Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU school uniform

289 replies

Ijustdontknowwhattodo1018 · 06/07/2023 19:04

Am I being unreasonable to refuse to buy new shorts?

The school uniform states plain Black shorts for PE but the teachers have been commenting on my child’s shorts and telling them they are not appropriate.
They are proper ‘sports’ shorts and not that it matters but they are not cheap, they’re good quality, good fit, they don’t fall down etc.
I just don’t see what the problem is and what infuriates me is that they keep telling a 4 year old rather than telling me why there is a problem…after all, it is me who is buying the uniform and not my child.

Also, are we not supposed to be building children up, not making them feel self conscious?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
CremeEggsForBreakfast · 07/07/2023 23:08

If its a group communication, OP, your child has not been named, and the description does not match what your child is wearing then how on earth do you know it refers to you so specifically that its outing?

FWIW, when you said "sports shorts" I pictured loose fitting, shiny, black shorts that come to about the knee. What you have looks maybe more like dance shorts which are not the same.

If the teacher has had time to talk to you then you've had a chance to ask the teacher too so.... Just do it.

KrisAkabusi · 07/07/2023 22:46

Emmalb2619 · 07/07/2023 22:27

I actually can’t believe you’ve posted about this here. I can barely believe I’m taking the time to comment. Ask the teacher for clarification. Problem solved. I love a bit of mumsnet as much as the next person, but this post I simply don’t get. Why wouldn’t you just ask the school? Truly I don’t understand.

Because she knows exactly what the problem is, her child has been told by the teacher, but she doesn't want to say it here because everyone agrees with the school.

Emmalb2619 · 07/07/2023 22:27

I actually can’t believe you’ve posted about this here. I can barely believe I’m taking the time to comment. Ask the teacher for clarification. Problem solved. I love a bit of mumsnet as much as the next person, but this post I simply don’t get. Why wouldn’t you just ask the school? Truly I don’t understand.

Branwells77 · 07/07/2023 22:18

Looking at them shorts they look far to short and won’t fit tight that absolutely wouldn’t of been allowed in my children’s primary school buy your child the correct uniform. Also actually speak to the staff instead of your poor child

LadyPenelope68 · 07/07/2023 22:05

JunipeJuniper · 07/07/2023 21:37

Because I've worked in schools for years and know it's what most little girls wear. To me, black cotton cycling shirts are completely appropriate and normal school PE attire. I doubt half the people commenting have been in a primary PE session this century.

I’ve taught in Primary Schools for 20 years, these type of shorts are not PE Shorts and would not be acceptable in any of the schools I’ve worked in.

PuttingDownRoots · 07/07/2023 21:42

DD wars cycling shorts. They have to be mid thigh length but they are allowed along with leggings, joggers, skorts, and football shorts. Preferably black, but they are happy with navy or grey.

EmeraldFox · 07/07/2023 21:39

JunipeJuniper · 07/07/2023 21:37

Because I've worked in schools for years and know it's what most little girls wear. To me, black cotton cycling shirts are completely appropriate and normal school PE attire. I doubt half the people commenting have been in a primary PE session this century.

Ds was born 2006, they were never allowed to wear cycling shorts at school.

MysteryBelle · 07/07/2023 21:38

TempestuousBehaviour · 07/07/2023 15:02

There isn’t one universal definition of p.e shorts though, there have always been variations in what is available. Next, m&s and Asda all sell very short tight shorts in the p.e sections of their websites… if the school has a style they prefer they need to specify, otherwise people will buy whatever they like.

No, no, no @TempestuousBehaviour. We are talking about a specific person, the Op, who claims to not know what the school meant. We’ve all explained it to her. Which didn’t really need to be explained.

And then the refrain, ‘I don’t understand! Why is the school correcting me, I bought Plain Black Shorts (I bought my little boy girl’s shorts that are very short and tight like hot pants Donna Summer would wear in the disco 70s hee hee!!) I don’t understand😢 how dare they 😡’

’What are PE shorts? Never heard of them? What is PE? Where am I?’

The Op is being obtuse on purpose. We all know it. You know it too. Some of us are just saying it out loud.

JunipeJuniper · 07/07/2023 21:37

EmeraldFox · 07/07/2023 21:28

How do some people read 'PE' from 'cycling'? Clearly PE, rugby, football shorts are appropriate as they do these things. They are also similar shorts though some striped some not, some cotton, they are all loose on the leg. Cycling is a one off bikeability course in year 6, cycling shorts would be appropriate there.

Because I've worked in schools for years and know it's what most little girls wear. To me, black cotton cycling shirts are completely appropriate and normal school PE attire. I doubt half the people commenting have been in a primary PE session this century.

EmeraldFox · 07/07/2023 21:28

How do some people read 'PE' from 'cycling'? Clearly PE, rugby, football shorts are appropriate as they do these things. They are also similar shorts though some striped some not, some cotton, they are all loose on the leg. Cycling is a one off bikeability course in year 6, cycling shorts would be appropriate there.

LolaSmiles · 07/07/2023 19:04

@LolaSmilessome people are always going to cause an argument because they enjoy the drama or need to feel special or important- I don’t think you can totally eliminate that.

Most people when given a clear instruction about uniform will just follow it… giving vague instructions is inviting more hassle
I agree, you're right. The vague instructions don't help.

Un7breakable · 07/07/2023 18:58

Can't tell from photo but are they skin tight? School PE shorts are usually the loose football type.

TempestuousBehaviour · 07/07/2023 17:49

LolaSmiles · 07/07/2023 16:55

Yeah, the shops don’t give a shit. They will stock what they can sell.

Schools don’t need to be single supplier to solve the problem- plain black shorts, should be loose fitting and to the knee- would mean most kids wore suitable shorts and the school would have a basis for telling parents that hot pants aren’t acceptable

I agree with you. I hate single supplier uniforms.

I think I'm jaded from seeing the lengths some parents will go to to feel they've won with the school.

Common sense says your description would be perfectly fine, but experience tells me some parents will still buy shorts not in that description and then come to school arguing and claim that their children is being body shamed/sexualised/humiliated by being given appropriate kit. Some parents will even tell their child to refuse to do the detention, then when it escalates to internal isolation for repeatedly refusing to follow school rules, the parents will claim their child has been put in isolation for no reason and then make some noises about the school not caring about their child's education because they're just a pair of shorts.

I didn't appreciate that some parents were this obsessed with picking a fight until I worked in schools. It would make normal reasonable parents weep.

@LolaSmiles some people are always going to cause an argument because they enjoy the drama or need to feel special or important- I don’t think you can totally eliminate that.

Most people when given a clear instruction about uniform will just follow it… giving vague instructions is inviting more hassle!

LolaSmiles · 07/07/2023 16:55

Yeah, the shops don’t give a shit. They will stock what they can sell.

Schools don’t need to be single supplier to solve the problem- plain black shorts, should be loose fitting and to the knee- would mean most kids wore suitable shorts and the school would have a basis for telling parents that hot pants aren’t acceptable

I agree with you. I hate single supplier uniforms.

I think I'm jaded from seeing the lengths some parents will go to to feel they've won with the school.

Common sense says your description would be perfectly fine, but experience tells me some parents will still buy shorts not in that description and then come to school arguing and claim that their children is being body shamed/sexualised/humiliated by being given appropriate kit. Some parents will even tell their child to refuse to do the detention, then when it escalates to internal isolation for repeatedly refusing to follow school rules, the parents will claim their child has been put in isolation for no reason and then make some noises about the school not caring about their child's education because they're just a pair of shorts.

I didn't appreciate that some parents were this obsessed with picking a fight until I worked in schools. It would make normal reasonable parents weep.

TempestuousBehaviour · 07/07/2023 16:36

LolaSmiles · 07/07/2023 15:30

There isn’t one universal definition of p.e shorts though, there have always been variations in what is available. Next, m&s and Asda all sell very short tight shorts in the p.e sections of their websites… if the school has a style they prefer they need to specify, otherwise people will buy whatever they like
I take your point and school should be specific in the OP's situation.

Equally shops don't care what individual schools say. Their aim is to make money and once the tags are out and it isn't being returned they really don't care if someone has bought 3 pairs of skin tight tregging-yoga pant style trousers that the school obviously says aren't in the uniform.

Twas ever thus.

One year I saw some children's pinafores with peplums on them when that was the fashion.There was that horrible trend for Skousers (black school type trousers with a weird skirt flap over the top) too 20+ years ago. The very fitted white shirts without proper collars, or that had no buttons until around the boobs were also a trend too.

Shops have always stocked items in their school lines that many schools probably wouldn't accept.

As a parent I don't understand why anyone would rely on "but the shop had it in their uniform section".

Yeah, the shops don’t give a shit. They will stock what they can sell.

Schools don’t need to be single supplier to solve the problem- plain black shorts, should be loose fitting and to the knee- would mean most kids wore suitable shorts and the school would have a basis for telling parents that hot pants aren’t acceptable.

TempestuousBehaviour · 07/07/2023 16:31

MysteryBelle · 07/07/2023 15:22

Next, m&s and Asda all sell very short tight shorts in the p.e sections of their websites

That doesn’t mean you have to buy them. Common sense. Why buy very short very tight hot pants for a 4 year old to wear on PE class? I mean, read your own words. PE shorts are traditionally loose fitting, @TempestuousBehaviour.

The length has varied over the years but very short ones are impractical, the tiny ones worn by professional NBA basketball players in the 70s not withstanding 😅 Children do no need to be put in very tight, skin constricting hot pants from the disco days 😂

Very tight bike shorts are actually not good for you to wear, they’re so constricting. They’re designed for pro bike racers for speed, sleekness, and air dynamics in order to win races. They can be harmful in constricting private parts too much. Children in PE need to be unconstricted in the activities they all be doing. Please use your noggin.

I wouldn’t buy them for all the reasons you said, i’m purely making the point that if a uniform list says ‘plain black shorts’ people will buy this type of thing- they are widely considered acceptable by parents and schools.

I have been to schools, had kids in schools and been supply staff in schools both primary and secondary and this type of shorts have been acceptable unless the school states a specific style. Possibly it’s a regional thing if they would be against school rules where you are 🤷‍♀️

Buy they are black and they are shorts so they fit the bill as ‘plain black shorts’.

Whatwouldscullydo · 07/07/2023 15:56

As a parent I don't understand why anyone would rely on "but the shop had it in their uniform section

People are busy. People are poor. No one had the time or the inclination to sit there cross referencing items. Asda shorts are three inches shorter than sainsbury ones let's get the shirts here and the shorts there..

They either wanna just go to sainsbury on the one day off they have that week , grab everything they need and get home before the toddler has a meltdown. Or pick up the package from next after work and hope they make the bus still.

Stock is also often an issue. Everyone wants the same items while asda decides that having 3 age 4-5 pinafores on the shelf is perfectly fine or someone's pulled out all the grey socks in m&s .. sometimes u just have to get a back up and hope for the best. U end up sending them.in in those " modesty shorts" while you wait for nexts' " back in stock" email

LolaSmiles · 07/07/2023 15:30

There isn’t one universal definition of p.e shorts though, there have always been variations in what is available. Next, m&s and Asda all sell very short tight shorts in the p.e sections of their websites… if the school has a style they prefer they need to specify, otherwise people will buy whatever they like
I take your point and school should be specific in the OP's situation.

Equally shops don't care what individual schools say. Their aim is to make money and once the tags are out and it isn't being returned they really don't care if someone has bought 3 pairs of skin tight tregging-yoga pant style trousers that the school obviously says aren't in the uniform.

Twas ever thus.

One year I saw some children's pinafores with peplums on them when that was the fashion.There was that horrible trend for Skousers (black school type trousers with a weird skirt flap over the top) too 20+ years ago. The very fitted white shirts without proper collars, or that had no buttons until around the boobs were also a trend too.

Shops have always stocked items in their school lines that many schools probably wouldn't accept.

As a parent I don't understand why anyone would rely on "but the shop had it in their uniform section".

MysteryBelle · 07/07/2023 15:24

Fraaahnces · 07/07/2023 15:08

They’re bike shorts, not PE shorts. You’re being provocative. You know what they mean. You see a billion other kids wearing appropriate PE kit and you went off-piste. Get the poor kid proper shorts.

Yes, this is it in a nutshell!

MysteryBelle · 07/07/2023 15:24

Excuse the typos actually they’re autocorrect garbage. Annoying.

MysteryBelle · 07/07/2023 15:23

they are doing, not all be doing lol.

MysteryBelle · 07/07/2023 15:22

TempestuousBehaviour · 07/07/2023 15:02

There isn’t one universal definition of p.e shorts though, there have always been variations in what is available. Next, m&s and Asda all sell very short tight shorts in the p.e sections of their websites… if the school has a style they prefer they need to specify, otherwise people will buy whatever they like.

Next, m&s and Asda all sell very short tight shorts in the p.e sections of their websites

That doesn’t mean you have to buy them. Common sense. Why buy very short very tight hot pants for a 4 year old to wear on PE class? I mean, read your own words. PE shorts are traditionally loose fitting, @TempestuousBehaviour.

The length has varied over the years but very short ones are impractical, the tiny ones worn by professional NBA basketball players in the 70s not withstanding 😅 Children do no need to be put in very tight, skin constricting hot pants from the disco days 😂

Very tight bike shorts are actually not good for you to wear, they’re so constricting. They’re designed for pro bike racers for speed, sleekness, and air dynamics in order to win races. They can be harmful in constricting private parts too much. Children in PE need to be unconstricted in the activities they all be doing. Please use your noggin.

Fraaahnces · 07/07/2023 15:08

They’re bike shorts, not PE shorts. You’re being provocative. You know what they mean. You see a billion other kids wearing appropriate PE kit and you went off-piste. Get the poor kid proper shorts.

TempestuousBehaviour · 07/07/2023 15:06

I just googled plain black pe shorts and in the first few images were short/tight shorts from Asda, decathlon and Matalan. It surely must be obvious to the school people will buy these.

TempestuousBehaviour · 07/07/2023 15:02

MysteryBelle · 07/07/2023 14:34

I said skintight very short very tight constricting hot pants are inappropriate for children in PE class, not that kids at your school don’t wear them.

There are things called PE shorts. For PE. Cycling shorts are for…professional cycling. Designed for that sport. Should we put children in tight polyester shirts with logos too?

There isn’t one universal definition of p.e shorts though, there have always been variations in what is available. Next, m&s and Asda all sell very short tight shorts in the p.e sections of their websites… if the school has a style they prefer they need to specify, otherwise people will buy whatever they like.

Swipe left for the next trending thread