Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell the school to get lost

140 replies

Maisemoo · 05/07/2023 20:35

So had 4 missed calls from DS10 school today while I was in a meeting so I returned the call as soon as I saw this. Lady on reception told me I had to come in for a meeting regarding sons attendance as is 89.9% which is below the 90% threshold! I explained since Sept son had E. coli (for which hospital letter was shown), D&V and covid, he also finishes 20 mins early every 3rd Wednesday to attend CAHMs due to his ASD and anxiety- again school have the paperwork for this. Receptionist kept telling me I wasn’t in trouble and not going to be told off- to which I replied I am an adult so was not in fear of being ‘told off’. Receptionist said I had to attend Monday at 10.00- I start a new job Monday so told here I won’t be attending- all the absences were genuine and I had no interest in a pointless meeting. Receptionist rang 3 more times with different days and times before getting the hint I was not interested- AIBU to refuse this or should I just of sucked it up and gone

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Moglet4 · 07/07/2023 17:39

You clearly haven’t spent much time in a school if you think teachers have more time off than pupils (outside of the long overdue strike action)

Iamnotthe1 · 07/07/2023 17:35

The school are just trying to meet their legal duty. Below 90% attendance is low and is atypical. The "Keeping Children Safe in Education" update for 2023 also now states that children who are repeatedly absent are classed as "Children missing education" and, as such, the school must investigate in line with their legal safeguarding duty. That's the case even if there are reasons listed against each absence. The school can't just decide not to bother.

Nellodee · 07/07/2023 17:17

My daughter was close to the concern level. What tipped her over was school sending her home sick one day. We then got the attendance call about her being below 90% !

Walkaround · 07/07/2023 17:14

Lunde · 07/07/2023 17:07

The problem is that everyone has got obsessed with "auditability" and common sense has left the building.

Surely schools should focus their limited resources on unexplained absence or cases where school intervention would be helpful. In OP's case the school already had evidence at their fingertips of the hospital records for e-coli and knew that the school itself had sent the child home for D&V. What is the actual point of hounding parents for meetings in this case? What is the point of the school making 4 phone calls to harass OP into a meeting to tick a box? It's just a waste of resources.

D&V can last a day or two, or a week or more. If it lasts longer than expected, then the school may decide it doesn’t have enough information. If it lasts less time than expected, the school may instead be asking the parents to collect their child and give them another day off. Schools are expected to keep track of hundreds or even thousands of children, they won’t always make the right call.

euff · 07/07/2023 17:08

I wish I'd done what you did op. Completely genuine reasons for DC being off that year including chicken pox which isn't over in a day. Followed their own sickness procedure. Before I was allowed to wfh so nearly three hours in commuting meant that I had to pretty much take the day to go to the pointless meeting. I explained that with both of us working full time out of the house we weren't going to be keeping DC off on a whim and having to take the time off work.

Lunde · 07/07/2023 17:07

The problem is that everyone has got obsessed with "auditability" and common sense has left the building.

Surely schools should focus their limited resources on unexplained absence or cases where school intervention would be helpful. In OP's case the school already had evidence at their fingertips of the hospital records for e-coli and knew that the school itself had sent the child home for D&V. What is the actual point of hounding parents for meetings in this case? What is the point of the school making 4 phone calls to harass OP into a meeting to tick a box? It's just a waste of resources.

Walkaround · 07/07/2023 17:01

Anxiety-based absences have increased massively since covid. It seems excessively defensive to assume the school is questioning whether or not the absences are genuine. Schools do not just question absences because they think parents are liars or not too bothered about school attendance. Sometimes they just want to be sure that there isn’t more going on than the main reason reported, especially if an absence was for more than a few days - it’s not as if most parents bother to give more than one reason for an absence, as one reason is usually enough. The school may just want to check in to establish whether the extended illnesses have exacerbated the anxiety and whether that in turn may have lengthened the duration of the illness absences, or whether there is more medical information that they ought to be aware of to understand whether the absences were of a normal duration for the illness initially reported, or longer due to an additional issue as yet unmentioned. Talking to parents can help people in school to connect up different pieces of information they have received at various points so that nothing important gets missed.

Fruttidelbosco · 07/07/2023 14:38

It just sounds like a bit of poor judgement from someone on reception. Give them a break! They talked to you as though you were a child because they talk to children all day. They were saying it to reassure you.

Schools have to worry about attendance because there is a crisis in attendance since Covid. There are children who never came back or children who now routinely miss significant amounts of school. This is more important than you being irritated by a persistent but polite low-paid admin worker.

Just go through the motions. Allow the school to secure the information and be nice to the receptionist.

If you deter schools from investigating absence, you are obstructing safeguarding practices. Sometimes, keeping children safe is more important than a small inconvenience or irritation to you.

TempestuousBehaviour · 07/07/2023 14:29

moggo · 05/07/2023 22:35

89.9% is classed as persistent absence no matter what the reason. As others have said, that is a lot of school to miss and could very well affect your dc's outcomes. It is the school's responsibility to intervene at this percentage to see what support can be given to raise children's attendance. This guidance comes from the government and must be followed by all schools. Ultimately, the research is there that children who dip below 90% are most at risk of having their futures impacted by poor results. It is great that you provide evidence for each absence and this means that you will not be a major concern to the school as you are engaging with the process. However, refusing to attend a meeting intended to offer support is not helpful. The handing in of evidence means less if a child is at say 70% because the attendance is very poor and there are likely to be underlying issues that need addressing. No amount of evidence is going to make the school leave this alone.

In September there is new guidance coming in which is less punitive on parents and more supportive which is a good change due to the many issues that have arisen since Covid etc. No school aims to punish parents but still needs to adhere to government guidance. There is no intention to catch parents out but only to offer help to ensure that their children can be as successful as possible. I would imagine this is what you want too.

Again, .01 percent absence is not going to tip the op’s child into failing exams territory. If he is going to fail his GCSEs that amount under 90%, then he should have had intervention at 90.1%, because he would already have been struggling then.

see what support can be given to raise children's attendance.

What support can the school give to stop the child catching E. coli or d&v? Are they going to go round to the op’s house and teach them all to wash their hands or something?! The school will have a policy that says children must stay of 24/48/72 hours with d&v… perhaps they could help by getting rid of that?! If the kids go in throwing up they will have better attendance figures…

cyclamenqueen · 07/07/2023 14:14

LolaSmiles · 07/07/2023 13:44

I don't think it is a case of low hanging fruit to be honest. A family who are good with attendance who happen to have had an unwell child aren't magically going to improve attendance off the back of a meeting.

It's just box ticking.

That’s exactly what I mean. It’s easy to bring people like this in for meetings so they target them first

LolaSmiles · 07/07/2023 13:44

I don't think it is a case of low hanging fruit to be honest. A family who are good with attendance who happen to have had an unwell child aren't magically going to improve attendance off the back of a meeting.

It's just box ticking.

RedRobyn2021 · 07/07/2023 13:00

Argh, definitely not unreasonable. I would struggle not to lose my cool with this.

WTF475878237NC · 07/07/2023 12:33

they are just going for the low hanging fruit , they know that this family is conscientious so easy to target and get their percentage of follow up stats for Ofsted to compensate for all the real problem cases where the parents don’t even call back.

^ a total waste of resources when there are families with issues who need support.

Prescottdanni123 · 07/07/2023 09:51

@moggo

Well, that is what one poster is saying happened and to be honest, it doesn't surprise me. When I worked as a supply teaching assistant, I experienced quite a lot of insane procedures in the various schools I worked at. I haven't left the current school for 4 years because it is the first sane(ish) one that I have come across.

cyclamenqueen · 07/07/2023 09:31

moggo · 05/07/2023 22:50

@Quiverer meetings are offered at this level of attendance because often there are underlying reasons for this amount of absence (not counting Covid or injury in this of course). Some children are absent with colds or upset stomachs which can actually mask anxiety, bullying, friendship issues or unmet need. A meeting, including the child, can be useful in getting to the bottom of what is going on. Of course there may be nothing going on but the questions need asking.

But in this case the school have third party evidence including of hospital admittance . The child has attended for 2 previous years with high attendance so clearly the risk is low.

they are just going for the low hanging fruit , they know that this family is conscientious so easy to target and get their percentage of follow up stats for Ofsted to compensate for all the real problem cases where the parents don’t even call back.

curliegirlie · 07/07/2023 09:20

Theos · 05/07/2023 21:48

What’s the intention of the strike? Is it that teachers are losing ££ just to piss you off? Or perhaps to show that they cannot be paid peanuts

I’ve taught for 31 years. I’ve NEVER seen shortages like this. If you’re happy for your kid to have no language or maths teachers you crack on

Ahhh, but the language teacher shortage is even worse, as they've been chipping away at MFL for the best part of 20 years (so, Labour as well as the Tories). I think it was in 2004 that MFL stopped being compulsory at GCSE. And then the wonder why no language teachers are coming through....when fewer and fewer kids take languages at GCSE and A-Level, and language departments have been shut in universities, right left and centre, it's hardly rocket science, is it?! And all that is before you add Brexit into the mix.

As a German graduate, it's something I feel passionately about. I absolutely loved my year abroad and then having the opportunity to do my PhD in German history and go on many archive visits. My twenties would have been so much poorer without this opportunity and I think that it's tragic that fewer and fewer young people will have those chances. Speaking the language of the country you're in or visiting is so empowering. Apologies, I will jump off my soap box and stop derailing the thread.

OP I've not read this to the end, but it sounds wholly disproportionate. Even my youngest, who had an 86% attendance record earlier in the year because of various bouts of illnesses in the Autumn term only got a snotty letter. And that was despite us taking them out of school 4 days before the Easter holidays started. (Both kids have hit over 90% now).

LolaSmiles · 07/07/2023 09:12

^ this is what I don't get. Trying to get meetings with parents where there is clear genuine illness doesn't benefit anyone. If they need to document what they're doing, far better to write to a parent to say we acknowledge attendance has been low due to illness, let us know if we can support etc and leave it at that. Better to use resources wisely not just have pointless meetings to "prove" a school is doing something about attendance to Ofsted.
I'd agree. I think the consistency approach is probably taken to avoid claims of favouritism even though schools aren't daft and know when a child has been unlucky with a couple of long illnesses Vs the ones who have odd days off.

I think as long as school have made contact with a parent at various trigger points to have an appropriate discussion for the situation then that should be enough. In the OP's situation, a phonecall from the relevant leader saying what you've outlined should suffice in my opinion.

Isthisexpected · 07/07/2023 08:45

Even if parents don't choose to engage, the inspectors will recognise the work of the school.

^ this is what I don't get. Trying to get meetings with parents where there is clear genuine illness doesn't benefit anyone. If they need to document what they're doing, far better to write to a parent to say we acknowledge attendance has been low due to illness, let us know if we can support etc and leave it at that. Better to use resources wisely not just have pointless meetings to "prove" a school is doing something about attendance to Ofsted.

Avondale89 · 07/07/2023 08:41

I can’t believe some people on here are equating a child off sick to teachers striking. It’s a wonder we have any teachers left the way they’re treated and spoken about in this country.

Lokipokey1 · 07/07/2023 08:37

Explain your point to OFSTED because this is where all this ridiculousness comes from! As a teacher, I hate it. Ticking a bad attendance box on the report of a child that’s had covid, followed by Strep that keep them off for 2 full weeks that’s had 95+ attendance every other year makes me feel like shit!

NotOnYourNellies · 07/07/2023 08:27

Honestly ignore it, I'm speaking from insiders view too
You've explained, have given evidence etc a meeting won't change a thing
Their paperwork is their problem

Zanatdy · 07/07/2023 08:25

When my kids had EColi (caught from a local farm) they were banned from school and nursery for 5wks on public health grounds. So not an awful lot you can do about that! Didn’t impact either of them long term!

Zanatdy · 07/07/2023 08:23

I’ve had a few letters when my DD’s attendance dipped below 80%. Asked to provide any evidence for any other sickness / appointments. I told them to ask their office as I sent her in most days and they called me to pick her up. I ignore them, DD (15) recently won an award for highest achieving girl in her year group. She had a terrible start to puberty and ended up with a blood transfusion when her first period wouldn’t start and then suffered from low iron / ferritin for ages. They can get lost yes!

Walkaround · 07/07/2023 08:20

Maisemoo · 07/07/2023 07:32

I fully understand the correlation between reduced attendance and impact on learning but sickness is sickness and as I said this is the first year DS has been anywhere near under 90%. If they had rang and asked if I wanted a meeting or any support I wouldn’t of been so blunt and probably still wouldn’t of gone as each absence was fully explained but the patronising was not helpful

The patronising clearly also wasn’t intended. The receptionist needs more training and support (which, knowing staffing levels in schools isn’t available) - they will not be the one holding the meetings, they are just being given the humiliating job of phoning people who are guaranteed to have a hostile reaction to them, so it’s not that surprising if they are not very good at explaining what the meeting will cover and why the school would like you to come in for a meeting.

TempestuousBehaviour · 07/07/2023 08:11

Misknit · 05/07/2023 20:52

The reason the government and school are hot on persistent absence (which is the category your son has fallen into) is because his chances of gaining 5 good GCSE drops on average from 81% to 57% so you won't have to worry if you know that he is achieving really well and is more than capable of working up on any content he has missed.

I am sure when you picked his school you paid attention to the Ofsted rating. Ofsted look very carefully how schools tackle attendance. They will use the evidence they have attempted to meet with you to support improving attendance as they will have done with all other parents whose children fall into that category. Even if parents don't choose to engage, the inspectors will recognise the work of the school.

@Misknit persistent absence covers a whole range of attendance levels- achievement doesn’t fall from 80 odd % to near 50% the second attendance ticks .01 under 90%.

so you won't have to worry if you know that he is achieving really well and is more than capable of working up on any content he has missed.

Whether he is achieving well or not, if he is ill he is ill. Children who are vomiting or have E.Coli are not able to go to school.