Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 year old so rude and disrespectful to me

61 replies

Cantlastsixweeksofthis · 07/07/2023 19:02

Is this normal?

Dd is speaking to me rudely, for example if I bring toast, she’ll almost shout ‘I wanted cereal!’ Today she said ‘You’re doing everything wrong!’ Or she’ll say ‘I said not like that!’ It’s getting embarrassing in public and I have to admit I get angry at her as rudeness is my pet peeve, she sounds bratty and spoilt. She’s a lovely, fun, smart girl, but not when she is like this.
Can’t help wondering what I’m doing wrong and how to deal with this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PomTiddlyPomPom · 08/07/2023 08:40

OlympicProcrastinator · 08/07/2023 06:33

I despair at some of these replies. My children have on occasions tried this and a simple, “nope. The way you’re speaking is rude and won’t be tolerated.” Or “do NOT speak to me like that” followed by the nice, pleasant way as an example. They repeat it back nicely and THEN they get what they want.

Never would I give my kids something if they didn’t say please or spoke rudely to me. Equally, I say please and thank you to them, speak kindly and respectfully and model good behaviour.

All this ‘ignore’ it and ‘wait for them to calm down’ crap is indulgent nonsense.

This in spades!
I wouldn't have let mine speak to me like that as toddlers never mind at five years old.
Developmentally five year olds are capable of understanding that being rude to mum is not on, they wouldn't get away with that behaviour in school and they know it.
Nip it in the bud OP or you are in for some rough teenage years.

billy1966 · 08/07/2023 08:25

Absolutely no way I would tolerate that.

Do not bring her anywhere.
Dump her meal when she speaks like that.

No technology and very early to bed because she is obviously tired.

Most children do not speak to their parents like that but I have definitely seen a bit of it.

In each case the mother was very soft and kind.

This will only get worse and will be noticed by others.

Other parents will judge you both and will prefer if their child doesn't get involved with her.

You are really letting her down by not being super firm.

Also the way she speaks to you could leak into how she treats others and come 8-10 you could have a deeply unpleasant child on your hands.

Nip this very firmly in the bud.

DysmalRadius · 08/07/2023 07:53

I know a lot of people who swear by 'hand in hand' parenting too and I've done a free session with one of their team which was very useful as a reminder of how much logic you can expect from a child and how you can keep your cool when they're losing it. Generally I think the more ideas we have of what to do, the easier it is to find something that works in the moment.

Easterbunny23 · 08/07/2023 06:50

Thanks @DysmalRadius and @7worfs.

Yes I think the injury thing is a sense of embarrassment for sure.

He’s a lovely little guy when he’s not in a rage, he’s always had huge, deep feeling emotions, since day 1. He used to scream like he was being murdered as a hungry baby! But it definitely comes with a price.

OlympicProcrastinator · 08/07/2023 06:33

I despair at some of these replies. My children have on occasions tried this and a simple, “nope. The way you’re speaking is rude and won’t be tolerated.” Or “do NOT speak to me like that” followed by the nice, pleasant way as an example. They repeat it back nicely and THEN they get what they want.

Never would I give my kids something if they didn’t say please or spoke rudely to me. Equally, I say please and thank you to them, speak kindly and respectfully and model good behaviour.

All this ‘ignore’ it and ‘wait for them to calm down’ crap is indulgent nonsense.

Ginger1982 · 08/07/2023 05:56

I can sympathise. My 6 year old can be similar and I get angry too if he's repeatedly rude to me. I will speak in a calm voice initially but do admit if he persists I do lose my temper. We're all human at the end of the day.

DysmalRadius · 07/07/2023 23:58

Easterbunny23 · 07/07/2023 20:43

When he’s calm @Aquamarine1029 yes, I do. There’s no use in talking to him before the red mist has cleared. He’ll say sorry mummy and is very down on himself.

But once the red mist descends next time, it’ll happen again.

My son was like this at that age and what really helped was talking about it when he was calm and explaining that being cross is ok but being unkind isn't.

I found it really helped to focus on what he can do when he's cross to help relieve that urge to lash out (shouting, stamping feet, punching a pillow) rather than what he can't. This then means that you can redirect it when it happens with an alternative and it means they aren't compounding whatever went wrong originally with a post meltdown guilt/telling off for rudeness.

Injuries are a flash point for my son too - he doesn't want sympathy or cuddles, just to be left alone so I respect that and leave him to it until he's ready for a bit of commiseration. I'd focus on taking the personal attacks out while reassuring that we all feel frustrated and angry, but we don't need to ruin someone else's day over it!

MrsTerryPratchett · 07/07/2023 23:48

Surprisedbysummer · 07/07/2023 20:47

As a teacher, I have noticed that polite, respectful children have polite respectful parents. Children model their behaviour on their parents. Shouty, rude children tend to have shouty rude parents.
The term,'Punishment', is so loved by a section of MN. Schools don't use the term anymore but talk about behaviour management. That is your goal OP, to encourage polite behaviour from your daughter by modelling polite respectful interaction in your dealings with your daughter. Honestly, it works.

Nature.

Nurture.

Teachers aren't in the main evolutionary psychologists. Being 'slow approach', shy or quiet are very stable, heritable traits. Fortunately, being judgemental isn't. It's a choice.

Darkdiamond · 07/07/2023 21:44

Surprisedbysummer · 07/07/2023 20:47

As a teacher, I have noticed that polite, respectful children have polite respectful parents. Children model their behaviour on their parents. Shouty, rude children tend to have shouty rude parents.
The term,'Punishment', is so loved by a section of MN. Schools don't use the term anymore but talk about behaviour management. That is your goal OP, to encourage polite behaviour from your daughter by modelling polite respectful interaction in your dealings with your daughter. Honestly, it works.

I agree with this, but as a teacher you will know that modelling is only part of the learning process. Children need support to apply their learning and a big part of this is swift, meaningful feedback. I agree that we should model the behaviour we want children to imitate, but they also need firm boundaries and redirection. I'm a Year 1 teacher with a 5 year old myself. I am a calm and respectful in my interactions with children, but my own kids still test the boundaries and that needs to be addressed, there and then. Modelling can only go so far. When I was doing my teacher training, one of my lecturers said 'with children, always make the implicit explicit' and that has been my mantra for almost two decades.

7Worfs · 07/07/2023 21:35

@Easterbunny23 interesting. My 4yo has started getting self-conscious about falling/hurting himself in front of people; probably sense of embarrassment developing. He now won’t let me ask if he’s ok or offer a cuddle.

PeachesOnTheBeaches · 07/07/2023 21:26

Easterbunny23 · 07/07/2023 21:11

Yes you’re right @7Worfs but it doesn’t make it any less mortifying when it’s in public!

I have no idea how to anchor him. I need to read The Explosive Child. He moves on relatively quickly once calm but the damage is done in terms of public meltdowns. His main trigger is if he hurts himself but it could be anything when he’s in a bad mood.

Who cares if it’s happening in public?

Don’t parent for Doris down the road like so many do. Parent your actual child and sod everyone else.

JazbayGrapes · 07/07/2023 21:16

she's likely copying you or other adults.

Easterbunny23 · 07/07/2023 21:11

Yes you’re right @7Worfs but it doesn’t make it any less mortifying when it’s in public!

I have no idea how to anchor him. I need to read The Explosive Child. He moves on relatively quickly once calm but the damage is done in terms of public meltdowns. His main trigger is if he hurts himself but it could be anything when he’s in a bad mood.

MrsJamin · 07/07/2023 21:09

You must absolutely deal with this right now. Don't do anything for her if she is rude to you. Seriously you'll be in so much trouble by the time she hits preteens, and it'll be too late. I never let my boys be rude to me and now they're very pleasant teenagers to live with, with respect for me and other people.

Gytgyt · 07/07/2023 21:06

Ladylonglegs · 07/07/2023 20:58

It’s not patronising. It’s the truth.

I can't stand that type of tone and it's usually by those that think they know all yet don't even have their own kids yet. I'll just agree to disagree with you on this one.

Fillyfrog · 07/07/2023 21:04

My DD went through this at 5 and 6. I used to think who is she talking to?! One little tidbit that helped for me is 'would you speak to Mrs Jones like that?!' (insert their own teacher name there) she would say no. I'd say well don't speak to me like that please, it's rude and unkind. You could see her thinking about it afterwards and it definitely nipped it in the bud a few times.

bussteward · 07/07/2023 21:04

DD4 is going through this phase too, maybe it is a 4-5 year old thing. She also does the thing mentioned by pp, “My water is empty!” Irritatingly from several rooms away and I haaaate being bellowed at by anyone from a different room, I won’t have it. I can hear her growing increasingly furious and doing Rumpelstiltskin foot stomps, working herself into an empty water bottle frenzy. It’s always, always worse when she’s tired or hungry so after de-escalating and appropriate response, I deploy porridge or banana.

It’s also always worse if I butt heads with her – I’m very sleep-deprived with the new baby and have zero patience so occasionally lose my rag with the rudeness and it never ends well, we both just ramp up and up and up. Staying calm stops it getting worse, even if she continues to be a ratbag and it doesn’t actually get better. She does always apologise and will sometimes explain that she was hungry/tired/angry and didn’t know why (I know why: hungry/tired/too much TV) and so she was rude/shouty. We’re working on appropriate ways to deal with being angry, so sometimes she’ll run off in the middle of a rudeness spell yelling “I NEED QUIET TIME!” and go and seethe in her bedroom at the injustice of life. Then return later to apologise and request, politely, the thing she wanted in the first place. We also use lines like “We don’t shout in this house”, and “You’re right, I was grumpy this morning and I shouldn’t have been, I’m sorry” – she’s very keen, rightly, to point out that I’m also a ratbag at the moment.

RedRobyn2021 · 07/07/2023 21:03
  1. Model how you want your child to behave
  1. Do some research about what your child is developmentally capable of at only 5-years-old
  1. Adjust your expectations
  1. Don't listen to the authoritarian parents of Mumsnet, it is gross and outdated.
Greentree1 · 07/07/2023 21:01

Tell her it's not acceptable, she is old enough to understand. Consequences if she carries on, you should not be abused by your child, even verbally.

willstarttomorrow · 07/07/2023 21:00

Of course it needs to be tackled appropriately. However please been mindful of the behaviours that you as adults are modeling to your children. I work in child protection so at the extreme end. Children learn societal norms from those around them. At such a young age they have not yet learnt appropriate behaviours, it is your job as an adult to manage and work with this. They will not yet understand context of why this is important. Of course it is okay to be annoyed, but you also need to consider your child's lived experiences. Many adults and parents talk to each without respect, shout and say horrible things. Our children pick up on this.

MissyB1 · 07/07/2023 20:58

Saschka · 07/07/2023 19:56

DS went through a phase of this. An icy “DS, that was incredibly rude. Do you want to ask me politely, or do you want to go without?” worked. I had to follow through a few times, but once he realised I meant it he stopped.

We also talked about “best manners” for strangers: you can say “Mummy can I have a drink?”, but for strangers you need to be politer: “Please could I have a drink of water? Thank you”.

“I want a drink!” or even more annoying “My water bottle’s empty!” gets absolutely no response at all, beyond “oh that’s interesting. Hope you sort it out!”

Yes this is pretty much how I would handle it. A sharp look and and calm but stern voice. And never give or do what she has just demanded! She either speaks politely or goes without!

Ladylonglegs · 07/07/2023 20:58

Gytgyt · 07/07/2023 20:53

How patronising. Nobody likes a know it all!

It’s not patronising. It’s the truth.

7Worfs · 07/07/2023 20:57

Easterbunny23 · 07/07/2023 20:43

When he’s calm @Aquamarine1029 yes, I do. There’s no use in talking to him before the red mist has cleared. He’ll say sorry mummy and is very down on himself.

But once the red mist descends next time, it’ll happen again.

You are describing a different issue - it’s not the rudeness that’s the issue, it’s your DS struggling to regulate his emotions and they completely overwhelm him.

Read on how to anchor him and help him regulate.
Think about his triggers - at that age it could be that he feels so powerless over his life that he needs a bit more choice/independence (within reason and in a controlled environment).

PeachesOnTheBeaches · 07/07/2023 20:57

Gytgyt · 07/07/2023 20:53

How patronising. Nobody likes a know it all!

She’s 100% right.

PeachesOnTheBeaches · 07/07/2023 20:56

No, it’s not normal at age 5. Toddler age, yes absolutely, but she should have been taught better by now.

How did you react to it when she was a toddler? Did you not teach her manners?

If you’re getting angry that’s just adding fuel to the fire and she’s going to do it more.

Swipe left for the next trending thread