Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you think the UK will survive these?

188 replies

wheresmymojo · 06/07/2023 22:01

Linked to another thread but I don't want to take that one off on to too much of a tangent.

Things don't feel brilliant in the UK right now, it's not the first time we've had 'bad times' though.

However I feel it's different this time because we have four massive looming global changes coming...usually when you're in 'bad times' there aren't four much, much bigger problems already on their way.

I'm interested in how people think the UK will fair, I spend a lot time trying to understand / imagine what the world will look like after some of these things but haven't remotely wrapped my head around what all four combined would look like?

The four things I see on the horizon are...

  • The impact of climate change (personally I think 1.5c+ change is pretty inevitable now)
  • The aging population / huge decrease in working age population
  • The potential for AI to become more intelligent than humans
  • The decline of the West and rise of the East
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheWayoftheLeaf · 04/09/2023 23:28
  1. were very far north. When it gets bad enough the whole world will be up the creek. We'll probably all fucking die together.

  2. more immigration to fill the tax void.

  3. if AI becomes more intelligent hopefully they like humans!

  4. more people will move East.

Takoneko · 04/09/2023 19:26

ReginaRegina · 04/09/2023 19:03

In the long term depopulation is surely good. There are far too many humans on the planet already and it seems ridiculous to keep adding more to cope with the existing ones.

Global depopulation will happen and will begin by the end of the century. Only Africa has any real population growth left to do, and its fertility rate is also declining rapidly (as always happens when infant mortality declines and life expectancy increases).

China’s population is projected to fall by as much as half by the end of the century.

Depopulation will help to reduce global carbon footprint but also presents economic challenges, especially when it is rapid. So countries that manage to slow their rate of depopulation and prop up their working age population with migration will be far better placed than those like China who have relatively low immigration and a fertility rate that has declined at a truly alarming rate. They have very few young people who will be reaching working age and a huge population bubble about to reach retirement. They really are facing a huge economic challenge. Add to that a huge imbalance of males to females in the population ratio among younger people and their fertility rate per woman is even more alarming. They have 1.28 births per woman. 2.1 per woman is generally considered replacement rate, but that’s in typical countries where women are a little over half the population. In some age brackets Chinese women are only 46% of the population.

Our economy is far better placed because we aren’t going to have the same cliff edge scenario that they will. Our baby boomers have reached retirement age at a time when immigration propped up the working age population and softened the economic blow. We’ve had a far softer landing,

ReginaRegina · 04/09/2023 19:03

Takoneko · 04/09/2023 18:52

We are better placed than most, I think.

  1. Climate change- we are lucky enough to live at a latitude where climate change is unlikely to make our climate unliveable. We may attract a lot of climate migrants but that will help with 2.
  2. Depopulation/ageing population. We have been insulated from the effects of this by strong levels of immigration. We have had a below replacement birth rate since the 70s. Immigration has bolstered our working age population and left us far better off than a number of other countries in this regard.
  3. AI- is potentially a problem, but no reason it will be more of an issue for the U.K. than anywhere else.
  4. The decline of the West and rise of the East- I don’t think there will be a rise of the East. China’s window of economic opportunity is closing and they are on the brink of a period of rapid depopulation (especially in working age adults) that they are going to find impossible to reverse and painful to mitigate. It is going to be incredibly rapid and they aren’t attractive to migrants in the same way Europe, the US or New Zealand might be. Even India now has a below replacement birth rate and negative net migration. Their population is expected to begin shrinking around the middle of the century. It’s actually Africa and the global south that is entering a window of economic opportunity with a large working-age population and small older demographic. I think worries about the domination of China were premature and don’t reflect the demographic reality that China finds itself in now.

In the long term depopulation is surely good. There are far too many humans on the planet already and it seems ridiculous to keep adding more to cope with the existing ones.

BartholemewHolmes · 04/09/2023 19:02

Takoneko · 04/09/2023 18:52

We are better placed than most, I think.

  1. Climate change- we are lucky enough to live at a latitude where climate change is unlikely to make our climate unliveable. We may attract a lot of climate migrants but that will help with 2.
  2. Depopulation/ageing population. We have been insulated from the effects of this by strong levels of immigration. We have had a below replacement birth rate since the 70s. Immigration has bolstered our working age population and left us far better off than a number of other countries in this regard.
  3. AI- is potentially a problem, but no reason it will be more of an issue for the U.K. than anywhere else.
  4. The decline of the West and rise of the East- I don’t think there will be a rise of the East. China’s window of economic opportunity is closing and they are on the brink of a period of rapid depopulation (especially in working age adults) that they are going to find impossible to reverse and painful to mitigate. It is going to be incredibly rapid and they aren’t attractive to migrants in the same way Europe, the US or New Zealand might be. Even India now has a below replacement birth rate and negative net migration. Their population is expected to begin shrinking around the middle of the century. It’s actually Africa and the global south that is entering a window of economic opportunity with a large working-age population and small older demographic. I think worries about the domination of China were premature and don’t reflect the demographic reality that China finds itself in now.

I agree with you generally. AI may well mitigate issue 2

Highandlows · 04/09/2023 18:58

What's so scary about Africans? I don't think Europe has anything to fear, it's not like Europeans have ever done anything to harm Africans or the African continent. We do not need an invasion of uneducated people bringing up more poverty and having 5 kids at least.

Highandlows · 04/09/2023 18:54

The decay of democracy is equally concerning - giving up democratic rights to organisations like the EU, UN and WHO seems to be promoted by politicians of all stripes who seem to prefer the exercise of power without being accountable.

THIS and these organisations have many far left individuals. Check their backgrounds. It is very concerning.

Takoneko · 04/09/2023 18:52

We are better placed than most, I think.

  1. Climate change- we are lucky enough to live at a latitude where climate change is unlikely to make our climate unliveable. We may attract a lot of climate migrants but that will help with 2.
  2. Depopulation/ageing population. We have been insulated from the effects of this by strong levels of immigration. We have had a below replacement birth rate since the 70s. Immigration has bolstered our working age population and left us far better off than a number of other countries in this regard.
  3. AI- is potentially a problem, but no reason it will be more of an issue for the U.K. than anywhere else.
  4. The decline of the West and rise of the East- I don’t think there will be a rise of the East. China’s window of economic opportunity is closing and they are on the brink of a period of rapid depopulation (especially in working age adults) that they are going to find impossible to reverse and painful to mitigate. It is going to be incredibly rapid and they aren’t attractive to migrants in the same way Europe, the US or New Zealand might be. Even India now has a below replacement birth rate and negative net migration. Their population is expected to begin shrinking around the middle of the century. It’s actually Africa and the global south that is entering a window of economic opportunity with a large working-age population and small older demographic. I think worries about the domination of China were premature and don’t reflect the demographic reality that China finds itself in now.
PurpleButterflyWings · 04/09/2023 18:27

ReginaRegina · 04/09/2023 18:11

Perhaps you and all the like minded could go and jump in the sea. That would start the whittling down.

Yep this! ^ Like the people who loathe the UK so much but won't leave, the ones who have this 'human race should all die 'stance are not so quick to jump in the nearest lake with a 2 x 3 concrete slab strapped to them are they?!

How would these people feel if we had a post apocalyptic type situation - and half the world's humans had to die, and the powers that be came to them to volunteer (before they started picking people!) Are these people going to volunteer, and let their parents and children and husbands go to their death? LMFAO. As if! 😆

PurpleButterflyWings · 04/09/2023 18:21

Longagonow96 · 04/09/2023 06:24

Bet you've never been to Albania.
These "Britain is the shittiest country in shittonia" threads are soooo tedious and ill informed.

This. ^ Funny how people (UK born Brits,) are so vocal about how loathsome and vile this country is, yet they don't leave. If you're not going to leave, then put a sock in it. You're BORING!

ReginaRegina · 04/09/2023 18:11

gamerchick · 07/07/2023 15:11

Personally the sooner the human race is wiped from the planet. Or whittled down to safe levels, the better.

We've had a shot and we suck. Time to let the planet heal and get on.

Perhaps you and all the like minded could go and jump in the sea. That would start the whittling down.

Wsmi · 04/09/2023 07:02

This country is will be a developing country like in the old communist Easter Europe by 2040. It is widely expected that our economy will be smaller than Poland’s by 2035.

Govt corruption will continue, much as it has done for the last 25 years but they don’t try and hide it anymore.

The way that welfare tax credits were introduced by nu Labour to help their lobbying friends suppress wages started a devastating cycle of low productivity in this country that has led to our economy’s rapid decline. They then went on give away our billions to their friends on a war where the infamous weapons of mass destruction didn’t exist. Finally the billions printed on behalf of the taxpayer to give to banker friends while our economy never recovered from that shock.

In the last few years, the corruption has been so brazen, it defies belief. Healthy people locked up in their houses, while even more money printed than was printed in 2008 and several hundred million borrowed to line more pockets. The inflation that followed conveniently all blamed on Ukraine as though borrowing and printing a trillion £ to ‘save the NHS’ by locking up healthy adults had nothing to do with it. Of course the energy industry also needed their windfall so they did very well out of it billions paid to them through artificially high prices and government ‘helping’ pay our bills. Let’s not even talk about Ukraine. The defence contractors had a had a few lean years, so they needed to be taken care of. What could be more helpful to them than a war in Europe. Next? If you missed out on by not investing in big Pharma, big oil or big defence in the last few years, you still have time to get on the gravy train. Invest in these green companies. They are due their share of cash ripped off from the taxpayer. Or you could get into the asylum business. After all, there is a whole industry in housing, hotels, security and law around migrants who are being actively encouraged.

Consider this, half of all spending in this country is spent by the government. It’s not money they created through enterprise. It’s either money they have borrowed or printed, destroying the economy and stoking inflation or money that people in tax. What do we get for that? Can anyone name how that money is being spent well. Where does it all go? And why people keep calling for more to be spent without questioning where it all goes.

Longagonow96 · 04/09/2023 06:24

stbrandonsboat · 06/07/2023 23:00

I think we'll end up a bit like Albania.

Bet you've never been to Albania.
These "Britain is the shittiest country in shittonia" threads are soooo tedious and ill informed.

littleblackcat27 · 04/09/2023 05:36

The people funding it aren’t the wealthy millionaires

You can say that again.......

Dabralor · 03/09/2023 19:39

Dunno OP. I'm just going to continue loving my kids, pottering at my allotment and hugging all my dogs. Make as good choices as I can in life and hope for the best.

IsitChristmasyet23 · 03/09/2023 19:16

TheThingIsYeah · 03/09/2023 18:15

@IsitChristmasyet23 Couldn't agree with you more.

State dependency is the highest on record. Over half of adults now take out more than they put in. That’s just not sustainable long term.

This is the salient point for me. . So many seem to be quite happy to delegate personal responsibility to the State (one only has to look at the rabid deference to the daft covid rules as an example). Adult income tax-payers in the UK are now in the minority.

The West - and the UK especially - will continue on a path of managed decline. But hey, we've replaced plastic straws with paper ones!

Which is why we are now in our period of decline. It was all fine when people were getting free Covid money, UC ‘top ups’ for working in less than full time in entry level jobs. It was all fine when it was hysterical teachers and nurses saying that buildings were dangerous and full of asbestos. Just made up, the state wouldn’t let it get that bad…It still is fine because people only realise when it impacts them.

Oh, and the disappearance of state employees because they aren’t paid enough. The silent and slow erosion of the NHS now, where it is often the point of no return and too late. It will be no better under Labour. Painful fact is, as small minority are funding everyone else and there is only so much to take.

At no point in this country did the majority think who is paying for all of this? Government wastage is a red herring. Over half the population don’t pay enough to cover what they take from the state. Benefits, NHS, education, etc. The people funding it aren’t the wealthy millionaires. They are a tiny, ever decreasing minority of higher rate tax payers who pay for everyone and get nothing out. Paying the highest marginal tax rates in the world.

Frankly, we are screwed.

TheThingIsYeah · 03/09/2023 18:15

@IsitChristmasyet23 Couldn't agree with you more.

State dependency is the highest on record. Over half of adults now take out more than they put in. That’s just not sustainable long term.

This is the salient point for me. . So many seem to be quite happy to delegate personal responsibility to the State (one only has to look at the rabid deference to the daft covid rules as an example). Adult income tax-payers in the UK are now in the minority.

The West - and the UK especially - will continue on a path of managed decline. But hey, we've replaced plastic straws with paper ones!

IsitChristmasyet23 · 03/09/2023 13:16

Climate change. When you go to America and see their cheap fuel, massive cars, excessive plastic and 5 million plastic bags for every shop - what we are doing is meaningless really. Comes from the right place but it’s a drop in the ocean so climate change is inevitable. We will be lucky to even stay away from worst case targets.

We are already well on our way to a crack pot economy and I think it will be 10-15 years absolute max before we see the impact of that. The tipping point has been passed. State dependency is the highest on record. Over half of adults now take out more than they put in. That’s just not sustainable long term. Our hospitals and schools are collapsing. Anyone with good earning potential or who has transferable career prospects should leave. The rich get richer and the people who earn good money are paying for over half the population to access collapsing schools. That will get worse and more people will leave.

AI is a good thing. It’s may actually bring some competence and ability to a country which values low wage jobs and minimal education.

The West is already in massive decline anyway. Just look around you.

NoYohgurtAgain · 03/09/2023 12:49

Fivethirtyeight

May be so, but so many important parts of society are left to ‘the markets’ to shape. Without some significant changes, the system is absolutely set up to increase the wealth of the wealthy and keep the poorest, poor and getting poorer. The odds are very much stacked for you if you have wealth and against you of you don’t. In many many ways. The inequality in this country is staggering, and that increases mental health issues (for all, not just the poorest), increases crime, and puts extra pressure on health and social care. It’s not good for anyone really - apart from the psychopathic wealthy (the more empathic and/or anxious wealthy suffer psychologically).

Fivethirtyeight · 03/09/2023 12:33

NoYohgurtAgain · 03/09/2023 12:15

There are some things we can do;

minimise the effects of the climate emergency by cutting carbon, insulating homes and putting in place things that will help us tolerate things better.

increase food security by changing farming practices and encouraging home growing.

reduce inequality so that there isn’t such a disparity and those who are the most vulnerable still have a decent quality of life. Tax wealth rather than increasing income tax for example.

turn caring into a profession - make it a viable career choice.

put in legislation around AI. Place more value on roles that AI can’t do - creativity, human to human relational and caring. Those roles that have been undervalued for years (many due to patriarchal structures).

mostly we need to stop rampant, unfettered capitalism - this doesn’t mean we have to go completely the other way.

We don’t have unfettered capitalism.

Central banks fix the price of money.

And at least since the 1990s regulation has been growing.

Govt uses debt as well as taxes to increase the proportion of spending that is directed by them, not by individuals.

This is why we are poorer than we were.

Senior politicians know we would all be happier, healthier and richer if they cut back Govt. But their interest is in taking citizens’ cash, taking their salary from it and in the power (financial, favours, and social) they have from controlling how it is spent.

Fivethirtyeight · 03/09/2023 12:26

ManAboutTown · 06/07/2023 23:14

I am more pessimistic about the world in general and Britain in particular than I have ever been and I grew up with the Cold War and 3 day weeks / power cuts.

For different reasons than OP though.

Climate has always changed and the more pertinent question is whether we can do anything about it. Spunking billions on projects that won't move the dial particularly if China and India don't play ball seems a fast route to self impoverishment to me.

The advance of the Thought Police though is a much bigger concern. Orwell wrote 1984 as a warning not an instruction manual. Dissent on a large range of important subjects - climate change, trans rights, Brexit, lockdowns, vaccinations is not tolerated. These are subjects that should be openly debated.

The decay of democracy is equally concerning - giving up democratic rights to organisations like the EU, UN and WHO seems to be promoted by politicians of all stripes who seem to prefer the exercise of power without being accountable.

I'm glad I'm not 21

Same. Except Brexit. Smaller jurisdictions and competition between them is better for citizens. While continents Governed with no easy alternative favours the political class.

21 year olds can leave.

NoYohgurtAgain · 03/09/2023 12:15

There are some things we can do;

minimise the effects of the climate emergency by cutting carbon, insulating homes and putting in place things that will help us tolerate things better.

increase food security by changing farming practices and encouraging home growing.

reduce inequality so that there isn’t such a disparity and those who are the most vulnerable still have a decent quality of life. Tax wealth rather than increasing income tax for example.

turn caring into a profession - make it a viable career choice.

put in legislation around AI. Place more value on roles that AI can’t do - creativity, human to human relational and caring. Those roles that have been undervalued for years (many due to patriarchal structures).

mostly we need to stop rampant, unfettered capitalism - this doesn’t mean we have to go completely the other way.

ReginaRegina · 03/09/2023 12:08

Caradonna · 07/07/2023 19:20

USA has it's own supplies of oil and gas and coal. And as it moves away has all the space in the world for pv panels and wind turbines.
But it is also raking in a vast profit as it owns and runs almost ALL the internet software and streaming services which we happily all pay for to their low tax offices in Ireland or similar. But they buy nothing of ours in return.

But the USA isn't one person/entity. Average person isn't getting royalties from Microsoft.

ReginaRegina · 03/09/2023 12:06

wheresmymojo · 06/07/2023 23:44

Climate change does make a difference because of the mass migration of tens of millions of people and the instability of food sources given our huge reliance on imports from countries that may not have the water / temperatures to reliably produce the same food.

Im very familiar with the topic of AI. AI as it stands today is fine...

I have an IQ of 155 and I cannot understand quantum physics no matter how hard I try. Einstein had an IQ of 160ish. That 5 points difference is huge...

AI is predicted to be able to get to something like 1600 IQ in the coming years. Imagine that in the hands of the wrong people...

Thats without talking about Artificial General Intelligence and singularity which is a whole other ballgame.

Raw processing power isn't the same as reasoning though.

user1477255159 · 03/09/2023 12:00

Many in developing countries are currently taking advantage of the care visa using it as a means to secure education and home student university fees for their children. The syndicates are charging about £12,000 to sponsor a care visa. This is worthwhile as it enables the applicant bring in their husband or wife and unlimited amount of children. In countries where documents can easily be forged and defended it's a way to bring in many children of other family members. This is cheaper than the study visa where you have to re-apply after 2yrs for another 2yrs to work and pay the NHS surcharge. So this will also help boost population but as you say it increases demand on other services.

Caradonna · 07/07/2023 19:20

USA has it's own supplies of oil and gas and coal. And as it moves away has all the space in the world for pv panels and wind turbines.
But it is also raking in a vast profit as it owns and runs almost ALL the internet software and streaming services which we happily all pay for to their low tax offices in Ireland or similar. But they buy nothing of ours in return.

Swipe left for the next trending thread