are! Say'That's not very nice', ignore the @I wanted x instead' and walk away. Stay calm but firm and don't let it trigger you.
If she does it when you're out take her home immediately if you can.

Saschka · 07/07/2023 19:56

DS went through a phase of this. An icy “DS, that was incredibly rude. Do you want to ask me politely, or do you want to go without?” worked. I had to follow through a few times, but once he realised I meant it he stopped.

We also talked about “best manners” for strangers: you can say “Mummy can I have a drink?”, but for strangers you need to be politer: “Please could I have a drink of water? Thank you”.

“I want a drink!” or even more annoying “My water bottle’s empty!” gets absolutely no response at all, beyond “oh that’s interesting. Hope you sort it out!”

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 07/07/2023 19:55

What do you mean when you say you get angry?

DidyouNO · 07/07/2023 19:54

I recommend reading Therapeutic parenting by Sarah Naish. Also get a copy of A-Z of therapeutic parenting where you can look up the behaviour and read the parenting 'reaction'
It makes so much sense. Like a real parenting how to.

35965a · 07/07/2023 19:51

Correct it every time. Definitely don’t ignore it!

7Worfs · 07/07/2023 19:48

Why did you get angry? You should’ve just said ”You aren’t getting toast nor cereal until you remember your manners” or something to that effect, and manage the situation calmly.

If she is embarrassingly rude, you firmly say “Don’t speak like that, it’s rude”, and if she gives you the lip, speak sternly and apply a consequence immediately.

Ladylonglegs · 07/07/2023 19:42

Don’t ignore it — that’s terrible advice. My children didn’t do this so no, I don’t think it’s normal but it can be changed. Sometimes we all get into bad habits and behaviours without realising. Have you asked anyone else you know why they think she’s acting like this?