Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - only one without a desk

233 replies

Nurse1980 · 05/07/2023 23:35

Hi,

I recently returned to work following an episode of sickness.

We all had our own desk in the office (including myself). I’ve come back, and a six month temporary member of staff is now at the desk that was mine.

So Im having to use a laptop and sit at a filing cabinet, as I’ve no desk. I’m also disadvantaged as our job is much easier with two screens (all desks have two screens).

I’ve brought it up with my manager and was told that she was working on it.

I’m not sure if I’m overreacting (been off with stress and PTSD) and just finished my phased return. So I’m more sensitive than normal perhaps?

OP posts:
Rinkydinkydink · 07/07/2023 10:00

When I returned from maternity a new member of staff had been given my desk and computer.
I ended up with no computer ( architect so had no way of doing any drawings, accessing any drawings or in fact doing anything ) sitting in the kitchen next to the toilet four flights down from my colleagues. My boss was in the room next door, the level above was all storage, the level above that the secretaries then architects and draughtsmen on the top floor.
The plan, of course, was to make my life hell. They obviously didn’t want to employ a women with 8month old twins and a 3year old.

Gave me a chance to read the Harry Potter series though, at their expense.

viques · 07/07/2023 09:58

OP it would be awful if that laptop accidentally fell off the filing cabinet wouldn’t it?

readingrocks · 07/07/2023 09:56

This seems like bullying and is worse as you are coming back after sick leave. I think you need to escalate it and ask for a workplace assessment. Also keep a daily record of your working arrangements and a timeline of your interactions with your boss and what has (or has not) been promised. Take a photo of the filing cabinet and your so-called work station. If you are the only person who does not have space to use two screens then that also needs mentioning.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 07/07/2023 09:43

I'm public sector. We've been hot-desking for about 15 years. All staff are trained on DSE - either via video, or with a trainer coming in to see individuals. All desks have moveable monitors, vertical and normal mice, office chairs with lots of flexibility and footrests. We also have a bank of about 9 standing desks. Everyone has a locker too for their stuff. Works ok!

Appleofmyeye2023 · 07/07/2023 09:35

lunar1 · 06/07/2023 18:24

I'd go to the gp and get signed off until I had a desk and chair. This would give me serious back pain

Yep, this is other way to go.
get a doctors certificate to show that you are experiencing musculoskeletal issues specifically related to work station and that you don’t have ability to change it.
but, I’d only go that way after an EHS risk assessment is done, or if they refuse or delay doing that immediately.

user1471538283 · 07/07/2023 09:34

This is a way to make you feel so uncomfortable you leave.

But you need to put your foot down. Contact the Union as this is against health and safety, tell your line manager that until a desk is sorted you will either be working from home or off sick as this is making you more stressed. This is their problem to solve.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 07/07/2023 09:32

Nurse1980 · 06/07/2023 22:49

I’ll be having words, it’s my day off tomorrow so I’ll be speaking to my manager.

We need two screens to work effectively (everyone else has two screens), it will take me forever to pick it up on a laptop.

Insist on a EHS risk assessment. Make sure they document that you can’t do your job without 2 screens and er, that’s why everyone normally is issued with 2 screens.
don’t do this informally by the manager. They already know the situation. We’ve quoted law at you (me and others), insisting on a formal written risk assessment
that way they know you know your rights

Appleofmyeye2023 · 07/07/2023 09:28

Ragged · 07/07/2023 07:37

All desks are standing desks? Wow.

Public sector doesn't have resources like that.
I seem to remember that in late 2021 we got a training video on setting up home environment to avoid RSI-back ache risk. Or maybe it was early 2022.

I could add a lot of details, either my jobs or a close friend in last 4 years: anecdotes about NHS & civil service (get one laptop & charger, nothing else ), county council (best equipped, had own dock stations at home, even! before 2020), universities (staff buy & use their own laptops / desktops a lot, likely no employer-provided equipment at all for WFH) etc.

This is interesting and I wonder if it’s to do with a larger female workforce that don’t want to push on issues because that’s the way we’re socialised

But, I think the biggest difference is that i worked in private manufacturing - global company. Whilst not all desks were sit-stand there were zones you could go to with your laptop to do standing for a while, and in certain jobs where you were essentially glued to the desk they were sit /stand.
we all had metal case ergonomics chairs. When they were issued in early 2000s we all got an individual visit by EHSteam to show us how to adjust the chair.
Each year we had to complete a self assessment on our seating and desk arrangement and do the mandatory training on how to sit properly, managing lighting, movement etc. in USA they even installed a programme that stopped any key strokes for 2 mins every 20mins to force people to move . I’m retired now, but still use ergonomic chair for my hobbies and always take time to adjust my position correctly for task I’m doing - still use those basic rules of how your posture should be supported by chair, position of your screen etc.

but our company was a FTSE Index company. They weren’t going to take any risks of one person claiming work place injuries - it would have opened up cans of worms for others to follow . All those desks and chairs for 40,000 employees worldwide (ok quite a lot of those didn’t need desks all day) couldn’t have come cheap - but they weren’t going to risk it.

so the big difference between our company and companies that don’t seem to get the importance of this, is a “safety” culture. In manufacturing you have a real possibility of someone being killed or having life changing injuries if PPE isn’t used and procedures followed. And that didn’t stop at shop floor - they knew, as most do in these industries, you can’t have one attitude on shop floor of factories, and another in the offices. We had huge amounts of safety training each year, office ergonomics and slips/trips training was a part of that.

Public bodies obviously think they can get away with it as there just probably isn’t that focus on personal health and safety re ergonomics except in fire - I wonder whether the attitude to office space is different there? Ok, police and ambulance probably also have personal safety- but perhaps not same ergonomics focus as fire? (Someone can probably enlighten me?) Without a safety culture these things are just not perceived as important. And there’s probably not that awareness , like the poster, that there are laws to protect the health and safety of individuals at work in respect to ergonomics. As employees we had a lot of exposure to the law regarding our responsibilities to “duty of care” (near miss reporting etc ) , so in turn we did get to see what the companies duty was to us in turn .

Thebirdhouse · 07/07/2023 09:27

Anna79ishere · 07/07/2023 08:47

This is terrible. So the manager at the time knew and they did not do a thing? They knew how difficult it must have been and still made it happen? There are loads of terrible people around and they are one. they should be feeling humiliated and I would have told them so.

Yes she knew. She was a weak manager and would never have stood up for her team.

I was a diligent worker and perhaps they knew (before I did) that a young baby meant less likelihood of staying late which was the norm in that dept.

It’s hard to be the person targeted as it’s embarrassing when everyone else knows and can see what’s happening.

In the same dept. somebody was later told to work in the corridor as there wasn’t room for her desk in the main office. They actually put her working in the corridor outside the door. The poor woman ended up in tears and had a breakdown.

It was full of mini managers who were promoted because they were the type of people who let ‘power’ go to their heads and got satisfaction from treating people appallingly or were weak - the common factor was both types were happy to act as puppets having their strings pulled by the puppet masters (higher Mgt). The place attracted a certain personality and in the end anyone who had any principles left.

Ragged · 07/07/2023 09:25

How long would the H&SE ringing authorities contacting the union etc. take? I'm guessing that those complaint processes take MONTHS to play out.

Not sure OP has said how long she is back at work, but also says she is new to the Trust (so probably new to this admin team and not clear how much notice they had that she was turning up), that a desk has been procured now.

skyeisthelimit · 07/07/2023 09:19

If you have returned from sickness and now don't have the same equipment as everyone else, then surely that is discrimination? It is hardly likely to help you manage your stress.

Even with a laptop they can provide a wireless mouse and keyboard for starters.

Take it up with HR if your manager won't do anything, but it sounds extremely unfair.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/07/2023 09:16

If it continues, an you are forced to leave, you could go down the constructive dismissal route. But get EVERYTHING documented.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/07/2023 09:11

Appleofmyeye2023 · 07/07/2023 09:06

This is a health and safety issue. Ergonomics. Talk to HR.
First ask them to conduct a menadatory health and safety assessment immediately. So it’s on record . Id be giving them a deadline of 48 hours to get your desk to sit at ANYWHERE in the company as a temporary measure- even the bloody HR office. Someone can go out to an office supplier and pick up a cheap office table, jeez I bought one in IKEA for £6o recently.
if they don’t comply within 48 hours raise a grievance.

law is
https://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/books/hsg57.htm

This is excellent advice.

H&S is definitely the only route to go if our manager isn't helping.

And it's a genuine route, too - your long-term health could be seriously affected.

user1492757084 · 07/07/2023 09:08

The Manager said that she was working on it.
Have you given her a few days to sort it? It might be hard to source an appropriate desk and screens.
Just do your best (you can do no better than that) and ask every few days. Move your file and screen to a nice position near a window.
After about two weeks I would be asking the Manager if it would help for you to talk directly with HR.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 07/07/2023 09:06

Nurse1980 · 05/07/2023 23:48

Hi, no I haven’t spoken to HR. Only my manager.

There isn’t an option to work from home.

It’s little things, like I’ve nowhere to keep my belongings so they are stored in a box file.

This is a health and safety issue. Ergonomics. Talk to HR.
First ask them to conduct a menadatory health and safety assessment immediately. So it’s on record . Id be giving them a deadline of 48 hours to get your desk to sit at ANYWHERE in the company as a temporary measure- even the bloody HR office. Someone can go out to an office supplier and pick up a cheap office table, jeez I bought one in IKEA for £6o recently.
if they don’t comply within 48 hours raise a grievance.

law is
https://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/books/hsg57.htm

Seating at work - HSG57

Very specific guidance on how to ensure workplace seating is safe and suitable for all

https://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/books/hsg57.htm

Kpcs · 07/07/2023 08:52

I think this has been done deliberately to make it uncomfortable for you at work and prompt you to leave.

Anna79ishere · 07/07/2023 08:47

Thebirdhouse · 06/07/2023 00:19

This happened to me when I came back from maternity leave too. Tbh it felt like they did it on purpose and singled me out. I left that dept shortly afterwards as I felt very uncomfortable about how I was being treated. The manager at the time, spoke to me a couple of years later, (by this time I was in a different dept), and she mentioned how hard it must have been for me when I returned from mat leave and brought up the desk situation and I got the impression it had been done deliberately.

Thats a long time ago now but I still feel a mix of humiliation and sadness when I think back to it.

This is terrible. So the manager at the time knew and they did not do a thing? They knew how difficult it must have been and still made it happen? There are loads of terrible people around and they are one. they should be feeling humiliated and I would have told them so.

Icannot · 07/07/2023 08:34

I work from a laptop with a monitor attached as my second screen, could this work for you? I have my screens above and below one another.

elizaagain · 07/07/2023 08:25

Another point - given that it sounds as if they are trying to get you to "resign of your own free will (apparently)" and that IS a public sector trick. Be prepared for them to try other things to also try pushing you. One thing that comes to mind is the "gossip machine" - there's always one or two that will gossip or bully if it's hinted at them that that is what management would like. One deliberate "gossip" was fat and pretty toothless and so I would pretend not to hear her accidentally-on-purpose gossiping about me loud enough for me to hear as I walked past and then later pointedly look at her figure up and down and her teeth very analytically (I was slim and have decent teeth). Another one would bully me by taking up a bit of workspace that was mine to use or accidentally on purpose walking towards me and accidentally brushing hard against me - and I had to find ways to deal with her too. Another one would put say a wastebin in my way on the floor (hoping I'd trip on it) and various other little bits and bobs (I went to higher management about him - and she told him to stop it). So be aware of nastier/more stupid members of staff that that particular manager may try and trigger against you and be ready to deal with them as well. Also there were times when I had to go to a higher management person when my own line manager was doing personal bullying (eg restricting me in ways that another member of staff on her team wasnt restricted - and the higher management person agreed with me and told her to stop it).

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 07/07/2023 08:05

I wouldn’t take the desk the temp is sitting at, I’d take the bosses and tell them to work on the filing cabinet if it’s so acceptable.

elizaagain · 07/07/2023 08:04

I can sympathise - as I had this done to me one time. I was pretty darn aware they were trying to get rid of me anyway - and it was just one of the things they did to try and make me "resign of my own free will" (apparently). As I recall - I just had to be very firm in my attitude - that I needed a desk of my own again/was used to having one/everyone else had one. What they did with me was put me at a succession of temporary desks (eg if someone was ill or something). As far as I recall - what got me back to having a desk of my own again was being very "firm" of making it plain I had long-term plans to stay in my job (ie was keeping my job till retirement - which I did), adjusting whatever was the latest "temporary" desk I was at to suit my own "health and safety" requirements (obviously that would put pressure on the real "owner" of that desk to put pressure on management that they didn't like their desk being constantly altered by me to suit me). I think it was basically the "health and safety" angle I played on as I recall and "Everyone else has a desk....I normally have a desk....why havent I got one?". Probably best for you to ask for a health and safety assessment - that should put pressure on them. Definitely make it very plain, in every way you can, that you ARE keeping the job however long you decide you will (ie you would be telling them in effect "It ain't no good you trying to make my life uncomfortable - I'm onto you - and it ain't happening" is the overall message you will be conveying.

LIZS · 07/07/2023 08:02

midgetastic · 07/07/2023 07:43

From memory DSE regulations may suggest that you should not be working at a laptop without a screen and keyboard

I doubt it , such is very common in remote and mobile workers if not ideal. What is required is a risk assessment of each workstation, often done by the individual, so that screen, desk, chair etc are at an appropriate height to avoid back and neck strain and lighting is adequate. Op could submit one demonstrating that it does not comply.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/07/2023 07:58

Zooeyzebra · 06/07/2023 00:09

Occupational Health and Safety risk. You need a desk with a correct height chair

A user's workstation furniture should minimise the risk of injuries. Posture also plays a vital role in preventing upper limb disorders.
Desk health and safetyThe work desk or work surface should:

  • be big enough to allow the user to arrange the screen, keyboard, documents, etc in a flexible way
  • have a matt surface
  • be big enough to let the user work comfortably and to change position
  • be stable and positioned so that it's comfortable and easy to use where an employee uses a document holder
Office chair health and safetyWorkstation chairs should:
  • be stable and allow the user to work comfortably
  • be adjustable in height
  • have a seatback adjustable in height and tilt
Other workstation considerationsOther features of the workstation you should consider include:
  • arm supports must not interfere with movement, eg by stopping the user getting the chair under the work surface
  • seat width should be wider than the hip width of the person using it
  • the back rest should provide support for the back in all sitting positions, particularly the lumbar region.
  • a foot rest may be needed if users are unable to rest their feet flat on the floor
  • the importance of correct and comfortable seating should be emphasised to employees in a risk assessment

This.

It's ridiculous not having a desk. You could end up with severe back, neck and shoulder problems - point this out to them. Are you not already feeling physical aches and pains related to this at the end of the day? Short term, you will recover, but long term they can become permanents and lead to severe disability

Are you in a union?

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 07/07/2023 07:56

dolol · 05/07/2023 23:49

You should be able to home work

Not everyone can work from home!

GreenMini · 07/07/2023 07:48

Aside from the physical practicalities of not having the right equipment to do your job, you'd think after a period off with stress they would want to make it as easy as possible for you mentally to come back. And this isn't it!

Swipe left for the next trending thread