Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car crash at Wimbledon school.

534 replies

DataNotLore · 07/07/2023 13:40

Can everyone stop driving these fucking stupid ego-tanks in urban areas now?

Who needs a fucking wank panzer in Wimbledon???

Ban them in urban areas.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
5stargeneral · 13/07/2023 10:49

@MissHen
I agree, for your average rural person anyway, but fitting car seats in is a huge issue. I think this is why so many people are buying SUVs now.

MissHen · 13/07/2023 08:27

The best rural vehicles are small hatchbacks and estates with front wheel drive. It is about the skill and experience of the drivers. Running costs need to be low. seasonal work means many have to take them of the road during the Winter. I'm afraid the SUV are not much help in extreme weather. The Village Garage has an ancient Land Rover Defender with winch which gets them out of trouble. I think it's about want not need. Which is fine. Own your choices. How can you reduce their impact on others? Is Road Safety on your Neighbourhood plans? Get involved. Mark this tragedy with making changes. We can do this.

SamanthaCaine · 12/07/2023 23:22

Just in case you can't be bothered to go back a few pages @Pinklagoon

https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/oct/07/a-deadly-problem-should-we-ban-suvs-from-our-cities

It's frankly bizarre that you talk about intelligent debate but go on to compare older small cars with brand new SUV's. Highly intelligent.

Why not have a read and come back and tell me where you got your original statistics about fewer accidents and greater numbers of SUV's on the road. I'd love to read that paper when every other bit of research done has categorically stated that SUV's are worse than cars.

'A deadly problem': should we ban SUVs from our cities?

Statistically less safe than regular cars and with higher CO2 emissions, campaigners argue the heavily-marketed cars have no place in urban areas

https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/oct/07/a-deadly-problem-should-we-ban-suvs-from-our-cities

SamanthaCaine · 12/07/2023 22:28

Pinklagoon · 12/07/2023 20:38

Well if you want some intelligent debate bring it on, tell me how many older and smaller low cost cars have more safety by design features as standard?

Virtually all new SUVs and other mid to high range vehicles come with most of the of the following safety be design, that are not included in a lot of cheaper cars and older vehicles.

Automatic emergency braking,
Forward collision alerts,
Pedestrian/cyclist detection,
Lane departure alerts,
Lane following assist,
Lane tracing assist,
Road sign recognition,
Blind spot monitoring with rear cross-traffic alerts and collision avoidance,
Driver attention warnings,
Parking sensors front/side/rear,
Wide-angle camera system and a millimeter-wave radar.

Some might say your using your mental gymnastics to say none of these features now save lives or have been part of the reduction in pedestrian incidents. 🙄

Well if you'd read the links that a pp provided, you'd see that your post is as ludicrous as it was.

The stats are there but clearly you've found a way to add 2 and 2 to equal WTF?

OneTC · 12/07/2023 22:06

Pinklagoon · 12/07/2023 20:38

Well if you want some intelligent debate bring it on, tell me how many older and smaller low cost cars have more safety by design features as standard?

Virtually all new SUVs and other mid to high range vehicles come with most of the of the following safety be design, that are not included in a lot of cheaper cars and older vehicles.

Automatic emergency braking,
Forward collision alerts,
Pedestrian/cyclist detection,
Lane departure alerts,
Lane following assist,
Lane tracing assist,
Road sign recognition,
Blind spot monitoring with rear cross-traffic alerts and collision avoidance,
Driver attention warnings,
Parking sensors front/side/rear,
Wide-angle camera system and a millimeter-wave radar.

Some might say your using your mental gymnastics to say none of these features now save lives or have been part of the reduction in pedestrian incidents. 🙄

They worked out well at the school didn't it.

Someone said earlier about is there an epidemic of them killing people compared to other cars but I don't think there needs to be. They worsen outcomes for other people in the event of a collision. That's a very horrible decision to make for other people. It's your own safety at others expense. Any small car can have all of these safety features and will be safer for everyone else by design.

When 5 people die every day on the roads then you can do stuff that even makes a small percentage difference in survivability means you're bettering the chances of plenty of people every year.

People are selfish. The same arguments get rolled out by people who can't imagine having their own life impacted at all, just substitute gun, dog, SUV, whatever status symbol/weapon

Pinklagoon · 12/07/2023 20:41

bonfirebash · 12/07/2023 20:33

There is cameras in them so they will be able to see. And reversing sensors
Which is probably more use than my car with no camera and reversing sensors that go off when they want

This 100% , What is obvious most of the people bitching in this thread most likely have never been in modern cars with all the inbuilt safety features.

Claiming all SUV drivers are driving blind is highly in factual.

Pinklagoon · 12/07/2023 20:38

SamanthaCaine · 12/07/2023 17:31

Some mental gymnastics there.

Well if you want some intelligent debate bring it on, tell me how many older and smaller low cost cars have more safety by design features as standard?

Virtually all new SUVs and other mid to high range vehicles come with most of the of the following safety be design, that are not included in a lot of cheaper cars and older vehicles.

Automatic emergency braking,
Forward collision alerts,
Pedestrian/cyclist detection,
Lane departure alerts,
Lane following assist,
Lane tracing assist,
Road sign recognition,
Blind spot monitoring with rear cross-traffic alerts and collision avoidance,
Driver attention warnings,
Parking sensors front/side/rear,
Wide-angle camera system and a millimeter-wave radar.

Some might say your using your mental gymnastics to say none of these features now save lives or have been part of the reduction in pedestrian incidents. 🙄

bonfirebash · 12/07/2023 20:33

CrazyHedgehogLover · 12/07/2023 20:25

@mollyminniemo that picture looks very similar to the ones I see in my area! Although maybe slightly smaller, literally looks identical, this type of one nearly reversed into me and my children the other day! Safe to say when you’re a pedestrian on a pavement seeing this coming towards us was scary, I had to run out the way with my children and my toddler in the pram!

issue is when there this size is they can’t even see who is behind them! Let alone hitting someone in front of them.

There is cameras in them so they will be able to see. And reversing sensors
Which is probably more use than my car with no camera and reversing sensors that go off when they want

CrazyHedgehogLover · 12/07/2023 20:25

@mollyminniemo that picture looks very similar to the ones I see in my area! Although maybe slightly smaller, literally looks identical, this type of one nearly reversed into me and my children the other day! Safe to say when you’re a pedestrian on a pavement seeing this coming towards us was scary, I had to run out the way with my children and my toddler in the pram!

issue is when there this size is they can’t even see who is behind them! Let alone hitting someone in front of them.

mollyminniemo · 12/07/2023 19:52

Horrendous!! An adult woman is swallowed up next to this ugly tank let alone a child.

Car crash at Wimbledon school.
5stargeneral · 12/07/2023 18:17

@SamanthaCaine That's not me and my family btw! Taken from a blog. I don't have an SUV either. I'm just interested because it's hard to find photos of kids standing near them. I'm curious. They seem to slope, with the exception of the Landrover Defender 110.

5stargeneral · 12/07/2023 18:13

SamanthaCaine · 12/07/2023 17:30

We have cars bigger than the Kodiaq. The Audi Q8 is one and a Range Rover another for starters.

That photo is angled downwards but you can see quite clearly that your youngest would be hit square in the chest/face if you drove into him. Your eldest doesn't look like they'd fare much better either to be honest.

Found a site and have some pics you might find interesting. Not much of a difference between the Audi Q8 and Skoda Kodiaq but the Landrover Defender 110 size is noticeable.

Car crash at Wimbledon school.
Car crash at Wimbledon school.
Car crash at Wimbledon school.
Car crash at Wimbledon school.
SamanthaCaine · 12/07/2023 17:31

Pinklagoon · 12/07/2023 15:59

I get the arguments but is there really an epidemic of SUVs killing people in vastly greater numbers than other cars, or is this a theoretical argument?

If you look at statistics for pedestrians, deaths and incidents of pedestrians have fallen over 48% in the last 12 years and continue to fall. In correlation to this SUV`s are now becoming one of the most popular vehicles.

So statistics show pedestrian deaths falling, and SUV ownership rising. 🤔

All newer cars especially larger ones are getting more advanced collision detection and avoidance built in, so you could say that older cars are more dangerous to pedestrians than newer ones with technology. But that wont fit the narrative will it.

Some mental gymnastics there.

Car crash at Wimbledon school.
SamanthaCaine · 12/07/2023 17:30

5stargeneral · 12/07/2023 17:07

That's an American SUV unavailable here. US SUVs are absolutely huge, our largest are their smallest. Skoka Kodiaq (pictured) is one of the largest SUVs available in the UK.

We have cars bigger than the Kodiaq. The Audi Q8 is one and a Range Rover another for starters.

That photo is angled downwards but you can see quite clearly that your youngest would be hit square in the chest/face if you drove into him. Your eldest doesn't look like they'd fare much better either to be honest.

5stargeneral · 12/07/2023 17:07

That's an American SUV unavailable here. US SUVs are absolutely huge, our largest are their smallest. Skoka Kodiaq (pictured) is one of the largest SUVs available in the UK.

Car crash at Wimbledon school.
Hibiscrubbed · 12/07/2023 16:56

Wenfy · 07/07/2023 22:26

How do you think poor people who live in / near farms manage? I live in a rural area - all the farm hands drive second hand polos. The cars seem to handle fine in all weather types with the right chains / wheels.

Well, I probably wouldn’t ask them to help me tow a cow out of a ditch. I’m sure they’re grateful when I move fallen trees off the road, though.

SpongeDiving · 12/07/2023 16:55

Dotjones · 12/07/2023 16:11

The problem of people using it as a method to flaunt their wealth could be reduced significantly by making the tax/charge punitive and based on the individual's wealth or, better, by making an assumption about the person's wealth.

For instance you could have to buy a special licence to own or use a large vehicle, the cost of which is £50,000 per year or 20% of your income or 20% of the value of your assets (including fixed assets like property), whichever is higher. Anyone falsifying information would be jailed for 10 years. Only the owner would be allowed to drive the car, therefore you couldn't have a situation where someone buys it for someone else to limit the cost.

An SUV-lite licence could be available for people who genuinely need one, like greenlaners or farmers, but the terms of this licence could prohibit you from using the vehicle in built-up areas.

If you buy a "lite" licence your SUV would have to be a specific vivid colour like hot pink with yellow wheels. If you buy a full licence it has to be lime green with postbox red wheels

This is a really strange post. Reads like a wish list of punishments! If the government were to ban SUVs where unnecessary - and I’d hope they’d do it on the basis of solid research proving that they cause unacceptable levels of harm - there are ways of doing it that don’t involve jailing people for ten years and hot pink cars.

bonfirebash · 12/07/2023 16:49

@Dotjones that'll be great for you know, people who sell and service the cars and collect them who need to drive them Hmm

Just because I drive a LR occasionally, I'm still on min wage!

Fightyouforthatpie · 12/07/2023 16:45

Dotjones · 12/07/2023 16:11

The problem of people using it as a method to flaunt their wealth could be reduced significantly by making the tax/charge punitive and based on the individual's wealth or, better, by making an assumption about the person's wealth.

For instance you could have to buy a special licence to own or use a large vehicle, the cost of which is £50,000 per year or 20% of your income or 20% of the value of your assets (including fixed assets like property), whichever is higher. Anyone falsifying information would be jailed for 10 years. Only the owner would be allowed to drive the car, therefore you couldn't have a situation where someone buys it for someone else to limit the cost.

An SUV-lite licence could be available for people who genuinely need one, like greenlaners or farmers, but the terms of this licence could prohibit you from using the vehicle in built-up areas.

If you buy a "lite" licence your SUV would have to be a specific vivid colour like hot pink with yellow wheels. If you buy a full licence it has to be lime green with postbox red wheels

Hilarious.

MLMsuperfan · 12/07/2023 16:23

If SUV ownership really is rising that's scary. We need to do something about it,

Dotjones · 12/07/2023 16:11

Pearlsaminga · 12/07/2023 12:43

They shouldn't be banned outright but they should be subject to higher charges when driving in urban areas, along the model of London congestion charge. And banned during certain times of day, like lorries
@potniatheron
It's not that I disagree with you, but one problem with higher charges is that the SUV then becomes a way to advertise your wealth and status, driving one becomes a way to show everyone that these higher charges are of no consequence to someone as rich as you.
I like the idea of restricting their usage but governments seem very hesitant to place restrictions on the wealthy and Powerful (presumably because they are wealthy and Powerful and do not wish to be restricted in any way)

The problem of people using it as a method to flaunt their wealth could be reduced significantly by making the tax/charge punitive and based on the individual's wealth or, better, by making an assumption about the person's wealth.

For instance you could have to buy a special licence to own or use a large vehicle, the cost of which is £50,000 per year or 20% of your income or 20% of the value of your assets (including fixed assets like property), whichever is higher. Anyone falsifying information would be jailed for 10 years. Only the owner would be allowed to drive the car, therefore you couldn't have a situation where someone buys it for someone else to limit the cost.

An SUV-lite licence could be available for people who genuinely need one, like greenlaners or farmers, but the terms of this licence could prohibit you from using the vehicle in built-up areas.

If you buy a "lite" licence your SUV would have to be a specific vivid colour like hot pink with yellow wheels. If you buy a full licence it has to be lime green with postbox red wheels

CrazyHedgehogLover · 12/07/2023 16:02

I fully agree op! I live in a very rural area and the school is a small village school, I see ridiculously large estate cars reversing and one actually nearly hit me and my children the other day! Woman explained “oh sorry I didn’t see you there”.. there’s been an increase in accidents in our area which are involving these massive estate cars.

my mum has a smaller car and she also lives in a small town and the amount of times one has nearly reversed/gone into her car is unreal.. totally not necessary for them to be on the roads at all in rural areas unless as others have posted they are a farmer and genuinely need that type of vehicle.

Pinklagoon · 12/07/2023 15:59

EggWind · 12/07/2023 15:50

I get the arguments but is there really an epidemic of SUVs killing people in vastly greater numbers than other cars, or is this a theoretical argument? If the former then fair enough.

As a truck driver in urban areas I'm on the road all day and the biggest danger to me is those in fast cars hurtling around. Fiesta STs seem to be the prime offender. Only the other day some young lad overtook another car whilst going downhill in a 30mph zone and only just swerved back in in time - he was so close I lost sight of him below the cab in the final moment. He would've 100% been dead had we collided as I was running at 32t gross weight.

I get the arguments but is there really an epidemic of SUVs killing people in vastly greater numbers than other cars, or is this a theoretical argument?

If you look at statistics for pedestrians, deaths and incidents of pedestrians have fallen over 48% in the last 12 years and continue to fall. In correlation to this SUV`s are now becoming one of the most popular vehicles.

So statistics show pedestrian deaths falling, and SUV ownership rising. 🤔

All newer cars especially larger ones are getting more advanced collision detection and avoidance built in, so you could say that older cars are more dangerous to pedestrians than newer ones with technology. But that wont fit the narrative will it.

EggWind · 12/07/2023 15:59

Apparently there's talk of restricting all cars to 70mph. It's not a 'fun' option as it prevents people from going over and using the autobahn but for domestic driving it would prevent the habitual speeder which is a fairly large % of drivers.

EggWind · 12/07/2023 15:50

I get the arguments but is there really an epidemic of SUVs killing people in vastly greater numbers than other cars, or is this a theoretical argument? If the former then fair enough.

As a truck driver in urban areas I'm on the road all day and the biggest danger to me is those in fast cars hurtling around. Fiesta STs seem to be the prime offender. Only the other day some young lad overtook another car whilst going downhill in a 30mph zone and only just swerved back in in time - he was so close I lost sight of him below the cab in the final moment. He would've 100% been dead had we collided as I was running at 32t gross weight.

Swipe left for the next trending thread