Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cashless everything is annoying and inconvenient

230 replies

JazbayGrapes · 05/07/2023 21:09

Went to London last weekend. A concert in Hyde Park. Nobody in food/drink stalls wanted to take cash. Is this a new normal?

OP posts:
mogsrus · 06/07/2023 07:51

Cash helps me keep in budget ,how? You buy something with cash & you may keep the receipt. You buy something cashless & immediately get a receipt so you know exactly how much you have spent either way.
cash is a filthy cumbersome article, that ruins items that are designed to keep it in.
working in the gaming business as I do,please come round sometime & I’ll open a few cash machines for you, they are disgusting inside with sticky dust & it makes me cringe when people put it to their mouths that’s totally gross.
Handle cash all day & your hair stinks, empty a 2p changer by hand when the motor won’t deliver coins,5 scoops of coins & your hands are black.
Cashless arcades are the future as so much employee fraud can & does go on, & weekly banking is exhausting, starting @ 5am, empty all machines, record all the meters, run all cash through a cash counter, bag it all up, store in safe and finish the day sometimes 8pm if the cash doesn’t tally with the meters & tomorrow you do the paperwork.
Cashless arcade you can start work @ 8 30 & by 9 you’ve finished with everything just about correct & you can open, The sooner the better, cheaper & cleaner

Ambi · 06/07/2023 07:46

HellsTeethandBucketsofBlood · 05/07/2023 21:16

Where has this myth that dealing with cash is expensive come from? Its card transactions that take a percentage of the price. Cash is free? Banks just get richer from every small purchase you make

Cash receipts are expensive to businesses, loss and theft are the big ones. Costs of security vans to collect cash to deposit. Business banking charges for cash deposits. It is absolutely not free.

ButterflySquared · 06/07/2023 07:42

Just as an aside, my Mother was the manager of a large leisure complex in the 1970’s and 1980’s. I remember her taking the takings to the bank in her shopping basket as no one would suspect just a wicker shopping bag. She would walk through town with 20k easily. Which would be about 78k in todays money.

The previous manager used to take it in bags handcuffed to his wrist, I remember her declaring him an idiot for drawing attention to himself.

Prefer card payments and it helps stomp down the black economy which is a real issue and not discussed much but tax lost will be more than the likes of tax avoidance by big companies. All those who car washes and hairdressers that are fronts for money laundering can’t launder. There will be other ways but no cash hinders organised crime.

LubaLuca · 06/07/2023 07:39

We only need cash for the barber, they don't take cards (none of the 'Turkish' barbers in our area do). I've often wondered if it's a front for money laundering, why wouldn't they accept card payments?

I don't think cash will disappear, but it will become far harder to access it and use it.

Fizbosshoes · 06/07/2023 07:33

I understand it at concert venues, the queues are usually ridiculous and would e even longer if the staff had to deal with money/change. Possibly more hygienic too as just preparing food/drink and not handling money as well.

Although I did have a whinge at the weekend in a carpark when I could only pay by app. I forgot my password (I knew it was one of 2) but it wouldn't let me have 2 tries....so had to request a verification code to my phone....it never arrived...then request again by email... then reset password....then pay 20p more than I would have done at the machine. Whole process took about 10 min. Paying by card or cash at the machine would have been loads quicker!

Stripeysocks0 · 06/07/2023 07:28

I don’t know the last time I paid with cash! I can’t even remember my pin to take cash out 😂

Ohyeahwaitaminute · 06/07/2023 07:24

I like the option of both. I don’t want my bank to know of EVERY transaction I make. That smacks of Big Brother.

I’d like the option of taking out cash and spending it how I like. I don’t want my entire financial life digitally tracked.

In my local shop, it’s a split of about 50/50 with cash and contactless payments.

User106487665 · 06/07/2023 07:23

user6482959 · 06/07/2023 07:21

What? If this ever happened, just go on your banking app and lock your card.

Are you very elderly OP? Maybe someone ca. guide you on banking tech.

You may not know it has been stolen or lost immediately

user6482959 · 06/07/2023 07:21

JazbayGrapes · 05/07/2023 21:18

Why do you struggle - do you not have cards and only have cash (where from? Surely a bank?)

I just prefer cash. I do use card but i leave a limited amount on there in case its stolen and swiped.
I live in Bristol where totally cashless are still unpopular, at least my part of town.

What? If this ever happened, just go on your banking app and lock your card.

Are you very elderly OP? Maybe someone ca. guide you on banking tech.

User106487665 · 06/07/2023 07:01

I generally keep about £200 at home anyway so I would have some cash without going to the cashpoint, I think cash stolen from the home is probably covered by house insurance but if the house was burgled that would probably be the least of my worries. I also keep about £20 in my purse

sashh · 06/07/2023 06:47

HellsTeethandBucketsofBlood · 05/07/2023 21:16

Where has this myth that dealing with cash is expensive come from? Its card transactions that take a percentage of the price. Cash is free? Banks just get richer from every small purchase you make

Not for businesses.

OP My local community shop is cash only so there are some places still taking cash.

User106487665 · 06/07/2023 06:38

theGooHasGone · 06/07/2023 04:33

🥱

There are lots of no-fee international cards (Wise, Monzo, Revolut) that just charge inter-bank exchange rates, so international travellers aren't inhrently getting screwed.

There are equally well lots of credit cards that will give you cashback or rewards for spending money using them - these rewards are paid out of the merchant fees that the vendors pay for accepting cards.

If your bank is worth anything they'll enforce multi-factor authentication, so anyone who steals your phone won't be able to log in - plus of course you have a passcode/face/fingerprint lock on the phone so they won't be able to unlock it anyway. If you don't - come on now, it's 2023.

You're not interesting enough for the card processors or banks to care what you're spending money on. Cashless society is the way things are going. Cash is a pain to handle.

It has been recommended recently not to have banking apps on your phone as some people have had money stolen from their bank accounts so obviously all this multi factor authentication didn't work, best to keep all the apps on iPad and just use a phone for general stuff, not many people bank when they are at the pub or shopping.

Aishah231 · 06/07/2023 06:36

It is much more convenient but also discriminating against the very poor and potentially dangerous. It's mad to give banks and the government power to freeze your bank accounts if you do or say something they don't like? Seems a mad conspiracy theory until you realise they have already done this to others.

User106487665 · 06/07/2023 06:30

Wingedharpy · 06/07/2023 00:45

I'm very old and usually pay with groats and farthings but, may I ask the tech savvy folk on here, what happens if you lose or break your phone if all your banking details are on it?
Do you add any extra security "stuff" to your phone to keep your details safe and inaccessible to others?

It has been recommended quite recently to not have your banking app on your phone because of people watching you put your password in and then stealing the phone, if you have biometric ID on your phone this is less likely to happen.

I don't keep the actual banking apps on my phone as I rarely use it, I use my iPad mainly, which is at home, I have never had to do any banking when I have been out as I just use cards. I only use credit cards for paying for things as I wouldn't want fraud on my bank account. I also use a different credit card for Amazon and PayPal as they can be hacked and you can lose access to that card. I obviously pay these credit cards off each month to not incur interest charges. I am fairly old so probably a bit more suspicious of technology than a younger person.

rwalker · 06/07/2023 05:58

My friends a hairdresser she’s gone cashless
no trips to the bank
no carting cash about all day
no float for customers change
everything recorded makes book keeping easier

Ponderingwindow · 06/07/2023 05:52

I got my dd a parent managed debit card at 13 because cash is is definitely not the preferred currency in our area. Some venues are specifically cashless, some stores just state a preference for cashless or only have one register that takes cash.

user1492757084 · 06/07/2023 05:43

I find it inconvenient too and every transaction takes a fee.
Cash is cheaper for the buyer.
In protest I use more cash than ever ..

PuddlesPityParty · 06/07/2023 05:37

Yeah not really seeing how it’s inconvenient. Personally if I’m going to a Gig or festival etc. I transfer money onto my Monzo card so if I misplace it or whatever it’s no big deal.

NEmama · 06/07/2023 05:17

@Flopsythebunny you do realise that you can pay cash into post offices?

Whataretheodds · 06/07/2023 04:55

HellsTeethandBucketsofBlood · 05/07/2023 21:16

Where has this myth that dealing with cash is expensive come from? Its card transactions that take a percentage of the price. Cash is free? Banks just get richer from every small purchase you make

If you're a sole trader working a market stall cash is a security risk and a logistical effort that you've got to factor in. If you're employing staff you have to pay them for the time it takes to balance the till, bank the cash, and to withdraw and set out the float at the beginning of the next shift.

hengelian · 06/07/2023 04:52

Wingedharpy · 06/07/2023 00:45

I'm very old and usually pay with groats and farthings but, may I ask the tech savvy folk on here, what happens if you lose or break your phone if all your banking details are on it?
Do you add any extra security "stuff" to your phone to keep your details safe and inaccessible to others?

  1. You tell your phone provider and they instantly lock down your phone so it is completely useless to anyone who has stolen/ found it.
  2. Some people have location services like 'find my iphone' so it can be tracked.
  3. Most phones these days need Face ID or a fingerprint to unlock them, or at the very least a pass code.
  4. Most banking apps have two factor authentication or a separate password to the phone unlock, so even if you got into the phone you couldn't get into the banking apps.

It's pretty secure.

hengelian · 06/07/2023 04:49

@JazbayGrapes You're actually more likely to lose money permanently if your wallet/ cash is stolen than if your card is stolen. No bank will reimburse you for lost cash.

hengelian · 06/07/2023 04:48

JazbayGrapes · 05/07/2023 21:18

Why do you struggle - do you not have cards and only have cash (where from? Surely a bank?)

I just prefer cash. I do use card but i leave a limited amount on there in case its stolen and swiped.
I live in Bristol where totally cashless are still unpopular, at least my part of town.

If you're worried about your card being stolen/ swiped, have you thought about using Apple Pay/ phone payments? They're more secure in that way especially if you have your phone locked with a passcode/ Face ID etc.

To be honest though you are probably worrying unnecessarily because most major banks will give you the money back if your card is stolen and used, as long as you report it as soon as you realise.

theGooHasGone · 06/07/2023 04:33

🥱

There are lots of no-fee international cards (Wise, Monzo, Revolut) that just charge inter-bank exchange rates, so international travellers aren't inhrently getting screwed.

There are equally well lots of credit cards that will give you cashback or rewards for spending money using them - these rewards are paid out of the merchant fees that the vendors pay for accepting cards.

If your bank is worth anything they'll enforce multi-factor authentication, so anyone who steals your phone won't be able to log in - plus of course you have a passcode/face/fingerprint lock on the phone so they won't be able to unlock it anyway. If you don't - come on now, it's 2023.

You're not interesting enough for the card processors or banks to care what you're spending money on. Cashless society is the way things are going. Cash is a pain to handle.

OfficerChurlish · 06/07/2023 02:33

Hard no-cash rules disadvantage the most marginalized - children, beggars, people (mainly women and girls) under coercive control or typically policed by a relative, people who rely on tips or handouts, and people who don't have enough money, an address, or ID to open a bank account - or who can't afford to open more than one and are left without options if their one account/card is compromised or has technical difficulties. Also international travellers, who get dinged for transation and conversion fees with every 90p tap. By all means, have cash-free options for people who want it, but there are also reasons to resist it.