Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The classic 'why don't you retrain?' question on MN

111 replies

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 06/07/2023 21:29

I've just read the 4999th 'why don't you retrain?' suggestion on mumsnet in the last week and I want to scream.
I am a single parent, trying to escape mostly minimum wage admin jobs. I have a degree and I'm relatively skilled. I've never had a 'career' as much as I've tried, I have applied for many graduate jobs, schemes, companies with progression opportunities. I think part of this is down to wanting to stay in the public sector and third sector. The highest level I've got is around 27K and then after that there's no more opportunities.
I do have limitations in that I'm not interested in working with numbers or HR. I like people, I like working in roles where you deal directly with people. I couldn't work in procurement or accounts or payroll.
So I decided to retrain and was lucky enough to be accepted onto a scheme which will allow me to become qualified in around two years. You also get paid a basic wage.
Whilst I am grateful this job has involved taking a £300 a month pay cut, having to commute 35 miles each day, having to find childcare which goes on past six to cope with the commute, doing my coursework on evenings and weekends, having to find overnight childcare for a week for training, giving up my NHS holiday allowance and only getting five days off between now and Christmas to cover all school holidays and also risking failing at it and then being unemployed.
So whilst I don't doubt that it will pay off and I pray I can make it work, it has taken every ounce of my courage and I still have frequent moments of thinking what the hell have I done. I simply could not have done it without support from my parents and their dad (one day a week). Lots of people don't have this, especially single mums.
So what I'm saying is, when people trot out the 'why don't you retrain?' line, please some idea of what that actually means and the work involved, also what these magical retraining opportunities are. I see 'part time accountancy' or 'open university' are often suggested without little insight about whether that suits the person's skills or whether they can afford the fees. If a mum is struggling on MW trying to make ends meet, it's very unlikely she could shell out for tuition fees!
Oh yes and the whole 'should have established a career before kids'. Well if we all had known that our relationships would fall apart, mortgage rates would rocket and lurpak would cost £15 then we'd all be playing the lottery more frequently!

OP posts:
NurseEssie · 07/07/2023 02:17

Rainpigeon · 06/07/2023 22:43

I'm a loan mum too and just coming to the end of a 12 month full time course, I'm totally burnt out and still got my thesis to finish. It's cost me much more money than I expected, been completely stressful and I'm not certain there is a job at the end. Government help shocking too. No help with childcare costs and half of my student loan (all of which went towards the fees) has been taken from our universal credit. I wouldn't push anyone to do this of they weren't really sure about it. It's been relentless.

Sorry I had to re read that about 5 times Grin You mean 'a lone mum', not a 'loan mum'.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/07/2023 02:05

Grumpy101 · 07/07/2023 01:47

While I mostly agree with your point on how difficult it is to retrain when you have small children, I do take issue with this: only public/charity sector, no numbers or HR. My DH is the same as you in his preferences but at least he doesn't complain about how little money he makes (mostly because I bankroll our lifestyle). The rest of us in the private sector doing numbers or something equally tedious and boring, make more money exactly because we're doing jobs that others don't want to do. Unfortunately public and charity sector will never pay well. And you are making a conscious choice, so own it. There's a part of me that would love to draw the lines you have. But financial security and comfort is a lot more important to me. The point is, especially in the UK where there are a lot of opportunities (and I say this as an immigrant to the UK a long time ago), you do have choices to make so I find the moaning a bit unwarranted in many situations, including yours.

I agree with you.

Grumpy101 · 07/07/2023 01:47

While I mostly agree with your point on how difficult it is to retrain when you have small children, I do take issue with this: only public/charity sector, no numbers or HR. My DH is the same as you in his preferences but at least he doesn't complain about how little money he makes (mostly because I bankroll our lifestyle). The rest of us in the private sector doing numbers or something equally tedious and boring, make more money exactly because we're doing jobs that others don't want to do. Unfortunately public and charity sector will never pay well. And you are making a conscious choice, so own it. There's a part of me that would love to draw the lines you have. But financial security and comfort is a lot more important to me. The point is, especially in the UK where there are a lot of opportunities (and I say this as an immigrant to the UK a long time ago), you do have choices to make so I find the moaning a bit unwarranted in many situations, including yours.

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 07/07/2023 01:03

@RantyAnty no, I'm saying 'just retrain' as as a suggestion to anyone who is struggling to progress in their career should have some idea about how they should achieve that e.g whether training is even available, free or affordable, whether it will actually result in a better paid job and whether it can do alongside a full time job. Otherwise it's just as useless as the 'take in ironing' comments.

OP posts:
RantyAnty · 07/07/2023 00:50

I don't understand what you expect people to say or are you just having a moan?

Do you want people to say yeah you're right. You're stuck. Keep the nmw job, do nothing, or have more kids.??

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 07/07/2023 00:35

@Mumtothreegirlies yep, and also the difference in how much promotion and retraining opportunities are likely to come your way as a part time, or even full time working mother. Especially in the public sector.
If I absolutely busted my gut as a band 4 admin, if I learnt about every different part of, I don't know, cardiology, if I read every different text book on it, no one would come and offer me the chance to retrain. No one would give me a band 5 because I worked the hardest or knew the most. So what options do we really have?

OP posts:
Mumtothreegirlies · 07/07/2023 00:32

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 06/07/2023 23:10

@CountryCousin I did realise and thought about it long and hard, which is why it pisses me off when 'retraining' is casually dropped into threads like it's not 1.) time consuming 2.) expensive 3.) not possible for many parents.
Add a SEN child or no support network or MH issues, it becomes quickly apparent that it isn't an option at all for some.

I think some of these women must have had a lot of support during their careers hence why they fail to see the logistics in retraining.

Sunsetandsunrise · 07/07/2023 00:30

bellac11 · 06/07/2023 22:06

People are idiots OP

They live in social media fantasy land a lot of the time and have no idea about the realities and logistics of life in general let alone the 'why dont you retrain' factors.

I remember a really bad thread, this person posted, it was clear from the OP that this was a really vulnerable woman, very likely with some degree of learning need or trauma history (or both) which meant she had significant limitations, in terms of where she could live due to her finances, she couldnt drive, there were social services involved on and off with her children

You can guess the ideas that came thick and fast (with the emphasis on the thick)

Child minding
Taking in washing
Get a part time job (where she couldnt get to on public transport and pick her children up on time)
Move
learn to drive
Do work online (like that pays well)

Various other bright ideas.

i remember that thread. People clearly had no clue.

Mumtothreegirlies · 07/07/2023 00:29

yanbu
I think people forget it’s 2023 and the days of if you work hard it’ll all pay off are sadly over. I honestly think the only hope of being comfortable with all these rising costs is to be self employed. I read peoples stories on MN talking about how hard they work for a company and how stressed they are and it breaks my heart tbh.

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 07/07/2023 00:27

@Tangled123 it'll be worth it when you get there!

OP posts:
Tangled123 · 07/07/2023 00:25

I agree with you OP. Education is so damn expensive and the ones who need it most can’t afford it, either because they can’t afford to not work full time or the fees are really high.

I am 3 years into a 4 year professional course but it took me 10 years after graduating to be able to afford the first 2 years and another year or so to get a job where my employer will pay the rest of it. I also had a baby during that time, so I had to get a second job to cover her nursery fees, while working full time to cover everything else. Not easy to fit study in around that, and my relationships and house are definitely suffering because of it.

EmmaPaella · 07/07/2023 00:18

XenoBitch · 07/07/2023 00:13

I tried it when it was cheap. I can't do self directed study at all. I literally need a hand hold to get anything like that done.

There’s that too! I was bad enough at self-motivation at a real university (where I scraped a fairly useless degree).

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 07/07/2023 00:17

@Yellowlegobrick who said I'm not academic? I'm not good at maths but I have a 2:1 degree and a good understanding of the sector I want to go into. I can articulate myself well. Plus I think you'll find most high paying firms want well educated P.A's these days who can match the register of their clients and write emails on their behalf with the correct tone and phraseology.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 07/07/2023 00:13

EmmaPaella · 07/07/2023 00:12

I totally agree. Retraining is time consuming, expensive and not always feasible. Also people on here talk about OU like it’s still really cheap. And I couldn’t afford it even when it was cheap.

I tried it when it was cheap. I can't do self directed study at all. I literally need a hand hold to get anything like that done.

justasking111 · 07/07/2023 00:13

The OP men two sectors I've worked in. Public sector and third sector. The first was waiting for dead mens shoes. Took a break to have two babies. Retrained to get a degree in marketing. Worked in hospitality the pay was meh but I enjoyed it. Then ten years in the third sector where the pay hardly rose although the responsibility did.

I couldn't have worked in a high flying career with two children to raise.

EmmaPaella · 07/07/2023 00:12

I totally agree. Retraining is time consuming, expensive and not always feasible. Also people on here talk about OU like it’s still really cheap. And I couldn’t afford it even when it was cheap.

Yellowlegobrick · 07/07/2023 00:11

. It's like saying they don't have the right to have a preference in terms of their career.

Well no, people are suggesting well paid jobs that fit well around family life.

Reality is creative or people focussed jobs pay piss all.

Yellowlegobrick · 07/07/2023 00:09

In the nicest way, if you are generally not academic etc, there's a big question whether retraining will even boost your earnings.

Take childcare - you could do all the lectures x training and the reality is, you'll earn more as a PA in a big company planninh travel and meetings.

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 07/07/2023 00:07

@XenoBitch exactly. I find it really frustrating when the OP says that they're creative or like helping vulnerable people and they get suggestions to become an accountant or sell garden furniture remotely. It's like saying they don't have the right to have a preference in terms of their career.

OP posts:
theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 07/07/2023 00:05

@StillMedusa as the mother of a child with autism, you are worth your weight in gold to me. Teachers are great but her T.A honestly makes everything 100% better. I dread you guys being off sick more than I dread being sick myself!
I wish wish wish you were paid what you deserve. Not everyone could do your job!

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 07/07/2023 00:03

Yellowlegobrick · 06/07/2023 23:59

The reason people suggest accountancy is that you can be "training" on the job, earning 30k, sent to college during working hours funded by the employer & able to study flexibly in evenings/weekends, with salaries easily hitting 40k plus on qualifying.

Its like a well paid 9-5 job, but you are training within that and improving your prospects as you go.

Not everyone is cut out to be an accountant.
It is the same when people suggest you try coding... like it is something everyone has an aptitude for. I had to some as part of a course years back. Someone else did the coursework for me.... I could not do it all.

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 07/07/2023 00:02

@Yellowlegobrick but I am really really bad at maths... and organisation. You could not make an accountant out of just anyone. The basic capability has to be there.

OP posts:
Yellowlegobrick · 06/07/2023 23:59

The reason people suggest accountancy is that you can be "training" on the job, earning 30k, sent to college during working hours funded by the employer & able to study flexibly in evenings/weekends, with salaries easily hitting 40k plus on qualifying.

Its like a well paid 9-5 job, but you are training within that and improving your prospects as you go.

StillMedusa · 06/07/2023 23:51

Absolutely OP!
I'm in a very low paid job... I'm a Special Ed TA.
I have a degree, but four children, one of whom has special needs...and my Dh was for many years in the Armed Forces.
I actually did start to retrain ..doing a second degree in Occupational Therapy, and then Dh got posted to a war zone, I had no family near to help with child care, and I had to withdraw in my second year because I simply couldn't juggle childcare/afford it.
Now my kids are grown...but I still have one with SN at home and always will. And I'm too old to realistically train for a different career (mid 50s) and I'm needed as Grannyc are as my duaghter couldn't manage HER career without me caring for my little grandchild.

It sucks!

XenoBitch · 06/07/2023 23:35

I see this a lot on MN too, and I fucking hate it. I am in the LCWRA group of UC, and was told I should use my time "not working" to retrain... like I could afford any course (and no, the countless Gov funded lvl 2 ones don't mean much, plus I did try one and could not even do that).
I live alone, so no one to support me if I went back into education. My benefits would be stopped if I could manage a course anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread