Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband annoyed that my family haven't arranged to celebrate DCs birthday

639 replies

HailHale · 07/07/2023 08:51

Will try to keep it short. My husband and I share a child and he also has an older child with his ex. Our child is 3 and SS is 8.

The children's birthdays are about 2 weeks apart.

For my toddlers birthday my family came round and we all had a food together, my grandma made a cake, family members all brought a dish kind of thing. It wasn't extravagant but it was a nice day/evening.

I need to preface this with saying I have never arranged or planned anything for my SS for his birthday before as its always been between DH and his mum and this is the first year I've done something like this for our toddler as other years they were just too young to really care.

This year unfortunately his mum is away looking after a very unwell family member and so SS is with us over his birthday (which is tomorrow).

DH randomly asked me this morning whether I'd planned anything for it and when I said no why? He said i should have asked my family to do the same for SS. He works all week and apparently doesn't have the time to be planning parties (I'm part time). I will add here that DH has no family here, they are all abroad and not close.

Aibu to not have arranged anything with my family for SS and to not rush around doing it now? Happy to go for a meal just us but not asking my family to mess around now at the last minute because he's not done anything for his own son.

OP posts:
funinthesun19 · 08/07/2023 08:23

I’m sure the dss will be very excited this morning to see what his dad has organised and planned for him. 🎂🎈🎉 🎁

Coolhwip · 08/07/2023 08:20

StephanieSuperpowers · 08/07/2023 08:08

I'm pretty sure though that deepening her heart, the OP is aware that when we say mum and dad usually organise it, we mean mum does. He probably has no real involvement in thinking or planning and only gets involved if he's given a couple of token tasks. Doesn't sound like he bothered his arse for the toddler either.

It's not fair to expect the OP to do thus. It's not right. It's not her job. But she's a grown up and at the centre of this story is an 8 year old, prime birthday madness age, whose mum is away for his birthday and none of the adults around him cared enough to plan anything nice.

All these doom laden posts are so bizarre.

DSS came home on Tuesday, OP finds out a couple of days later he is staying for his birthday.

DH and OP have presents.

DH and OP have no plans on the weekend and OP is happy to do things with DSS.

DH therefore has the whole weekend to make it special for his son and OP is happy to take part.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 08/07/2023 08:13

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 07/07/2023 09:03

I need to preface this with saying I have never arranged or planned anything for my SS for his birthday before as its always been between DH and his mum and this is the first year I've done something like this for our toddler as other years they were just too young to really care.

Wonder how much arranging DH has ever done, left it to the woman and tagged along i presume, looks like he thought a different woman would leap in this time too. This is on him.

Exactly this!!
Your DH has not sorted anything, his Ex has sorted it and brought him into the discussion in EXACTLY the way he is expecting you to do.
Personally once I knew your SS was going to be with you I would have been bringing up the discussion of how you were going to celebrate. Should YOU have to bring it up, NO that's his dad's role but if he hadn't then i would have to ensure the kid had a lovely day. Says a lot about what your DH sees as his role and his expectations of a 'woman's role'.

StephanieSuperpowers · 08/07/2023 08:08

I'm pretty sure though that deepening her heart, the OP is aware that when we say mum and dad usually organise it, we mean mum does. He probably has no real involvement in thinking or planning and only gets involved if he's given a couple of token tasks. Doesn't sound like he bothered his arse for the toddler either.

It's not fair to expect the OP to do thus. It's not right. It's not her job. But she's a grown up and at the centre of this story is an 8 year old, prime birthday madness age, whose mum is away for his birthday and none of the adults around him cared enough to plan anything nice.

Coolhwip · 08/07/2023 08:02

KingJamesTheTurd · 08/07/2023 07:54

@aSofaNearYou We're going round in circles and will just have to agree to disagree. I think that if you marry someone who has a primary aged child, it is very, very weird not to communicate about the child's birthday - even if just to say at some point in the couple of weeks before: "what's Timmy doing for his birthday?"

I think it's normal to talk to your partner about what's going on in the family, but you clearly don't.

Why would someone who is not even invited to DSS’ parties do this? It makes no sense. The mum and dad sort it between them every year.

aSofaNearYou · 08/07/2023 08:01

KingJamesTheTurd · 08/07/2023 07:54

@aSofaNearYou We're going round in circles and will just have to agree to disagree. I think that if you marry someone who has a primary aged child, it is very, very weird not to communicate about the child's birthday - even if just to say at some point in the couple of weeks before: "what's Timmy doing for his birthday?"

I think it's normal to talk to your partner about what's going on in the family, but you clearly don't.

It's normal to, but equally normal for it to not come up if it's not something you're concerned won't be sorted out.

Coolhwip · 08/07/2023 08:00

janinak84 · 08/07/2023 07:46

Well, we all are different. I would discuss this with my partner in advance if I knew his child would be with us for their birthday.
Surely it's not your family's responsibility to plan a party for that child. However, you and your husband should. Especially when his family is not around. It might not to be your child, but it's your husband's and they came as a package. You should treat him the same way you would treat your own one. And your husband should not expecting you to think of it.
But you really need to think he is a little child, and seeing his sibling having a lovely party but not having his own might feel him sad.
You could also plan a day out, or give him some options what you could possibly do.

But that’s just it. DSS was brought home on Tuesday, and OP didn’t even know if he was going to be with them for his birthday.

It’s crazy that you’re expecting OP to pull a party out of her arse when SHE ISN’T USUALLY INVITED TO DSS’ PARTIES and the ex doesn’t like OP doing things for her son.

The mum and dad have had WEEKS to organise a party for their DS but somehow it’s become OP’s responsibility to speak up and make this happen.

aSofaNearYou · 08/07/2023 07:59

KingJamesTheTurd · 08/07/2023 07:49

@aSofaNearYou I find it frustrating that you can't see the difference between a random neighbour's child and a step-child.

If you marry someone who has children, you have to assume some responsibility for that child. It is mind-boggling to think that you could live in the same house as your husband's child and regard them in the same way as a random neighbour's child. Surely you accept that you play a quasi-parental role in a step-child's life?

As I said upthread, it's one reason I would never have been involved with a man with children - I am too selfish to be a step-parent.

Oh for god's sake, why must people constantly look to come to this conclusion. The key point in the analogy was that the child had their actual parent present to do the parenting, not my relationship to them. It's so childish to constantly ignore that point and just say "so you think they're just a random child then?"

No I don't think of them like a random child. But their parent is there and I assume their parent will think about the things parents usually think of. I'm not hovering about, worrying that I might need to step in and do it for them, I assume they have it covered. Would it not be highly patronising not to? I'm sure my mum doesn't think of her GC as "random children" but she wouldn't assume she needed to organise a party for them either, because I would do that. On the same way I make sure they brush their teeth and get to bed on time. That is the natural assumption most people make about other people's kids, regardless of how much they might know and love them.

I have a SC. I would probably ask at some point what DP is thinking of doing for DSS's birthday because he is disorganised and forgetful and I know that. But if he was on the ball, I probably would not have cause to even think about it. It wouldn't be on my radar. OPs husband has always sorted it out in the past. There is no reason to assume he wouldn't do the same this year.

KingJamesTheTurd · 08/07/2023 07:54

@aSofaNearYou We're going round in circles and will just have to agree to disagree. I think that if you marry someone who has a primary aged child, it is very, very weird not to communicate about the child's birthday - even if just to say at some point in the couple of weeks before: "what's Timmy doing for his birthday?"

I think it's normal to talk to your partner about what's going on in the family, but you clearly don't.

KingJamesTheTurd · 08/07/2023 07:49

@aSofaNearYou I find it frustrating that you can't see the difference between a random neighbour's child and a step-child.

If you marry someone who has children, you have to assume some responsibility for that child. It is mind-boggling to think that you could live in the same house as your husband's child and regard them in the same way as a random neighbour's child. Surely you accept that you play a quasi-parental role in a step-child's life?

As I said upthread, it's one reason I would never have been involved with a man with children - I am too selfish to be a step-parent.

aSofaNearYou · 08/07/2023 07:47

KingJamesTheTurd · 08/07/2023 07:45

I'm not in the habit of checking whether other parents have parenting under control, I find that odd and micromanaging. Do you do that with other parents?
Of course I don't. But if one of their children were living under my roof (and especially if I were in loco parentis), I would at the very least be asking the child what he/she was doing for their birthday, and I'd be making sure they got to do what they wanted to do if nobody else had bothered to arrange it.

But how would you know nobody else had bothered to arrange it? They always have before, and the kind of things the usually organise are things that don't need to be prepared a long time in advance. She had every right to think that's what his dad was doing again,

janinak84 · 08/07/2023 07:46

Well, we all are different. I would discuss this with my partner in advance if I knew his child would be with us for their birthday.
Surely it's not your family's responsibility to plan a party for that child. However, you and your husband should. Especially when his family is not around. It might not to be your child, but it's your husband's and they came as a package. You should treat him the same way you would treat your own one. And your husband should not expecting you to think of it.
But you really need to think he is a little child, and seeing his sibling having a lovely party but not having his own might feel him sad.
You could also plan a day out, or give him some options what you could possibly do.

aSofaNearYou · 08/07/2023 07:46

@Aprilx It's so frustrating that people like you are taking such negative connotations from the simple act (or lack thereof) of not taking it upon yourself to think about something somebody's parent usually thinks about. If my neighbours child, my niece/nephew, my step child etc etc etc had a birthday coming up, I would not be thinking about needing to sort it out, not because I don't care about them or want to actively snub them. But simply because that is something parents usually do and as such, it just wouldn't cross my mind. I wouldn't be actively and spitefully thinking "not my problem", it would just not occur to me to consider that it might be. Nobody has really answered the question - why on Earth would it? That's why I asked you if you would assume you needed to sort out your neighbours child's birthday, even if one of their parents was present. Honestly, can anyone actually answer yes to that question? Because it would be a really odd way of behaving.

KingJamesTheTurd · 08/07/2023 07:45

I'm not in the habit of checking whether other parents have parenting under control, I find that odd and micromanaging. Do you do that with other parents?
Of course I don't. But if one of their children were living under my roof (and especially if I were in loco parentis), I would at the very least be asking the child what he/she was doing for their birthday, and I'd be making sure they got to do what they wanted to do if nobody else had bothered to arrange it.

Aprilx · 08/07/2023 07:39

aSofaNearYou · 08/07/2023 06:39

If their mum was away but their dad was home, would you assume you needed to organise their party? If so, what's wrong with YOU?

As has been said over and over again, nobody is eliminating the father from responsibility. But yes, if I had a 7 years old child temporarily living in my house, be it a stepchild, nephew, niece or the neighbours child and it was their birthday today, yes, I would have put some thought into it. I would have asked them what they want to do, I would have said to the other adult in the house “what are we doing for Fred’s birthday”. Is this really so hard to comprehend? Or would you have truly thought, I didn’t birth him, not my problem.

It seems there are a lot of people on this thread that can only think in binary terms, in that because somebody else thinks OP should have thought of it and discussed it, that must mean they don’t think the father should have thought of it. When that just isn’t the case. They are a horrible pair.

aSofaNearYou · 08/07/2023 06:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

If their mum was away but their dad was home, would you assume you needed to organise their party? If so, what's wrong with YOU?

JST88 · 08/07/2023 06:27

All children in the family should be treated the same if you’ve chosen to blend the family. How cruel

tidalway · 08/07/2023 00:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

InWalksBarberalla · 07/07/2023 22:35

He sounds like a shit dad.
Wouldn't he normally organise something special for his son for his birthday on top of what his ex does. And why would he need to contact his ex to find our who his son's friends parents are??

aSofaNearYou · 07/07/2023 21:38

*In the OP's shoes, I'd be asking the child's father what he had planned to do for his birthday, in the absence of the child's mother. I wouldn't make any assumptions at all about his father's ability to do anything at all.

In the absence of any plan on the part of the boy's father, I'd be asking the boy what he'd like to do, and whom he'd like to do it with, and then I'd be facilitating it.

This is the only reasonable and kind thing to do for the child. It's also one of many reasons why I wouldn't have taken on anyone else's children - because I am only really interested in my own children, not someone else's, and a child deserves to be treated as if they are an integral part of the family, not an inconvenience.

Anything else is point-scoring*

It's not the only reasonable and kind thing to do - when you assume their dad is responsible and capable. I'm not in the habit of checking whether other parents have parenting under control, I find that odd and micromanaging. Do you do that with other parents? He's sorted it out every other year so she has no reason to assume he wouldn't this year.

Notmygreen · 07/07/2023 21:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Agree

phoenixrosehere · 07/07/2023 21:36

Ridemeginger · 07/07/2023 20:50

I can't see where the OP has said the ex wife has had to fly anywhere. The DH's family is abroad. No mention of the mother's family being overseas too. I wonder where they are and why they are not stepping up for their grandson's birthday. Seems that everyone related by blood to this child is absolved from responsibility, and it is down to the OP and her family (who barely know him) to make sure he is not scarred for life, because he didn't have a birthday tea party with stranger step family.

You’re right. I misread that bit. It is curious on where the rest of the mum’s family is and how far she has gone away. If she has very few family, it’s unfortunate that she doesn’t even like if OP does a nice gesture for her son. This emergency doesn’t take away from the fact nothing seemed to be planned or maybe the ex did have something planned and is waiting til she returns. Can only imagine what she’ll say knowing OP was involved in some way when she is already likely stressed from what has happened with her relative.

KingJamesTheTurd · 07/07/2023 21:26

FWIW, I think both parents are prize twats. But the one who suffers for this is the child, so I'd be the bigger person in the OP's shoes, and make up for the parents' failings, just for the child's sake.

As I say, though, the fact that this is right is one of many reasons why I wouldn't have become a step parent. I know I couldn't do it properly.

StephanieSuperpowers · 07/07/2023 21:20

So he's 8 tomorrow. Send his father out for pancakes and berries to make '8' pancakes with a candle for his breakfast as a fun surprise. They love that. It only takes half an hour - total.

Bring him somewhere, anywhere, tomorrow. The zoo, waterpark, cinema, anywhere. Have a birthday tea out and go for ice cream.

Tell him that he's going to have his party next weekend when hopefully his Mum will be home to celebrate either him too and get that poor excuse of a parent to get his to do list and phoning finger out and organise.

HeckyPeck · 07/07/2023 21:09

Ridemeginger · 07/07/2023 20:58

The OP has already said she has no way of getting in touch with the boy's friends. The father has to step up to do this, but I suspect he's fucking clueless and leaves everything to his wife.

The AIBU and the husband's beef is that the OP hasn't organised a tea party with her family, in a situation where they hardly know him, the OP has never been involved with his birthday planning, she's in fact been actively excluded, and this demand has been landed on her at the 11th hour; and further, when the OP was assuming they would be doing something nice for him in any event, organised by her husband, who also has gone along with excluding OP from his son's birthday celebrations in years gone by. The OP has a job and a toddler, and is supposed to pull a birthday party out of her arse because his own blood relatives have done fuck all to ensure the boy has a nice birthday. And before anyone goes on about the mother being called away, I managed to run my own son's party in between running up and down the country to attend to my dying father, so it's not impossible. People, places, arrangements just need to be communicated. The mother and father of this child have clearly done nothing to organise a party before the emergency arose on Tuesday, otherwise there would be a plan in place long ago that the H and the OP can simply implement.

100% agree with this.

Both of the child's parents have actively excluded OP from even attending his parties in the past.

How was OP to know she's now expected to organise a party? I'm assuming her DH has a mouth and could have said to OP that he'd like her help with that please. (Plus apologised for excluding her from previous parties.)