Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The classic 'why don't you retrain?' question on MN

111 replies

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 06/07/2023 21:29

I've just read the 4999th 'why don't you retrain?' suggestion on mumsnet in the last week and I want to scream.
I am a single parent, trying to escape mostly minimum wage admin jobs. I have a degree and I'm relatively skilled. I've never had a 'career' as much as I've tried, I have applied for many graduate jobs, schemes, companies with progression opportunities. I think part of this is down to wanting to stay in the public sector and third sector. The highest level I've got is around 27K and then after that there's no more opportunities.
I do have limitations in that I'm not interested in working with numbers or HR. I like people, I like working in roles where you deal directly with people. I couldn't work in procurement or accounts or payroll.
So I decided to retrain and was lucky enough to be accepted onto a scheme which will allow me to become qualified in around two years. You also get paid a basic wage.
Whilst I am grateful this job has involved taking a £300 a month pay cut, having to commute 35 miles each day, having to find childcare which goes on past six to cope with the commute, doing my coursework on evenings and weekends, having to find overnight childcare for a week for training, giving up my NHS holiday allowance and only getting five days off between now and Christmas to cover all school holidays and also risking failing at it and then being unemployed.
So whilst I don't doubt that it will pay off and I pray I can make it work, it has taken every ounce of my courage and I still have frequent moments of thinking what the hell have I done. I simply could not have done it without support from my parents and their dad (one day a week). Lots of people don't have this, especially single mums.
So what I'm saying is, when people trot out the 'why don't you retrain?' line, please some idea of what that actually means and the work involved, also what these magical retraining opportunities are. I see 'part time accountancy' or 'open university' are often suggested without little insight about whether that suits the person's skills or whether they can afford the fees. If a mum is struggling on MW trying to make ends meet, it's very unlikely she could shell out for tuition fees!
Oh yes and the whole 'should have established a career before kids'. Well if we all had known that our relationships would fall apart, mortgage rates would rocket and lurpak would cost £15 then we'd all be playing the lottery more frequently!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
louderthan · 07/07/2023 12:49

Quite right OP. I did a masters a while back and I was lucky enough to be able to fund it from an inheritance. I don't have kids, was already working part time in a related industry and I still found it very very tough so hats off to you! It still didn't lead to well paid job but that's a whole other rant...
Whole-heartedly agree that lots of posters on here have literally no idea how most people in this country live.
My personal favourites are 'take in washing/ironing' (like it's the 1930s) and 'do paid surveys online'. What surveys?! I've been doing YouGov surveys for FOUR YEARS and have earned £50.

BlastedPimples · 07/07/2023 11:17

Completely agree op.

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 07/07/2023 10:04

I know that there is no magical high paying job without some work or retraining. I know not. What I'm referring to are comments which do not take into account personal circumstances and capability.
Like I said I would not be a good accountant, or coder. My brain doesn't work that way. An accountant might not make a good mental health nurse. Or SLT. Or HR professional.
There's just not loads of free courses out there, and if there are some aimed at low income parents they are generally aimed at getting people into work and/ or those who don't have a degree already. I'm not sure what Microsoft office training would offer me, when I have 10 years admin experience and I'm already in one of the better paid admin jobs for my region. It seems only on Mumsnet that admin jobs earning around 30K are common. There's some over that in higher education but I have never been offered an interview despite researching what they want and being able to demonstrate it through examples.
But aside from this, I don't want to work in admin anymore. I don't know whether it's through working alongside healthcare professionals but that is what I want to do. It's not easy though!

OP posts:
Comtesse · 07/07/2023 09:12

yanbu to say facile suggestions to “just retrain then” are annoying. You sound like a real grafter and I hope it works out for you!

SatelliteStomper · 07/07/2023 08:57

I agree OP. I did actually retrain in my early 30s when I was a single parent but it was almost 20 years ago and things were very different then. No tuition fees, a bursary, tax credits and I moved back in with my parents for the first 2 years of the 3 year course, so lots of childcare (not all) was covered. I was incredibly fortunate and I know that very very few people would be in that same position today.

Whilst retraining was a good move for me at that time, I would never ever breezily suggest 'just retrain' to someone struggling now - it's condescending and usually tone deaf to the realities for many people.

Unfortunately there are a lot of people on MN who can't see beyond the end of their own nose.

(And as for the point of this or similar threads, ime mostly posters just want an opportunity to rant, some sympathy/empathy or a listening ear. It's rarely a case of wanting their problems 'solved' by randoms on the internet. And that's fine.)

Newusernameforthiss · 07/07/2023 08:57

Massive agree OP. I am really lucky, love my work, am freelance, work in nursery hours etc etc. My brain is AT CAPACITY with children/house/mental load and I can just about do a job that builds on my previous 20 years of work.

The idea that I'd be able to retrain and do something new is laughable. And I have so much privilege. "Just retrain or move where is housing is cheaper" is regressive "on yer bike" nonsense and well done for calling it out 😜

WeightoftheWorld · 07/07/2023 08:42

theresalwaysguineapigcurry · 06/07/2023 22:40

Glad there's a lot of people who also roll their eyes. I would actually say that there are more jobs that are dead end than there are ones with progression. Especially if you then look into part time jobs.
The reality is that I couldn't have stayed in my current job anymore due to it not paying enough to live on. I had to either retrain or leave the NHS and try to find a better paid job in the private sector.
I love playing MN bingo with the 'take in ironing' ' set up as a private cleaner' or 'find a well paying remote role' (to the person who hasn't worked since the 80's)

I'm sorry of your struggles but this thread has made me smile! Completely with you OP and find the absolute clueless responses on threads to people struggling absolutely ridiculous. I'm one of those mums who feels trapped in low paid work even though I have a first class degree from a pretty respectable uni in a well respected subject, and I have been working continuously for almost a decade now (I'm late 20s). I've looked into retraining (mostly healthcare professions, but also some other roles) but it's simply not possible with preschool age kids, we just couldn't afford it.

FireflyJar · 07/07/2023 08:36

@theresalwaysguineapigcurry You sound brilliant, I would love to work with someone who has your spirit. Couldn't dad do a bit more to support you? I mean my ex never did but you could ask?

happyfoot · 07/07/2023 08:34

Curledupwithabook · 06/07/2023 21:57

I think a lot of Mumsnet users are still stuck in the idea that there are lots of:
a) Free or heavily subsidised courses
b) jobs that are happy to take people on with minimal skills & provide them with on the job training if they show 'aptitude' or can convince an interviewer that looking after a four year old means they've got transferable skills to run a project and manage a corporate budget.

The reality is most have to fight for jobs that are lower skilled than what they're capable of, and most 'professions' require a two or three year course with an investment of 20k of tuition costs plus finding living costs for the same time.

It's just not realistic for so many. I'm in a job that pays well (for where I live) but is incredibly stressful and a lot of unpaid hours. The jobs people recommend I retrain in would cost minimum 16k in fees, two years of barely earning, and would leave me with a maximum salary of 5k less than I'm on currently!

This. People have no fcking clue. They seem to think doing a short part time course will suddenly enable you to bring in 100k or something. Its ridiculous.

Coffeetree · 07/07/2023 08:31

Curledupwithabook · 07/07/2023 08:23

@Coffeetree I think the point OP is making is this 'advice' is usually on threads where the OP ISN'T looking for advice on how to retrain.

When a poster talks about work life being hard/stuck in a job they hate etc, there's often a response of 'just retrain'
A bit like the 'well why did you have a child with him' and 'just move to a cheaper area'.

Yes I see your point, it can sound really dismissive. There's that balance between trying to encourage someone and toxic positivity!

Mercymymercyme · 07/07/2023 08:28

I agree OP 100 percent.

This site has really opened my eyes to how so many people have no insight into how other people are not them, don’t have their resources or supports, or even energy levels. If you are someone who needs six hours sleep a night you have a whole load more time and energy to retrain than a single parent who needs ten and falls asleep exhausted at the same time as their kid! A whole load of things need to come together to retrain and not everyone has all of those things.

whatkatydid2013 · 07/07/2023 08:26

Honestly the thing that most annoys me about those kind of posts is that the underlying assumption is that the solution to many professions (particularly public sector and caring roles) being chronically underfunded/paid is that people should retrain and shouldn’t expect to be reasonably compensated for their work. It’s a real blind spot for many people that clearly not everyone can do that as there will always be a finite number of jobs that offer high wages. It’s obviously fine some jobs pay more than others but it’s not fine that people can’t earn enough in many jobs to pay for rent, utilities & food.

Mapples · 07/07/2023 08:25

Curledupwithabook · 07/07/2023 08:23

@Coffeetree I think the point OP is making is this 'advice' is usually on threads where the OP ISN'T looking for advice on how to retrain.

When a poster talks about work life being hard/stuck in a job they hate etc, there's often a response of 'just retrain'
A bit like the 'well why did you have a child with him' and 'just move to a cheaper area'.

If someone starts a thread like that though what responses are they hoping for? Ah it'll magically get better, maybe you'll win the lottery then you can leave work?

chohiad · 07/07/2023 08:24

@Curledupwithabook I grew up somewhere like that, we had to move away early 20s as we couldn't have the careers we wanted in our home town. We've had to move around a fair bit for our careers.

Curledupwithabook · 07/07/2023 08:23

@Coffeetree I think the point OP is making is this 'advice' is usually on threads where the OP ISN'T looking for advice on how to retrain.

When a poster talks about work life being hard/stuck in a job they hate etc, there's often a response of 'just retrain'
A bit like the 'well why did you have a child with him' and 'just move to a cheaper area'.

Curledupwithabook · 07/07/2023 08:21

To the PPs who talk about public sector/third sector being a choice, and a choice to earn less - that can really depend on where in the country you live. Where I am, public sector and NHS are the biggest employers. The private industry around here is things like warehouse work, small scale factories etc. There are no fancy corporations to aspire to work for! Obviously the people who own the small local businesses are likely to be making better money but you really have to have a specific personality type to be able to set up your own business, as well as being able to deal with the risk of it going under. Not everyone is in a position to do it.

Coffeetree · 07/07/2023 08:20

Well if someone is looking for advice around how to get to a better financial position, the simple answer is to retrain to a higher-paying qualification. That's borne out by statistics.

Simple, not easy.

What other advice are people looking for? Marry rich? Win the lottery?

In terms of "qualify as what?", that's not really a fair question because it depends on the person and their talents!

SomethingFun · 07/07/2023 08:13

There was another thread about disliking working and someone on there mentioned bullshit jobs, which is a book. The theory being we live in a world where bullshit jobs are paid well but could not exist tomorrow and the world would still turn, but perversely real jobs that matter like cleaning, child minding, bin collection, teaching etc etc are undervalued and looked down on. You sound like you want to do a real job.

I’ve retrained and I’ve moved from public sector to private, I had given enough of myself. I donate to charity now because I feel bad I don’t do as much to help others, but helping others wasn’t helping myself. I could always go back I suppose if they start valuing employees in my previous career again.

It is really hard op but also we need women and especially mothers to find routes into higher paying roles and industries. We need representation. Sadly we are made to work for it harder than we should do, which isn’t right or fair, so we have to be resilient and supportive of ourselves and each other. Not everyone can do something different for lots of different reasons, in which case maybe we should be fighting for fair wages for all too.

SecretVictoria · 07/07/2023 08:03

I agree OP. I’m in an industry that I like, but it is going through some huge changes and no one is sure what the outcome will be. It’s very unsettling.

When I was 16, I wanted to train in beauty therapy. Parents wouldn’t support it and pushed me to do A-levels. I’m not that academically clever and it was a disaster. Started at a more vocational college at 17, was told by admissions staff that I’d need to do hairdressing alongside beauty, which I’d have been terrible at.

I was out of work a few years ago (redundancy) and DH said we could look into getting me a shop if I wanted to do “nails and that” 🙄🤣. I told him it was lovely of him but I needed to be qualified. It’s all I’ve ever been interested in but I just never had the opportunity.

I'm now mid-40s and in our town there are hundreds of beauty/nail salons. It’s not realistic. There is a fairly well-known make up artist school not too far away and I’ve thought of doing one of their intensive courses. Trouble is, I can’t leave what (for now) is a stable job to maybe see if I could make a living at it. I couldn’t even do weddings etc as a sideline as I work shifts and EOW.

I did do OU when it was more reasonably priced and got a Diploma but I’m just not academically capable of a degree. I do have a skill set from my previous jobs but nothing that translates well to another industry and nothing that means I could WFH.

AgnesX · 07/07/2023 07:47

bellac11 · 06/07/2023 22:06

People are idiots OP

They live in social media fantasy land a lot of the time and have no idea about the realities and logistics of life in general let alone the 'why dont you retrain' factors.

I remember a really bad thread, this person posted, it was clear from the OP that this was a really vulnerable woman, very likely with some degree of learning need or trauma history (or both) which meant she had significant limitations, in terms of where she could live due to her finances, she couldnt drive, there were social services involved on and off with her children

You can guess the ideas that came thick and fast (with the emphasis on the thick)

Child minding
Taking in washing
Get a part time job (where she couldnt get to on public transport and pick her children up on time)
Move
learn to drive
Do work online (like that pays well)

Various other bright ideas.

You missed "go into tech". The turnover of developers is staggering because there are so many who are useless and you do need a degree of brain.

chohiad · 07/07/2023 07:45

The words that stuck out to me there were that you didn't want to work in the likes of HR or numbers and you like people, that isn't a barrier to earning more, that is a choice. The truth is if the lucrative careers were all easy and fun we'd all be in them. Too often people are told to "do what they love", which you should, to a degree, but you should also make calculated moves as to what earns more too. Some people seem to need permission to accept that. Yes there are barriers like childcare and funding, but not choosing lucrative careers because you "like people" is a choice, and it's one a lot of women make, there is a (sad) reason as to why so many traditionally female career paths are low paid.

ButterflyOil · 07/07/2023 07:39

I hear you, single parent for a long time and it took me until my late 30s to get the opportunity to retrain, before that was stuck in minimum wage jobs in an area that wasn’t suitable for me but didn’t have the things I needed to switch careers. I’d see people saying well upskill yourself in your spare time and I tried (and actually that was what started the change) but of course most of my time was taken up with single parenting, work and trying not to go under with bad MH (in part cause by being in shitty low paid stressful work that did not let me develop the things I am genuine good at and passionate about).

Its not as easy as many people make out.

Turquoisflutterby · 07/07/2023 07:38

Everyone has options and they aren't always easy, often you have to make sacrifices like you have. BUT you have made it work, so it is doable.

Also retraining could mean anything, it doesn't have to be a 2 year long degree or course. It could be upskilling on Microsoft Office online, it could be developing your softer skills to be able to move into management and so on.

Also there are government funds for further/ higher education that some single mums are eligible for

MurielThrockmorton · 07/07/2023 07:37

It's tough isn't it? I've tried to get a new qualifications as well, also was a lone parent. The first time I had to give up a Master's because of my DD's mental health, then I've been trying to pivot my business but that got derailed by my DF dying, my DM's care needs and Covid, and then I started another Master's and was diagnosed with cancer, possibly partly as a result of the stress of doing all of the above! I have started the second Master's again, but still have health issues, so I'm not convinced I will manage to finish it. I am so knackered that I would happily retire if I could, but there's no way financially I can do that and I do like learning.

Swipe left for the next trending thread