Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car park collision, who at fault?

160 replies

dolol · 05/07/2023 20:34

Sister had a collision this morning and wants to know who will be deemed as at fault

Car A driving along the car park row in a straight line, likely slightly too fast

Car B has reversed parked in the space. Is about to drive off, having done all observations. Crawls forward slightly to check left and right as visibility obscured by big vehicle parked to the left.

Car B (bonnet only a few inches out of the bay) collides with Car A who was doing some speed. MPH limit in car park when checked retrospectively was 5mph

All occupants fine but damage to the side door of Car A
Car B has paintwork damage near the headlight which will need buffing out and probably a new lower splitter

YABU - Car A at fault

YANBU - Car B at fault

Or possibly 50/50 fault? If 50/50 fault who would pay the excess? Thanks so much :)

OP posts:
Leftbutcameback · 05/07/2023 21:57

In terms of her insurance policy cost I’m afraid it will go up quite a bit on renewal. My OH had to claim on his policy after someone drove into him and then left, and it was a couple of hundred extra the next year. But then then extra amount reduced quickly.

Worth noting that you can sometimes reduce your policy cost by having a good driver added as an additional occasional driver. We added my mum (retired) and it brought it down by £70.

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:55

Is it usually cheaper to go to a garage not used by your insurer? With the one the insurer is recommending she will have to pay £600 excess and it’s probably cheaper to just get a quote from another garage isn’t it

OP posts:
dolol · 05/07/2023 21:54

mellicauli · 05/07/2023 21:52

Mt husband had the same issue coming out of our drive. Other driver admitted they were at fault. They were speeding. They signed a piece of paper to that effect. DH were inching out as visibility blocked by parked cars. Insurance company found in their favour.

Gosh

OP posts:
Rosietheravisher · 05/07/2023 21:53

Your sister is Car B, isn't she?

mellicauli · 05/07/2023 21:52

Mt husband had the same issue coming out of our drive. Other driver admitted they were at fault. They were speeding. They signed a piece of paper to that effect. DH were inching out as visibility blocked by parked cars. Insurance company found in their favour.

Soapyspuds · 05/07/2023 21:49

Car B will be at fault

Speed of car A is not taken into account
The fact visibility was difficult is not taken into account.

If you do not have clear visibility out of a parking space then the driver could find somebody half sensible looking and ask to be guided out verbally.

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:47

sandyhappypeople · 05/07/2023 21:45

Tell her she DOES NOT have to use the garage that the insurance recommends for her car repair (if she decides to get it repaired), she can go anywhere she chooses as long as they'll give her a written quote first. It wouldn't hurt to ring around if she's a bit hard up.

Thank you, I daresay it will be cheaper for her to get some more quotes before letting the garage that the insurer recommends fix it

OP posts:
Ophy83 · 05/07/2023 21:46

Both are at fault so likeliest outcome is a split of liability. In original statement you said she collided with car A which suggests she was moving even if slowly. However you suggest she was keeping a proper lookout and only creeping out. Car A should be driving sufficiently slowly and also keeping a lookout for people pulling out. The car park may have CCTV which would assist. Initially both sides pay their own excess, insurers work out fault and will pay repairs etc. If they can't agree on liability and no one was injured it goes to a small claims trial.

sandyhappypeople · 05/07/2023 21:45

Tell her she DOES NOT have to use the garage that the insurance recommends for her car repair (if she decides to get it repaired), she can go anywhere she chooses as long as they'll give her a written quote first. It wouldn't hurt to ring around if she's a bit hard up.

BamBamBambi · 05/07/2023 21:44

She will still need to declare the she’s had a claim made against her at her renewal.

BennyBlancofromtheBronx · 05/07/2023 21:44

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:42

Got you, thanks. I didn’t know they would reimburse them without her paying anything excess wise

What? That's the whole point of third party insurance (which is the legal minimum cover).

Mumtothreegirlies · 05/07/2023 21:43

Car B as car A had right of way. If car A was going dramatically over the speed limit then possibly 50/50.
I had a car pull out on me in a car park and they were found at fault by the insurance company.

Waitingforsummer75 · 05/07/2023 21:42

She only has to pay £600 if the damage costs more than that to repair. If it's £200 she'll just pay £200, but then she won't claim for her damage. Next step is to get a quote, as she's already contacted her insurance company, then she can decide whether to get the paintwork repaired or just live with it.

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:42

BennyBlancofromtheBronx · 05/07/2023 21:42

Your sister's insurer will reimburse the other driver's insurer.

Got you, thanks. I didn’t know they would reimburse them without her paying anything excess wise

OP posts:
tweener · 05/07/2023 21:42

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:40

Who would cover the other cars insurance if she didn’t pay any excess?

If she's found to be at fault she has two options, 1) pay her excess and get her car fixed while her insurance funds repairs on the other car. 2) don't pay her excess so don't get her car repaired. Her insurance will still be funding the other cars repairs and it will still be a claim against her.

BennyBlancofromtheBronx · 05/07/2023 21:42

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:40

Who would cover the other cars insurance if she didn’t pay any excess?

Your sister's insurer will reimburse the other driver's insurer.

sandyhappypeople · 05/07/2023 21:41

Quz · 05/07/2023 21:38

Two things that don't seem to be getting picked up on here. Assuming your sister (Car B?) really was just a bit out and stopped, Car A had to be driving a lot closer to the parked cars than they should have been. If that was the case, if they noticed Car B, but too late to completely avoid a collision, they certainly could have begun to turn away from the parked cars, but not soon enough to avoid part of the car hitting Car B. If the damage to car B is on the outside edge of the driver's side headlight, this is the most likely case. You said "right side" but I have no idea if that means right side looking at the car, or right side from the drivers perspective. I would think that an accident investigator would be able to tell this by the placement and direction of dents/paint scratches.

You could be right but I think you're overestimating just how much insurance companies 'investigate' .. they're absolutely useless. If there's no police involvement (obviously not for a fender bender) they will choose the path of least resistance and find the person 'not giving way' at fault without considering anything else.

SofiaSoFar · 05/07/2023 21:41

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:40

Who would cover the other cars insurance if she didn’t pay any excess?

If your sister is found to be at fault her insurance will pay the 3rd party's costs.

Her excess is nothing to do with 3rd party claims, though.

Dunnoburt · 05/07/2023 21:41

Car B St fault......Car A had right of way

TattoedLady · 05/07/2023 21:40

Car B is at fault.

They were stationary but moved from a parked position without full visibility into the side of a car that has right of way. Hitting the side of Car A indicates that Car B was moving into Car A at the time of the collision (however slowly).

Car B is at fault.

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:40

SofiaSoFar · 05/07/2023 21:38

It will be right, yes.

But, as I said above, she doesn't need to pay the excess at all if she doesn't claim for her own damage even if she's found to be entirely at fault.

Who would cover the other cars insurance if she didn’t pay any excess?

OP posts:
missmollygreen · 05/07/2023 21:39

Its not guess work, if car A claims on her insurance, her premium will 100% go up, that is how insurance works. Especially as a new driver

BamBamBambi · 05/07/2023 21:39

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:37

Her excess is £600 and the insurer have said that she will need to pay that to the garage for the repairs… what?! It’s only paintwork. Surely that can’t be right?

B is at fault.

How many panels did she hit?

of course it could be be £699 and It could be over £600…. It’s a skilled job painting a car.. they don’t just get a roller brush out 🤣

SofiaSoFar · 05/07/2023 21:38

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:37

Her excess is £600 and the insurer have said that she will need to pay that to the garage for the repairs… what?! It’s only paintwork. Surely that can’t be right?

It will be right, yes.

But, as I said above, she doesn't need to pay the excess at all if she doesn't claim for her own damage even if she's found to be entirely at fault.

Quz · 05/07/2023 21:38

Two things that don't seem to be getting picked up on here. Assuming your sister (Car B?) really was just a bit out and stopped, Car A had to be driving a lot closer to the parked cars than they should have been. If that was the case, if they noticed Car B, but too late to completely avoid a collision, they certainly could have begun to turn away from the parked cars, but not soon enough to avoid part of the car hitting Car B. If the damage to car B is on the outside edge of the driver's side headlight, this is the most likely case. You said "right side" but I have no idea if that means right side looking at the car, or right side from the drivers perspective. I would think that an accident investigator would be able to tell this by the placement and direction of dents/paint scratches.

Swipe left for the next trending thread