Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell the school to get lost

140 replies

Maisemoo · 05/07/2023 20:35

So had 4 missed calls from DS10 school today while I was in a meeting so I returned the call as soon as I saw this. Lady on reception told me I had to come in for a meeting regarding sons attendance as is 89.9% which is below the 90% threshold! I explained since Sept son had E. coli (for which hospital letter was shown), D&V and covid, he also finishes 20 mins early every 3rd Wednesday to attend CAHMs due to his ASD and anxiety- again school have the paperwork for this. Receptionist kept telling me I wasn’t in trouble and not going to be told off- to which I replied I am an adult so was not in fear of being ‘told off’. Receptionist said I had to attend Monday at 10.00- I start a new job Monday so told here I won’t be attending- all the absences were genuine and I had no interest in a pointless meeting. Receptionist rang 3 more times with different days and times before getting the hint I was not interested- AIBU to refuse this or should I just of sucked it up and gone

OP posts:
Maisemoo · 07/07/2023 07:32

I fully understand the correlation between reduced attendance and impact on learning but sickness is sickness and as I said this is the first year DS has been anywhere near under 90%. If they had rang and asked if I wanted a meeting or any support I wouldn’t of been so blunt and probably still wouldn’t of gone as each absence was fully explained but the patronising was not helpful

OP posts:
lillyblossoms · 06/07/2023 21:21

End-of-teaching-year exhausted @Theos? I get it. We all are, but most of us thankfully don't resort to name-calling. As Head of an Independent, I'd have an empty school if staff spoke to parents in the way the Op was spoken to. If staff are off frequently too then very little learning takes place and education is impacted. Accountability, as I mentioned before, works both ways.

swg1 · 06/07/2023 21:13

Misknit · 05/07/2023 20:52

The reason the government and school are hot on persistent absence (which is the category your son has fallen into) is because his chances of gaining 5 good GCSE drops on average from 81% to 57% so you won't have to worry if you know that he is achieving really well and is more than capable of working up on any content he has missed.

I am sure when you picked his school you paid attention to the Ofsted rating. Ofsted look very carefully how schools tackle attendance. They will use the evidence they have attempted to meet with you to support improving attendance as they will have done with all other parents whose children fall into that category. Even if parents don't choose to engage, the inspectors will recognise the work of the school.

This is a bit of a wonky stat tbh.

It's not that his chances of achievement drop it's that children with low achievement tend to have lower achievement. That is not the same thing.

In that category you will have the children with persistent unexcused absence because they just wander off before reaching the school gate. You will have the children with SEN which also mean that they are frequently ill. You will have the kids who have life limiting illnesses - no shit the cancer patients might get lower exam marks.

Correlation is not the same as causation. A lot of reasons for persistent absence are also reasons for low achievement.

Theos · 06/07/2023 09:51

lillyblossoms · 06/07/2023 00:59

Ask her what hers and the other staff attendance is! How much teaching is your son missing due to staff being off? Works both ways...

I’m not sure staff are learning and taking exams you donut

PTSDBarbiegirl · 06/07/2023 09:34

Springbecamethesummer · 05/07/2023 21:29

Rubbish, my son missed lots of school due to an anxiety disorder, l deregistered him age 14, never set foot in a school again, he still passed all his Exams, A**.
Ask what the attendance is like for teachers because they seem to have a lot more time off than most pupils, esp with these strikes.

Strikes are not 'time off'! The teachers are losing a days pay each time they strike & legally withdraw their labour as part of agreed industrial action. Schools have safeguarding responsibilities, OP should be able to outline reasons explained but the % will likely trigger an investigation anyway. Things have been firmed up since the recent murder through neglect cases in UK of toddlers and v young children. The school receptionist should be up skilled, what a condescending stupid way to speak to any adult.

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 06/07/2023 06:10

ReadingSoManyThreads · 05/07/2023 21:54

Wind your neck in, illnesses with evidence submitted from a hospital, is not a reason to consider this a safeguarding concern. Don't be one of those busybodies who tout "safeguarding" at every available opportunity. I am safeguarding trained by the way.

You should know better then.

lillyblossoms · 06/07/2023 00:59

Ask her what hers and the other staff attendance is! How much teaching is your son missing due to staff being off? Works both ways...

Dixiechickonhols · 06/07/2023 00:50

pleasehelpwi3 · 06/07/2023 00:21

can see why you are annoyed.
I’d email and confirm what each absence relates to and say evidence provided on x date or as advised at time. Just do this to the school- that's all the poor person in the office needs
I’d also argue disability related absence shouldn’t be included. If you like- but best to point that out to the DfE
End by saying you are happy to send him when fit and well but if he’s ill he won’t be in school. You could, but this is basically just saying you won't break the law and only serves to make you feel better and will be met with an exasperated shrug, sped read by the office staff
I’d also add he was able to attend on strike dates if you add another 5 or 6 strike days on as in attendance he’s way over 90%. Oh, save the office staff the teacher bashing and the passive aggressive crap, they get it all day every day and they've just had nine months of it, so cut them some slack. Or write to your MP and ask them to ask the government to fund schools properly so teachers don't need to strike.
See less

The office person doesn’t need to do anything with the email though except save it to the file. It’s not requiring a response.
They have repeatedly phoned Op to show they are doing their bit to comply and Op has has replied.
It’s not bashing to point out that stats may be incorrect if there have been additional closures.

greyhairnomore · 06/07/2023 00:49

That would annoy me. He will have made it up by the end of term.
Ignore them.

Walkaround · 06/07/2023 00:33

90% attendance isn’t a target…

Lunde · 06/07/2023 00:29

Gosh all of this over 0.1% where the parents have provided a hospital letter for 2 of the weeks and the other times he was sent home by the school.

No wonder education is in such a state in England everyone chasing the minutiae of targets and no one seeing the big picture

Scarfweather · 06/07/2023 00:22

This is why I’m happier with DCs now in independent schools. How the state school communicated with me as a parent was a major factor in switching. You aren’t treated like a child.
YANBU OP.

pleasehelpwi3 · 06/07/2023 00:21

Dixiechickonhols · 06/07/2023 00:07

I can see why you are annoyed.
I’d email and confirm what each absence relates to and say evidence provided on x date or as advised at time.
I’d also argue disability related absence shouldn’t be included.
End by saying you are happy to send him when fit and well but if he’s ill he won’t be in school.
I’d also add he was able to attend on strike dates if you add another 5 or 6 strike days on as in attendance he’s way over 90%.

can see why you are annoyed.
I’d email and confirm what each absence relates to and say evidence provided on x date or as advised at time. Just do this to the school- that's all the poor person in the office needs
I’d also argue disability related absence shouldn’t be included. If you like- but best to point that out to the DfE
End by saying you are happy to send him when fit and well but if he’s ill he won’t be in school. You could, but this is basically just saying you won't break the law and only serves to make you feel better and will be met with an exasperated shrug, sped read by the office staff
I’d also add he was able to attend on strike dates if you add another 5 or 6 strike days on as in attendance he’s way over 90%. Oh, save the office staff the teacher bashing and the passive aggressive crap, they get it all day every day and they've just had nine months of it, so cut them some slack. Or write to your MP and ask them to ask the government to fund schools properly so teachers don't need to strike.
See less

Walkaround · 06/07/2023 00:20

The school has to demonstrate that it is doing everything it can to support your child’s attendance. Given his ASD and anxiety, it is a legitimate concern that some of his illness absences may have been more prolonged than might be the case for a child who is not prone to anxiety. So a meeting would be your chance to explain how you think the school could better support your ds to help minimise the length of his absences, or to reassure them that you believe the illnesses have been purely physical and nothing more than temporary bad luck, and no-one, either you or the school, could have done anything to make them shorter. A meeting is your chance to educate the school on your child’s needs, should you feel it is failing to meet them, and if not, to enable them to put in writing confirmation that everyone is happy that the absences could not have been avoided or reduced and have not been so unsettling for your ds that a pattern of anxiety-based poor attendance is now at risk of being established. If you are generally happy with the school, would it really be so bad to have the meeting requested?

ASimpleLampoon · 06/07/2023 00:16

I work from home and have very flexible hours but would not attend that on principle

pleasehelpwi3 · 06/07/2023 00:15

MsRosley · 06/07/2023 00:02

I think I'd be putting in a strongly worded complaint.

....to the government, who tell schools to make those calls.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/07/2023 00:12

pleasehelpwi3 · 06/07/2023 00:01

Didn't say it was news. But am allowed to make the observation.
Doesn't make it right either. Maybe just maybe if 44 year old teachers could earn what 24 year old trainee solicitors do earn, there wouldn't be so many teachers leaving the profession only to be replaced by new young recruits, many of whom don't stay the course.
Don't understand why this thread is even entitled 'to tell the school to get lost' when anyone who's ever worked in a school knows it should be 'government' to get lost, as they're the ones making schools make these 'phone calls.

I'm sure many people would rightly castigate schools if they didn't investigate why children were absent and something happened to that child. Not the case with OP, but don't shoot the messenger.

Maybe I'm not following the advice I give to kids- ignore annoying people, don't react- it's what they want in reacting to the wilfully ignorant who trot out the DM lines about lazy striking teachers. On my strike day- not paid- I've spent all day.....working! It's basically an unpaid planning day and report writing to make up for the planning time I'm legally entitled to but don't get as a Y6 teacher at the end of Summer term in a stretched, short-staffed underfunded primary.

Without derailing thread but City trainees are not typical law earners.
Local authority solicitors/criminal legal aid etc are on very similar type wages to teachers.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/07/2023 00:07

I can see why you are annoyed.
I’d email and confirm what each absence relates to and say evidence provided on x date or as advised at time.
I’d also argue disability related absence shouldn’t be included.
End by saying you are happy to send him when fit and well but if he’s ill he won’t be in school.
I’d also add he was able to attend on strike dates if you add another 5 or 6 strike days on as in attendance he’s way over 90%.

MsRosley · 06/07/2023 00:02

I think I'd be putting in a strongly worded complaint.

pleasehelpwi3 · 06/07/2023 00:01

ichundich · 05/07/2023 23:16

Since when is it news that solicitors are among the highest earners and teachers aren't? My job requires a uni degree yet no one (not even in the city) will pay more than 35k for it, but I knew this when I chose my career.

Didn't say it was news. But am allowed to make the observation.
Doesn't make it right either. Maybe just maybe if 44 year old teachers could earn what 24 year old trainee solicitors do earn, there wouldn't be so many teachers leaving the profession only to be replaced by new young recruits, many of whom don't stay the course.
Don't understand why this thread is even entitled 'to tell the school to get lost' when anyone who's ever worked in a school knows it should be 'government' to get lost, as they're the ones making schools make these 'phone calls.

I'm sure many people would rightly castigate schools if they didn't investigate why children were absent and something happened to that child. Not the case with OP, but don't shoot the messenger.

Maybe I'm not following the advice I give to kids- ignore annoying people, don't react- it's what they want in reacting to the wilfully ignorant who trot out the DM lines about lazy striking teachers. On my strike day- not paid- I've spent all day.....working! It's basically an unpaid planning day and report writing to make up for the planning time I'm legally entitled to but don't get as a Y6 teacher at the end of Summer term in a stretched, short-staffed underfunded primary.

AdoraBell · 05/07/2023 23:56

YANBU. Ignore and if they continue persisting email the office/ head teacher about it.

Years ago when my DD was ill a teacher was seriously aggressive towards DD when she returned. Also told me that DD could not have any days of school and made DD to do 3 tests during lunchtime, meaning DD couldn’t eat. She’d had swine flu and the hospital told us to keep off school. School knew this. So the next time she was sick I took her to school. Teacher called to say DD was ill and had to go home. I did this every time. Teacher couldn’t face me after the third time.

Viviennemary · 05/07/2023 23:51

You have a hospital letter. The school are being ridiculous. As if anybody can justvtake a day off from work. Or suggest a time to suit you. Like an evening.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 05/07/2023 23:47

I would not take time off to go in for a meeting and miss work, I would tell the attendance officer to call me if they were concerned.

FluffyFlannery · 05/07/2023 23:40

PaigeMatthews · 05/07/2023 20:45

4 weeks off is a lot. Finishing early wont affect the attendance score as that will go on the afternoon registration, which he attends. Was he iff for two weeks with ecoli?

The child was sick! My gosh, Hoe daft can you be 🤦‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread