Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect children to move up through scout sections

41 replies

FromageFraisOff · 06/07/2023 22:36

I run a scouting section*, I have children ready to move up to the next section in Oct. I gave the next section up leader 9 months notice. They said it'd be fine. But have now revoked that and are giving priority to their waitlist. Our group leader (who all section leaders report into) is backing this approach.

I had told these parents their children had a place on the basis the next section up leader had told me they did. So I now need to break the news. These children didn't get the chance to put their name down on other groups waiting lists so have now effectively missed out on places elsewhere. I am furious. I am thinking about leaving scouting or at least this group.

AIBU to think this is not on?

*I don't want to name the sections in case it's a bit outing.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dasy2k1 · 18/12/2023 10:00

Im a cub leader and this is my priority list for allocating spaces

1 beavers moving up from our colony
2 Other cubs or beavers moving up from different groups where it is no longer practical to attend the same group (such as moving house)
3 children of anyone who is willing to help out with the group (regardless of section)
4 siblings of existing members (regardless of section)
5 anyone else

currently i have just cleared out my waiting list - but i only have 1 open space at the moment for brand new starters
I close to new entries when i have more than 24 on the books but can continue to take those moving up with an absolute hard limit of 32

budgiegirl · 08/09/2023 09:43

To me, a system that prioritises a beaver moving up to cubs over a child who was on the waiting list since age 5 and never got a space in beavers is arguably unfair (and this does happen in some areas) - after all it's not that child's fault that they haven't made a commitment and invested time and learning if they were never given the chance

But then, what do you do with the children who have aged-out of beavers if the isn't space for them to move up to cubs? Ask them to leave the scout movement? That goes totally against the scout ethos.

I think the problem varies widely from area to area - in some places the waiting lists are long even higher up. It may happen occasionally, but I'd say this is rare. It would be unusual for a child to be on a waiting list for scouts for the whole 3 1/2 years and never get the chance to join. The longest waiting lists are usually for beavers.

children who move into a new area are unlikely to ever have a chance to be part of it etc.
I don't know what happens in other areas, but our scout group never turns away a child who is already in the scout movement, we will squeeze them in somehow. And a child who is new to the area that is not part of the scout movement will likely get a place from the waiting list eventually, although it may take some patience!

UsingChangeofName · 05/09/2023 21:59

DinnaeFashYersel · 05/09/2023 08:08

fewer children overall get a scouts experience

This problem diminishes as they get older. The real pressure is on squirrels and beavers. In older sections adult to child ratios are widened meaning more kids can be accepted. And some kids drop out creating spaces. We rarely turn people away from scouts and explorers

But my point in volunteering stands. The primary barrier is lack of adults.

All of this.

I think the problem varies widely from area to area - in some places the waiting lists are long even higher up.

That would be very unusual. I'm not saying there aren't any 'blips' but census figures don't back up this at all. It is definitely overwhelmingly as @DinnaeFashYersel says.

Our District reflects the issue that it is volunteers we need. We have quite a few Colonies where there is room in the hall for more children to join, but the volunteers who are putting the work in are (understandably) reluctant to take on more dc, without more volunteers. Every group would prioritise the child of someone who is volunteering.

TiggerSnoozer · 05/09/2023 11:11

I think the problem varies widely from area to area - in some places the waiting lists are long even higher up.

I'm not arguing that waiting lists should be given priority over existing members either btw - just that a more equal approach could be taken for children who have been on the waiting list for a long time. To me, a system that prioritises a beaver moving up to cubs over a child who was on the waiting list since age 5 and never got a space in beavers is arguably unfair (and this does happen in some areas) - after all it's not that child's fault that they haven't made a commitment and invested time and learning if they were never given the chance.

I understand the volunteering point fully - I'm a PTA committee member so see the issues there first hand.

DinnaeFashYersel · 05/09/2023 08:08

fewer children overall get a scouts experience

This problem diminishes as they get older. The real pressure is on squirrels and beavers. In older sections adult to child ratios are widened meaning more kids can be accepted. And some kids drop out creating spaces. We rarely turn people away from scouts and explorers

But my point in volunteering stands. The primary barrier is lack of adults.

DinnaeFashYersel · 05/09/2023 08:04

Priority should be given to existing members.

They've already made the commitment and invested time and learning. They shouldn't be turfed out for newbies.

TiggerSnoozer · 05/09/2023 07:52

The volunteering point is separate. I'm simply questioning whether the process for admissions into higher tiers (for existing places) should always prioritise children moving up over waiting list children irrespective of waiting list times. It seems most people think it should with this way but it's not obvious to me why - the natural consequences of this approach is that fewer children have an opportunity to enter scouts later than Beavers, meaning fewer children overall get a scouts experience, but those who do get as much as they want; children who move into a new area are unlikely to ever have a chance to be part of it etc.

DinnaeFashYersel · 04/09/2023 22:27

TiggerSnoozer · 04/09/2023 17:53

Am I the only one that thinks a policy that moves existing children up through every stage of scouts over and above anyone on the waiting list however long they've been waiting doesn't sound fair either though?
Basically if you didn't get in at Beavers then no chance for your entire childhood? That's surely not how it's supposed to work?

My assumption would be something more balanced such as: you automatically go on the waiting list for the next tier up as soon as you start in the current tier. Then anyone who had been on the waiting list longer (e.g. missed out on a place in beavers) would get a place in cubs before you - but you would still get a place before anyone who joined the waiting list after you started beavers. That gives people some chance to get in later and seems much fairer.

Volunteer and the problem will be solved.

Pretty much the only thing that stops kids getting places is lack of adults.

UsingChangeofName · 04/09/2023 18:11

No, I think that current members should get priority.

Basically if you didn't get in at Beavers then no chance for your entire childhood? That's surely not how it's supposed to work?

Well, it doesn't work like that.
Firstly, not everyone that starts Beavers stays for the whole of Beavers, let alone moves up to cubs, then Scouts etc.
Secondly, if you don't get a place at the Beavers nearest to you, then the sensible thing to do would be to look at the next nearest group.
Thirdly, virtually every group I know will give priority to the child of a Scout volunteer. It makes sense. If you have more Leaders, then you can (usually) take more children / young people. So there is the option to volunteer, to get more children in.

TiggerSnoozer · 04/09/2023 17:53

Am I the only one that thinks a policy that moves existing children up through every stage of scouts over and above anyone on the waiting list however long they've been waiting doesn't sound fair either though?
Basically if you didn't get in at Beavers then no chance for your entire childhood? That's surely not how it's supposed to work?

My assumption would be something more balanced such as: you automatically go on the waiting list for the next tier up as soon as you start in the current tier. Then anyone who had been on the waiting list longer (e.g. missed out on a place in beavers) would get a place in cubs before you - but you would still get a place before anyone who joined the waiting list after you started beavers. That gives people some chance to get in later and seems much fairer.

Pipersouth · 07/07/2023 17:35

@CatsOnTheChair So sorry to hear you’ve waited so long. In our group if you’ve missed out on first section you will get priority on the wait list of the second section from new income (sadly still doesn’t guarantee a place but most do)

CatsOnTheChair · 07/07/2023 13:34

Having been on the waiting list for 4 years, I'd totally love the approach to admit off the wait list, BUT it would be totally and utterly unfair on those who have already been in the organisation.
So, I think your view is the correct one, and the leader of thee next group is unreasonable.

UsingChangeofName · 07/07/2023 13:18

It is not the first area of significant disagreement I've had, I was encouraged to ignore minimum ratios requirements. I refused to do that, which didn't go down well.

I'd mention that in your chat with the GSL too.

Seriously, that is a Safeguarding concern.
The DC will want to know, but, unless someone tells them, would never find out.

FromageFraisOff · 07/07/2023 09:21

@Hankunamatata

Yes the sections are in the same group.

OP posts:
FromageFraisOff · 07/07/2023 09:19

Thanks it is reassuring to hear that this is not how it's meant to be but frustrating as there is clearly a problem in this group.

It is not the first area of significant disagreement I've had, I was encouraged to ignore minimum ratios requirements. I refused to do that, which didn't go down well.

OP posts:
MeinKraft · 07/07/2023 01:12

YANBU. Tweet Bear Grylls (joking but seriously do escalate this)

Hankunamatata · 07/07/2023 01:10

Assuming your all the same group ie 1st summerbay then of course you prioritise the kids moving up. We plan kids moving up between the sections every year when all section leaders get together for twice yearly meetings.

Kids that have shown commitment (and parents for bringing them) in younger sections are much more likely to stick through cubs and more importantly scouts and explorers where you usually start loosing numbers in the teen years. You can also recruit helpers from parents easier as you have built a relationship

RedToothBrush · 07/07/2023 00:28

FromageFraisOff · 06/07/2023 23:03

Thanks. GSL won't get involved. Is deferring to the next section up leader.

Peter district then.

Section leader needs boot up the arse. This one is a basic fail that ends up losing dedicated people of all ages from scouting.

I guarantee it will be for 'mates'...

RedToothBrush · 07/07/2023 00:26

Hesma · 06/07/2023 22:39

Former Beaver leader here, always believed priority was given to current members of the scouting family over waiting lust. That is most odd! I’d query with your GSL.

This.

You don't do the wait list before current members.

Raise hell. It's not right.

GoodbyeErinsborough · 07/07/2023 00:14

Hesma · 06/07/2023 22:39

Former Beaver leader here, always believed priority was given to current members of the scouting family over waiting lust. That is most odd! I’d query with your GSL.

I'm also a former Beaver leader and this should definitely be the case!

LovePoppy · 07/07/2023 00:09

I’m shocked there isn’t a national strategy on this. In Canada for girl guides it’s VERY clear. I’d assume scouts was the same. I’d definitely take this higher. It seems so unfair.

To expect children to move up through scout sections
UsingChangeofName · 06/07/2023 23:57

This is certainly not how most scout groups work. I don't believe it is the decision of the GSL only. This policy should be set and agreed by the whole executive. We have recently got our written policies in place and this was one of them. In ours priority is given to those moving up.

Agreed

If you are a section leader you have a right to take up a place on the executive committee

Not automatically. Historically, that depends on the make up of the Exec. and what the Scout Council for the Group agree at the AGM.

So if you are not on it I suggest you look into this

With all the Transformation changes, it definitely won't be the case that Section Leaders will have automatic places on the Trustee Board (which is what the Exec should have been called for a while now).

This is the kind of thing that should be discussed and agreed by the committee. I would raise it in the next meeting

I agree it is the Trustees that should have such policies in a well run Group.
Of course if a group hasn't run into any issues with waiting lists before, and they have had inexperienced Trustees, then it might never have 'come up'.

pinkysmum · 06/07/2023 23:41

This is certainly not how most scout groups work. I don't believe it is the decision of the GSL only. This policy should be set and agreed by the whole executive. We have recently got our written policies in place and this was one of them. In ours priority is given to those moving up. If you are a section leader you have a right to take up a place on the executive committee, so if you are not on it I suggest you look into this. This is the kind of thing that should be discussed and agreed by the committee. I would raise it in the next meeting.

funtimesahead100 · 06/07/2023 23:32

same here, priority is alway given to existing members, we give a rough estimate of how many will move in the year and each section if spaces available will take a few from the waiting list.
When my children did, rainbows, brownies etc same time as scouting, you had to apply for brownies as it wasn't an automatic move up and in both cases my dd's had to wait one or 2 terms before joing the next section.
as others have said speak to your DC, it should be constitant across the district.
are they doing this as they want some friends kids to join?

entitledparents · 06/07/2023 23:25

Priority always to those in scouting as they progress through awards