Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Kate is truly picture perfect

461 replies

julylover · 07/07/2023 00:31

I mean - who looks that good in all their photos. She’s just so beautiful and incredibly photogenic! Not to mention extremely good at tennis, all other sports and everything else in between. William could not have chosen a better wire!

Kate is every inch the proud wife to support William at polo match

https://mol.im/a/12270651

Kate is every inch the proud wife to support William at polo match

The Princess of Wales, 41, was cheering on the Prince, 41, as he took part in the Out-Sourcing Inc. Royal Charity Polo Cup 2023 at the Guards Polo Club in Windsor this afternoon.

https://mol.im/a/12270651

OP posts:
Maireas · 09/07/2023 12:52

I have no idea what "jokes and bets" there were. However, maybe you have sources of information. All I know is what they've said in various interviews etc. Latterly, Harry said to Tom Bradby that they had never claimed that the RF was racist. It was the British press.

dontbejealousofmyartisticflair · 09/07/2023 12:39

I still would be very surprised if they found the jokes and bets as funny as Kate must have found the "door to manual" jokes.

Maireas · 09/07/2023 12:28

"the jokes and bet about the colour of their child"
Not even Harry and Meghan claimed that.

dontbejealousofmyartisticflair · 09/07/2023 12:24

The difference now is that when Meghan joined the family, Harry did not feel he got the support from his family and "the firm" when the media and others were criticising her. I imagine he didn't feel he owed them his loyalty any more when he didn't have theirs, and he now has the ability to financially support himself, so he left.

and good for him. It's obvious the treatment of Meghan was abysmal. The jokes and bet about the colour of their child, the blackamoor brooch, the video of William turning his side to Meghan and ignoring her while staring at the cameras. If that's how they behaved in public, you can imagine how it was in private.

There was enough speculation when Kate shrugged William off in front of Mary Berry. Why wasn't that scene cut off is anyone's guess.

Meghan behaved impeccably in public, turned up, did all the engagements required of her, and more, but was abused because she dared standing up for herself.

Harry was probably a bit naive to expect family support when he married a divorced mixed-race american, but I think it really damaged to royal family to be so out of touch with the real world.

ArcaneWireless · 09/07/2023 12:09

Indeed maireas

We need only look at some of the RF threads on here to see how popular or unpopular their choices have been.

Opinions - just like recollections - may vary.

As I said, it is a shame. I don’t think they have found the freedom, peace and contentment that they hoped their departure would give them.

And now, due to some opinions, it may be a harder trek to get back on that road.

I think they still have it in them to do great things for so many causes. But like you say maireas, it is time to park the baggage and move forward. All sorts of positive happenings await them if they choose that path.

ArcaneWireless · 09/07/2023 11:56

And so what if she takes the pictures?

nothing, but they are no better than the photos I see everyday on social media, most of my friends take amazing photos of their children.

Which is precisely what I said directly after the quote you posted.

They have the same charm to them as any mam’s photos of her bairns.

The same. Not better. The same. No fawning.

My point was that she is entitled to release the photos she likes of her home life. Home life will mean that she (or William or another family member) is likely to take the photos - just like your friends.

Maireas · 09/07/2023 11:55

Yes, I think he could have had a quieter life. It could have been accommodated. H and M were offered a low key start, to live quietly, no official work, just to bed in. The offer for M to continue with her acting was just that - a kind of normalisation and accomodation. Choices were made, and even with the best of intentions, mistakes were made.
So. How do you move forward? You stop with the mindset that you're a victim/justice warrior and just try to take some positives (and there are many) and find a purposeful life.

ArcaneWireless · 09/07/2023 11:49

I do get what you are saying badnomad. Time may well have given him the strength to leave.

I disagree though that a quieter life would have meant losing his family.

If anything, it was the actions during and after the leaving process that may have damaged family relations irreparably.

Shame when it could have been different. In all sorts of ways.

dontbejealousofmyartisticflair · 09/07/2023 11:43

And so what if she takes the pictures?
nothing, but they are no better than the photos I see everyday on social media, most of my friends take amazing photos of their children.

It's the fawning about normal photo just because of who she married which is funny

ArcaneWireless · 09/07/2023 11:38

I too liked the photo. It had a warmth to it and I prefer the more informal photos.

BadNomad · 09/07/2023 11:33

ArcaneWireless · 09/07/2023 11:17

badnomad and maireas

I always think of Harry and Chelsy Davy. They were great together, but shedidn't want that life and left.

and

Although, @BadNomad - Harry said he didn't want that life either.

It does make me curious why Harry didn’t leave the confines of the RF when Chelsy said it wasn’t for her.

Did he love Meghan more? Did he envisage more of a prominent role for himself in America? More opportunities? To be not the spare but the star?

Did he not fancy a life of out of the limelight with Chelsy? Was she not enough?

Chelsy may not have wanted the life. I get that. But to blame the press for the break up? It would have been a contributory factor possibly. The chance for a quieter life was there for the taking. And for whatever reason that road wasn’t chosen.

And I understand that H&M are still the subject of intense scrutiny despite leaving. My opinion of that is that it is likely due to their actions after leaving. I think it stirred the press pot. 💰

There is the great possibility that a quiet(er) life in Canada was there to enjoy. He didn’t seem to want to choose that either.

I think Kate and William are trying to balance it as best they can. Yes they are ‘public property’. That doesn’t mean they aren’t entitled to a part of their life away from intrusion. And good on her for taking the photos of the children. They are her children. She should be able to choose what is released for private occasions like birthdays.

And so what if she takes the pictures? They have the same charm to them as any mam’s photos of her bairns. (Even photos where the mam has captured her adult arcanechild looking like a pissy gargoyle….)

Same with H&M. They are protective over their children too and release pictures of their home life as and when they choose to. And rightly so.

Hmm I think because he was a lot younger then. He might not have had the courage to step away and do it alone and he probably still felt loyalty and obligation towards his family. At that time they hadn't done anything wrong towards him, so it might have felt like a huge betrayal to abandon them then and lose their support.
The difference now is that when Meghan joined the family, Harry did not feel he got the support from his family and "the firm" when the media and others were criticising her. I imagine he didn't feel he owed them his loyalty any more when he didn't have theirs, and he now has the ability to financially support himself, so he left.

As a royal, a quieter life means losing your family. That is not an easy choice to make.

jeffgoldblum · 09/07/2023 11:28

Very measured posts from both @ArcaneWireless and @Maireas , glad you both post , saves me typing out long posts myself ( I'm lazy!) 👍

Maireas · 09/07/2023 11:25

Yes, I wondered that, @ArcaneWireless - why didn't Harry take the chance to leave with Chelsey? He often said he wanted to live in Africa. That was her home.
Yet he married Meghan, then had a full on royal life, then swapped it for a full on celebrity life.
I wonder if he ever really knew what "leaving" meant. I suspect not.
Different point - I really love Kate's picture of Camilla: it seems to convey such a lot and is a very good composition.

BartholemewHolmes · 09/07/2023 11:20

twinklystar23 · 09/07/2023 08:45

I don't agree with a constitutional monarchy, per se. Hers and William job is to be "bland and boring" their role is to highlight various causes, institutions of the UK it is not about them. Kudos to any woman breaking into those circles,.
Also bet the gutter press hate that Kate releases her own pics of her children, on their birthdays, but also now Camilla! Not sure if it's a subtle two fingers up, who knows?!

I think they prefer something better than nothing

It’s more controlled than Diana days. The press don’t swarm Kate and her dc on the street as paps did back then but they can print the okayed event pics

ArcaneWireless · 09/07/2023 11:17

badnomad and maireas

I always think of Harry and Chelsy Davy. They were great together, but shedidn't want that life and left.

and

Although, @BadNomad - Harry said he didn't want that life either.

It does make me curious why Harry didn’t leave the confines of the RF when Chelsy said it wasn’t for her.

Did he love Meghan more? Did he envisage more of a prominent role for himself in America? More opportunities? To be not the spare but the star?

Did he not fancy a life of out of the limelight with Chelsy? Was she not enough?

Chelsy may not have wanted the life. I get that. But to blame the press for the break up? It would have been a contributory factor possibly. The chance for a quieter life was there for the taking. And for whatever reason that road wasn’t chosen.

And I understand that H&M are still the subject of intense scrutiny despite leaving. My opinion of that is that it is likely due to their actions after leaving. I think it stirred the press pot. 💰

There is the great possibility that a quiet(er) life in Canada was there to enjoy. He didn’t seem to want to choose that either.

I think Kate and William are trying to balance it as best they can. Yes they are ‘public property’. That doesn’t mean they aren’t entitled to a part of their life away from intrusion. And good on her for taking the photos of the children. They are her children. She should be able to choose what is released for private occasions like birthdays.

And so what if she takes the pictures? They have the same charm to them as any mam’s photos of her bairns. (Even photos where the mam has captured her adult arcanechild looking like a pissy gargoyle….)

Same with H&M. They are protective over their children too and release pictures of their home life as and when they choose to. And rightly so.

Maireas · 09/07/2023 09:11

I think she's definitely controlling the images and just giving enough of her family life, @twinklystar23 .

twinklystar23 · 09/07/2023 08:45

I don't agree with a constitutional monarchy, per se. Hers and William job is to be "bland and boring" their role is to highlight various causes, institutions of the UK it is not about them. Kudos to any woman breaking into those circles,.
Also bet the gutter press hate that Kate releases her own pics of her children, on their birthdays, but also now Camilla! Not sure if it's a subtle two fingers up, who knows?!

Maireas · 09/07/2023 08:44

Although, @BadNomad - Harry said he didn't want that life either.

BadNomad · 09/07/2023 08:42

I don't think many women in the upper-class/aristocracy actually do aspire to do what she is doing. Historically, a wife would have been found for William (like Diana was found for Charles) but that's not the done thing any more. In reality, William didn't have many options. It's harder these days to attract an "elite" woman with little personal history, no career ambition, who is willing to suppress her personality and play a part in public. It's not a very modern role for a woman and not many women want that.

I always think of Harry and Chelsy Davy. They were great together, but she didn't want that life and left.

Maireas · 09/07/2023 08:25

You certainly make good point, @twinklystar23 . I was just thinking that about Kate and also Sophie. In the European monarchies Letizia and Mary were also from non aristocratic and MC families, and have carved a successful role. I'm sure it's hard when you're up against the aristocracy and Eton types.

twinklystar23 · 09/07/2023 08:01

On the other hand could it not be argued that she weathered the snobbery of the upper classes. Could it be argued she's managed to do her public role professionally? In fact better than those who should have had advantage over her having been used and had mixed more closely on those circles? The nasty "doors to manual" comments to about her mother must have been incredibly hurtful, and that's what we know of. A woman from a relatively normal background has shown the toffs that she can do the role that many of them "aspire to" (Not just women here ) and does the job of being in the public eye without putting a foot wrong.

Has K.M smashed through the glass ceiling of aristocracy and the arrogant beliefs that many of them hold that they are better than the rest of us (look no further than the Eton educated ministers)

Just a thought....

dontbejealousofmyartisticflair · 08/07/2023 18:23

The only thing I disagree with a bit is her overzealous focus on early years

the Palace HAD to find something for her to "focus" on, taking a few photos of her children didn't quite cut it, don't we all.. and early years is the least controversial subject you could think about. It matters, of course, and no one is denying it does,

dontbejealousofmyartisticflair · 08/07/2023 18:22

Hadjab · 08/07/2023 15:43

Of course she does her job to perfection! What does she actually do again? Pops off to the odd charity where she has a few pics taken with some token [insert description of your choice] person. Goes to a gala dinner or three, makes small talk with dignitaries. Flirts at the tennis with retired tennis players. Wears clothes. Has babies.

Have I missed anything?

It hasn't gone unnoticed that she keeps the engagements as close to her house as possible, unless she REALLY has no choice.

Pops in a helicopter or a car with the police opening the way for 10 to 15mn, wave to the cameras and the public, shake a few hands, nod and grin, and go home again.

She might be doing just the bare minimum expected of her, but it's astonishing that people are praising her and impressed by what little she does

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 08/07/2023 15:51

I'm going to sound so sycophantic you might want to throw up, but William did a grand job choosing Kate to be his wife. She's perfect for the Royal Family. We never see any strong emotion, any pain caused by MM's remarks against her, and she just gets on with the job gracefully. She just seems like a really lovely, kind person. The only thing I disagree with a bit is her overzealous focus on early years, as for me it was my teenage years that fucked me up more and I feel we need to really rescue the mental health of teens especially in the days of constant social media pressures. I've blabbered and digressed a lot.