Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should we specifically be asking to be seen by a GP when booking a GP appointment ?

66 replies

Gigihadr · 06/07/2023 23:34

https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2023-07-06/debates/D98F2ABE-7B33-4748-B88E-ED7243469131/PhysicianAssociates

poor girl died after being seen by a physician associate and at no point during the appointment at the GP surgery was Emily made aware that the person who had diagnosed her was not a doctor. So sad ☹️

OP posts:
Gigihadr · 07/07/2023 12:32

Do people know a Physician’s Associate is not a doctor? Recently, my friend went to A+E with her relative.

The 1st member of staff said she was “like a doctor” 2nd said he was “better than a doctor” and a 3rd claimed to be “the most senior person there”.

None were doctors.

Dangerous in my opinion.

OP posts:
Pharmdrama · 07/07/2023 11:04

This is quite shocking.

I am an independent prescribing pharmacist. A mock of this very scenario (DVT leading to a PE) was in my prescribing OSCE exam and if you missed it you failed outright (I didn't miss it!!). I am very concerned it was missed on two occasions by a healthcare professional.

I also always introduce myself as a pharmacist and clearly explain my role. To do otherwise is disengenous and does not give the patient an informed choice.

There is so much scope for healthcare professionals other than GPs to contribute to patient care, in some cases a specialist nurse, physio, pharmacist etc may even be more appropriate. But it should always be transparent to the patient and they should have the right to say no.

Mapples · 07/07/2023 09:12

badluckorbadvibes · 07/07/2023 08:51

It seems any chest pain/shortness of breath is being put down to anxiety these days. I have a condition which is been over 4 years now and the amount of doctors I saw ( both during hospital admissions and at the GP surgery) who told me it was down to anxiety is absolutely shocking. I do get anxiety but it's never caused me this specific breathing difficulty, which is controlled with steroids now. It's shocking how dismissive they all were, while I sat there as a fat autistic person trying to get them to 'believe' me. It was horrendous. That's at the hands of qualified doctors, god knows what a PA would have made if it. I had to fight my way to medication, they didn't want to listen.

I agree this is a big issue. I have anxiety but when I presented with shortness of breath thankfully my GP said although it could be related to that I want to rule everything else out- I had blood taken, a chest X Ray booked and was prescribed an inhaler to help manage it. They all came back clear and the inhaler didn't really help, getting a grip of my anxiety with new meds and a referral to counselling did help but I'm so thankful they didn't just assume as it would have caused even more stress and this is how serious stuff is missed. Such a shame this isn't standard.

Mapples · 07/07/2023 09:05

Seen as it's illegal to impersonate a doctor then yes, it should be made abundantly clear when booking an appointment whether you will be seen by a GP, a PA or a nurse; my surgery are very clear on this when you book and at the start of any appointment. It's tragic as her symptoms were massive red flags, absolutely text book symptoms for this. Whilst GPs aren't perfect and do miss things, the chances of a PA doing so are so much higher, its scary. This is the government's plan though, fill the gaps with lesser qualified and lesser knowledgeable people and hope no one notices. PAs also aren't regulated which is very worrying.

ohmustyou · 07/07/2023 08:54

We're quickly getting a two tier system- those with private cover get to see doctors, the plebs get a "practitioner".

In theory, "practitioners" working with doctors make sense. The practice though? It's destroying our health service, and our health. If you want a doctor, you'll have to go private. It's already happened with mental illness- whole teams are staffed by practitioners. If you want to see a psychiatrist, you have to go private.

badluckorbadvibes · 07/07/2023 08:51

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 07/07/2023 08:38

This is really sad, though sadly the outcome may have not been different if she’d seen a gp. My Dd saw a gp and was also sent home twice from a&e when she went with chest pain and breathlessness over a period of a few weeks. Turns out she had PEs. But all the doctors she saw said it was anxiety

It seems any chest pain/shortness of breath is being put down to anxiety these days. I have a condition which is been over 4 years now and the amount of doctors I saw ( both during hospital admissions and at the GP surgery) who told me it was down to anxiety is absolutely shocking. I do get anxiety but it's never caused me this specific breathing difficulty, which is controlled with steroids now. It's shocking how dismissive they all were, while I sat there as a fat autistic person trying to get them to 'believe' me. It was horrendous. That's at the hands of qualified doctors, god knows what a PA would have made if it. I had to fight my way to medication, they didn't want to listen.

Medstudent12 · 07/07/2023 08:49

@Lemonyfuckit as a doctor at work (hospital based) introduce myself by my first name to patients. I don’t say Dr Surname, maybe I should who knows we all should.

Medstudent12 · 07/07/2023 08:47

Lemonyfuckit · 07/07/2023 08:41

Can I ask a very basic and possibly obvious question (as I too hadn't heard of physician associates until reading this tragic and avoidable case) - presumably physician associates absolutely do not have the title Dr? - so if you make an appointment at your GP surgery and your appointment is with Dr Bloggs, then at least you know you are seeing an actual qualified GP?

Yes they’re not doctors. But last person I saw in GP didn’t introduce themselves at all. That’s the issue. And online system didn’t tell me their name. But they won’t have Dr before their name.

Medstudent12 · 07/07/2023 08:45

*calves not valves! My bad

Medstudent12 · 07/07/2023 08:44

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 07/07/2023 08:38

This is really sad, though sadly the outcome may have not been different if she’d seen a gp. My Dd saw a gp and was also sent home twice from a&e when she went with chest pain and breathlessness over a period of a few weeks. Turns out she had PEs. But all the doctors she saw said it was anxiety

But this case, from the description in the debate was clear cut. To not check the valves for a DVT is inexcusable. This was a presentation a medical student would have recognised, this was an entirely preventable death.

Medstudent12 · 07/07/2023 08:43

MissTrip82 · 07/07/2023 00:50

Nobody wants to do the work it takes to be a doctor any more. There’s a real generational change. People just will not do it. And there’s a cost to taking the easier path.

I work in an icu and we really wonder how we’re going to staff it long term. A
solid ten years of grueling training after university to become a junior consultant (so still not an expert) is a really hard sell now.

Ask the ICU doctors you work with how easy it is to get an anaesthetic reg post. The posts are limited by the government. Plenty of people want to train to become consultants but can’t. Google the competition ratios.

Lemonyfuckit · 07/07/2023 08:41

Can I ask a very basic and possibly obvious question (as I too hadn't heard of physician associates until reading this tragic and avoidable case) - presumably physician associates absolutely do not have the title Dr? - so if you make an appointment at your GP surgery and your appointment is with Dr Bloggs, then at least you know you are seeing an actual qualified GP?

HaveYouHeardOfARoadAtlas · 07/07/2023 08:38

This is really sad, though sadly the outcome may have not been different if she’d seen a gp. My Dd saw a gp and was also sent home twice from a&e when she went with chest pain and breathlessness over a period of a few weeks. Turns out she had PEs. But all the doctors she saw said it was anxiety

Medstudent12 · 07/07/2023 08:32

Gingerkittykat · 07/07/2023 07:57

Are ANPs better qualified than physician assistants?

The ANP at my surgery is really good and can prescribe too. he also has a better bedside manner than the GPs!

ANPs I think also need a defined scope of practice. They’re not doctors. But as a doctor I prefer working with ANPs, most are excellent colleagues and unlike PAs they have extensive period experience of being a nurse/paramedic/physio etc. ANPs also do their own prescribing whereas PAs ask a doctor. It’s very stressful feeling like your registration is on the line prescribing for someone else who can’t prescribe such as a PA.

I’d be ok seeing ANP, they’re good clinicians.

Medstudent12 · 07/07/2023 08:28

Bubbleses · 07/07/2023 04:08

Pardon my ignorance but I’ve never even really heard of a physician associate! I suppose I have had limited contact with medical professionals though outside maternity care…

This is all quite shocking. I can’t understand how a PA could earn more than a doctor?! Is this at a very junior doctor level only - what kind of disparity are we talking?

So I’m a new registrar. Some of them their base pay is the same as mine, I’ve finished royal college membership exams and been a doctor for 5 years. I get paid more overall as I work more hours than they do (I work more than full time). They’re paid substantially more than the FY1 (new doctor who get £14/hour).

Registrar base pay is the same as band 7, it’s much lower than people think.

Notanotherwun · 07/07/2023 08:20

I don't mind seeing nurses or paramedics, at my practice if there is something they aren't sure about they check it with the duty doctor who comes and examines you. If appropriate safeguards are in place then there's no need to always see a GP for every ailment.

Mischance · 07/07/2023 08:18

I rang for appt and got call back from someone who did not sound on the ball at all and was not asking sensible questions. I asked her if she was a doctor and she said she was a PA. She went on to prescribe me a drug that I knew was incompatible with my current drug regime. I gave up on her and did not pick the drug up.

User10486743 · 07/07/2023 08:08

I saw a nurse practitioner at the surgery for my suspected skin cancer (non melanoma, not on my face) as no doctors appointment available and she took a photo, showed a doctor and I got a 2 week referral to the dermatology clinic, it looks to be a BCC and I have an appointment for its removal. I was pleased with the service I received.

Gingerkittykat · 07/07/2023 07:57

Are ANPs better qualified than physician assistants?

The ANP at my surgery is really good and can prescribe too. he also has a better bedside manner than the GPs!

Handholdplease85 · 07/07/2023 05:11

Our GPS have a couple of PAs as well as a couple of paramedics who run a minor illness clinic. In principle it makes sense but that’s assuming you have very clearly defined boundaries about what symptoms constitute a minor illness. For example one of my DDs gets ear infections a lot and needs antibiotics which is quite straightforward, they check her over and check her ears and then the prescription is signed off by a GP.

However if I want an appointment for anything more complicated then I make sure I specifically ask for a GP and when the receptionist asks why, I make sure I use the buzz words I know will get me an appointment. For myself it’s mentioning things like “to discuss my complex long term medical condition” or for the children it would be things to “to request a referral to a specialist” or “to discuss a potential underlying condition”. At our practice those things do seem to work. I do find it quite worrying that you need to do this to actually see a GP.

Weirdly though if you say “red flag” type words like sudden rash, very high temperature they will either book you in with a PA anyway or advise you to go to A&E. Doctors at my practice seem to be used for discussing long term and more complex medical problems - if you feel acutely unwell then it’s either a minor illness (so a PA) or a major illness in which case you get sent to A&E.

Ireolu · 07/07/2023 04:52

GP practices get round this by calling everyone 'clinicians' so you don't know if you are seeing a PA or a doctor. A lot of practices in London are heavily reliant on them because of falling GP numbers and GPs reducing their hours.

I would always ask because there are definite gaps in their knowledge and this horrible story proves that they don't always practice safely or with the required supervision of a doctor. Poor girl and her poor family.

Bubbleses · 07/07/2023 04:08

Medstudent12 · 07/07/2023 00:38

Also if anyone interested PAs get paid more than lots of doctors. Despite not being trained to prescribe and having less training. Hence doctors striking so hard.

Pardon my ignorance but I’ve never even really heard of a physician associate! I suppose I have had limited contact with medical professionals though outside maternity care…

This is all quite shocking. I can’t understand how a PA could earn more than a doctor?! Is this at a very junior doctor level only - what kind of disparity are we talking?

Gigihadr · 07/07/2023 03:46

Medstudent12 · 07/07/2023 00:23

You’re correct. They do a 2 year masters course rather than a 5/6 year medical degree. They also don’t sit postgraduate exams like doctors do or do formal training like we do. They are often favoured by hospital consultants for training and opportunities as unlike junior doctors they don’t rotate to other hospitals. This impacts upon doctors training.

They also don’t have the formative on call experience from out of hours on call shifts all doctors do early in their career. For example most have not done night shifts as they cannot prescribe so you cannot really have them independently covering wards alone at night.

They can be useful in a narrow defined role, but most get bored of basic tasks assisting doctors and push for career progression. Lots could have been doctors but became PAs instead. They have a better work life balance and the course is shorter.

I’ve worked with some great PAs, but many don’t understand the limits of their short training and their complete absence of formal post university training that doctors undertake.

A GP has worked as a doctor for 2 years (foundation programme, long hours). Then done a minimum of three years training as a GP (1 year hospital specialties, 2 years GP) and passed royal college or general practitioners exams. Most GPs have done other specialties before or they locummed for a few years before becoming GPs. So it’s common they’ve been doctors for much longer than 5 years when they qualify.

So a PA is very different from a GP and the tories plan to use them to patch up the nhs is terrifying.

That is absolutely terrifying !!!

OP posts:
TaylorSwiftFan · 07/07/2023 01:15

This is awful.

Do PAs exist in Scotland? I've only heard of them in the last month?

MissTrip82 · 07/07/2023 00:50

Nobody wants to do the work it takes to be a doctor any more. There’s a real generational change. People just will not do it. And there’s a cost to taking the easier path.

I work in an icu and we really wonder how we’re going to staff it long term. A
solid ten years of grueling training after university to become a junior consultant (so still not an expert) is a really hard sell now.