Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is very unfair on my boy?

56 replies

Tropicalsunshine · 06/07/2023 15:50

My son is away at uni and like most students has little money. He's a hard worker and had already arranged to start his full time summer job as soon as he got home this week. (Same job as last year)
He was then called for jury service this week for 2 weeks. He has filled in all the forms but apparently because he hadn't done a shift yet at his job he's not entitled to any payment for lost earnings. This has totally wrecked his summer plans as he will be £800 down.
AIBU to think this can't be correct? It's a totally unreasonable way to treat people.
Does anyone in the know have any advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
determinedtomakethiswork · 06/07/2023 22:35

It really pisses me off, because I've never been asked to do it!

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 06/07/2023 21:56

Needmorelego · 06/07/2023 21:03

@Tropicalsunshine wow wages for summer jobs have certainly improved since my day. So if he wasn’t doing the Jury Service he would be earning £1600 a month? That’s a lot for a summer job.
How long is he off university? If it’s 3 months he would be earning £4800 for the summer. Even with the loss of the 2 weeks £4000 is pretty good.
What does the money need to cover?

Adult minimum wage is £10.42 per hour so it's not vastly over the legal minimum.

£1600 per month only equates to a £19,200 annual salary.

He's not raking it in, he's scraping by, everything has gone up enormously.

Needmorelego · 06/07/2023 21:28

@Tropicalsunshine apologies if you think I am being flippant about the wage. I personally think it’s a good wage for a “holiday job”. That’s similar to what a lot of people earn for a permanent full time job. That’s why I was a bit surprised at the amount he is earning.
To be fair if he was going to have money “spare” for a 2 week holiday then he hasn’t lost as much (a holiday is a “nice to have” not essential like rent/bills/food).
Hopefully it will all be an interesting experience for him.

Tropicalsunshine · 06/07/2023 21:19

@Needmorelego
Of course they've improved since your day. 🤔 Have you seen the news? Inflation is a thing.
Are you really saying that traveling 2 hours a day to sit in a room, not be used and not be paid and miss out on earning doesn't sting? Glad you would be so happy with that.
He's very lucky to be living with us, we will feed him etc. etc.
It's July he's back early September. He was hoping for a 2 week holiday with his girlfriend which gives him 6 weeks to earn.

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 06/07/2023 21:12

@JudgeRudy I think it’s a bit late. He started on Monday I think (according to the OP). He is pretty much half done.

JudgeRudy · 06/07/2023 21:08

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 06/07/2023 15:56

He should Call the jury office and say he cannot do it for whatever reason. I got out of it when I lived in a village with a baby and no car. I doubt they do background checks etc and although someone does need to do jury duty, someone else in a more suitable position will take his place.

Yes, I'd go for that angle. Depending where the court is (let's say your home town town) I'd let them know that he cannot get from uni to court in time. They can't just assume he's staying at yours rent free.

Needmorelego · 06/07/2023 21:03

@Tropicalsunshine wow wages for summer jobs have certainly improved since my day. So if he wasn’t doing the Jury Service he would be earning £1600 a month? That’s a lot for a summer job.
How long is he off university? If it’s 3 months he would be earning £4800 for the summer. Even with the loss of the 2 weeks £4000 is pretty good.
What does the money need to cover?

Tropicalsunshine · 06/07/2023 20:59

He has a contract but hasn't done a shift since last year. It's all legit. Unfortunately his immediate boss said it would be fine. She even said she'd put him on the rota in case he was dismissed by the court. Higher up have now said he's not employed by them as he hasn't done a shift so they won't sign the form.
All those saying defer, it's way too late for that- it seemed like a good time to get it out of the way.

Some people seem to think there's a kindly person sitting around who will listen to him pleading poverty. Unfortunately they have been pretty rude and dismissive and haven't taught him anything good about serving the community.
I think I was hoping there would be a solution but thanks so much for the sympathy😀
We have decided to give him a bit ourselves.

OP posts:
fancreek · 06/07/2023 20:50

rwalker · 06/07/2023 18:20

Sounds like a cash in gd d job with no contract

On the basis of what?!?

Lacucuracha · 06/07/2023 20:40

He should have pleaded extreme financial hardship, as pp suggested.

Tropicalsunshine · 06/07/2023 20:36

@Needmorelego
A summer job that pays £11.50 an hour for 8 hours per day for 10 days? Pretty normal.

OP posts:
SayHi · 06/07/2023 19:24

Did the boss tell him he’d be getting paid or just saying it’s ok to not work those couple of weeks?

I think the boss probably meant that yes it’s fine to start later but didn’t mean he’d pay him.

I wish you posted sooner as there’s bound to have been some way to get paid if defer if.

My boss told me I wasn’t allowed to do it and so I had to defer it.
The courts then told me as I accepted but my boss said no, that I wouldn’t be called on again as it’s been put down as I’ve already done it.
Which I am gutted about as my dream is to do jury service!
This was during covid times when everything was different though.

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 06/07/2023 19:01

Allywill · 06/07/2023 18:57

sorry it’s my fault not explaining it properly. it’s not a separate insurance policy but rather that several loss of income type policies that self employed people can take out (to cover sickness injury business interruption etc) cover loss of income due to jury service. i agree it would be pretty pointless on its own!

I've found it essentially impossible to get that sort of insurance because I have a health condition, even though I haven't had any time off work in over 4 years, and always had a good sickness record before that.

Yes, my travel insurance is expensive (routinely 10x what my partner pays) but at least I can get that.

Business interruption insurance also routinely refused to pay out during lockdown.

Allywill · 06/07/2023 18:57

BiscuitsandPuffin · 06/07/2023 18:41

Given that some people go their whole lives without ever getting summoned, and simultaneously you can be summoned more than once, you would have to pay it until retirement. So surely you could just achieve the same result by saving the cost of the insurance every month?

And people who can't afford that are just as screwed as if they didn't have insurance, and they're the people who will really miss that income. So overall one of the most pointless insurances I've ever heard of.

sorry it’s my fault not explaining it properly. it’s not a separate insurance policy but rather that several loss of income type policies that self employed people can take out (to cover sickness injury business interruption etc) cover loss of income due to jury service. i agree it would be pretty pointless on its own!

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 06/07/2023 18:55

YANBU

I'm self employed and live in dread of the thought of getting called up for jury service as the business cannot run if I'm not there.

The amounts you can claim for lost earnings are an absolute pittance, and make no allowance for overheads, seasonal peaks and troughs, or anyone earning a decent amount.

Apparently £64.95 is meant to cover you for a whole days lost wages AND overheads AND extra care / childcare arrangements! Based on 6.5 hours work and zero overheads or care costs that's LESS than minimum wage!
https://www.gov.uk/jury-service/what-you-can-claim-if-youre-self-employed

When I was employed in a regular job it would have been an interesting fortnight. Now it's an unaffordably expensive fortnight.

Jury service

What to do if you're asked to do jury service - taking time off work, delaying jury service, claiming expenses. Includes information from the withdrawn 5222, 5222A and Juror Charter guidance

https://www.gov.uk/jury-service/what-you-can-claim-if-youre-self-employed

Ponoka7 · 06/07/2023 18:46

rwalker · 06/07/2023 18:20

Sounds like a cash in gd d job with no contract

Zaro hour contracts aren't cash in hand.

OP jury service should have been refused.

BiscuitsandPuffin · 06/07/2023 18:41

Allywill · 06/07/2023 17:33

You can get insurance to cover self employed earning when on jury duty. Don’t know how much it costs though.

Given that some people go their whole lives without ever getting summoned, and simultaneously you can be summoned more than once, you would have to pay it until retirement. So surely you could just achieve the same result by saving the cost of the insurance every month?

And people who can't afford that are just as screwed as if they didn't have insurance, and they're the people who will really miss that income. So overall one of the most pointless insurances I've ever heard of.

Rosemarypots · 06/07/2023 18:31

I was called between my second and third year of university. I wrote back saying that if I didn't do paid work over that summer I wouldn't be able to afford to go back for my third year - this was absolutely true, as my parents could barely afford to give me anything at that point, and I was studying somewhere with little opportunity for term time work. They wrote back straight away deferring me, and I've never been called since, nearly 20 years later.

NotOnYourNellies · 06/07/2023 18:24

Agree , I'd say financial hardship too, you never know

rwalker · 06/07/2023 18:20

Sounds like a cash in gd d job with no contract

LauraPausini · 06/07/2023 18:17

I would check with the court about this situation. I did jury service recently and the court staff were really helpful advising where people were having issues with the forms and getting their employers to provide the relevant details.

The employer doesn't have to pay his wages whilst on jury service but I can't see why they would prevent him from claiming the loss of earnings expenses he is entitled to if he is employed - unless by doing the jury service his contractual start date has moved back so the employer is saying he is technically not an "employee" yet?

EasterBreak · 06/07/2023 17:59

TrueScrumptious · 06/07/2023 16:01

I would say that it would cause extreme financial hardship is a good reason.

Agreed, valid reason. Just call them.

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 06/07/2023 17:57

Could your son speak to HR at work? Or a union if he's in one? Just in case it is a case of the employer being difficult and he actually could claim the money.

Allywill · 06/07/2023 17:33

Firecarrier · 06/07/2023 16:11

It is disgusting.

My DH got called twice. He was the only earner as I was SAHM. He was self employed and the poxy amount offered didn't cover it. It can really screw self employed people over too.

You can get insurance to cover self employed earning when on jury duty. Don’t know how much it costs though.

Needmorelego · 06/07/2023 17:15

A bit annoying for him but I assume he is living at home with you for the summer so at least he hasn’t got to pay rent and bills. I hope you won’t be letting him go hungry and switching off his electricity supply.
What summer job pays £800 for 2 weeks though?
(what you said he would lose)