Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Left a medicore restaurant review. Restaurant wants me to email them to discuss....what?

109 replies

roses2 · 06/07/2023 10:36

I went to a restaurant a few weeks ago. It was just alright, not as wow as I was expecting from the 4.6* Google reviews. My food was wrong, they returned it then the new meal was under cooked. DS wanted to order ice cream and the guy was in a rush and told DS "I will order you vanilla" when DS wanted a few seconds to think about what flavour after the man told him what they had.

It was £140 for 4 of us (2 adults & 2 kids). Not high end but not cheap either.

So I left 3* on Google and the restaurant posted back "please email us back to discuss".

I'm not sure I have anything else to say. It was in a village we went to visit for a day so I won't be back.

Does anyone ever reply? What do they want to discuss that I didn't already write about objectively in my review?

OP posts:
GeorgeMichaelsCat · 09/07/2023 12:40

roses2 · 08/07/2023 22:50

Not yet, its been 2 days since I emailed.

Oh dear, usual pattern

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 09/07/2023 11:44

I’d email them and find out what they have to say, but I wouldn’t alter my review.

Ispywithmycynicaleye · 09/07/2023 00:02

You are NBU. We recently went to a Gordon Ramsay restaurant for my birthday. Food and venu were shit! Toilets filthy, etc and his 'signiture' dish was awful and soggy! I am going to leave a bad review given it cost over £400 and I've had a better experience at the local carvery for £40 (same amount of people). Guess where we're 'not' going next year!

MercedesD · 08/07/2023 23:41

The point of reviews are for customers to see what the restaurant is like before visiting on one hand. And on the other for restaurants to see what they do well and what can be improved. That’s why they ask you to reply. It’s also to do with customer retention. If you left a 3 star review the restaurant may offer a voucher for you to try them again. Sometimes there are off days as in all work places. The idea is that they may offer you a voucher to come back and hopefully have a better experience. Also to determine areas of improvement for other customers.
it has nothing to do with offering bribes to remove reviews.

roses2 · 08/07/2023 22:50

SilverstoneF1 · 08/07/2023 20:54

Did they reply?

Not yet, its been 2 days since I emailed.

OP posts:
SilverstoneF1 · 08/07/2023 20:54

Did they reply?

Milly89 · 08/07/2023 15:24

I left a negative review for a restaurant on their fb page and they blocked me 🤣🤣 i wasn't rude in the review just said that I dont recommended as they sent out a raw hunters chicken, not once but twice!!

rowbotham · 08/07/2023 15:22

In a reverse of this, we had a not great experience in a local gastro pub that we had always previously enjoyed. I know times are tough and it’s family run so rather than posting on trip advisor I emailed them directly because I thought maybe better for their business and if I didn’t say anything and get an explanation, we wouldn’t be going there again. Heard nothing, no acknowledgment whatsoever.
not going again and should have reviewed in Tripadvisor !

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 06/07/2023 17:39

Ah, ok @LanaDeIRabies that has pleased me that it wasn't them. Irrelevant derail, I bought DD a satchel from Cambridge in the sale. For her 21st, and had her initials embossed. Only realised a couple of days later that I had given her old initials, she had recently changed name. Doh. All sale savings were wiped out in a mini break to the shop in Cambridge city centre, many many earth miles from where we actually live, while they re-embossed the initials. Fortunately, due to her middle name being the same initial as previous surname, they were able to add the correct end initial, and though it meant it was off centre, a bicycle embossing they also offer balanced it up. Entirely my fault. Guess what! I don't order things like that in a hurry now! My nerves won't stand another one of those!

LanaDeIRabies · 06/07/2023 15:03

@SpongeBobJudgeyPants no - Cambridge Satchels have always been brilliant (I've bought loads from them) and their CS is excellent. However that's the company who the one I reviewed implied that I owned! I wish 😂

The company in question was another UK satchel brand though. Not Zatchels, if that narrows it down!

purplecorkheart · 06/07/2023 15:00

Email and tell them what the issues are. You have nothing to lose by doing so. I had a friend who used to own a restaurant in a small town. If he got a bad review he would try and find out what the cause of it was to fix it. He found that people who were from the area did not tell him if there were issues as they liked him and knew all his staff so they did not want to give negative feedback.

WatchOutLurkerAbout · 06/07/2023 14:56

LanaDeIRabies · 06/07/2023 11:11

I once left a polite, factual one star review on Trustpilot for a satchel company - the bag I bought cost £160 but within a couple of weeks the straps had cracked and frayed, and when I tried to contact them, they didn't respond. The company left a very nasty response saying I had the same first name as the owner of their main competitor's company and if I didn't remove my review they would take legal action. I left the review up but TP removed it for not being a genuine review - they said I hadn't used the company in question. Needless to say I've shared the heck out of screenshots since and would tell anyone looking to buy a leather satchel not to use that particular company!

Hopefully they want to you to get in touch to put it right OP - maybe some vouchers or something.

@LanaDeIRabies I had the same with trustpilot but I was so so so annoyed with the company I'd bought from I went through a thoroughly invasive process with trustpilot where I had to send them the receipts for the purchase, proof of delivery (doorbell footage), I had to send the emails and photos I'd send to the company as well as screenshots of my 14 unanswered calls to the company - AND proof of ID and address.

But it was worth it because now not only is my review still on trustpilot it's now pinned to the top of this companies page with a great big "details vetted and confirmed by trustpilot as accurate" sticker on it.

Still didn't get my refund though. Gits.

Cirice · 06/07/2023 14:55

I had a company go down the ‘not a customer’ route with Tripadvisor. They pulled the review so I sent them everything I had from order numbers to poor product photos and they did reinstate it.

PousseyNotMoira · 06/07/2023 14:36

Bluevelvetsofa · 06/07/2023 12:04

I was asked to review something on Trip Advisor - a beauty brand. It took three weeks to arrive and when I used it I didn’t think it effective at all. In the review, I said it had taken too long to arrive and I wasn’t impressed with it. They wanted to know details about the order, long since deleted from email because it had, by then, been months and said they would take down the review if I didn’t provide what they wanted.

I told them the review was factual and truthful and I didn’t care if it was removed.

The most interesting thing to me here is learning that some people delete their emails. 😆 I don’t think I’ve ever deleted an email in my life.

Iamtheonwandlonely · 06/07/2023 14:31

I usually give a fair review of places.
But this one Chinese restaurant was awful.
It was Chinese New year and they moved our booking forward an hour,no problem.
Then we where sat right where the dragon passed.
Great, except the staff totally ignored us.
Asked for water got one glass.
Asked for the menu,the waitress cleaned the table beside us instead 🤣.

We left,got a takeaway on the way home
Left honest review and the manager got in contact and couldn't have been more apologetic.
Gave us some vouchers,we went again and it was fantastic.

Still left original post up but added the positive of a 2nd visit.

Bookworm20 · 06/07/2023 14:16

I left a bad review once for a restaurant as both the food and service was terrible. Food was wrong (missing about half of what it stated it came with), cold and another persons food was totally burnt (yet still cold) and when we pointed it out at the time they were very rude. The manager replied to my review with a rant and basically insulting me with things like, judging by your reviews of other places it shows what type of rubbish establishments you usually eat at and obviously are not used to good food!
Ummm, ok then. Just made himself look like a total idiot. Especially considering my other reviews were for a whole range of places.

mosiacmaker · 06/07/2023 14:12

Budikka · 06/07/2023 13:53

Actually, that put me off booking a property for an overnight stay. The owner wrote back to someone who had made some gentle criticism, all capital letters and no paragraph breaks. Now, if she had said: "sorry, I will be sure to fix this, etc. hope you will still be back again", I would have been suitably impressed. But I had no attention of staying at the same property with someone who seemed slightly unbalanced!

Yes I was recently getting some jewellery designed and thought I’d found the right jeweller but then saw her google reviews, every negative review received such a snappy long winded response that it was clear she was a complete nightmare. I found a different jeweller.

mosiacmaker · 06/07/2023 14:10

from the wording of the review they might genuinely want to find out what you didn’t like about the male waiter’s service so that they can resolve this issue and stop it happening for future customers. I would email and follow up with them as a courtesy - it’s really hard in the restaurant business right now!

SirQuintusAureliusMaximus · 06/07/2023 14:04

They'll probably offer you a free meal or something. I would take it and give them a chance. Good customer service can really help solve a negative impression.

I was once in a large party of about 8 or so people at a very smart Michelin starred London restaurant. The whole thing was a disaster - everything was wrong, orders taken then told off, waited ages for everything etc. Wrote to complain. Was offered a complimentary re-do.

Second go was so amazing - they really went out of their way - free champagne etc etc and everyone who came back went back again to that restaurant and raved about it far and wide.

It was a very good example of how to turn a negative into a positive through good customer service.

The remedy was just so impressive.

Showdogworkingdog · 06/07/2023 14:00

I recently ordered garlic bread (garlic bread!) in a restaurant and it was rank, greasy and chewy rubber bread with cheese that smelled like DH’s feet after he’s been wearing his trainers too long. Naturally enough when my plate was collected untouched they asked me if everything was ok so I told the about the garlic bread ( I don’t think I mentioned DH’s feet) and the waitress was so shocked she sent the manager over who was also shocked as in all the years he’s been running his restaurant, nobody has ever complained about it. I mean, I wasn’t that fussed tbh, but omg did they take it to heart.

Budikka · 06/07/2023 13:53

KnottyKnitting · 06/07/2023 10:50

I posted a so so review about a restaurant recently. The restaurant owner replied with an absolute tirade of rebuttals to my complaints - it made her look like a total loon and obvious to anyone reading it that " me thinks the lady doth protest too much!"

Actually, that put me off booking a property for an overnight stay. The owner wrote back to someone who had made some gentle criticism, all capital letters and no paragraph breaks. Now, if she had said: "sorry, I will be sure to fix this, etc. hope you will still be back again", I would have been suitably impressed. But I had no attention of staying at the same property with someone who seemed slightly unbalanced!

OnTheRunWithMannyMontana · 06/07/2023 13:48

I had this after leaving a negative review on a local
Pub grub place.

Toilets were flooded, no access to disabled toilet (I'm a wheelchair user) 90 minute wait for food and then served a vegetable patty that you could bounce a knife off.

They asked us to visit again so they could show us what they could do, got a free 2 course meal for 4 and a bottle of wine and in fairness it was lovely. And they didn't ask me to remove the previous review.

Theunamedcat · 06/07/2023 13:46

I complained directly to a restaurant because I asked for gluten free and she gave me the vegan menu....which isn't gluten free I pointed this out and she kept insisting it was fine for me because it was vegan I said no I need gluten free she said yes its vegan its fine for you no im intolerant to WHEAT and GLUTEN I'm not VEGAN no no no this is FINE FOR YOU ITS VEGAN.....manager please? Dude I'm not vegan I'm gluten intolerant fo you have food i can eat he just looked at me like 😶😶😶 🤔 😬 I was laughing but I said it's OK I will go elsewhere so we left I left a review the manager apologised saying my question caught him off guard and he had now given his staff more training I took the review down after about 6 months

DontYouThreatenMeWithADeadFish · 06/07/2023 13:29

I am not a fan of writing hatchet job reviews online as a first port of call and will try and sort out whatever issues I have had with the manager first. Most of the time if they are any good will try and resolve the issue but if management don't give a shit I am happy to leave a review that reflects the service/food.

Verystressedsenmum · 06/07/2023 13:28

This happened to me I left a review all true on trip advisor was asked to email so I did and guess what no reply so not inclined to go back .