Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy a home without a room for my MIL?

312 replies

Mastmw7g · 06/07/2023 03:23

We're buying a home and I was excited, then DH told MIL that all the bedrooms will be upstairs and she said she can't walk upstairs to sleep. My parents said something similar-- that my stepfather has knee problems that make navigating stairs difficult. I was so excited before but now I feel downtrodden that our families don't share our excitement.

OP posts:
concertgoer · 07/07/2023 07:00

Mastmw7g · 06/07/2023 05:44

They each visit twice a year, for about a week at a time. I'll research sofa beds for MIL. My stepfather likes privacy and the only private rooms are upstairs.

Near by hotel rooms would provide privacy!
there’s a travelodge at the end of our road. It is a great facility for guests! 😂

Boymum1005 · 07/07/2023 05:59

If they’re not contributing financially they don’t get an opinion.

if they’re providing a hefty deposit they probably do feel entitled to a say. However it’s still rude of them.

TBH it would be reason enough for me to go ahead and buy - if it meant my MIL COULDN’T stay the night 😂

ChocBananaSmoothie · 07/07/2023 03:30

Astsjakksmso · 07/07/2023 03:23

What rubbish.
It's great that you have enough money and somewhere stable to stay so you can 'continue to search'. Not everyone can. Doesn't mean they don't value their family! You cannot be 'thoughtful and kind' if you just can't afford it.

Exactly. And sometimes how kind and thoughtful we are about these things reflects how much kindness and thoughtfulness we got as children about this sort of thing.

Like some previous OP's, my parents insist on separate rooms and beds from each other. My mother can't handle my father's snoring. When I was a child I had to suck up being kicked out of my room for weeks on end for guests and was told to deal with it and I had no rights as I didn't pay for the home. When we went on holiday I had to share with two snorers and my parents thought it was hilarious that they kept me up all night and laughed at me. So now I say, suck it up, deal with it, you have no rights, it's my home. Actually I never say it, but if you raise me with the idea that you just have to suck up discomfort as a person who doesn't pay for the property, don't complain when it comes back at you.

Astsjakksmso · 07/07/2023 03:25

Also @Delectable @FluffyFlannery I'm from an Asian culture that values multigenerational living and actually If our parents wanted us to consider them they'd give us money for renovating.

They wouldn't just expect us to find a space. That would be Dishonoroable quite frankly

Astsjakksmso · 07/07/2023 03:23

Delectable · 06/07/2023 13:19

OP, many posters on Mumsnet are kinder to pets than humans.
Only you know the values you uphold in your family.
If you value relatives irrespective of age and multi-generational family ties then consider if you wish to continue searching. However be mindful the UK places little value on humans in old age so houses aren't build with the flexibility of a bedroom and shower room on the ground floor.
I'm facing a similar difficulty, looking for a house we can accommodate older relatives on the ground floor. It's only human to take care of, be responsible for, thoughtful and kind to one's family members especially the vulnerable ones.

What rubbish.
It's great that you have enough money and somewhere stable to stay so you can 'continue to search'. Not everyone can. Doesn't mean they don't value their family! You cannot be 'thoughtful and kind' if you just can't afford it.

SquigglyGum · 07/07/2023 02:43

I've had this with my own parents. My mum refuses to share a room with my dad (her husband!), so will expect to take up two beds (including linen) and two rooms if they stay. It's unbelievable. My dad likes to sleep on the sofa outside so often does that in the warmer months (we're not in UK, it's not quite as crazy as it sounds). When we did live in the UK we did include a downstairs toilet and shower as part of a renovation, to accommodate her, along with hiring a stair lift for the duration of her stay. She complained that the shower cubicle was too small. You cannot win.

I guess what I'm saying is buy the house you want to live in, research local accommodation options for over night visitors, and enjoy yourfreedom from hosting!

Sceptre86 · 06/07/2023 23:59

Get a stairlift, another option is a starlit downstairs. They make it work for as long as they can and then it becomes the norm for you to visit them.

LovePoppy · 06/07/2023 23:27

this is your house. Not theirs.

I might look into a Murphy bed of you wanted to set up a proper bed for them

Tinkerbyebye · 06/07/2023 19:16

You buy the house you want

they want to stay they can sleep in the lounge on, a bed settee, or get a air BnB

I8toys · 06/07/2023 19:14

Give them a list of nearest hotels?

strawberry2017 · 06/07/2023 19:13

This is your home, you cannot make decisions based on people who will spend 4 weeks out of 52 in it and what they want.
Yes they are family and of course you want to see them but you have to prioritise your families needs not there's.

YappyCamper · 06/07/2023 18:31

Coralsunset · 06/07/2023 05:04

I am pretty anti social and would call this a result OP.

Definitely buy the house that suits you, not overnight guests.

100%

Kugela · 06/07/2023 18:18

Some of the replies on this thread are very strange! I’m disabled with mobility issues so when I visit my DC and DGC I always stay in an accessible hotel room nearby. It means that I avoid moving anyone out of their usual bed and don’t need to worry about climbing narrow stairs or navigating awkward bathrooms.

I’m from a very loving, close family but wouldn’t dream of expecting my DCs to choose their home based on my needs.

@Mastmw7g I hope all goes well with your move to a new home and you have many happy years living there.

stayathomer · 06/07/2023 17:55

They sort of do, as using the relevant joints and muscles is the best way to speed up their recovery.
it would depend on the injury and age of the person- mil and dm were both asked did they live in bungalows as they were told they’d find stairs very difficult (mil had knee replacement, dm didn’t). A flight of stairs is a huge thing for someone recovering to manage

Sugarfree23 · 06/07/2023 17:46

Op that sounds like a good solution for your parents. When it's just the child that's in the bed I'd have it against the wall the way you would with a single.

The MIL sounds like it's much more problematic for her esp as she doesn't go upstairs in her own house. I think the only sensible solution there is to use the nearest travel lodge, probably cheaper than Air BnB.

But if her mobility is really that poor she may well struggle to visit regardless of your housing situation.

Madrid67 · 06/07/2023 15:30

If your parents don't have any particular health issues I don't see why they can't go upstairs at 73!

You say your mother in law is 59 with health problems do they actually stop her climbing steps? If so when she visits it might be better for her to stay on a hotel or a AirBnB.
Most houses have bedrooms upstairs and many don't have downstairs toilets either.
Enjoy your new home and don't let others make you question your decision. It's sounds the right move for your immediate family.

LancreWowhawk · 06/07/2023 15:28

Hi, OP - when DH and I stopped planning our house around guests who stay with us for a combined total of fewer than 20 nights a year, we suddenly started to unlock ways to use the space that are so, so much better for us. Go for it!

wutheringkites · 06/07/2023 15:05

Great to value family relationships and find solutions instead of the majority of saying sod them.

Well if op had asked if it's reasonable for them to want help with their bags and to stay in the most convenient room then I think the responses might have been different. Hmm

NamelessNancy · 06/07/2023 15:02

It sounds to me like buying this property will improve the lives of the op's children 52 weeks of the year. The idea from some that they should wait or overspend to prioritise the parents' needs for a couple of weeks a year is incomprehensible to me. I would hate for my kids to do that. We choose to have our children so imo they should be our number one priority.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 06/07/2023 14:50

Lovely OP, all about communication and what you're happy doing as a couple.

Great that you have a good relationship and can talk openly with both sets of parents.

@Delectable has said it well.

Great to value family relationships and find solutions instead of the majority of saying sod them.

diddl · 06/07/2023 14:17

It's good that your parents are willing to try.

If there's a downstairs toilet then they don't need to be up & down stairs more than once a day.

Obviously for MIL that won't work.

You can't buy a house for other people.

Perhaps instead of being annoyed she should be pleased that she has been able to stay up until now & not have to pay for a hotel/b&b.

diddl · 06/07/2023 13:49

Rinkydinkydink · 06/07/2023 08:33

They might,I’ve in a Bungalow.

I hadn't thought of that🙄

Delectable · 06/07/2023 13:19

OP, many posters on Mumsnet are kinder to pets than humans.
Only you know the values you uphold in your family.
If you value relatives irrespective of age and multi-generational family ties then consider if you wish to continue searching. However be mindful the UK places little value on humans in old age so houses aren't build with the flexibility of a bedroom and shower room on the ground floor.
I'm facing a similar difficulty, looking for a house we can accommodate older relatives on the ground floor. It's only human to take care of, be responsible for, thoughtful and kind to one's family members especially the vulnerable ones.

wutheringkites · 06/07/2023 12:56

All sounds very reasonable op!

GoodChat · 06/07/2023 12:53

Sounds like the perfect solution!

Swipe left for the next trending thread