Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Left a medicore restaurant review. Restaurant wants me to email them to discuss....what?

109 replies

roses2 · 06/07/2023 10:36

I went to a restaurant a few weeks ago. It was just alright, not as wow as I was expecting from the 4.6* Google reviews. My food was wrong, they returned it then the new meal was under cooked. DS wanted to order ice cream and the guy was in a rush and told DS "I will order you vanilla" when DS wanted a few seconds to think about what flavour after the man told him what they had.

It was £140 for 4 of us (2 adults & 2 kids). Not high end but not cheap either.

So I left 3* on Google and the restaurant posted back "please email us back to discuss".

I'm not sure I have anything else to say. It was in a village we went to visit for a day so I won't be back.

Does anyone ever reply? What do they want to discuss that I didn't already write about objectively in my review?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
N0ëlle · 16/07/2023 11:25

I'd hate that. You had your experience of the place. You're entitled to that.
What are they going to do? persuade you that you were WRONG? Or make you feel conflicted by offering you a voucher.

They shouldn't be focusing on you,they should focus on making sure tht other people don't experience their restaurant in the same way.

zingally · 16/07/2023 11:21

Ignore it.

It's a generic reply for one of two reasons: They'll comp you a voucher if you edit the review, or they just want to show other reviewers that they're willing to engage with complaints, but probably won't actually do anything.

Unknownunknowns · 16/07/2023 11:02

Just goes to show that their "Please email us...." was bullshit and aimed at PPs on here who said don't bother - that way the restaurant looks good, but it didn't cost them anything.
Even if I did live close I don't think I'd bother taking them up on it.

Astsjakksmso · 16/07/2023 10:40

Well at least you tried OP. Their loss.

roses2 · 16/07/2023 10:37

Update:
No response from my email. I waited a week then updated my Google review to say I emailed as they requested but got no reply.

Next day the restaurant reply saying sorry they missed my email and offered me a commentary meal for 2.

I don't live in the area and won't be back anytime soon.

Poor service on their part and shows the "please email to discuss" is bullshit which makes me want to score them even less than the 3* I gave them.

OP posts:
Cocolebombom · 11/07/2023 13:02

Frabbits · 06/07/2023 11:27

Reviews aren't left for the benefit of the business, it's to inform other customers of experiences.

Disagree. You go to a restaurant with certain expectations of a service they want to offer you. Yes a review helps warn others, however they are also there to help a business evolve and ensure that they meet the standards expected of their customers. If they want to get in touch to discuss their error, learn from it, and improve future service surely that's a good thing all round?

Lucyh999 · 10/07/2023 14:48

Not sure this is an AIBU post? What are your terms? Just email them and find out what they want?

LanaDeIRabies · 10/07/2023 13:37

Kingsparkle · 10/07/2023 08:14

@LanaDeIRabies - I was hoping it wasn’t Zatchels, I have two bags from them that still look brand new despite years of abuse and I was worried their standards had slipped as I was thinking about buying a third.

Zatchels are brilliant, definitely not them!

Elphame · 10/07/2023 12:27

Monster80 · 10/07/2023 07:15

@Elphame Erm, did you fall and hit your head, this whole thread is about restaurant reviews. My point remains, reviews are subjective, different people have different views, it’s the world we live in.

I think you got out of bed the wrong side!

One of my reviews was for a local restaurant that gave DP severe food poisoning. They were 5 rated at the time. They were inspected the following week and given a 1 rating for food hygiene.

Am I going to change my review for a free meal? No I'm not. Potential customers need to know that they run a real risk of being ill. It will gradually drop down assuming they don't continue to make people sick.

mastertomsmum · 10/07/2023 08:42

I think the reply you got was generic. Ass covering but does at least show they take reviews seriously/monitor them.

My friends and I had a weird experience at a restaurant a few years back. Various bad bits of service throughout the meal and then - at the end - over coffee and after dinner drinks in the bar, where we had been encouraged to go, they switched the lights off on us and other people in restaurant as well. It wasn’t even that late. 3 of us submitted Tripadvisor reviews mentioning this. The manager had a right go at us. No apology at all.

Kingsparkle · 10/07/2023 08:24

I always look at how places respond to reviews. A few negative reviews with a polite and courteous response from the business never bother me.

We have a fancy children’s play place near us. Since it opened I’d been thinking of going as it looked nice but something about their tone on social media seemed off so I’d never booked. Lo and behold they got their first few negative reviews (along with lots of positive) and they would post those reviews to their social media and complain people were trying to destroy their business. The reviews were polite but complained about the overbearing and unreasonable policies of the place which the owners in their responses would confirm were their policies.

After seeing a post one day complaining they weren’t getting enough customers, I politely messaged them to say I had been meaning to book but their use of social media to shame those with a less than positive experience and some of their policies had put me off. They sent me a tirade back about how fake reviews were ruining their business and they had every right to do XYZ. Then they sent another ranting message and blocked me. It was surreal. When they fail, it won’t be a surprise.

Kingsparkle · 10/07/2023 08:14

@LanaDeIRabies - I was hoping it wasn’t Zatchels, I have two bags from them that still look brand new despite years of abuse and I was worried their standards had slipped as I was thinking about buying a third.

Astsjakksmso · 10/07/2023 08:05

I can see that you've emailed them OP but honestly I never rely on reviews. I don't know why anybody would!
Apart from removing negative reviews etc tas already discussed there are companies you can pay to write loads of good reviews. Especially with ChatGPT.
And, most people only bother reviewing when things are bad.
I've been to a fair few restaurants with 3* or below reviews, perfectly fine. Others with rave reviews where the food was plastic.

Of course If you're visiting a destination as a one off perhaps you can avoid being ripped off but I always ask real people...that I know.

FlamingoQueen · 10/07/2023 08:01

I wouldn’t worry about it. I once left a scathing review for somewhere and told them I was doing it as I left the cafe. They added a comment on my review to say call them to discuss. I asked if it was the manager of the place I had been talking to because if it was, what was the point. I would discuss with Head Office though. No reply!
It is a well known chain, but my comments were justified. Never going back to that particular store again, so not worried.

jc12689 · 10/07/2023 07:49

nancy2022 · 06/07/2023 10:47

Often it's just a generic reply so other viewers can see they have tried to rectify it.

I bet no one ever replies.

I did and got a £40 voucher. They didn't ask me to edit the review, they just seemed genuinely interested in improving .

Monster80 · 10/07/2023 07:15

@Elphame Erm, did you fall and hit your head, this whole thread is about restaurant reviews. My point remains, reviews are subjective, different people have different views, it’s the world we live in.

Elphame · 09/07/2023 20:19

Monster80 · 09/07/2023 16:06

Sorry to be disagreeable @Elphame reviews are strictly subjective, one persons thoughts are not necessarily another’s. One man’s restaurant trash is truly another man’s dining treasure. If the restaurant is concerned enough to offer a refund, I would suggest they aren’t complete bounders and do care about the customers issues. Unless you have evidence that this isn’t a one off, the restaurant has every right to ask to refund the diner in return for the review to be removed. They also have the option to refute the review online, which plenty do - probably with good reason.

Did I mention restaurants? I don't think I did!

roses2 · 09/07/2023 16:33

Can I ask OP - did you give them the chance to rectify it there and then or just pay up and leave quietly then post your review?

The first meal came out wrong. They took it back after I told them and the second meal was under cooked. I didn't want to send it back again as I had already been waiting long enough.

When taking dessert orders I asked the waiter to come back and I will order dessert when my son was ready. He didn't seem to want to and was trying to push my son into making a decision by telling him "I will bring you vanilla ice cream".

They had enough chances to rectify and I don't think I was unreasonable in not giving them unlimited chances to rectify.

OP posts:
MXVIT · 09/07/2023 16:16

Can I ask OP - did you give them the chance to rectify it there and then or just pay up and leave quietly then post your review?

I only ask because even though you had bad service if it's the latter then it's really a bugbear of mine

Monster80 · 09/07/2023 16:06

Sorry to be disagreeable @Elphame reviews are strictly subjective, one persons thoughts are not necessarily another’s. One man’s restaurant trash is truly another man’s dining treasure. If the restaurant is concerned enough to offer a refund, I would suggest they aren’t complete bounders and do care about the customers issues. Unless you have evidence that this isn’t a one off, the restaurant has every right to ask to refund the diner in return for the review to be removed. They also have the option to refute the review online, which plenty do - probably with good reason.

grass321 · 09/07/2023 14:17

Diddykong · 06/07/2023 11:37

There's a local restaurant here that attacks low reviews with accusations "well we have reviewed our cctv and saw you did get the broccoli and that you dropped a fork on the floor so we should bill you for bending that, stop being so ungrateful" it is mind boggling what the manager hopes to achieve with this tactic.

We have similar. The responses are hilariously offensive and paint the restaurant in a far worse light than the original review. It's hard to pick a favourite as there are so many.

But if you happened to be in Bushey, looking for an Italian and see one called Blue Check, you might like to filter the three star and below reviews on TripAdvisor....

LlynTegid · 09/07/2023 13:48

I would have ignored them. Your plan as you have to give them ten days seems reasonable.

Elphame · 09/07/2023 13:44

Oh and I have most definitely been offered bribes to do so as well as moral blackmail that I was harming a small business ( from somewhere I wouldn't actually class as a small business)

Elphame · 09/07/2023 13:40

Monster80 · 06/07/2023 12:14

Ask for a refund and offer to remove the review. If 4 people ate for free and you won’t be going back, what’s the conundrum?

It makes a complete nonsense of the review system and is unfair on future customers. Surely you can see that?

I've been asked a couple of times to change poor reviews - I always edit them as requested but don't change my star rating.

I point out that I've been contacted and asked to improve a poor rating so any future customers might like to take this into account when reading their reviews!

roses2 · 09/07/2023 13:16

GeorgeMichaelsCat · 09/07/2023 12:40

Oh dear, usual pattern

I will give them 10 days. If no response, even just to acknowledge my detailed feedback with the description of the impatient man in my email. I will update my review to say I emailed them but they didn't reply.

OP posts: