Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy a home without a room for my MIL?

312 replies

Mastmw7g · 06/07/2023 03:23

We're buying a home and I was excited, then DH told MIL that all the bedrooms will be upstairs and she said she can't walk upstairs to sleep. My parents said something similar-- that my stepfather has knee problems that make navigating stairs difficult. I was so excited before but now I feel downtrodden that our families don't share our excitement.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Feedthatgoat · 08/07/2023 16:43

I am 73 and have a torn miniscus in my knee but I manage to get up and down my stairs. I take my time and hold on really tight when coming down. Take no notice of them its your house enjoy it.

NickyT64 · 08/07/2023 12:54

Mastmw7g · 06/07/2023 12:37

My parents do not have stairs in their home. They're 73, so they are older.

My MIL is only 59, but has a lot of health issues so my parents are actually more mobile. She does not go upstairs in her home. FIL is 58 and has no problem going up and down stairs.

We could visit them more. That would solve this. It's time and money. I should let them know we'll have more money to visit now that we're not saving to buy a house.

Stairlift???

Likewhatever · 08/07/2023 09:46

Reading your updates OP I think it’s not unreasonable for both sets of parents to mention their limitations. I wish I’d been more considerate of my parents’ mobility issues when I was younger, you only appreciate them when they start affecting you personally.

I don’t think they should dictate how you resolve the issues, but it’s helpful to know about them in advance so you can think of a solution you’re happy with. If they only visit for a few weeks a year, would one of the DC be prepared to decamp temporarily to a different room for the duration?

hettie · 08/07/2023 09:43

I'm surprised to hear those advocating OP buys a different house so that she can "be kind" to elderly relatives who visit infrequently. Housing costs are a serious intergenerational issue, anyone under 40 has much much less choice and frankly many simply can't afford to accommodate accessible spare rooms. It's madness to even consider.
But the house you need for your family op, relatives can rent a nearby Airbnb or get a hotel room unless they are offering to pay the massive costs associated with an extra downstairs bedroom

RidingMyBike · 08/07/2023 09:36

A sofa bed doesn’t really work for many older people, especially if they’ve developed mobility problems. So we didn’t go down the sofa bed route.

RidingMyBike · 08/07/2023 09:35

You buy a house for the people who will be living in it, not for guests. Yes, it can be nice if you can accommodate them (if you want to!) but, especially when they reach the stage when mobility is a problem, you just can’t. We have done this but the house is really close to a fully accessible chain hotel which is far better and safer for visitors with mobility problems. Ground floor room, wet room style shower with grab rails etc.

Dibbydoos · 08/07/2023 07:41

Sofa bed in the lounge, though I suspect all bathrooms are upstairs too....

Sugarfree23 · 07/07/2023 21:34

While sofa beds might be comfy, most are far lower than a standard bed, which makes it more difficult for someone with mobility issues to get in and out off.

However I think the most logical solution for MIL is a local hotel. Most will have rooms suitable for disabled access with extra grab rails on the shower etc Bed at a suitable height.

Take her back at bedtime and collect her in the morning.

Shimmeringshadow · 07/07/2023 21:16

Could you build a cabin in the garden which they could sleep in? Just a thought 🤔

ScotsBluebell · 07/07/2023 20:26

There are some really nasty posts on here. (Not talking about OP here, because it was a reasonable question but some of the responses are horrible!) I can only assume some of you hate your parents and in-laws and never ask them for help with anything? Sometimes disability creeps up on you, or arrives unexpectedly and it's often sooner than you think! We're getting on a bit, but can manage stairs. I can still run up them, DH crawls due to severe disabilities, but gets there. Downstairs sofa beds are pretty comfy these days. My only proviso to anyone buying a house, young, old and everything in between, would be to look for or install a downstairs loo and basin - An extra shower is nice, but it's not essential. An extra loo - even if you've got young kids - is a godsend.

Jeannie88 · 07/07/2023 19:59

When younger and my parents able wouldn't have crossed my mind but now I would try to accommodate. Not as in buy a different house but make a comfortable sleeping area downstairs and make them feel welcome. Of course, if we had them all with us we would be elated to have this dilemma because when they've gone and you realise you don't have to think about these issues it hits hard! Please cherish your parents and appreciate they are getting older os almost I can say. X

Likewhatever · 07/07/2023 19:15

Comfy sofa bed or hotel, OP. Perfectly workable solutions.

laylababe5 · 07/07/2023 19:07

Could you use one of the downstairs rooms as a guest bedroom? Maybe you have a small second sitting room that would work if you put in a couch cum bed? Or if you have a decent sized garden and the budget you could build a summer house/guest room?

lookingforchangenowww · 07/07/2023 18:44

Mastmw7g · 06/07/2023 03:48

They do visit, that's why they all were disappointed.

I suppose that’s a good thing then, which means they can visit but not stay over ? 😆
I would never buy a house thinking about visits to be honest

FootieMama · 07/07/2023 18:37

I bought a house with a extra livingroom that can double as guest room downstairs. Its very convenient.

TedEsMum · 07/07/2023 18:08

DH needs to intercede here and tell his mum that she is welcome to stay over occasionally, but the rooms are for you and your DH, and the kids.

pollymere · 07/07/2023 18:00

We bought a sofa that was also a bed. My IL have slept happily in our sitting room. I do have a downstairs bathroom though. But if it's just for one night, they don't need a shower.

PinkFootstool · 07/07/2023 16:50

sueelleker · 07/07/2023 16:19

I had a TKR, and also managed stairs.

I'm sure some people manage beautifully, but mobility isn't binary.

By way of example):
One of my parents has osteoporosis and has had multiple fractures to the legs including femur, hip replacements and knee replacement before 70yo. Add on years worth of fractures to the spine and they are very bent over and have uneven leg lengths from poorly healed breaks and multiple surgeries, let alone pain issues.

Another parent needs a hip replacement (probably both actually) and is currently stubbornly refusing surgery. Also has shoulder issues linked with trying to rely on crutches and years of doing all the physical help and care of the other parent.

Both require walking aids, both struggle to haul themselves up the stairs using the bannisters, and both would struggle to sit down onto the stairs let alone stand up at the end if they went up and down the stairs on their bums.

Just because your own mobility and the surgery allows you to do things, doesn't mean everyone will have the same experience....

Reduced mobility is very common and stairs may well be the nemesis of many!

sueelleker · 07/07/2023 16:19

Battytriker · 07/07/2023 08:59

My husband has chronic arthritis, now has had 2 full knee replacements and has always slept upstairs. The first few days he went up and down on his bum, not terribly dignified but not impossible either!

I had a TKR, and also managed stairs.

ChocBananaSmoothie · 07/07/2023 12:39

Manthide · 07/07/2023 12:28

Dd2's Chinese MiL has bought houses for each of her 3 children for upwards of £1 million each. Dd2 and her dh are renovating their house with some of the monies not used in their original purchase. I don't think MiL is getting involved in this though I expect dd2 will have a guest room with ensuite for visitors (upstairs).

If my mother or MIL want to buy me a house and have that kind of budget, it seems quite reasonable to ensure there is a space for them to stay when they visit.

Manthide · 07/07/2023 12:28

ChocBananaSmoothie · 06/07/2023 11:53

Agree. And I hate to get on the 'Chinese thing' because I don't like to stereotype, but I've also noticed a lot of Chinese parents seem to buy their children houses as a gift. My parents aren't doing that.

Dd2's Chinese MiL has bought houses for each of her 3 children for upwards of £1 million each. Dd2 and her dh are renovating their house with some of the monies not used in their original purchase. I don't think MiL is getting involved in this though I expect dd2 will have a guest room with ensuite for visitors (upstairs).

Fourfurrymonsters · 07/07/2023 12:14

Mastmw7g · 06/07/2023 05:44

They each visit twice a year, for about a week at a time. I'll research sofa beds for MIL. My stepfather likes privacy and the only private rooms are upstairs.

Then they can go and stay in a hotel.

Manthide · 07/07/2023 12:12

I think a downstairs toilet is essential for visiting elders but a downstairs bedroom. They wouldn't like dd2's flat as the living room is upstairs!

readingbluecat32 · 07/07/2023 09:33

I worried about this - as my parents are quite elderly (mum is 73, dad is 89 this year). All our bedrooms are up stairs and my dad lives in spain so only comes 1/2 a year. He manages just to go upstairs the one time for bed and one time to come down in morning, as we have bathroom on bottom floor - once he is down for the day no more stairs.
if he gets too old and can’t do stairs we will invest in a sofa bed or blow up mattress.
i have 2 kids under 3 so sadly can’t make sacrifice for my parents when I need to prioritise the kids. This will be our family/ forever home - whereas to be harsh, my parents won’t, so have to make the decision for the needs of the kids for next few decades!

Battytriker · 07/07/2023 08:59

My husband has chronic arthritis, now has had 2 full knee replacements and has always slept upstairs. The first few days he went up and down on his bum, not terribly dignified but not impossible either!