Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have I broken up with her? And was I wrong to do so?

53 replies

SitItOut · 07/07/2023 15:45

We are two women.

The background:

I am currently receiving chemotherapy. I’ve tried to carry on life as normally as possible, the prognosis is very good. I’m very active.

I’ve been seeing someone for 4 months, it’s a long distance relationship, she lives 300 miles away. When she comes to visit, she stays for a couple of weeks or so. We video chat daily, several times a day, we eat together, garden together, walk together, that sort of thing. The distance doesn’t bother either of us, we enjoy a change of scene.

Several times it has happened that my partner seems to have absolutely no idea what I’m going through or considers it when making her plans. Examples:

Wanting to go out dancing late, when it reached midnight, I suggested it was time to go, she didn’t want to, I finally just stood up and insisted, I was exhausted and my whole body was aching. As we made our way home, she said she did not like that I had rushed her and she’d had to down her drink quickly.

She insisted on going on a big trip that would take all day and most of the evening… she stated she was going whether I went with her or not, because she had already bought the train tickets, I said that’s fine, I’ll join you later in the day when I’d had time to rest. We’d been on the go daily for nearly two weeks, and I was dead on my feet. She put quite a lot of pressure on, I wanted to make her happy, so I went. This was early on in our relationship.

One evening I had a bath and told her I was very happy the tension in my body had eased somewhat… she asked why there should be tension in my body?

She has asked me how I am maybe once or twice in 4 months. She never mentions my treatment. She hasn’t asked a single question about it. I don’t think she’s ever even Googled what chemotherapy is.

She is from a European culture that is quite no nonsense and not “mushy”. I’m not sure though that this can entirely explain her reactions.

The last straw was that she brought her teenage son and rather large pet with her, because she wanted to show her son my city. I don’t think she considered the extra burden that would put on me during this time, my home is quite small. I don’t mind having her family to stay, but perhaps this is best when I’ve finished my treatment? Her son lives with his father full time.

Last night I told her that because of the above examples, I couldn’t take her seriously as a partner, that we can enjoy each other’s company and have fun, but as to the rest, this wasn’t an ideal sort of relationship for me.

She video called me today, and I couldn’t face it, I texted her that I was napping today and I would text her tomorrow. She said she was sending me warm hugs. I’m not sure what to do next. I feel sad.

Have I broken up with her? Was I unreasonable to do so?

OP posts:
OneFlipflopleft · 07/07/2023 21:01

And here we go, live experience:) I forgot to express the most important part; to wish you a lot of strength and power and a good recovery.

C152 · 07/07/2023 21:19

I'm sorry for your diagnosis, OP, and I am glad that the prognosis is good.

In terms of your partner, no, to me it doesn't sound like you've broken up with her. It sounds like you're happy for the relationship to be casual and perhaps she wanted to video call you to discuss this?

Whether you do actually break up is neither right nor wrong. Some people just aren't suited, or just aren't right for each other at a particular time. However, she doesn't sound cruel and unfeeling to me, OP. But it does sound like you both communicate in different ways, and part of potentially different expectations on both sides may very well be cultural.

I also think it is possible you may be expecting too much of her in understanding the actual reality of chemotherapy. I personally haven't found a single person who understands the reality, unless they've been through it themselves. True, some can be more thoughtful than others and actually ask what it is like for you, but most people haven't the faintest idea and some may very well be afriad/embarrassed to ask. She has also admitted to you her thought process - perhaps she views it in the same way as her aunt: you may be sick of talking about it, so she won't be the one to bring it up, but she will show how she cares in other ways.

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 07/07/2023 21:21

I'm sorry it sounds like she is using you. You don't have to stay with her if the situation isn't making you happy. You have enough on your plate already. Hope you get well soon xx

Grumpy101 · 07/07/2023 21:38

Take a step back, at least take a break. You are going through something massive and she's not that supportive. Fuck cultural differences, she's being uncaring.

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 07/07/2023 21:51

Indeed. You shouldn't have to do mental gymnastics to try and justify someone's behaviour towards you. If it doesn't feel right, it isnt right, whatever the reasons may be.

SitItOut · 07/07/2023 21:58

OneFlipflopleft · 07/07/2023 20:57

When I read your posts I read your love for her through the lines.
You are the writer but still I also sense her love for you. You two have different ways of showing love and different ways of communicating.
Throw away your expectations and just openly speak out when something she does or says sits wrong with you. Do not keep it in and wait with speaking out when it has already become a problem for you. It might be that there is the difference.
I have my roots in a European country where indeed we are direct when we speak, and we do also try and solve everything with a joke. But it is to get you to smile. It is meant well, but perhaps perceived as blunt. Which I can understand, she can too probably. When it is explained or nipped in the bud.
Good luck for you both, I think there is love there, just needs some tuning.

Thank you for your beautiful messages, they are very helpful and kind.

Initially I thought they were isolated incidents and I didn’t want to jump on her for oversights. Dealing with each one individually at the time would have been better though. I will learn from this.

I did tell her the staff had told me there have been suicides during treatment sometimes, that this journey occasionally breaks people. I did tell her the side effects can be extremely severe. Can someone really miss the seriousness of the situation?

I wonder if she may be neurodivergent.
She can take things literally at times.
She has an extremely strict diet.
She’s a whizz with numbers.
she’s fairly androgynous.
She appears to love being alone a lot, and doesn’t have any close friends, although she is friendly and sociable.
She has several times taken things literally in amusing ways after she’s had a few drinks.
She once told me she never misses people, that she knows she’ll see them again but doesn’t miss them.
She said she wasn’t sad after she broke up with her ex, she just moved on, and that was that.
I’ve never heard anyone tell me they never miss anyone.

A little bit of comfort would have been nice. When I’ve occasionally told her what has happened on infusion day, I am met with silence, she may occasionally nod, or say okay, then we move swiftly on. Once I told her I had been in A&E the night before but everything was fine, she didn’t ask what had happened or what the Drs said, so I didn’t mention it, never did ask what all that was about!

OP posts:
SitItOut · 07/07/2023 22:01

C152 · 07/07/2023 21:19

I'm sorry for your diagnosis, OP, and I am glad that the prognosis is good.

In terms of your partner, no, to me it doesn't sound like you've broken up with her. It sounds like you're happy for the relationship to be casual and perhaps she wanted to video call you to discuss this?

Whether you do actually break up is neither right nor wrong. Some people just aren't suited, or just aren't right for each other at a particular time. However, she doesn't sound cruel and unfeeling to me, OP. But it does sound like you both communicate in different ways, and part of potentially different expectations on both sides may very well be cultural.

I also think it is possible you may be expecting too much of her in understanding the actual reality of chemotherapy. I personally haven't found a single person who understands the reality, unless they've been through it themselves. True, some can be more thoughtful than others and actually ask what it is like for you, but most people haven't the faintest idea and some may very well be afriad/embarrassed to ask. She has also admitted to you her thought process - perhaps she views it in the same way as her aunt: you may be sick of talking about it, so she won't be the one to bring it up, but she will show how she cares in other ways.

No one understands, you are right, but everyone, without exception, has understood that I may be suffering, and may have needs, and ask about how I’m feeling.

OP posts:
SitItOut · 07/07/2023 22:12

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 07/07/2023 16:37

That's a hugely intense relationship, 4 months and she visits for a madly busy 2 weeks each time. Even without your treatment, that would be exhausting for quite a lot of us!
She needs to understand too that culturally you sometimes do and perceive things differently.
Yes, you've put the brakes on things, you've said things need to slow down. I'm not sure that you have actually broken up completely. What is needed is a bit of breathing space and for her to be a bit more mindful of you having treatment and how floored it leaves you. She'd be very welcome at your local Maggie's centre, or one nearer to her, and they would be able to chat and answer questions that she might not feel she can ask of you.

I sent he a link to one of the cancer centres in her city, I explained they offer support to friends and family. That was 4pm. Then at 9pm, I sent her another message wishing her goodnight very nicely. She hasn’t respond to either. So I am being ignored, given the silent treatment. I suppose she thought that is what I have been doing today and is doing it back. Although I’ve never ignored her messages, and I took my leave of her today, rather than disappearing without explanation.

Once, when we were talking about something, she told me if there’s a behaviour she dislikes, she likes to do it back to the person, to show them why it’s not desirable. I told her I just prefer to tell the person what it was I didn’t like and just remove myself from the situation, she said my way was better, she volunteered that, I didn’t ask her. So I think she’s got for this, although I’ve never experienced it.

She also explained her former relationship had become very toxic and that was why it had to end for good. Does it not take two participants for a relationship to become toxic? That information is now making me nervous.

OP posts:
Justkeepingplatesspinning · 07/07/2023 23:09

You can't control how she behaves and responds to you, but you can control the effect you allow it to have.
I think you've been polite and warm while keeping your boundaries in place, and if she is 'tit for tat' ignoring you it's misplaced.
There's not much else you can do but look after your own wellbeing. If she's meant for you, it'll come right.

SitItOut · 07/07/2023 23:36

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 07/07/2023 21:21

I'm sorry it sounds like she is using you. You don't have to stay with her if the situation isn't making you happy. You have enough on your plate already. Hope you get well soon xx

The thought did cross my mind.

There was a super weird situation where she told me that she knows me and not to go super crazy treating her son to experiences. I didn’t realise that there could be an expectation that I will be treating her son. I will be providing them with a bed and food and surely the rest is for her?

After a few days, I noticed if we were out and about, and looking at ice cream vans or stopping for drinks and snacks, her son would say yes, if I offered, and say I don’t know if she offered. He seemed very uncomfortable awkward when this happened. I had the sense he may have been told to do this by his mum.

She is currently studying a course online and not working, so money I would imagine would be tight, although she has two or three side hustles. I

I don’t mind chilling in but not if it’s done like that.

She also gave her card to her son at times, and HE would produce it when it was time to pay, I felt awkward taking a card from a child. He’s 14.

Once, she said she wasn’t sure where her card was, I waited and she produced it from her phone case.

On the evening of the dancing, she gave her slim card wallet to me because she said her outfit didn’t have space. When we got to the bar, I wasn’t thirsty, she she bought herself, a drink, from a card she produced from her trousers, I don’t know what was in the card wallet, maybe spare cards.

I was a bit baffled and my alarms were going off. I paid for myself only after the first few episodes, in the last, we had usually taken it in turns to pay.

Did I overreact?

I couldn’t be sure if what was happening was what appeared to be bappening.

If she had just said she was short, there wouldn’t need to be a all this awkwardness.

I’m not working right now either, and I have no side hustles.

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 08/07/2023 06:52

Going against the grain, I think yab a bit u embarking on a long distance relationship when you have so much going on. These kind of relationships tend to be full on for the periods you spend together. Hope your chemotherapy is successful and you're in a better place to have a more satisfying relationship soon.

JMSA · 08/07/2023 06:59

If you have broken up with her, then you've 100% done the right thing.

Her son living full-time with his father is a major red flag too. She's probably a person that people don't want to be around, and for good reason.

SitItOut · 08/07/2023 10:14

JMSA · 08/07/2023 06:59

If you have broken up with her, then you've 100% done the right thing.

Her son living full-time with his father is a major red flag too. She's probably a person that people don't want to be around, and for good reason.

I did wonder about this. I didn’t ask why, I thought it might be too sensitive or prying a question. She said she didn’t really know him anymore and saw him maybe once a month. Bringing him along was to get to know him better.

She said the father had tried to brainwash the children because he is both homophobic and racist. I assumed this might be the reason.

She had previously left the children for months at a time whilst “travelling” with her ex. She said she had paid for some of these travels with a credit card and had some debt still to clear now.

The father apparently told her to please let him know when she’s leaving the kids and the country so they can live with him during that time, she said she wants to train her children to be self sufficient and responsible (which they are), and also that they did not at the time want to live with their father.
The 14 year old obviously changed his mind at some point.
I initially assumed he had moved because he was getting older and didn’t have his own room and his brother would be gaming and shouting into the small hours.

On the being financially responsible front, she’d also started two businesses apparently, but neither were successful, because of Covid and other reasons related to rental properties were the business was being sold.
She said it’s been programmed in her culturally to be entrepreneurial.
She is definitely not “spend-y”, so I’m surprised she’s in debt.

The leaving teens at home and not telling their responsible father about it disturbed me… what if there was an emergency? She said she had left them with the numbers of two trusted female middle aged women who would keep an eye on them.
I can’t deny that she’s raised capable, polite, responsible teens.
She doesn’t believe in molly coddling or infantilising, because she and her siblings were raised the same way and she believes it was good for them.

OP posts:
AngleofTheNorth · 08/07/2023 10:39

She doesn’t believe in molly coddling or infantilising, because she and her siblings were raised the same way and she believes it was good for them.

Yet look at all the doubts you have about her ...

merryhouse · 08/07/2023 11:24

Hang on - she abandoned her children to go travelling with a fuckbuddy?

(That's before we get on to the financial stuff...)

Morewineplease10 · 08/07/2023 11:27

There is a lot going on here OP.

Some good stuff but also quite a lot of red flags.

I'd knock it on the head and focus on you and your recovery for the foreseeable.

SitItOut · 08/07/2023 13:04

Morewineplease10 · 08/07/2023 11:27

There is a lot going on here OP.

Some good stuff but also quite a lot of red flags.

I'd knock it on the head and focus on you and your recovery for the foreseeable.

I’m leaning towards keeping it casual until I have finished my treatment, and saving any visits for post treatment. Happy to stay in contact and make travel plans for the future, that might be a nice way to forget what has happened recently. Her other son is 19 now and I won’t be concerned that I’m aiding and abetting a mother leaving her children.

We seem to be great travel companions and have that in common.

I wouldn’t have got through recent times as easily without her. She did spend all day with me at the cancer centre once while she was here, she offered, I didn’t ask. We chatted and that helped pass the many hours because there was a hold up that day.

We have so many things in common, I am extremely attracted to her. I quite like her plane speaking actually. I love that she is very into self development and is actually emotionally literate, in the sense that she’s an excellent lister and listens to understand is very open minded and non judgemental to a fault. And I absolutely adore all the get up and go she has!

If it wasn’t for all the sex stuff and the slight coldness, no one would be able to pry her from my cold lifeless hands!

OP posts:
SitItOut · 09/07/2023 23:28

We have broken up.

She sent me a long text saying she wanted to explain everything.

She said she consciously didn’t ask me how I was or discuss my treatment with me, because she believes words have power. And that she knew I would be feeling unwell all the time, and that by asking me about it, she would be making me say negative things about my health, and that might result in negative outcomes. So this was her way of supporting me through this.

She said I never told her I was tired the night we went out dancing, and if I had, that would have been the end of it, she would have left a full drink without a second glance. And if I had done so, we need never have discussed it again.

The day of the big trip, she said I wanted to go out the night before, and had been drinking and basically that I had made my own self tired and that is why she said the next morning that she was going with or without me… if I had not suggested going out the night before, then she would have been happy to stay home with me if I was not feeling good.

The tension in the body, and said she sometimes feels her emotions as tension in the body and that was her way of asking what I was feeling…
Although she had just finished saying why she avoids asking me how am / how I’m feeling.

She said “if you have not found me as a good partner for deep talks the you expect me to be, I am sorry but you need to decide if you want to continue.”

That line especially I think highlights the personality traits I’ve been dealing with… the frankly blunt brutality at times.

So it is over, I took her up on her offer.

OP posts:
Justkeepingplatesspinning · 10/07/2023 04:49

It sounds as though it's the right outcome, I'm not understanding some of the explanations, hope you're okay.

Riapia · 10/07/2023 05:14

She’s a selfish and self centred arsehole.
Not someone you need in your life at any time. Especially at this time.
Good luck with your treatment.
❤️❤️

BritInAus · 10/07/2023 05:14

It sounds like you are very different people with very different needs, wants and communication styles. I think you have made the right decision to end things. I can't imagine anyone - however blunt or plain speaking - to have their partner (who has cancer) saying they went to A&E the night before and literally just ignoring it. That's not blunt - that's really, really weird and uncaring.

You sound lovely - best wishes for your treatment and I hope there's a wonderful woman out there for you when it feels right :)

SitItOut · 10/07/2023 10:24

BritInAus · 10/07/2023 05:14

It sounds like you are very different people with very different needs, wants and communication styles. I think you have made the right decision to end things. I can't imagine anyone - however blunt or plain speaking - to have their partner (who has cancer) saying they went to A&E the night before and literally just ignoring it. That's not blunt - that's really, really weird and uncaring.

You sound lovely - best wishes for your treatment and I hope there's a wonderful woman out there for you when it feels right :)

Thank you everyone for you well wishes, very kind!

She IS a little unusual. That’s why I thought about neurodivergence.

If so, that would explain a lot… she had told me herself she can be easily fooled… apparently she dated a man for two years who was married, but she didn’t know he was married, even though she rarely saw him, and even then only on weekday evenings.

She has an extreme believe that people are free to do as they like without anyone interfering or questioning them. Each belief of hers is taken to an extreme. She was genuinely concerned that it hadn’t occurred to her he may be married, she just believed what he said.

She was brought up in a very rural place in a very traditional way, and hadn’t lived in a big city until she immigrated 20 years ago.
She met her last partner through work and had considered herself straight up until that point.

It was her partner who introduced her to group sex, threesomes, an open relationship… she said she found the open aspect extremely difficult for some time, but did it for her partner and got used to it and grew to like everything.

Her parents are very traditional and were distressed at her coming out.
They blamed her partner for changing her. A lot of her ideas seem to come from her ex.

I suspect she may have been a bit vulnerable and not worldly wise and was preyed upon. She fiercely defends her partner and regrets nothing. I didn’t criticise but asked questions.

Being so malleable and suggestible, yet so fierce and tough at the same time… I worry for her a little, and her children, but I also don’t need any of that.

OP posts:
Fraaahnces · 10/07/2023 10:42

I’m sorry that this woman couldn’t be a proper partner to you when you need one. Would someone with her beliefs be able to be monogamous? I think you were already feeling lonely within that relationship and there are few things worse. She seemed very happy for you to provide food and lodging for free which suited her travel agenda. I suspect a lot of her explanations are actually justifications for bad behaviour, tbh.

Thesenderofthiscard · 10/07/2023 10:47

4 months? I’m not sure that’s anything more than a girlfriend.
you hardly no-one another, of course she doesn’t really know what going on with you.

but it’s not working for you, so move on.

Thesenderofthiscard · 10/07/2023 10:50

Oh, and sexually you seem completely incompatible.
You don’t want to be in an open relationship, but she’s already in one and you’re the newbie? Forget it. Find yourself a nice , monogamous lesbian without all that baggage.