Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what happens if you take ADHD medication

62 replies

RestingandSmilingBFace · 06/07/2023 15:05

...but you were misdiagnosed and actually it's trauma that makes you present in an ADHD way.

Anyway think they've had this experience?

I do believe ADHD is a thing but I also think it can be very tricky to work out if it's that your trauma.

Thank you

OP posts:
Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 06/07/2023 17:26

RestingandSmilingBFace · 06/07/2023 17:20

@Rainbowsandbutterflies1990

am curious as to why u would think you would be more qualified than an actual professional who assesses if people have adhd ?

Are you really curious? Or are you just being passive aggressive? I do not think I am more qualified than a professional. And I don't know if she is traumatized or has ADHD. I am not invested in either result. I am invested in her getting an accurate diagnosis and support.

Please quote me on what I have wrote that makes me appear like I am against her getting an ADHD diagnosis.

I admit it was passive aggressive im sorry ive been awake since 3am my autistic daughter has been awake since, i have adhd myself. , the fact u are asking is why I'm assuming u don't want her to get adhd diagnosis. If she was to go for an adhd diagnosis then it would be the professional deciding that, it didn't matter what u thought.

RestingandSmilingBFace · 06/07/2023 17:26

@YouCantTourniquetTheTaint

If your partner has ADHD then her symptoms would have been present in childhood. Assessments are very thorough, and go back to childhood.

But her mum died when she was a young child...4 years old.

OP posts:
Sunnyfeelgood · 06/07/2023 17:25

I think perhaps you are taking your experience and applying it too widely?

There is no one way for people who have been through trauma to present. You said for you, you don't like silences, for other people who have been through trauma it would be the opposite. Perhaps in your case it was misdiagnosed, but the overlap between ADHD and PTSD isn't that big! I say this as someone who treats trauma and clients who have ADHD.

Someone else also said above - just because you experience a traumatic event, doesn't actually mean you are traumatised. Two people could go through the same thing and one could brush it off and have little to no impact, where for the other it could change their life massively. Or, someone may be traumatised for a few years after the event and then recover.

Courgeon · 06/07/2023 17:24

There's various therapeutic approaches for trauma, intensive psychotherapy, compassion focussed therapy, EMDR, integrative psychotherapy and others. It depends on the person and the formulation, ie What's causing the problems and keeping them going. And some therapies work better for some people than others. Some people may benefit from a more exploratory type approach, others may prefer to learn specific skills to deal with specific problems.

Hotterthanhades · 06/07/2023 17:22

AP5Diva · 06/07/2023 16:49

The only trauma I know that can cause acquired ADHD is a brain injury due to banging your head.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-distracted-couple/201510/why-do-brain-injuries-look-adhd

so psychological trauma can’t do it, it would have to be physical trauma causing a brain injury.

That’s not exactly correct.

the OP isn’t suggesting that trauma causes ADHD- they are saying that ADHD and trauma can present in similar ways.

this is a reasonable concern, and one I struggle with (I have many ADHD traits but it may also be trauma)

besides, Gabor Mate ( MD / author/ ADHD specialist) argues that childhood trauma does indeed lead to higher risk of ADHD in some people.

nothing is proven- you can’t say with any certainty that there is or isn’t a link.

Countdowntowinter · 06/07/2023 17:22

My friend was told if your not adhd then the meds won't work to help with concentration etc and you would be less able to concentrate. Trauma needs a much different approach.

YouCantTourniquetTheTaint · 06/07/2023 17:22

"Firstly, people aren‘tADHD, they may have ADHD, but you can[t say someoneisADHD.Well I actually prefer ADHDifferent. I believe in the neurodiversity movement." Um do you have ADHD? If not please don't label people with ADHD as anything.

If your partner has ADHD then her symptoms would have been present in childhood. Assessments are very thorough, and go back to childhood.

If someone without ADHD is given a stimulant medication then it will act like a stimulant. In ADHD regardless of if you're hyper or not it will calm your brain, inattentive ADHD doesn't mean there's nothing going on in our brains it means there's too much going on and we can't concentrate.

That fucking Panorama program has done do much fucking damage it's unreal. It was so poorly researched.

Here's the response to the Panorama program from the ADHD foundation:

https://www.adhdfoundation.org.uk/2023/05/15/response-to-bbc-panorama-private-adhd-clinics-exposed/#:~:text=The%20over%20reliance%20on%20a,how%20to%20manage%20ADHD%20successfully.&text=We%20are%20disappointed%20that%20BBC,sensationalist%20piece%20of%20television%20journalism.

Response to BBC Panorama "Private ADHD Clinics Exposed" - ADHD Foundation

The BBC Panorama programme Private ADHD Clinics Exposed examines three private clinics offering ADHD assessments and prescribing medication.   Whilst we welcome responsible and informed television journalism, any reporting that does not engage with pat...

https://www.adhdfoundation.org.uk/2023/05/15/response-to-bbc-panorama-private-adhd-clinics-exposed/#:~:text=The%20over%20reliance%20on%20a,how%20to%20manage%20ADHD%20successfully.&text=We%20are%20disappointed%20that%20BBC,sensationalist%20piece%20of%20television%20journalism.

RestingandSmilingBFace · 06/07/2023 17:20

@Rainbowsandbutterflies1990

am curious as to why u would think you would be more qualified than an actual professional who assesses if people have adhd ?

Are you really curious? Or are you just being passive aggressive? I do not think I am more qualified than a professional. And I don't know if she is traumatized or has ADHD. I am not invested in either result. I am invested in her getting an accurate diagnosis and support.

Please quote me on what I have wrote that makes me appear like I am against her getting an ADHD diagnosis.

OP posts:
AP5Diva · 06/07/2023 17:17

RestingandSmilingBFace · 06/07/2023 17:12

@AP5Diva ah hah. Well I didn't know that. Thanks for sharing I'll have a proper read later. Thank you!

I think you are unnecessarily worrying tbh, certain symptoms of ADHD and PTSD overlap, but a professional psychologist is going to be able to see the difference through their assessment. It’s also possible to have both ADHD and PTSD. So I’d leave it to the professionals.

Anotherparkingthread · 06/07/2023 17:13

I can tell you what adhd meds do for adhd.

For me, my adhd is a lot like being in a room with 100 screens and each is playing a different image and audio, all concurrently. When I take the medication it's like the majority of the screens begin to play the same thing and I can tune into a specific task or though. They become linier and one at a time, I can see the order in which events happen and which take priority. I can focus on one thing.

If you don't have adhd I imagine the effect would be a stimulant so instead of clarity you will experience anxiety, feeling scattered, hyperactivity, inability to sleep.

RestingandSmilingBFace · 06/07/2023 17:12

@AP5Diva ah hah. Well I didn't know that. Thanks for sharing I'll have a proper read later. Thank you!

OP posts:
RestingandSmilingBFace · 06/07/2023 17:11

Thanks @Courgeon that's really insightful and fascinating. What is the reset trauma therapy? So

OP posts:
Clementineorsatsuma · 06/07/2023 17:06

RestingandSmilingBFace · 06/07/2023 16:19

@beeskipa but what if the reason you can't do stuff is because of trauma not ADHD. Trauma symptoms can present just like ADHD.

Then the ADHD meds wouldn't work.
And you may have both. There's enough issues with medicos forgetting that coexist without it being backed up on random chats tbh.
Trauma therapy works for trauma. ADHD meds work for ADHD.

badluckorbadvibes · 06/07/2023 17:01

My concern with her going to an ADHD assessment is that if you asked her if she suffers from childhood trauma she would say no

I wasn't asked this?

I do have c-PTSD which was diagnosed separately from ADHD and also autism.

maidmarianne · 06/07/2023 16:59

If trauma causes executive dysfunction that looks like adhd, then adhd meds will at least help the executive function issues, but obviously can't fix the underlying trauma. It's quite hard sometimes to get the meds right so it's not as simple as it pointing to a misdiagnosis if they don't work straightaway.
Are you concerned about side effects? I don't understand why you don't want her to try the adhd meds and see.
Untangling what is trauma and what is adhd when the trauma occurred at such a young age is going to be almost impossible anyway. You can suggest psychotherapy, but just because someone suffers something very difficult doesn't automatically mean they would end up traumatised.

clothesintervention · 06/07/2023 16:57

MumblesParty · 06/07/2023 16:26

Do you and your friend have any idea how dangerous that is?

But if an overreaction, no? <Thinks back to the vast amounts of recreational amphetamines we took in the 90s>

ADHD meds are very mild!

HairyKitty · 06/07/2023 16:53

Trauma may present as adhd but the brain is not the same, therefore stimulant meds won’t have the same effect on the trauma impacted brain.
If you don’t have adhd meds will not have the significant calming, clarity or organising effect etc. If you don’t get these benefits it doesn’t mean you don’t have adhd, it could mean the dose is wrong or you don’t benefit from stimulants

Courgeon · 06/07/2023 16:52

In my previous clinical life I used to do ADHD assessments for children and teenagers. A lot of kids presented with an ADHD type picture due to neglect/abuse /other adverse childhood experiences. Some were likely born with ADHD. However given ACEs affect how your brain develops in terms of the neural pathways during times of intense brain development whatever the causation it's an ADHD type picture. Sometimes trauma based therapy for children AND their carers can "reset" the brain but it's pretty hard to come by that type of therapy.

I've since discovered I have ADHD and likely had it all my life. Seeing as I'm nearly 50 I'm not going down the meds route as I've learnt other strategies to deal with it and also not to take on too much and overwhelm myself.

WiddlinDiddlin · 06/07/2023 16:51

Maybe.... she is in fact, NOT traumatised by the death of her mother?

You've assumed she must be, but its entirely possible she is not.

RestingandSmilingBFace · 06/07/2023 16:50

@FlyingUnicornWings how can they know if her symptoms were there before her mum died?

@Whichclubisittonight

Firstly, people aren‘tADHD, they may have ADHD, but you can[t say someoneisADHD.

Well I actually prefer ADHDifferent. I believe in the neurodiversity movement. Similarly people are Autistic they don't have autism.

Secondly, why are you so keen for her not to have ADHD?

I am keen for her to get the support she needs and an accurate diagnosis.

It would actually be more simple if she did have ADHD/ is ADHDifferent as she is open to having ADHD. She is not open to exploring her trauma...IF she has it.

If she goes for an assessment, they‘ll be able to tell her whether they believe she has it or not and I suspect they‘re far more qualified than you are to make that call.

Of course they are more qualified to make the call. I'm not trying to diagnose her. I'm on a forum to help my understanding. It was me who suggested ADHD to her. She had never considered it before I talked to her about it.

She may not use the word trauma, but they may well ask her questions about her past and draw their own conclusions.

That sounds reassuring. Thank you

If she‘s generally struggling, why would you not want her to pursue this and see if medication helps her?

I do want her to persue it. And I also want her to be open minded about the effects of her mum dieing.

OP posts:
AP5Diva · 06/07/2023 16:49

The only trauma I know that can cause acquired ADHD is a brain injury due to banging your head.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-distracted-couple/201510/why-do-brain-injuries-look-adhd

so psychological trauma can’t do it, it would have to be physical trauma causing a brain injury.

Why Do Brain Injuries Look Like ADHD?

Are ADHD and brain injuries linked, or do they just look similar?

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-distracted-couple/201510/why-do-brain-injuries-look-adhd

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 06/07/2023 16:49

I am curious as to why u would think you would be more qualified than an actual professional who assesses if people have adhd ? If your friend doesn't have adhd then they will not be assessed with adhd. It's a thorough process. Regardless of what some resent bias bbc documentary was trying to show.

AP5Diva · 06/07/2023 16:47

RestingandSmilingBFace · 06/07/2023 16:31

I know that trauma changes the brain. So I guess what I am really wondering is if trauma makes your brain as if you are ADHD or if it just presents like ADHD and the difference in the brain is different.

My girlfriends mum died when she was 4.5 years old. She doesn't remember her mum and thinks she is unaffected by it as she has no memory of her mum being around or her actually dieing. She presents like she has ADHD. Struggles to listen to people. Is scatty. Is ALWAYS busy, doesn't like silences. Can't relax.

My concern with her going to an ADHD assessment is that if you asked her if she suffers from childhood trauma she would say no. And there's no way of checking if her behaviour was like it was before her mum died anyway. Her dad died recently. So how is anyone to know why she is the way she is....apart from being diagnosed ADHD and then going on the meds and then them not working!

Trauma can’t make you present like ADHD at all. You’d present with PTSD symptoms.

AP5Diva · 06/07/2023 16:44

They won’t work (apart from placebo effect) and may get side effects from too much dopamine—ranging from headaches, loss of appetite, and jitteriness to elevated blood pressure, palpitations, and insomnia. And the person is likely to feel a bit sluggish and maybe even have low mood, since you've just overloaded the brain with more dopamine than it needs.

Whichclubisittonight · 06/07/2023 16:38

"So I guess what I am really wondering is if trauma makes your brain as if you are ADHD or if it just presents like ADHD and the difference in the brain is different."

Firstly, people aren‘t ADHD, they may have ADHD, but you can[t say someone is ADHD.

Secondly, why are you so keen for her not to have ADHD? If she goes for an assessment, they‘ll be able to tell her whether they believe she has it or not and I suspect they‘re far more qualified than you are to make that call. She may not use the word trauma, but they may well ask her questions about her past and draw their own conclusions.

If she‘s generally struggling, why would you not want her to pursue this and see if medication helps her? Even in the unlikely event she was misdiagnosed and prescribed medication, she would soon find out it didn‘t work.

Let the experts decide whether she has it or not.