Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car park collision, who at fault?

160 replies

dolol · 05/07/2023 20:34

Sister had a collision this morning and wants to know who will be deemed as at fault

Car A driving along the car park row in a straight line, likely slightly too fast

Car B has reversed parked in the space. Is about to drive off, having done all observations. Crawls forward slightly to check left and right as visibility obscured by big vehicle parked to the left.

Car B (bonnet only a few inches out of the bay) collides with Car A who was doing some speed. MPH limit in car park when checked retrospectively was 5mph

All occupants fine but damage to the side door of Car A
Car B has paintwork damage near the headlight which will need buffing out and probably a new lower splitter

YABU - Car A at fault

YANBU - Car B at fault

Or possibly 50/50 fault? If 50/50 fault who would pay the excess? Thanks so much :)

OP posts:
mum11970 · 05/07/2023 23:57

An insurance company will have a list of garages who they recommend in the area but you have the legal right to choose your repairer. You can’t choose who the other party uses though.

mum11970 · 05/07/2023 23:46

Sorry, I know what you mean now. A splitter will probably be £100-200 and labour charges of about £60 ph, if not more. Then there is the paintwork to deal with.

FloydPepper · 05/07/2023 23:44

Jessbow · 05/07/2023 22:38

So when you sister pulled forward, having done all her checks, why did she pull out in front of a car coming along the car park, not only oming along the car park, but doing so faster than they should have been?

I'm sure she'll say she didnt see it coming, in which case she is in no position to judge what speed it was doing. Why assume it was exceding the speed restriction?
She either saw it coming or she didnt

Yep

the car she didn’t see but could see was going too fast drove sideways into the front of her stationary car

BadLad · 05/07/2023 23:39

OP, you seem to be misunderstanding what excess actually means.

If you take out an insurance policy with £300 excess and cause damage to your own vehicle, you will have to pay the first £300 yourself. So if you had a crash which was your fault and the repairs to your car cost £500, your insurers would only pay £200. If the repairs cost less that £300, you would have to stump up the whole cost yourself.

Your excess has nothing to do with damage to other people’s cars. If you are at fault for an accident, your insurers will cover the entire cost of the other driver’s repairs. You won’t have to pay for it, but your insurance will likely be more expensive when you come to renew it.

Insurance covering damage to other drivers vehicles is required by law. This is to prevent people from causing a crash and then saying they can’t afford to pay for the other party’s repairs. There is no obligation to have insurance to cover traits to your own vehicle.

SparklingDrink · 05/07/2023 23:38

BennyBlancofromtheBronx · 05/07/2023 20:40

Speed is very rarely counted as negligence (and casual observers often get speeds way out). And no insurer is going to spend money on having the speed in a car park calculated when one party failed to give way.

Darn woman speeding in a car park , as I was coming out of a road, bumped me. Or I bumped her.
I was blamed, yet she wasn’t there when I started moving, bloody woman, was also smoking.
She wouldn’t stop to exchange details, said she had no damage, but came looking for me the next day, and decided she did have damage. Sadly you will be classed as at fault.

dolol · 05/07/2023 23:37

mum11970 · 05/07/2023 23:35

If it needs a new spoiler it will probably be way over £600

Sorry, splitter? Lower splitter. The band of rubber/plastic underneath the bumper at the front

OP posts:
mum11970 · 05/07/2023 23:35

dolol · 05/07/2023 23:23

Having googled it looks like she will need scratches buffing out and a new lower splitter. I don’t think that would be £600. I don’t know why the insurer thinks she should pay a 600 excess to a garage literally miles away from where she lives, it’s in the next county for goodness sake! She said the other party had a company car so were wanting to go through the company insurance for it

If it needs a new spoiler it will probably be way over £600

sandyhappypeople · 05/07/2023 23:33

neilyoungismyhero · 05/07/2023 23:10

Personally I would think it's knock for knock..IF she was emerging v. slowly because of reduced visibility ie large vehicle next to her impeding her view and IF the other vehicle was going at speed it's 50/50 surely? How else was B supposed to exit her space other than v slowly emerging? If I was B I would be pressing my case.

insurance companies don't give a toss unfortunately, they just blame the person that doesn't 'give way'.

I had one a few years ago, pulling out onto a 70mph dual carriageway from a t junction, into an empty inside lane (great visibility, a few cars in outside lane, nothing in inside lane), as I went a car slammed into me and then flew off the road. He had been racing another car and they had been bullying people out the way for miles apparently, he was in the outside lane, but swerved to undertake the cars in front just as I pulled out, he had braked but he was still doing over 100mph when he hit me, it's very lucky we weren't both killed.

The insurance were horrific, he told them he was trundling along on the inside lane doing 70 and I just pulled out, so they immediately found against me without looking at any of the evidence I provided and they then 'lost' the three witness details I provided and said they never had them, they just said I was at a give way and should have given way. The was a police crash investigation, witnesses, a court case against the driver for dangerous driving, and all the while them fucktards from Hastings Direct wouldn't listen to any of it, they did eventually but good god it was an ordeal!

Insurance companies will always take the path of least resistance.

SofiaSoFar · 05/07/2023 23:28

don’t know why the insurer thinks she should pay a 600 excess to a garage literally miles away from where she lives, it’s in the next county for goodness sake!

It will be an "approved repairer" of theirs., that's all. You're not obliged to use them but the insurer will try to push it.

Regarding them saying she'd need to pay the £600 to them, they'd be talking generally and assuming it's more in value of damage than the excess.

dolol · 05/07/2023 23:23

SofiaSoFar · 05/07/2023 23:19

This is bollocks.

Completely wrong, so best to completely ignore.

Having googled it looks like she will need scratches buffing out and a new lower splitter. I don’t think that would be £600. I don’t know why the insurer thinks she should pay a 600 excess to a garage literally miles away from where she lives, it’s in the next county for goodness sake! She said the other party had a company car so were wanting to go through the company insurance for it

OP posts:
SofiaSoFar · 05/07/2023 23:19

HaveSomeIntrospect · 05/07/2023 22:48

She will have to pay the £600 anyway. It is the excess in the cost of the claim in it’s entirety, your sisters and the other driver’s if your sister is found to be at fault and the insurer pays out against your sister

This is bollocks.

Completely wrong, so best to completely ignore.

BranchGold · 05/07/2023 23:16

Not to kick your sister when she’s down, but it’s worth letting her know, and everyone really, to only have an ‘affordable’ excess on your car insurance.

I see the sliding scale on the comparison sites offering £1k excess coverage, but it’s only worth going for if you know you can get your hands on a grand at short notice.

neilyoungismyhero · 05/07/2023 23:10

Personally I would think it's knock for knock..IF she was emerging v. slowly because of reduced visibility ie large vehicle next to her impeding her view and IF the other vehicle was going at speed it's 50/50 surely? How else was B supposed to exit her space other than v slowly emerging? If I was B I would be pressing my case.

youhadmeatsausageroll · 05/07/2023 23:09

k1233 · 05/07/2023 22:12

And that is why you don't reverse into car parks - people have no warning you are about to exit vs if you are reversing out they see your reversing lights and brake lights so know to take care. Same for pedestrians.

This makes zero sense

Fernbreeze · 05/07/2023 23:07

k1233 · 05/07/2023 22:12

And that is why you don't reverse into car parks - people have no warning you are about to exit vs if you are reversing out they see your reversing lights and brake lights so know to take care. Same for pedestrians.

What the hell are you talking about? Most companies and businesses including virtually all construction have a rule that all parking must be done with reverse parking as it's the safest method to park.

Sorry but your utterly wrong.

Rufus27 · 05/07/2023 23:07

Happened to me. I was car A, but I wasn’t speeding (I was hardly moving). Car B admitted they were at fault so they paid to repair the damage (four figure sum).

Anothnamechang · 05/07/2023 23:00

Also, my excess was deducted from a final payout- the fault claim made my car a write off due to the age of the car etc.

Anothnamechang · 05/07/2023 22:59

I’ve had two accidents, one fault and one non fault. My premium actually went down the next year when I added the fault claim! Insurance varies so much. With you saying there’s damage to the side of car A- do you mean car A has scraped past Car B when they had stopped? That’s the only perspective I can see it not being fault on Car B’s part?

MrsHaaland · 05/07/2023 22:56

Dash cams can be so cheap these days, I would never be without one as you never know when you may need it to prove what actually happened.

sandyhappypeople · 05/07/2023 22:55

HaveSomeIntrospect · 05/07/2023 22:48

She will have to pay the £600 anyway. It is the excess in the cost of the claim in it’s entirety, your sisters and the other driver’s if your sister is found to be at fault and the insurer pays out against your sister

no she won't. That's what the insurance is for. You only pay excess on your own claim (if you decide to claim)

Lucyintheskywithadiamond · 05/07/2023 22:53

If the damage is on the other cars door it will class as a fault accident on your sisters policy as this will show she has driven in to the car.

she will not have to pay her excess if she does not claim for her own car but it will be logged as a claim on her policy.

you say the car was speeding, that would be very hard to prove.

the post about not to reverse in to a parking is incorrect, it is much safer

sandyhappypeople · 05/07/2023 22:52

ClearConfusion · 05/07/2023 22:34

You may find that no one is at fault, as you are not on a road, and the land is privately owned. I only mention this because of an incident when my youngest son was two. I was in Morrison’s supermarket car park, just undoing his pushchair straps when a speeding car, skidded into us. The side of car hit the pushchair and the front hit me. There was three police cars, two fire engines and an ambulance in attendance. My son had to be cut out of his pushchair by firefighters, I was wedged against the door which broke off and I fell to the ground. The police said they couldn’t do anything about it, as it wasn’t an offence, as she wasn’t on a road, it was private land. The woman never even apologised, she just stuck her head in the ambulance and said I don’t know why everyone’s upset, he’s not dead!! She nearly killed my toddler, but it wasn’t a crime.

That's horrific! Was he okay? did you try and pursue her through civil court?

I've read about this sort of thing before where the police can't do anything for motoring offences as it's on private land, I don't think that matters from an insurance/damage/injury point of view though.

Repts · 05/07/2023 22:50

You're better off not going through insurances sometimes - if you all get quotes on how much it'll cost to repair, and if it's cheaper than the £600 excess, then all can avoid insurance companies. The other driver, in theory, wouldn't want to go through insurance either as even if they're not at fault, it will still affect their no claims bonus, so it usually works for both parties if they avoid insurance companies altogether and you just sign something to say that no one can come for more money etc.

Florenz · 05/07/2023 22:48

If it goes to the insurance, it will almost certainly go 50/50. Collisions in car parks usually do unless one party is very clearly entirely at fault.

HaveSomeIntrospect · 05/07/2023 22:48

She will have to pay the £600 anyway. It is the excess in the cost of the claim in it’s entirety, your sisters and the other driver’s if your sister is found to be at fault and the insurer pays out against your sister