Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you think the UK will survive these?

188 replies

wheresmymojo · 06/07/2023 22:01

Linked to another thread but I don't want to take that one off on to too much of a tangent.

Things don't feel brilliant in the UK right now, it's not the first time we've had 'bad times' though.

However I feel it's different this time because we have four massive looming global changes coming...usually when you're in 'bad times' there aren't four much, much bigger problems already on their way.

I'm interested in how people think the UK will fair, I spend a lot time trying to understand / imagine what the world will look like after some of these things but haven't remotely wrapped my head around what all four combined would look like?

The four things I see on the horizon are...

  • The impact of climate change (personally I think 1.5c+ change is pretty inevitable now)
  • The aging population / huge decrease in working age population
  • The potential for AI to become more intelligent than humans
  • The decline of the West and rise of the East
OP posts:
StormShadow · 07/07/2023 16:52

I agree Japan, China and South Korea have much worse population pyramids but USA seems to have many internal problems of it's own.

It does, but they also have some of the more favourable demographics of rich countries, are essentially impossible to invade, have a willingness to accept at least some immigration plus the advantage of being English speaking, and most importantly they're on top of the perch already. Someone would have to surpass them. There are currently no realistic candidates.

BartholemewHolmes · 07/07/2023 16:43

DuesToTheDirt · 07/07/2023 14:54

The four things I see on the horizon are...

  • The impact of climate change (personally I think 1.5c+ change is pretty inevitable now)
  • The aging population / huge decrease in working age population
  • The potential for AI to become more intelligent than humans
  • The decline of the West and rise of the East

I'm going to add to those

  • war as a result of climate change, as countries compete for resources, and as migration increases. Even if the UK is not involved directly in a war, if any western countries or major powers are at war we would almost certainly be affected, as we have been by Ukraine.

Someone mentioned free speech and the crushing of dissent - this is definitely an issue currently but I think (hope) it's only temporary.

I agree with your last point. Some countries have a geographical advantage and can more easily defend borders but if other countries can’t or are in trouble it could get more volatile.

DandelionBurdockAndGin · 07/07/2023 16:36

I don't think the East will rise, not with those population pyramids and general attitude to immigration. Gonna be another US century.

I agree Japan, China and South Korea have much worse population pyramids but USA seems to have many internal problems of it's own.

Here in UK have a decade of more 18 year olds coming of age. The number of 18-year-olds, which fell during the 2010s, has begun to rise sharply. Britain had 715,000 of them in 2020 and expects to have 893,000 in 2030—a 25% increase which should help the economy for a bit.

I think we are vulnerable on food - we've been dependent on imports for a really long time so farming and global warming impacts are a big vulnerability- but we are still a rich country.

I think A.I will shake down eventually get redirected to useful places after laws suits and limits get placed on it next few years.

I think there are many worse places to be in the world than the UK despite all the challenges we are undoubtedly facing.

Last I checked our birth rate is below replacement level.

We're not far of death rates exceeding birth if we haven't already reached that in UK - most of the population increase is due to immigration.

World wide fertility rate in 2020 was 2.30 births per woman - 2.1 is the replacement level - most of higher fertility is from sub-Saharan Africa were child mortality remains high.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 07/07/2023 16:05

@2bazookas
The reason first world women produce more children than they can house and feed, is the welfare society

Last I checked our birth rate is below replacement level. In some countries they're actively giving incentives to increase the birth rate.

In the developing world one of the best ways to reduce the birth rate is to educate women. Educated women have less children and their children have a higher survival rate.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 07/07/2023 16:00

babbscrabbs · 07/07/2023 06:59

We all know (I hope) that it's systemic govt driven change we need, not just bamboo toothbrushes... As said on this thread we are seen by some as a "world leader". We don't hold the weight we used to as a nation, but we're still punching.

If the UK govt took decisive action on climate change, there would also likely be a ripple effect that would lead to other nations and citizens taking notice and making their own changes because of our standing.

Exactly. And the more countries that join in, the more pressure it puts on the rest.

Surely trying is better than not trying and explaining to our children/grandchildren that we didn't bother because we were waiting for someone else to do it first.

2bazookas · 07/07/2023 15:56

The aging population / huge decrease in working age population

Did you ever give a thought to the effect two world wars had on populations?
The cream of manhood was decimated. After WW1, many women in UK faced a lifetime as childless spinsters because there were not enough men to go round. After WW2, Australia and Britain were so desperate for workers they bribed people to migrate.

The reason third world women produce so many children, is the knowledge so many won't survive infancy. The reason first world women produce more children than they can house and feed, is the welfare society. The rich West has skewed population growth in the third world, by foreign aid we're going to stop. Our wealth has skewed population growth at home, by a nanny state that produces helpless dependents. Will we face a generation unable/unwilling to support themselves, too physically or mentally unfit for employment? What's going to happen to all the obese diabetics with circulatory and MH problems, when there's no more "free" health care and medication? Nature will take its course here and in Africa.

BartholemewHolmes · 07/07/2023 15:36

gamerchick · 07/07/2023 15:11

Personally the sooner the human race is wiped from the planet. Or whittled down to safe levels, the better.

We've had a shot and we suck. Time to let the planet heal and get on.

Do you have dc?

3BSHKATS · 07/07/2023 15:36

gamerchick · 07/07/2023 15:11

Personally the sooner the human race is wiped from the planet. Or whittled down to safe levels, the better.

We've had a shot and we suck. Time to let the planet heal and get on.

Speak for yourself

gamerchick · 07/07/2023 15:11

Personally the sooner the human race is wiped from the planet. Or whittled down to safe levels, the better.

We've had a shot and we suck. Time to let the planet heal and get on.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/07/2023 15:03

@Caradonna yes this was my point too in my post below- these are not single young people living in house shares that are now coming in- I'm not anti immigration at all but by losing so many young EU workers they are being replaced by people who I think will actually have bigger demands on housing and healthcare and are unlikely to be coming here just for a few years-

My view is with the EU is that at least it was a 2 way street and gave uk citizens 'other options' too for work or retirement , short term or long term- now most of us have lost those easy options unless you have an EU passport or are wealthy enough to buy your way in or have very specific sought after shortage skills .

Remember the 'we hold all the cards' - no we didn't- we held none of them .

DuesToTheDirt · 07/07/2023 14:54

The four things I see on the horizon are...

  • The impact of climate change (personally I think 1.5c+ change is pretty inevitable now)
  • The aging population / huge decrease in working age population
  • The potential for AI to become more intelligent than humans
  • The decline of the West and rise of the East

I'm going to add to those

  • war as a result of climate change, as countries compete for resources, and as migration increases. Even if the UK is not involved directly in a war, if any western countries or major powers are at war we would almost certainly be affected, as we have been by Ukraine.

Someone mentioned free speech and the crushing of dissent - this is definitely an issue currently but I think (hope) it's only temporary.

SerendipityJane · 07/07/2023 14:52

We aren't irrevocably doomed

Depends on the "we", really. Returning to 410CE Britons, they weren't doomed either. But it would be a long wait for their next avocado.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 07/07/2023 14:52

Their*!

Spendonsend · 07/07/2023 14:50

Lolalondon2 · 07/07/2023 13:56

Can someone just give me a very brief rundown of what the actual problems are here and how we are all now irreversibly doomed??

We arent irrevocably doomed but if no one is prepared to acknowledge potential weaknesses then no one can plan to mitigate them. Just as if you dont know your strengths you cant build on them.

My water and waste supplier is currently not great. I should be able to look to political parties who should propose different ways to get water supply great again and pick between the parties on the basis of which i think is best.

We know my bit of the uk is getting drier, we know someone elses bit of the uk is flooding more - wheres the plan.

We know population is ageing. But noone seems to plan for it.

fail to plan you plan to fail.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 07/07/2023 14:49

@celeteeleste i think they expressed themselves poorly but I do agree to some extent is it really going to continue being appropriate to keep people alive past there natural expiration regardless of quality of life? I think these conversations will need to be had sooner or later if we want to keep some sort of free at the point of use healthcare and have conversations around what we will continue to provide and treat etc

celeteeleste · 07/07/2023 14:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

anythinginapinch · 07/07/2023 14:43

Showerscraper · 06/07/2023 22:43

I actually think we're better placed in terms of climate change than an awful lot of other countries, I really wouldn't want to be any further South ... No question the future looks rocky though

You know that without the Gulf Stream, uk would be like Greenland don't you? And the Gulf Stream is... well, fucked as a consequence of climate change?

SerendipityJane · 07/07/2023 14:40

History is measured in centuries.

One wonders what the Britons waving goodbye to the last of the Romans in 410 were thinking. I'm guessing they didn't think it would take the better part of a millennia to recover.

celeteeleste · 07/07/2023 14:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

bobblyjob · 07/07/2023 13:56

Sendmymillioninaninvoice · 07/07/2023 10:58

The British self deprecating, modest stance on everything is INFURIATING!

The latest is- we are a fading country post Empire. Bullshit. The British are hard as nails, the strategise, explore, try new things and see the bigger picture. They stab enemies in the back while smiling to their face. They ally well and negotiate. People are so desperate to say “everything is terrible, woe us me” whilst being propped up by free healthcare and a generous benefits systems and living in a temperate climate with friendly people. If you really feel that way would you like to experience the joys of being a woman living in Mexico? No? Strange that!

Does anyone remember the Hole in the Ozone layer? You know, the one that was going to kill us all? It healed. We will survive and we will adapt and we will thrive.

Some of you need to get your “The End is Nigh” board on and parade around the town centre. I need a laugh.

The hole in the ozone layer didn’t just go away on its own
and yes it is absolutely a fading country post empire. People forget that a few hundred years ago, India and china were all powerful until Britain went in and screwed them over. They are now recovering and building strength and Britain is declining. It’s cycles of power and that’s ok. I also am not sure stabbing people in the back is something to be proud of

Lolalondon2 · 07/07/2023 13:56

Can someone just give me a very brief rundown of what the actual problems are here and how we are all now irreversibly doomed??

meddysam · 07/07/2023 13:49

People are so desperate to say “everything is terrible, woe us me” whilst being propped up by free healthcare and a generous benefits systems and living in a temperate climate with friendly people.

Why are you assuming people who criticise are on benefits?

Sendmymillioninaninvoice · 07/07/2023 10:58

The British self deprecating, modest stance on everything is INFURIATING!

The latest is- we are a fading country post Empire. Bullshit. The British are hard as nails, the strategise, explore, try new things and see the bigger picture. They stab enemies in the back while smiling to their face. They ally well and negotiate. People are so desperate to say “everything is terrible, woe us me” whilst being propped up by free healthcare and a generous benefits systems and living in a temperate climate with friendly people. If you really feel that way would you like to experience the joys of being a woman living in Mexico? No? Strange that!

Does anyone remember the Hole in the Ozone layer? You know, the one that was going to kill us all? It healed. We will survive and we will adapt and we will thrive.

Some of you need to get your “The End is Nigh” board on and parade around the town centre. I need a laugh.

Caradonna · 07/07/2023 10:47

It’s crazy - 700,000 a year so 3/4 a million a year -we only have 67 million population now - all this we need careworkers but how many million care workers do we need?
The number of nurses, midwives and nursing associates registered to practise in the UK has grown to a record total of 788,638. Just to give you an idea of numbers. (From google)

These are families coming in who need medical care and schools and big houses.

Freshair1 · 07/07/2023 10:02

How are people calling those that are realistic 'doom mongers'. Seriously, wise the f up. We all need to give a s and do our individual best to make good choices. It's not doom, it's already happened.