Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Ask if You are Materialistic?

154 replies

BeLikeThatSometimes · 06/07/2023 22:40

And if so, is there anything wrong with it?

I have dreamt about nice clothes and “stuff” in general as far as I remember back, perhaps because we had limited budget growing up and nobody was spoilt.

Now reasonably successful professional, my tastes and aspirations are different but I still think a lot about material things and how they make life more enjoyable and beautiful. My friends and parents are not like this, my mother is big on culture, my grown up daughter values experiences more, and I feel shallow and indulgent I’m comparison, obsessing over prospect of new hand towels, shoes, body lotion, bedding, garden furniture etc. Not a hoarder but always something “next on the list” to research, check out etc - not always buy!

Anyone else like this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
randomusername03 · 20/07/2023 18:15

Everyone's materialistic, just some to a higher degrees than others. Unless you are wandering the wild with just the clothes on your back and living off the land. I dont think there are many of them on mn.

whereeverilaymycat · 10/07/2023 13:07

I would say yes, although now in a healthy way.

When I was young we had no money and although I would occasionally covet something, generally it didn't register. I then went to a school which had quite a big bullying problem and having the 'right' bag / shoes / coat etc offered a degree of protection. I wasn't popular or confident, but having the right things was a bit of currency. Same in the work place I spent most of my career. I absolutely used stuff as a way of cultivating an image and making up for where I felt I lacked.

Now I'm out of those environments it matters less to me. When pushed, actually what I value is security and I'm now less inclined to buy stuff frivolously. I'm naturally a home bird so although experiences are a higher priority now, I still prefer to be at home and invest there. I appreciate things that are beautiful and well made and buy the best quality I can. But I'm less compulsive now and understand my triggers.

I've never judged others explicitly. But I know I would be ranking myself based on how well I perceived others to be doing. I'm glad I've moved on from that and don't wrap my self worth up in what I own any more. I love shopping and like nice things, but it's for the right reasons now thankfully.

Sceptre86 · 10/07/2023 06:49

No but my sister and sil are both like this. We were not poor growing up, went to bed with fill bellies but only dad worked and mum was a sahm. As a family of 6 eating out was a luxury as was having more than one birthday present. In general I'm still one for saving for a rainy day and hate the thought of not having a buffer. I do like nice things but am not massively into brands or believe that more expensive is better. I tend to spend money on experiences though, we didn't travel much as kids (went to a lot of theme park day trips) but not for a weekend away. I do like to go for a long weekend away in the UK when we get chance.

My sister grew up in the same household but always felt more hard done by that dad couldn't afford certain things. It's caused her no end on grief as she's always chasing money.

My sil was raised by a single mum who did her best but with 3 kids and no job had to rely on family to provide the basics for her kids (grew up overseas). She married bil who earns well. She openly admits to buying her kids whatever they want because her mum was unable ti do the same. It's understandable but nephew now asks the minute you step through the door what you have got him. If my dh buys me jewellery or I treat myself then she must have the same.

cruisingabout · 09/07/2023 23:31

I grew up witnessing extreme wealth while being from just an upper middle class family, used to be willing to do anything for money. I realised that I can't afford to be materialistic due to my upbringing. I have made peace with the fact that I'll probably never be thrilled and fully satisfied with anything I own, because whatever I own I've probably seen someone I know owning a much better version of it. I've adjusted myself to want material things that 'matter', rather than status symbol items.

for example I buy second hand furniture, my phone, tv and laptop are all 5+ years old, but I own a 5 bed house with a big private garden in an expensive location, because privacy, safety and good connection to london are what matter to me, shinny new furniture and the latest gadgets aren't. h and ils are very impressed with the house, while me and my parents find it nice but slightly underwhelming. 1 week after moving in I was window shopping for a fancier house with an even bigger garden in a more desirable location, and have convinced h to aspire to move into one in the future. same with the car, it's a posh-ish car bought on cash with the intention to keep for 10 years, was very happy with it, still happy with it and have grown attached to it emotionally, but doesn't stop me from window shopping for a bigger car as it's more spacious inside providing more comfort.

it's like whatever I get I'll immediately want the fancier version of it, it's preventing me from gaining much joy from material things.

Aquarelles · 09/07/2023 22:01

It's an interesting question. I guess in a way, I am materialistic.

I've just moved house recently and have spent thousands on all new furniture, pictures, TV, dining table, sofas. I didn't need to buy any of it. I had loads of stuff already, but I've chucked it all and bought new.

In my defence, this is my first house which is just mine alone, having lived 13yrs prior with a man who refused to do any decorating or buy anything new. I may have got a little excited and carried away Grin

HappyMe6 · 09/07/2023 21:46

I wouldn’t say I’m materialistic I’m retired love nice things but my nice things do not come with huge price tags,

ThisIsACoolUserName · 09/07/2023 21:31

NEmama · 09/07/2023 16:54

Not that it happens often but what if one of you is sick or shits the bed?

Haha. In our 20 years together, that's never happened!
If it did, I guess we'd strip the bed and sleep with the bare mattresss and duvet, which at that point would be the least of our worries 😏

PureLife89 · 09/07/2023 18:35

No I'm not materialistic at all

Old car, old phone, don't really buy clothes or shoes. Appliances all ten years old, anything that's newer is because the previous one had broken so no choice but to replace

Even the items I use for my hobby are ten or more years old

I just don't have the urge to have to constantly have the latest phone or watch or car. I'm just very easily pleased and happy with what I have

My parents are the same. My Dad divorced over thirty years ago and he still has all the same plates, cups, cutlery from when my Mum lived there

rc22 · 09/07/2023 18:16

I don't think it's materialistic to buy nice things as long as you can afford to do so. I think it's materialistic to judge the value of someone as a person by what they own or what they earn.

Miajk · 09/07/2023 17:57

Peony654 · 06/07/2023 23:16

Definitely not. I’d rather spend money on holidays, trips, experiences. There’s so much overconsumption in the world and I don’t want to add to it

This.

I used to be materialistic but I realised:

  • it's clutter
  • it's bad for the environment
  • it's a waste of time (shopping)
  • it's a huge waste of money

You could travel, retire early, have experiences, etc.

Nothing wrong with appreciating quality of items and buying when you need them but living in the pursuit of stuff is depressing.

bonzaitree · 09/07/2023 17:33

I’m not materialistic as such but I do like the comfort of financial security and money in the bank. So so important to me and the main driver for my career.

DrSbaitso · 09/07/2023 17:32

ThisIsACoolUserName · 09/07/2023 14:11

We also only have one set of bedding.

Why not get a spare set?

NEmama · 09/07/2023 16:54

ThisIsACoolUserName · 09/07/2023 14:11

We also only have one set of bedding.

Not that it happens often but what if one of you is sick or shits the bed?

boobot1 · 09/07/2023 15:51

allmyliesaretrue · 06/07/2023 23:13

^ this! I love travel, experiences, time with family/friends (usually sharing said experiences) but I also love ‘nice stuff’ in my home because it gives me pleasure every day. I like nice clothes, shoes, bags, makeup etc because they make me feel good about myself.

@BeLikeThatSometimes ignore the hair shirt brigade and do whatever makes you happy! I am of an age now that used to be referred to as a ‘pensioner’, only the government has fucked me over there!!

I spent yesterday sacrificing to get my qualifications, get started in my career, rear
my children while pretty much working for my pension to pay childcare… put them through uni… and the rest!

There are no pockets in a shroud and if I want to do/buy the things I love before I shuffle the mortal coil, I’ll be fucked if I let anyone judge me or make me feel bad!!

This, well said. Who wants to be the richest in the cemetary. Life is for living.

Scottishlanza · 09/07/2023 15:51

I tend to buy quality in sales (but not designer) and expect any item to last. I only buy what I love and when they are worn out I try and replace with broadly the same thing. I’ve had everyday handbags for 12 + years and the leather has been immaculate but had to replace as insides shabby. I’ve had my last two cars for 13 years each, current one I love and it’s still going strong.

Holidays on the other hand, if I’m not having 5 a year I’m not happy

Mummytotheboy · 09/07/2023 15:36

I like nice things I don't like lots of things! I'm also a big believer in the phrase buy cheap you buy twice! I'd rather have 2 decent quality handbags that will last me than 10 cheap ones

JaneyGee · 09/07/2023 14:59

Not really. I don’t have a problem with people who are though. If you work hard, and love cars, or nice clothes, or whatever, then good luck to you. So long as you aren’t too selfish and greedy, materialism can be a good thing. People who take pride in their house, polish their car, dress well, etc, make the world a more attractive place.

Personally, I work hard and save for the sake of my mental health. I’m a profoundly introverted person. I crave space and silence. Well, I don’t just crave them, I need them. If I had to live on a big housing estate, with noisy, intrusive neighbours, it would be a death sentence. Unfortunately, to have peace and quiet in this crowded island you need money. I’d sacrifice everything - nice house, big car, expensive restaurants, etc, - just for space and light and silence. Silence, space, books, and green fields, those are the things I want. If I had a big, empty, sunlit room lined with books, and a view of fields out the window, I could live on minimum wage, wear the same old clothes each day, eat my dinner out of tins, etc, and be perfectly happy.

Theyshallnotgrowold · 09/07/2023 14:19

Plantymcplantface · 06/07/2023 22:51

Nope. I’m the opposite, always trying to get rid of stuff, find it hard with sentimental things and things I’ve inherited, but I actually would happily own at least 50% less of what I have.

Me too!

meganorks · 09/07/2023 14:14

I'd say no. Not really into things, would also rather have experiences. I'd happily spend a small fortune on a michelin restaurant but would feel really uncomfortable owning an expensive handbag.
My husband has bought me gifts before and has had to say 'it's not as expensive as you are thinking!'. He got me something for Xmas once that was faulty and was happy when I exchanged it that a) it wasn't as expensive as I thought it was and b) it was now in the sale and I got the replacement at the sale price!

ThisIsACoolUserName · 09/07/2023 14:11

NEmama · 09/07/2023 09:47

How do you manage. What if one of you is ill?

We also only have one set of bedding.

Theonlyreason · 09/07/2023 14:06

@BackAgainstWall

You don’t sound especially materialistic. My mother in law has beautiful items in her beautiful home but will replace a sofa after a year because, because, because (because she’s materialistic and always has some form of excuse to buy something new). I mean each to their own, but she doesn’t actually have that much money and then stresses she has no money. I find that bizarre.

Some people have so much money a new sofa each year is neither here nor there but to stress yourself out over that when you can’t really afford it is mental.

mustardrarebit · 09/07/2023 13:42

I like to buy good quality things that I use frequently, like knives, pans, blender, oven, bed, sofa, tv, a reliable and practical (not fancy) car, shoes and winter coats, printer, laptop etc. My DH collects whisky and work tools. We have a valuable piano and rugs but that's about it for splurges. I have a couple of nice bags and sunglasses pre-dating kids but wouldn't buy more.

Segway16 · 09/07/2023 12:50

No, I prefer experiences. I like to spend money on things like garden furniture that will allow us to better enjoy our outdoor space. I like me and my children to look well presented. But I wouldn’t generally spend hundreds of pounds on something that isn’t especially useful (like a designer bag or something). I’d rather spend the money on a nice meal, a weekend away or a day out for the children.

Ratonastick · 09/07/2023 12:02

I love nice things. I’m exactly the same as OP, while I was growing up we were skint (actually we weren’t but my Ps would only spend on my DBs, different story). Anyway, now I have money. I have worked like crazy for 35 years, I have no mortgage, plenty of savings for a secure future, DS has launched and I can spend on frivolities for myself. I can lose hours looking around the web for the nice thing I want, I prowl for bargains once I have chosen and I look at the lovely things I have and they make me happy. And, yes, my cat’s water bowl is Le Creuset and it matches my kettle!

PhoenixIsFlying · 09/07/2023 11:58

Less is more.
Less things but I value them more.