Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy a home without a room for my MIL?

312 replies

Mastmw7g · 06/07/2023 03:23

We're buying a home and I was excited, then DH told MIL that all the bedrooms will be upstairs and she said she can't walk upstairs to sleep. My parents said something similar-- that my stepfather has knee problems that make navigating stairs difficult. I was so excited before but now I feel downtrodden that our families don't share our excitement.

OP posts:
wutheringkites · 06/07/2023 11:43

So again, it’s about you. Not about family. I think I’m understanding the modern British mindset now.

China has one of the lowest birth rates in the world at the moment. Sounds like young people there aren't thinking about family much these days

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 06/07/2023 11:41

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:35

What Chinese stereotypes? That we care for those who raised us? I thought that should be a given for every culture.

You’re not a great advert for modern British culture if that’s your cold response. Families come first.

In my culture, kids come first. We work hard to help them become independent and successful adults, we don't have ridiculous expectations of them sacrificing everything to look after us, and plonk 100 of thousands out of thin air to buy a bigger home.

Each to their own.

My Chinese brother-in-Law and his siblings have never shared any of your ridiculously dramatic comments, and they are still a very close family. Despite the excessive covid restrictions that have affected China harder and longer than people realise.

kingtamponthefurred · 06/07/2023 11:39

Meanwhile, back in the real world, most households in the UK don't have a dedicated spare room at all, let alone downstairs.

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:38

ChocBananaSmoothie · 06/07/2023 11:36

Glad you can manage that. I can't sleep on a floor.

So again, it’s about you. Not about family. I think I’m understanding the modern British mindset now.

Sad.

ManateeFair · 06/07/2023 11:37

Sugarspiceallthingsnice2 · 06/07/2023 07:26

Stair lift

I don't think putting in a stairlift that will be in use for one week per year is actually a proportionate response to this issue either

ChocBananaSmoothie · 06/07/2023 11:36

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:32

I can sleep in the floor. Why would I not want to spend every precious moment with those whom I adore?

Glad you can manage that. I can't sleep on a floor.

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:35

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 06/07/2023 11:32

give us a break with your Chinese stereotypes will you.

Maybe the elders should have provided the kids with a better education, better opportunities allowing them to finance a big enough house to offer en-suite guests room convenient to meet their expectations?

What Chinese stereotypes? That we care for those who raised us? I thought that should be a given for every culture.

You’re not a great advert for modern British culture if that’s your cold response. Families come first.

wutheringkites · 06/07/2023 11:35

@FluffyFlannery

You are being a touch dramatic.

For what it's worth, I really like my PIL and would like them to visit more often, but the journey is a challenge for them.

Instead, I happily fly to their country as often as we can manage it and sleep on the worst sofa bed known to man so my son can see them regularly.

But if they had tried to make us feel bad about our choice of house after the immense struggle we'd had to get it, I would have thought a lot less of them.

happyfoot · 06/07/2023 11:34

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:28

Putting your own parents in a hotel? Never!

Why? other people have explained what the housing situation is like and the cost involved of adaptations which they would have to pay themselves as the council wouldnt. People on this thread are acting as if its easy to just rustle up thousands of pounds when the cost of buying a house in the first place is very expensive. Of course people love their parents but love doesnt allow you to buy whatever it is you want, that takes money unfortunately. Love goes both ways surely and maybe the parents can contribute if the OP is struggling on her budget to find something that suits them too, surely that would be the most loving thing all round- mutual compromise from all involved

BashfulClam · 06/07/2023 11:33

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:29

I just feel the love 🤦‍♀️

There is a massive backstory about the manipulative, sly old boot but I’ll leave that. Would you let your MIL dictate how you should decorate a room in your home?

ManateeFair · 06/07/2023 11:32

user1492757084 · 06/07/2023 05:16

Consider wether there is enough room for yourself to sleep and bathe downstairs should you be recovering from knee surgery etc.

I think the 99% of homeowners whose bedrooms and bathroom are upstairs probably manage OK

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 06/07/2023 11:32

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:27

our parents would certainly never make demands but as their children, we would ensure we did the right thing by them. Each situation is different I know, but I’m appalled at the harshness of the responses as if parents are non-entities and mean nothing. I’m just so grateful to be Chinese when I read all of them. What I’m reading is inhumane. If you think so little if family, why continue the line? I just hope the children of these posters show more humility and responsibility to their elders when they (the posters) reach their dotage.

give us a break with your Chinese stereotypes will you.

Maybe the elders should have provided the kids with a better education, better opportunities allowing them to finance a big enough house to offer en-suite guests room convenient to meet their expectations?

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:32

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 06/07/2023 11:29

then give them your bedroom and go in the hotel yourself, or stay with friends nearby.

Works too.

I can sleep in the floor. Why would I not want to spend every precious moment with those whom I adore?

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:30

Netcam · 06/07/2023 11:15

I think your approach is very warm and caring and I do think we have a different attitude towards older people in this culture. I applaud you for this. But I also think there are generally not expectations to provide a guest room for elderly parents in this country and houses are not generally built with the idea in mind, particularly affordable ones. Most houses at the cheaper end of the market will not have a separate downstairs room or a full downstairs bathroom. So to find one would probably mean sacrificing other things you need in a house, or stretching your budget too much, or impossible based on affordability. I have always found it hard enough finding something affordable enough to meet our overall needs and a bedroom for each child. DS2 age 16 has had a tiny box room as his bedroom for most of his life and he is moving to DS1's bigger room as he is going to uni in September. But when he comes home in the holidays he will have a tiny box room. It is reality.

Thank you for the nicer response. I understand that. I really do. My gripe is about the posters here who seem to be devoid of any love or compassion for those that have raised them. It’s awful to read.

TheWalrusdidbeseech · 06/07/2023 11:29

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:28

Putting your own parents in a hotel? Never!

then give them your bedroom and go in the hotel yourself, or stay with friends nearby.

Works too.

Waterfallgirl · 06/07/2023 11:29

I cannot get over the fact that pp on here think that the op should choose a house (she and her DP pay for it) to accommodate PIL or Dparents who stay 2 weeks out of 52!
… or that they should of course put in a stair lift or buy an outdoor building.
Just crackers !

the cost of a stairlift or outdoor building would far exceed the cost of a few nights in a premier inn or a sofa bed in the dining room or whatever.

Plus last time I looked 99% of homes have bedrooms upstairs - where are all these properties with downstairs bedrooms that the op has to fork out extra (30/40k?) for anyway?

OP don’t let them take the shine off your new house .

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:29

BashfulClam · 06/07/2023 11:17

Sounds a bit like my MIL, I use the spare room as an office since Covid. She didn’t like that there was a desk and computer in ‘her room’. She stays once a year at Christmas, we nipped that this year with DH taking her home at 10.30pm (it’s a ten minute drive). It’s certainly not and will never be ‘her room’, she also wanted to choose the decor..

I just feel the love 🤦‍♀️

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:28

happyfoot · 06/07/2023 11:23

I agree. Putting in a walk in shower etc and making adaptations will cost £££ and I presume they arent going to contribute to that! Surely it would be far cheaper all round for them to stay nearby

Putting your own parents in a hotel? Never!

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 11:27

wutheringkites · 06/07/2023 10:56

I’m pretty appalled that the responses here are all about me, myself and I.

Op currently lives in a small flat with kids. We were in that same situation a couple of years ago and my absolute priority was giving my son a better home, with outdoor space and near good schools. I moved away from my home city so I could provide this for him.

My PIL wouldn't have dreamed of making demands of us about our decision of house - they understood that we had saved for a decade to get there and still made some life changing compromises.

our parents would certainly never make demands but as their children, we would ensure we did the right thing by them. Each situation is different I know, but I’m appalled at the harshness of the responses as if parents are non-entities and mean nothing. I’m just so grateful to be Chinese when I read all of them. What I’m reading is inhumane. If you think so little if family, why continue the line? I just hope the children of these posters show more humility and responsibility to their elders when they (the posters) reach their dotage.

happyfoot · 06/07/2023 11:23

BMW6 · 06/07/2023 07:25

I'm confused - why can't they simply stay in a nearby hotel or B&B???

Obviously they can visit your home in the day, you have a downstairs loo, then at night they go to the accommodation to wash and sleep.

What's so wrong with that?

I agree. Putting in a walk in shower etc and making adaptations will cost £££ and I presume they arent going to contribute to that! Surely it would be far cheaper all round for them to stay nearby

BashfulClam · 06/07/2023 11:17

Sounds a bit like my MIL, I use the spare room as an office since Covid. She didn’t like that there was a desk and computer in ‘her room’. She stays once a year at Christmas, we nipped that this year with DH taking her home at 10.30pm (it’s a ten minute drive). It’s certainly not and will never be ‘her room’, she also wanted to choose the decor..

thehoneymonster · 06/07/2023 11:16

BadNomad · 06/07/2023 09:56

I can't believe people are seriously suggesting a stair lift for the sake of 2 visitors.

Mind you, my grandad had one when I was little and I loved slow-mo going up the stairs on it. Cumbersome thing though.

People on Mumsnet are crackers

Netcam · 06/07/2023 11:15

FluffyFlannery · 06/07/2023 10:38

Surprised by the responses. Your parents are family. If you love and care about them then of course it would matter to you that they can’t use the stairs. When we bought our place, husband and I made sure there was a spare guest room downstairs for my mother. We don’t believe in having hardened hearts towards those who took care of us growing up. But we’re Chinese and family comes first.

I think your approach is very warm and caring and I do think we have a different attitude towards older people in this culture. I applaud you for this. But I also think there are generally not expectations to provide a guest room for elderly parents in this country and houses are not generally built with the idea in mind, particularly affordable ones. Most houses at the cheaper end of the market will not have a separate downstairs room or a full downstairs bathroom. So to find one would probably mean sacrificing other things you need in a house, or stretching your budget too much, or impossible based on affordability. I have always found it hard enough finding something affordable enough to meet our overall needs and a bedroom for each child. DS2 age 16 has had a tiny box room as his bedroom for most of his life and he is moving to DS1's bigger room as he is going to uni in September. But when he comes home in the holidays he will have a tiny box room. It is reality.

thehoneymonster · 06/07/2023 11:15

bridgetreilly · 06/07/2023 08:34

@thehoneymonster My parents considered exactly that plus a whole host of other scenarios so that they could be sure the home they moved into about 20 years ago would be as future proofed as possible. It was a VERY good thing to have done.

It is not that common when house hunting to consider what might happen if you randomly need knee surgery and need a temporary downstairs bedroom.

thehoneymonster · 06/07/2023 11:11

thehoneymonster
Who even considers this when buying a house?!

I did, but I am older and have an adult child with disabilities. One reception room could be a permanent bedroom and there is a downstairs shower room. I wouldn't want to live in a house without a downstairs loo either.However the situation here isn't the same and the parents should just take themselves off to a hotel for their visit.


Obviously an elderly person or someone with a physical disability will consider the layout and accessibility of the home they are buying, to suit their needs.

But buying a house based on the needs of a very rare overnight visitor is bonkers.