Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be rude to this woman in an art gallery

391 replies

hengelian · 05/07/2023 22:22

I was in an exhibition in a large London gallery today, totally engrossed in the art works. I was staring at a painting and a woman interrupted me to ask me to take a photo of her in front of it.

I did it but I was quite off with her about it and probably a bit rude (said 'umm.. ok', took one photo and walked away, didn't ask her if it was OK etc).

I find it really rude that she interrupted me in an art gallery - to me this is like being interrupted in the middle of a movie at the cinema. I was experiencing a whole thought process which she dragged me out of so she could have a photo of a work she didn't even properly look at.

Art galleries aren't there for photos, they are there for you to look and experience.

AIBU?

OP posts:
catscalledbeanz · 06/07/2023 10:16

"totally engrossed in the art works. I was staring at a painting and a woman interrupted me to ask me to take a photo of her in front of it. " you were totally engrossed but seem to have full awareness of exactly how long the lady did or did not engage with the painting? She may too have been gazing at it a step behind you, only to come from her reverie to ask a fellow true lover of art to record her with the piece so she may always look back and remember how it impacted her?

You do seem to be policing how to "properly" appreciate art imo. It comes across as judgemental and condescending

Angelil · 06/07/2023 10:15

MarkWithaC · 06/07/2023 08:40

There’s an awful lot of inverse snobbery on here. It’s interesting how exercised some people are getting about someone looking at an artwork and having a thought process.

I was asked to take a pic for someone in a gallery recently, but I was very obviously not looking at the work; I was standing away from the paintings and putting my water bottle back in my bag. So I was happy to oblige. But I’d be mildly annoyed if I was looking at/thinking about/immersed in a work and someone asked me to take a picture. I don’t think that’s unreasonable.

I agree. There is trenchant anti-intellectualism in Britain which frankly is one of the (many) reasons why I left the country. Heaven forbid that someone should actually have a brain or use it…

Malarandras · 06/07/2023 10:13

I never take take photos of art in galleries as I would rather enjoy it in the moment. If other people want to it doesn’t bother me, as long as they aren’t blocking it for an unreasonable amount of time. I never see the need to be rude to people, unless they started out being unnecessarily rude to me. Even then I find over politeness works best as it unnerves them.

bruffin · 06/07/2023 10:11

kungfupannda · 06/07/2023 10:02

Bit of an overreaction to a minor interruption.

I think there's a bit of all of us that likes to feel as though we're doing something just a little bit better than people around us. I went to an immersive exhibition recently. It was intended just to fill in time as I had to be in the area, but I finished up enjoying it far more than I'd expected. I work in a creative field - not art - and one of the galleries turned out to be great for just sitting and letting my mind wander around a project I'm working on. I'm usually more of a look and move on gallery viewer. There were a lot of people taking photos and videos - I took some myself - and one family was quite distracting, doing little dances and mini performances, and inevitably being in someone's line of sight. I was annoyed by it for a few minutes, and felt a bit judgy - then realised I was being an arse, and the kids were engaged and enjoying it, and there was plenty of space for everyone to do things in their own way - which was probably exactly what was intended.

Galleries need people to keep visiting. Lovely though they are when it's quiet and you can wander undisturbed, that's not great for the gallery. You can't help being irritated by something, but you can help building it up into a big judgy thing.

Was it Frameless, its so much fun. Loved watching the little ones kicking leaves etc

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/07/2023 10:07

I know people are always diagnosing each other Willy nilly on here, but it does occur to me that getting “pulled out” of a thought process could be much more annoying if you have, for example, ADHD or ASD.

I know there’s no evidence Op specifically has it, but it would explain her feelings quite well.

This is what came to my mind

kungfupannda · 06/07/2023 10:02

Bit of an overreaction to a minor interruption.

I think there's a bit of all of us that likes to feel as though we're doing something just a little bit better than people around us. I went to an immersive exhibition recently. It was intended just to fill in time as I had to be in the area, but I finished up enjoying it far more than I'd expected. I work in a creative field - not art - and one of the galleries turned out to be great for just sitting and letting my mind wander around a project I'm working on. I'm usually more of a look and move on gallery viewer. There were a lot of people taking photos and videos - I took some myself - and one family was quite distracting, doing little dances and mini performances, and inevitably being in someone's line of sight. I was annoyed by it for a few minutes, and felt a bit judgy - then realised I was being an arse, and the kids were engaged and enjoying it, and there was plenty of space for everyone to do things in their own way - which was probably exactly what was intended.

Galleries need people to keep visiting. Lovely though they are when it's quiet and you can wander undisturbed, that's not great for the gallery. You can't help being irritated by something, but you can help building it up into a big judgy thing.

Americano75 · 06/07/2023 10:02

What were you looking at OP? I'd love to know.

I can see why you would be annoyed to be honest. And I don't think you were all that rude either!

QueefQueen80s · 06/07/2023 10:00

Your life must be hard if you get worked up about little things like this.
You can tell from you being bothered about this, that you have many little passive aggressive battles in your day to day life.
Just smile and let it go, life will be easier.

Thundercats77 · 06/07/2023 10:00

YANBU OP. You were in a moment, immersed, enjoying and being taken in by what you were viewing and she came and disturbed you. I wouldn't have a problem with her taking a pic in such a setting but I would have a problem with her being oblivious to the fact that you were enjoying that moment. She could have waited for you to shift away or grab someone else walking by.

shockthemonkey · 06/07/2023 10:00

hengelian · 06/07/2023 04:15

If you were in a cinema watching a movie and someone came and tapped you on the shoulder and asked you to take a photo of them with the movie, would it bother you?

To me, this is no different. Art is a story. I'm not being pretentious and I certainly don't think I'm better than anyone else for appreciating art in this way, I was just experiencing it and enjoying that experience which I was rudely pulled away from.

It’s quite different to watching a movie actually. If you miss a moment in the cinema you can’t rewind and get it back. You could thus miss a crucial line or pivotal moment in the plot.

In an art gallery it can be expected that even deep thinkers can interrupt their contemplation and take up again from where they left off. No doubt you will now tell us why in your case that would be an incorrect assumption due to the deep deep nature of your engagement.

That said, I do think the lady was a little forward for my tastes but I’m sure I could have remained polite and gracious.

ErrolTheDragon · 06/07/2023 09:59

It's rude and annoying for someone to interrupt a stranger who is engrossed in anything, be it art or not.

Smoothiecarton · 06/07/2023 09:58

@hengelian did I say that toddlers or teenagers aren’t capable ?🤔no i didn’t !
It’s good to see them there whether they’re engaging with the art or not. If they don’t this time that’s ok, they’ve learned that the gallery is a welcoming place, they’ve learned people like themselves are represented on the gallery walls, they’ve learned that engaging in whatever way they see fit is fine and comes without judgement.

bruffin · 06/07/2023 09:56

Placesto · 06/07/2023 09:51

I don’t understand why you feel that this poster couldn’t have looked at the painting and then taken a photo for her own enjoyment later. Sometimes there are too many in one exhibition that I would want a postcard of and are not available in a book that I usually can’t afford to buy. Sometimes I haven’t taken a photo intending to purchase one or two postcards of the paintings I’ve really enjoyed seeing in real life, only to find it’s not in the selection available. Plus some would hate me as, once years ago, I didn’t see that you could take photos until the end so rushed back in snapping at my favourites mindful of others of course. However I bet someone judged me seeing how all they saw was me snapping and moving on.

I too would hate someone interrupting my own enjoyment of a painting when they could do their own selfie. If this happened too often I’d be very unhappy.

I donht people taking pictures of the art, just not selfies

Placesto · 06/07/2023 09:51

Sunflowering · 06/07/2023 06:12

I’ll never understand this- time you could have spent looking at the Mona Lisa you instead spent taking a crap photo of the Mona Lisa, when (much better) images of that picture are readily available online, in the postcard shop etc. I mean, obviously you’re free to do it if you want but why?

I don’t understand why you feel that this poster couldn’t have looked at the painting and then taken a photo for her own enjoyment later. Sometimes there are too many in one exhibition that I would want a postcard of and are not available in a book that I usually can’t afford to buy. Sometimes I haven’t taken a photo intending to purchase one or two postcards of the paintings I’ve really enjoyed seeing in real life, only to find it’s not in the selection available. Plus some would hate me as, once years ago, I didn’t see that you could take photos until the end so rushed back in snapping at my favourites mindful of others of course. However I bet someone judged me seeing how all they saw was me snapping and moving on.

I too would hate someone interrupting my own enjoyment of a painting when they could do their own selfie. If this happened too often I’d be very unhappy.

bruffin · 06/07/2023 09:50

DrSbaitso · 06/07/2023 09:47

Why are you studying how long they look at it? Shouldn't you be looking at it?

Why shouldn't they be in the picture if it's a record of the time they saw it? They can get perfect pics of the art itself online.

Im trying to look at it, but people kerp standing in front of it!

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 06/07/2023 09:50

How pretentious of you.

MostlyBlueberryFlavoured · 06/07/2023 09:49

You're a rude and unpleasant person and I feel sorry for the paintings.

LolaSmiles · 06/07/2023 09:48

There’s an awful lot of inverse snobbery on here. It’s interesting how exercised some people are getting about someone looking at an artwork and having a thought process
I don't think it's appreciating art and thinking about it that's prompting the responses.
It's the pretentious drivel accompanying a complete non-event that's getting mildly mocked.

There's probably lots of people out there who are very knowledgeable about art and they'd not be this wound up about this.

DrSbaitso · 06/07/2023 09:47

bruffin · 06/07/2023 09:40

Because they dont even look at it. If they really were interested they wouldnt need to be in the picture blocking out half of the picture/object

Why are you studying how long they look at it? Shouldn't you be looking at it?

Why shouldn't they be in the picture if it's a record of the time they saw it? They can get perfect pics of the art itself online.

EhrlicheFrau · 06/07/2023 09:42

Sorry, no. - that would have been my response.

Wheresthebeach · 06/07/2023 09:41

Everyone taking endless pics of paintings in art galleries is incredibly annoying - arms waving around blocks the view of others. She should have asked another person who had their phone out to do it, at least they'd had been kindred spirits!

bruffin · 06/07/2023 09:40

DrSbaitso · 06/07/2023 09:37

How do you know they're not interested in the object itself?

Is it more acceptable if every person who queues up signs a pledge of authentic thought first?

Because they dont even look at it. If they really were interested they wouldnt need to be in the picture blocking out half of the picture/object

DrSbaitso · 06/07/2023 09:37

bruffin · 06/07/2023 09:33

Its really annoying when there are queues of people lining up for photo ops and they really not interested in the picture itself.
Berlin wall was awful for this. Harry Potter this bloke needed to pose in front of every exhibit .

How do you know they're not interested in the object itself?

Is it more acceptable if every person who queues up signs a pledge of authentic thought first?

BackAgainstWall · 06/07/2023 09:36

Are you usually inflexible and selfish?