Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Kate is truly picture perfect

461 replies

julylover · 07/07/2023 00:31

I mean - who looks that good in all their photos. She’s just so beautiful and incredibly photogenic! Not to mention extremely good at tennis, all other sports and everything else in between. William could not have chosen a better wire!

Kate is every inch the proud wife to support William at polo match

https://mol.im/a/12270651

Kate is every inch the proud wife to support William at polo match

The Princess of Wales, 41, was cheering on the Prince, 41, as he took part in the Out-Sourcing Inc. Royal Charity Polo Cup 2023 at the Guards Polo Club in Windsor this afternoon.

https://mol.im/a/12270651

OP posts:
Maireas · 07/07/2023 20:54

ArcaneWireless · 07/07/2023 20:52

Isn’t feminism all about leaving women the fuck alone to be who they want to be, provided they’re not hurting anyone else?

You’d think.

Spot on.

Beezknees · 07/07/2023 20:53

Migrainehaterforlife · 07/07/2023 20:39

God is this thread still going?😂coming back to see how many people quoted my observation of jealousy and tried to intellectualise their bullying is hilarious. I can't imagine what you're like as colleagues, friends and god forbid mother in laws if you have sons. Kate is phenomenal, she's classy, beautiful, educated and drama free despite the constant nastiness and criticism following her around as shown on this thread. To me that is a role model. It would be so easy for her to throw a strop or change herself because of what nasty women say and she doesn't and that is exactly what I aspire to be like in life :)

You haven't said what she has done that makes her phenomenal. Being "classy and beautiful" is not something that I find inspiring in women. It doesn't take any guts or daring. I don't even dislike her, but she doesn't do anything that could be called "phenomenal".

Maireas · 07/07/2023 20:53

dontbejealousofmyartisticflair · 07/07/2023 20:47

It's not difficult when she's never actually done anything.

She had a few years of wearing completely unsuitable outfits, not appropriate for her position in legal engagements, but apart from that. The perfect Stepford Wife, smile, nod and don't let any thought trouble your little head.

Oh, I'm sure she's got plenty of opinions. She just chooses not to share them with the general public.

ArcaneWireless · 07/07/2023 20:52

Isn’t feminism all about leaving women the fuck alone to be who they want to be, provided they’re not hurting anyone else?

You’d think.

Maireas · 07/07/2023 20:51

Migrainehaterforlife · 07/07/2023 20:39

God is this thread still going?😂coming back to see how many people quoted my observation of jealousy and tried to intellectualise their bullying is hilarious. I can't imagine what you're like as colleagues, friends and god forbid mother in laws if you have sons. Kate is phenomenal, she's classy, beautiful, educated and drama free despite the constant nastiness and criticism following her around as shown on this thread. To me that is a role model. It would be so easy for her to throw a strop or change herself because of what nasty women say and she doesn't and that is exactly what I aspire to be like in life :)

I agree. The level of scrutiny she's under would drive me mad
She's remained dignified throughout.

Nogbadthebad · 07/07/2023 20:51

'She had a few years of wearing completely unsuitable outfits, not appropriate for her position in legal engagements'

Eh?

Beezknees · 07/07/2023 20:50

Blossomtoes · 07/07/2023 20:43

She’s never put a foot wrong. I have huge admiration for her.

Not being allowed to voice any opinions because she has to Keep Up Appearances.

dontbejealousofmyartisticflair · 07/07/2023 20:47

Blossomtoes · 07/07/2023 20:43

She’s never put a foot wrong. I have huge admiration for her.

It's not difficult when she's never actually done anything.

She had a few years of wearing completely unsuitable outfits, not appropriate for her position in legal engagements, but apart from that. The perfect Stepford Wife, smile, nod and don't let any thought trouble your little head.

Blossomtoes · 07/07/2023 20:43

She’s never put a foot wrong. I have huge admiration for her.

Migrainehaterforlife · 07/07/2023 20:39

God is this thread still going?😂coming back to see how many people quoted my observation of jealousy and tried to intellectualise their bullying is hilarious. I can't imagine what you're like as colleagues, friends and god forbid mother in laws if you have sons. Kate is phenomenal, she's classy, beautiful, educated and drama free despite the constant nastiness and criticism following her around as shown on this thread. To me that is a role model. It would be so easy for her to throw a strop or change herself because of what nasty women say and she doesn't and that is exactly what I aspire to be like in life :)

MadKittenWoman · 07/07/2023 20:37

Stepford Wife.

Grapewrath · 07/07/2023 20:37

pilates · 07/07/2023 16:36

@Grapewrath how can you say someone is boring when you don’t know them? Catherine does have to act in a certain way because she is royalty. She doesn’t have much choice really. Not sure what you expect?

In the same way we judge the public persona of anyone in the public eye. I just find her quite dull and not very entertaining. I find her fashion sense bland and her interviews are very bland
Behind closed doors she might be quite the riot😁

IronCurtain · 07/07/2023 20:34

IronCurtain · 07/07/2023 20:34

See, I find that presumptuous and arrogant. Aware of the influence you might have on others - fine. A role model? That’s not something you can decide yourself.

Perhaps if you are the sort of person to equate fame with desirable or aspirational, then you are more likely to be upset when a famous person doesn’t fit your personal definition of success. But I’d have thought most women beyond their teenage years realise famous people (women!) are just people, and to hold them to absurd standards in all areas of their lives just because they’re well-known is…ridiculous?

Think of a woman in your life. Maybe your mum? Or sister? Would you tear her down if she looked less than (your idea of) beautiful and fashionable, if she prioritised her kids over her job, if she decided to be a working mum, if she paid for childcare, if she had different interests to yours? Would you berate her day in day out for failing to be an ‘appropriate’ role model?

Isn’t feminism all about leaving women the fuck alone to be who they want to be, provided they’re not hurting anyone else?

Sorry that was to @CurlewKate

IronCurtain · 07/07/2023 20:34

See, I find that presumptuous and arrogant. Aware of the influence you might have on others - fine. A role model? That’s not something you can decide yourself.

Perhaps if you are the sort of person to equate fame with desirable or aspirational, then you are more likely to be upset when a famous person doesn’t fit your personal definition of success. But I’d have thought most women beyond their teenage years realise famous people (women!) are just people, and to hold them to absurd standards in all areas of their lives just because they’re well-known is…ridiculous?

Think of a woman in your life. Maybe your mum? Or sister? Would you tear her down if she looked less than (your idea of) beautiful and fashionable, if she prioritised her kids over her job, if she decided to be a working mum, if she paid for childcare, if she had different interests to yours? Would you berate her day in day out for failing to be an ‘appropriate’ role model?

Isn’t feminism all about leaving women the fuck alone to be who they want to be, provided they’re not hurting anyone else?

Forestfire12345 · 07/07/2023 20:16

She's had work done and a team who do her hair and made up !
Sound like a child with a crush

Maireas · 07/07/2023 20:07

I couldn't agree more, @IronCurtain , it's so depressing.
Apart from the body shaming going on, accusing someone of looking "middle aged" is such a ridiculous insult.

Maireas · 07/07/2023 19:52

Absolutely, @MrsMarzetti . Why ridicule her? Indeed.

DewinDwl · 07/07/2023 19:48

MrsMarzetti · 07/07/2023 18:33

Why ridicule a woman for what she wears and for putting her children before her job?

Re read my post and you will find that my criticism is for the role and the institution. I don't know KM - I imagine you don't either but you seem sure about her priorities?

I assume that what we see of her is mediated and controlled by the royal family. I think she has scope to play a very different role, a less shallow one that is more relevant to people's lives. However the monarchy doesn't seem interested in some of her strengths. Maybe they are right and this reflects the views of the majority of the country who just want to see matronly outfits and shaking of hands and cutting of ribbons?

I think it's a shame and a missed opportunity that Kate's role is so restricted but on the other hand as a republican I think whatever mistakes bring the Windsors downfall are welcome.

ArcaneWireless · 07/07/2023 18:59

or someone looking for snark

And finding it in shiteloads.

“This is not a criticism but …”
or
”I find them this that or the other” - when they don’t know her from an egg.
or
“painfully thin/drawn/haggard/old looking”
or
”someone else is prettier”
or
whatever else is insulting to her life, parents, education and anything and everything else.

A thread which is at least 95% pile on and that was the whole point of it eh?

Gushingly complimentary my arse.

LetsPlayShadowlands · 07/07/2023 18:52

I think you're being unreasonable. I also think you're being pathetic.

Give me Kathy Burke or Miryam Margolyes over Kate any day. Not 'glamorous'. Not 'Picture perfect'. But I'd rather have them as my Queen.

pilates · 07/07/2023 18:37

@Nogbadthebad exactly what I said. It’s just a way to bitch and pitch Meghan and Catherine against each other. So if anyone, it could be Meghan’s pr team to stir up hatred. Who knows?

MrsMarzetti · 07/07/2023 18:33

DewinDwl · 07/07/2023 11:05

The thing that depresses me is how restrictive her role seems to be. There is no need for it. Think about people like queen Maxima in the Netherlands and Letizia in Spain - they had great professional careers in competitive fields before they even met their spouses. I realise the fair comparison with be with Camilla but that's a whole other thread.

In that respect Maxima and Letizia truly are someone to look up to. They are also true modern ambassadors for their country - for example showcasing young designers etc. Kate's outfits are often not only old-fashioned but old for her age to the point of sometimes making her look really odd.

In comparison to other monarchies the role Kate is allowed to play seems practically Victorian, bland and irrelevant to people's lives to the point of absurdity. IMO Kate's role could be an engine to modernise the monarchy but they are so out of touch they don't realise. One of the RM's many mistakes - bring on the republic!

Why ridicule a woman for what she wears and for putting her children before her job?

Nogbadthebad · 07/07/2023 18:21

'The op did sound rather gushing, as if written by Katie's pr team' - no, these posts always open the doors to pages of criticism about looks, thinness, demeanor, clothes, work, marriage, children etc., It's far more likely to be a journalist or someone looking for snark.

BallantyneValentine · 07/07/2023 17:54

Chickychoccyegg · 07/07/2023 17:03

I find her very average looking, like a lot of wealthy women of her age, not bad looking, but we'll groomed.
I met her very recently in Edinburgh, and she seemed nice, very polite.
The op did sound rather gushing, as if written by Katie's pr team , if I had to choose, which I also think is rather sad and horrible, I'd say Meghan is better looking.

I remember when I saw Meghan on Suits I thought she was the most beautiful woman I have ever seen. Herself and Kate are both very attractive women.

dontbejealousofmyartisticflair · 07/07/2023 17:37

For hundreds of years being a good Queen has been about having a career but about producing heirs and not doing anything to embarrass the RF. Lots of SAHM's still make a career out of bringing up their children.

but you'd think we have moved away from just producing heir and being a Stepford Wife.

It's the decade before she got married when she didn't do anything and didn't have any interest that is sad.

Of course she would have had to give up most of her careers like the others did, even William did if you believe his PR, but at least she would have shown she had a brain and knew how to use it.