Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car crash at Wimbledon school.

534 replies

DataNotLore · 07/07/2023 13:40

Can everyone stop driving these fucking stupid ego-tanks in urban areas now?

Who needs a fucking wank panzer in Wimbledon???

Ban them in urban areas.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
MLMsuperfan · 12/07/2023 12:51

Non-commercial vehicles should have a maximum bonnet height such that a four foot person would not be pulled underneath the vehicle in the event of a collision.

SamanthaCaine · 12/07/2023 12:47

Pearlsaminga · 12/07/2023 12:16

5k a day fine for anyone breaking the restrictions
Forcing them to walk 5K a day might be a better deterrent 🤣

🤣🤣 brilliant!

SamanthaCaine · 12/07/2023 12:47

@OneTC

Glad to hear you were ok. Obviously all accidents are different but TV presenter Dan Walker was hit by an SUV at a lower speed and he was lucky to survive. The dash cam video was horrific.

I made a similar point upthread. It most definitely is an arms race as you need an ever larger vehicle to see over the one in front. My other car is a 2 seater roadster, which I've owned for aeons and I've noticed a definite change over the years. I have to drive with my wits about me more as I am often missed by SUV's looking to change lanes. They either can't see me below their doorline or their blind spot monitors don't scan that far below. Either way I have to make sure never to be alongside but ahead or in their nearside mirror.

We should really adopt the Japanese law for Kei cars as they reduce congestion too.

Pearlsaminga · 12/07/2023 12:43

They shouldn't be banned outright but they should be subject to higher charges when driving in urban areas, along the model of London congestion charge. And banned during certain times of day, like lorries
@potniatheron
It's not that I disagree with you, but one problem with higher charges is that the SUV then becomes a way to advertise your wealth and status, driving one becomes a way to show everyone that these higher charges are of no consequence to someone as rich as you.
I like the idea of restricting their usage but governments seem very hesitant to place restrictions on the wealthy and Powerful (presumably because they are wealthy and Powerful and do not wish to be restricted in any way)

potniatheron · 12/07/2023 12:22

Yeah I really don't see the point of the huge SUVs in urban areas ('wank panzer' is excellent and I shall be adopting it into my vocabulary).

Especially the ones with cattle bars on the front.

Interesting that you seem to have touched a nerve in this thread. Mumsnet is quick to call for a ban on all dogs when someone gets gored, even though it's a rare occurence and dogs bring so much joy and assistance to many. But no one needs a wank panzer in urban areas. Status symbol only.

They shouldn't be banned outright but they should be subject to higher charges when driving in urban areas, along the model of London congestion charge. And banned during certain times of day, like lorries.

Pearlsaminga · 12/07/2023 12:16

5k a day fine for anyone breaking the restrictions
Forcing them to walk 5K a day might be a better deterrent 🤣

Pearlsaminga · 12/07/2023 12:15

The people who buy these for safety are making a willing choice to endanger the lives of other road users. They are also making vehicles into an arms race
@OneTC
SO TRUE
I have long thought that there is an arms race going on when it comes to vehicles, they are all getting bigger and bigger I gave up cycling on the road and the long while back the massive vehicles crowd out everything, everywhere trying to navigate around each other I can barely see over them to cross the road these days. And the roads are getting pulverised full of potholes which makes everyone think they need a bigger vehicle to cope with the smashed up roads.
I wonder if we will end up in a situation where no one is allowed a vehicle over a certain size and weight, and you can't have more than a certain number of vehicles per person, because otherwise there will be no room for anyone to get on the roads 🤷

OneTC · 12/07/2023 12:10

Merrily pottering along on my bike once and a bloke in a fiesta ran into the back of me, he said, doing about 35mph.

Because I ended up on the bonnet I somehow escaped almost completely unharmed (bruised coccyx from when I fell off the bonnet) but if that had been a high fronted vehicle I don't imagine my outcome would have been as fortunate. I'd have either been seriously injured by the impact itself and/or I'd have been catapulted onto the busy roundabout.

The people who buy these for safety are making a willing choice to endanger the lives of other road users. They are also making vehicles into an arms race. When everyone is in a vehicle that is as dangerous as yours, what are you getting next?

The denial of physics and constant accusations of knee jerk reactions are ridiculous. There is nothing knee jerk about doing something that worsens outcomes for people every day, this event is just what has brought an ongoing conversation to the fore.

Fine some people need them, but prove that need and get that category or exemption added to your license.

The implementation of this would not be difficult, we have all the tools to do it already. Licenses, ULEZ zones, vehicle registration already covered it all. 5k a day fine for anyone breaking the restrictions

Anxioys · 12/07/2023 11:43

I am 6 foot tall and the bonnet of Defender would hit the top of my hip. That would put me on the ground. A child would have no chance, I think

Pearlsaminga · 12/07/2023 11:42

It's exactly why, as an engineer I despise them and would never buy one. It doesn't matter what you hit, pedestrians, cyclists, horse riders, other cars, the results are never good, except perhaps for the occupants of the SUV. Yet they handle worse, use more fuel, have the aerodynamics of a brick and generally cost more to run
If you try to explain that to the proto-homanids who salivate over these vehicles their eyes will glaze over with boredom, they don't care about that, as soon as they get behind the wheel they get a huge rush of dopamine because now everyone can see how GodLike rich and Powerful they are. Who cares if a few peasants are crushed 🤷

justteanbiscuits · 12/07/2023 11:17

In our row of 6 houses we are the only household that doesn't have a SUV. Every single one of those car's has a bonnet that roughly comes up near my shoulder and I am an adult woman. We live in London and the closest any of these has come to driving 'off road' is pulling onto their drive way. It's appalling.

SamanthaCaine · 12/07/2023 09:07

mollyminniemo · 12/07/2023 07:54

That photo does say it all SamanthaCaine. Horrific. The tank size of the thing then knowing how much it weighs too. Nobody stands a chance against that. Prowling around towns and villages right next to schools. Zero need for an off road vehicle in London whatsoever they are absolute monstrosities. I only hope some people with them think twice about keeping them and anyone in a city actually still considering owning such a stupid thing will now think twice.

Definitely. I appreciate it's an American vehicle but you could easily substitute any SUV in the UK and it would look terrible.

It's exactly why, as an engineer I despise them and would never buy one. It doesn't matter what you hit, pedestrians, cyclists, horse riders, other cars, the results are never good, except perhaps for the occupants of the SUV. Yet they handle worse, use more fuel, have the aerodynamics of a brick and generally cost more to run.

Small, lightweight and economic needs to be the default for most people and this type of vehicle reserved for the 5% of people that actually need them.

Hopefully one day they'll become as socially unacceptable as bull bars, before they were banned.

MissHen · 12/07/2023 09:00

Perhaps there should be a 'Special demonstration' event of these vehicles and Supercars. Safety, capabilities and Implications of owning. Each driver goes out with an instructor on an off road course. If they're a worry suggest they sign up for a 'luxury' weekend of driving instruction.
As a society we need to respond to this tragedy, there should be review and response.

bonfirebash · 12/07/2023 08:13

mollyminniemo · 12/07/2023 07:57

Interestingly also - the Land Rover Insta has removed ability to comment in posts… wandering if the backlash has (hopefully) begun?

Not that I've heard. I'm just hoping people don't take it out on the people who work for Land Rover

mollyminniemo · 12/07/2023 07:57

Interestingly also - the Land Rover Insta has removed ability to comment in posts… wandering if the backlash has (hopefully) begun?

mollyminniemo · 12/07/2023 07:54

That photo does say it all SamanthaCaine. Horrific. The tank size of the thing then knowing how much it weighs too. Nobody stands a chance against that. Prowling around towns and villages right next to schools. Zero need for an off road vehicle in London whatsoever they are absolute monstrosities. I only hope some people with them think twice about keeping them and anyone in a city actually still considering owning such a stupid thing will now think twice.

SamanthaCaine · 11/07/2023 19:35

jannier · 11/07/2023 16:53

The faster you hit something the greater the combined force....hit a pedestrian at 20 they are more likely to survive than 30 if an electric car reach a higher speed over a shorter distance it will do more damage

Sure but not all EV's are faster accelerating or heavier than Chelsea tractors so am not sure what point you're making. Except a poor attempt at making EV's sound worse than they are in reality.

What sort of distance are you talking about. Can you actually quantity the difference between 20 and 30mph for two cars where one can accelerate faster than the other?

But if you want to compare, most if not all EV's have regenerative braking, diesel Discoveries don't. So one will grind to a halt if you lift off whilst the other will naturally drag and carry on regardless.

jannier · 11/07/2023 16:56

Qilin · 11/07/2023 14:59

Not necessarily.
It's not just weight and speed. It's also the height of the bonnet, etc.

And the safety of the bumper....but the picture posted is an American car and no safety bumper

jannier · 11/07/2023 16:53

SamanthaCaine · 11/07/2023 15:20

Speed and acceleration are totally different things so you're confusing two things.

Electric cars can be heavier but not necessarily so. A Tesla model 3 can be the same or less than a 3 series BMW. But my BMW i3 has a lower mass than a Golf. There are no absolutes, especially when a lot of cars still have diesel engines i.e. most SUV's, which are significantly heavier than petrol.

The faster you hit something the greater the combined force....hit a pedestrian at 20 they are more likely to survive than 30 if an electric car reach a higher speed over a shorter distance it will do more damage

Heckythump1 · 11/07/2023 16:02

SamanthaCaine · 11/07/2023 15:11

Says it all really.

Blimey, that's a scary visual!

SamanthaCaine · 11/07/2023 15:20

jannier · 10/07/2023 23:12

Electric cars are typically very heavy compared to combustion engined cars they also have instant acceleration so would do more damage than a Chelsea tractor....we know survival rates go down with speed.

Speed and acceleration are totally different things so you're confusing two things.

Electric cars can be heavier but not necessarily so. A Tesla model 3 can be the same or less than a 3 series BMW. But my BMW i3 has a lower mass than a Golf. There are no absolutes, especially when a lot of cars still have diesel engines i.e. most SUV's, which are significantly heavier than petrol.

DataNotLore · 11/07/2023 15:15

@SamanthaCaine

Sums the problem up

OP posts:
SamanthaCaine · 11/07/2023 15:11

Says it all really.

Car crash at Wimbledon school.
Qilin · 11/07/2023 14:59

jannier · 10/07/2023 23:12

Electric cars are typically very heavy compared to combustion engined cars they also have instant acceleration so would do more damage than a Chelsea tractor....we know survival rates go down with speed.

Not necessarily.
It's not just weight and speed. It's also the height of the bonnet, etc.