Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car crash at Wimbledon school.

534 replies

DataNotLore · 07/07/2023 13:40

Can everyone stop driving these fucking stupid ego-tanks in urban areas now?

Who needs a fucking wank panzer in Wimbledon???

Ban them in urban areas.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
17
OneTC · 15/07/2023 10:43

And twisted should say replaced :|

OneTC · 15/07/2023 10:42

EggWind · 14/07/2023 22:46

Well, yeah they don't need them but big houses/second houses are equally unnecessary alongside cars that can do 200mph. I'd be up for extra tests however as it's frustrating how often I have to back up a 35ft truck on tight lanes due to women who seemingly don't know how to reverse their range rover.

Houses: don't run people over

200mph: illegal, as with all speeding, as this is recognised to be dangerous and worsens outcomes so there are laws that attempt to mitigate it's impact on others.

I would happily support laws that limited top speed and engine power and fuel economy. They can set them geographically and remotely if they like so you can still buy a 200mph car and drive it that fast on tracks or wherever you're allowed.

If you allow that some SUVs are necessary, then like other necessary vehicles like 35t trucks, bin lorries, ambulances etc they will stay. If we twisted all the unnecessary ones with something with a smaller footprint then the lives of all those 35t, ambos etc would be sufficiently improved. There was someone arguing on the other thread that they needed it for their cleaning business. That's not need, any microvan has more space for equipment. There was someone else who said they could get a different vehicle to accommodate their disability but thought it looked a bit shit. That's not need either.

A quick Google image search shows that the majority of SUVs are very much not intended for grunt work. The price and the specs they are available in from the factory further betray their true intended use

😅<-- I clicked this by accident and now my phone won't delete it. plz ignore

User10486743 · 15/07/2023 07:44

We have a SUV, EV and small ICE car which we tow for holidays, we just use each one as appropriate, we live fairly rurally though and I would just use the EV for city driving rather than the SUV. People should buy cars appropriately for different situations.

SamanthaCaine · 15/07/2023 07:15

EggWind · 14/07/2023 22:46

Well, yeah they don't need them but big houses/second houses are equally unnecessary alongside cars that can do 200mph. I'd be up for extra tests however as it's frustrating how often I have to back up a 35ft truck on tight lanes due to women who seemingly don't know how to reverse their range rover.

Why are you so resistant to the facts provided? It's like willful ignorance. You keep making baseless claims without anything to back it up.

Like 'loads of fiestas' and that they're doing 60 in a 30.

Do you know there are about 33 million cars on UK roads. Fiesta ST's make up a tiny percentage. Do you know how I know? Anyone can visit How Many Left and find out for themselves. There are less than 8 thousand so about 0.002%.

https://www.howmanyleft.co.uk/

There's more Range Rovers alone than Fiesta STs. The fact is, there are worse outcomes for people when hit by SUV's and that's a fact. Your inability to recognise the difference between the frontal area of your pick-up and its mass really is astounding.

How Many Left?

How Many Left. See how many cars of any make and model are left on Britain's roads.

https://www.howmanyleft.co.uk

EggWind · 14/07/2023 22:46

Well, yeah they don't need them but big houses/second houses are equally unnecessary alongside cars that can do 200mph. I'd be up for extra tests however as it's frustrating how often I have to back up a 35ft truck on tight lanes due to women who seemingly don't know how to reverse their range rover.

OneTC · 14/07/2023 22:39

Like I said earlier if you have a demonstrable need then crack on, get an exception added to your license, your plate goes on a database and you don't get fined 5k a day for going into London. whether that's disability, work or whatever. But people who are buying these for the school run don't need them

EggWind · 14/07/2023 22:20

Yeah, but people who've clearly said they need big cars for work are being told 'not our problem'. I used to have a pickup because I needed it to get around the big construction sites I work on - big newbuild estates etc.

There are plenty of things that kill more people which haven't been banned.

OneTC · 14/07/2023 22:09

Because no one is suggesting anyone gives up their transport, just that they might like to opt for a more (unrelated) child friendly form

OneTC · 14/07/2023 22:08

No I've said all along that an epidemic isn't required to start thinking about changes in who can drive them.

EggWind · 14/07/2023 21:56

Hot hatches are no doubt fast but they're relatively low in numbers.

This is just straight up untrue. The Fiesta ST is incredibly popular hence it being the most stolen car in the UK. And Golf GTIs/Seat FR models are everywhere.

So?

It's still less people dead at no real inconvenience.

Well, the argument was that they're causing some kind of epidemic of deaths when in fact pedestrian deaths are actually way down the list.

The problem is more speeding than big cars. Speeding is listed in 'the fatal five' causes as documented by the fire and rescue service.

DdraigGoch · 14/07/2023 15:01

5stargeneral · 12/07/2023 17:07

That's an American SUV unavailable here. US SUVs are absolutely huge, our largest are their smallest. Skoka Kodiaq (pictured) is one of the largest SUVs available in the UK.

US SUVs are genuinely huge. People often refer to Range Rovers etc. as "tanks" but that's a bit unfair on tanks when an M1 Abrams has better forward visibility than some of those American leviathans.

DdraigGoch · 14/07/2023 14:57

5stargeneral · 14/07/2023 08:54

All I can find online are blogs saying 1993-1998 Defenders were banned in the USA because of new regs about airbags. And the USA has rules about importing vehicles that were not sold in the US. You have to wait 25 years. Old Landies are legal in the US under classic car rules.

The classic Defenders finished production in 2016, they no longer complied with the 2015 Euro NCAP regulations. Obviously you can still own an old one, "NCAP" stands for "New Car Assessment Programme".

www.euroncap.com/en/vehicle-safety/the-ratings-explained/vulnerable-road-user-vru-protection/

SamanthaCaine · 14/07/2023 12:22

EggWind · 14/07/2023 11:45

But the number of deaths of car occupants is almost double the deaths of pedestrians according to gov.uk. This makes me think that it's unlikely to be parents dropping kids off. You need to be going at some speed to kill somebody in another car.

Sorry but you weren't specific with your post. Given the discussion has been about pedestrians I assumed you were referring to them and not passengers in cars.

Passenger deaths are obviously due to vehicle vs another vehicle or some other stationary object (trees, parked cars, walls etc). There's a body of research that also suggests that SUV's are worse again for the following reasons:

High CoG leading to instability and rolling during a collision.
Inflated confidence due to feeling safer than other vehicles.
Worse road holding than an equivalent car.
Higher mass and resulting impact.
Higher mass and bonnet line, resulting in worse outcomes for other vehicles.

I experience daily, the issues SUV drivers expose others too. Consistently, SUV drivers are unable to maintain lane discipline and cut corners on blind bends. I often find one crossing the apex on my side, because it's easier than slowing down and cornering properly. I've been clipped, scraped and avoided head on collisions on A/B roads due to this. I rarely see the same thing with other cars as they're smaller and have superior road holding.

Hot hatches are no doubt fast but they're relatively low in numbers. A/B roads are the most dangerous and responsible for the most deaths, precisely because of oncoming traffic and the speed limits.

OneTC · 14/07/2023 11:56

EggWind · 14/07/2023 11:45

But the number of deaths of car occupants is almost double the deaths of pedestrians according to gov.uk. This makes me think that it's unlikely to be parents dropping kids off. You need to be going at some speed to kill somebody in another car.

So?

It's still less people dead at no real inconvenience.

We can't stop people driving overall (yet) but we could limit the choice of available vehicles based on safety.

The outcome isn't only worse for pedestrians, the outcome is worse for people in vehicles that are hit by SUVs

I understand people wanting to be safe, I want to be safe, I would not however make a decision that improved my safety at the direct expense of other people. That is immoral

EggWind · 14/07/2023 11:45

SamanthaCaine · 13/07/2023 22:44

You only need to look at accident statistics to know that it's most likely the parent picking or dropping off the kids.

It's not how powerful the car is but the type of car that's critical and SUV's are much more likely to kill thaia Fiesta of any flavour.

From: www.gov.uk/government/statistics/reported-road-casualties-great-britain-pedestrian-factsheet-2021/reported-road-casualties-great-britain-pedestrian-factsheet-2021

Driver or rider failed to look properly 7,768
Driver or rider careless, reckless or in a hurry 2,858
Driver or rider failed to judge other person`s path or speed 1,787
Stationary or parked vehicle(s) 1,243
Poor turn or manoeuvre 1,142
Exceeding speed limit 1,057
Aggressive driving 1,011
Loss of control 840
Travelling too fast for conditions 740
Dazzling sun 738

But the number of deaths of car occupants is almost double the deaths of pedestrians according to gov.uk. This makes me think that it's unlikely to be parents dropping kids off. You need to be going at some speed to kill somebody in another car.

5stargeneral · 14/07/2023 08:54

DdraigGoch · 13/07/2023 23:14

The old Defenders that were banned from production because they didn't meet modern crashworthiness standards, particularly in respect of pedestrian safety?

All I can find online are blogs saying 1993-1998 Defenders were banned in the USA because of new regs about airbags. And the USA has rules about importing vehicles that were not sold in the US. You have to wait 25 years. Old Landies are legal in the US under classic car rules.

DdraigGoch · 13/07/2023 23:23

EggWind · 12/07/2023 15:59

Apparently there's talk of restricting all cars to 70mph. It's not a 'fun' option as it prevents people from going over and using the autobahn but for domestic driving it would prevent the habitual speeder which is a fairly large % of drivers.

The technology exists in modern cars to force them to dynamically adhere to limits. Not just capping top speed at 70, but the car knowing when you're in a 20 zone.

DdraigGoch · 13/07/2023 23:21

EggWind · 12/07/2023 15:50

I get the arguments but is there really an epidemic of SUVs killing people in vastly greater numbers than other cars, or is this a theoretical argument? If the former then fair enough.

As a truck driver in urban areas I'm on the road all day and the biggest danger to me is those in fast cars hurtling around. Fiesta STs seem to be the prime offender. Only the other day some young lad overtook another car whilst going downhill in a 30mph zone and only just swerved back in in time - he was so close I lost sight of him below the cab in the final moment. He would've 100% been dead had we collided as I was running at 32t gross weight.

If you're in a truck then there's not a lot that's a threat to your personal safety. Think about a pedestrian however. If you get hit by a low-bonneted car then you'll end up on to of it. If you get hit by a high-bonneted car then you'll end up underneath.

DdraigGoch · 13/07/2023 23:14

5stargeneral · 13/07/2023 11:30

@mollyminniemo It was this one. It's 17cm lower than old Defenders.

The old Defenders that were banned from production because they didn't meet modern crashworthiness standards, particularly in respect of pedestrian safety?

SamanthaCaine · 13/07/2023 22:44

EggWind · 13/07/2023 20:32

So who is the greater danger? The woman picking up her kids from school in a SUV or a chav in a Fiesta ST doing 60 in a 30mph zone?

I feel like most egregious speeding I see is young lads in hot hatches (i.e. small with a high power to weight ratio). The stats show this demographic to be a high risk and they don't generally drive SUVs.

So do we also ban Golf/Polo GTIs, Fiesta/Focus STs, Audi S1/S3, BMW 140i, etc?

You only need to look at accident statistics to know that it's most likely the parent picking or dropping off the kids.

It's not how powerful the car is but the type of car that's critical and SUV's are much more likely to kill thaia Fiesta of any flavour.

From: www.gov.uk/government/statistics/reported-road-casualties-great-britain-pedestrian-factsheet-2021/reported-road-casualties-great-britain-pedestrian-factsheet-2021

Driver or rider failed to look properly 7,768
Driver or rider careless, reckless or in a hurry 2,858
Driver or rider failed to judge other person`s path or speed 1,787
Stationary or parked vehicle(s) 1,243
Poor turn or manoeuvre 1,142
Exceeding speed limit 1,057
Aggressive driving 1,011
Loss of control 840
Travelling too fast for conditions 740
Dazzling sun 738

DataNotLore · 13/07/2023 22:36

EggWind · 13/07/2023 20:32

So who is the greater danger? The woman picking up her kids from school in a SUV or a chav in a Fiesta ST doing 60 in a 30mph zone?

I feel like most egregious speeding I see is young lads in hot hatches (i.e. small with a high power to weight ratio). The stats show this demographic to be a high risk and they don't generally drive SUVs.

So do we also ban Golf/Polo GTIs, Fiesta/Focus STs, Audi S1/S3, BMW 140i, etc?

The first one.

She's driving a big, clumsy vehicle near small children she can't see and nobody will stop her.

The second one will get nicked pretty quickly with all the cameras round here.

OP posts:
EggWind · 13/07/2023 20:32

So who is the greater danger? The woman picking up her kids from school in a SUV or a chav in a Fiesta ST doing 60 in a 30mph zone?

I feel like most egregious speeding I see is young lads in hot hatches (i.e. small with a high power to weight ratio). The stats show this demographic to be a high risk and they don't generally drive SUVs.

So do we also ban Golf/Polo GTIs, Fiesta/Focus STs, Audi S1/S3, BMW 140i, etc?

mollyminniemo · 13/07/2023 13:42

Ok thanks 5stargeneral but to me that almost looks worse! That’s a taller woman and the boy fairly tall and they are just swallowed up in comparison to its heft, the girl just lost completely next to it.

Isittimeformynapyet · 13/07/2023 11:37

NotTerfNorCis · 07/07/2023 14:08

Can't help noticing how the Mail keeps referring to a 'woman driver'. If it'd been a man, it would have been 'driver'. In fact I've never heard the phrase 'man driver'.

Sounds about right for the Mail.

Stop reading it

5stargeneral · 13/07/2023 11:30

@mollyminniemo It was this one. It's 17cm lower than old Defenders.

Car crash at Wimbledon school.
Swipe left for the next trending thread