Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car park collision, who at fault?

160 replies

dolol · 05/07/2023 20:34

Sister had a collision this morning and wants to know who will be deemed as at fault

Car A driving along the car park row in a straight line, likely slightly too fast

Car B has reversed parked in the space. Is about to drive off, having done all observations. Crawls forward slightly to check left and right as visibility obscured by big vehicle parked to the left.

Car B (bonnet only a few inches out of the bay) collides with Car A who was doing some speed. MPH limit in car park when checked retrospectively was 5mph

All occupants fine but damage to the side door of Car A
Car B has paintwork damage near the headlight which will need buffing out and probably a new lower splitter

YABU - Car A at fault

YANBU - Car B at fault

Or possibly 50/50 fault? If 50/50 fault who would pay the excess? Thanks so much :)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SofiaSoFar · 07/07/2023 22:38

It's possibly worth noting that "dual carriageway" doesn't mean "2 lanes in each direction". There could be 1, 2, 3 or even more in each direction.

sandyhappypeople · 07/07/2023 18:27

Fightyouforthatpie · 07/07/2023 16:26

You think entering lane one of a dual carriageway doing a very slow speed with vehicles approaching in lane 2 at 70 is OK, and it's the same as a motorway slip road? Ok then.

I like how you presume to know what I think 😀 who said it was the same? I said the same rules apply, except in one you build up speed before you join and the other you build up speed after you join. You don’t have to wait for the whole road to be clear of cars, that’s not how they’re designed to be used.

t junctions on dual carriageways are in fact horrible, and I think stretches of roads that have them should be limited to 50mph, but I don’t design the roads or junctions.

Unfortunately there’s quite a few of them round here.

Fightyouforthatpie · 07/07/2023 16:26

sandyhappypeople · 07/07/2023 15:35

Same rules apply when joining a multi lane road from a sliproad or junction, except you need to allow extra room to build up speed.

You think entering lane one of a dual carriageway doing a very slow speed with vehicles approaching in lane 2 at 70 is OK, and it's the same as a motorway slip road? Ok then.

pilates · 07/07/2023 16:18

Car B

Countdowntowinter · 07/07/2023 16:09

Witnesses are very important. Either driver can say what they want and their perspective may be quite different. I witnessed a straight forward car knock and the driver of the car at fault still argued it right to point of court. I was asked to attend. It was cancelled on the day. I think they were testing if any witnesses would actually attend (I had already given witness statements which they had seen).

Some fight all the way even though at fault.

sandyhappypeople · 07/07/2023 15:35

Fightyouforthatpie · 07/07/2023 15:26

You said it was a T junction so nothing like joining a motorway.

Same rules apply when joining a multi lane road from a sliproad or junction, except you need to allow extra room to build up speed.

Aprilx · 07/07/2023 15:31

dolol · 05/07/2023 20:37

Even if they are saying they were stationary?

They couldn't have been stationary if they hit the other car on the side. If they were stationary but sticking out, the other car would have hit them on the front.

Fightyouforthatpie · 07/07/2023 15:26

sandyhappypeople · 07/07/2023 15:19

The police and courts have disagreed in this instance.

Joining a multi lane road isn't the same as a normal road, you only have to make sure your lane is clear (or suitable gap) to go, and obviously care and attention to make sure no one is actively indicating to come over. How would you ever join a motorway for instance? You can't wait for the entire road to clear.

I actually waited for the inside lane to be completely clear. The fact that the other driver was speeding at 120mph plus and decided to swerve over to illegally undertake 'slower moving' (70mph traffic) while racing another puts the blame for the collision firmly at his door, it wouldn't have made us any less dead given the right circumstances, but there is nothing I could have done different.

But thank you for taking the time to give me your opinion.

You said it was a T junction so nothing like joining a motorway.

sandyhappypeople · 07/07/2023 15:19

Fightyouforthatpie · 07/07/2023 09:02

You pulled out onto a 70mph dual carriageway when you could clearly see vehicles approaching? You were 100% to blame, you can't just assume vehicles in one lane won't switch to the other, that's nuts.

The police and courts have disagreed in this instance.

Joining a multi lane road isn't the same as a normal road, you only have to make sure your lane is clear (or suitable gap) to go, and obviously care and attention to make sure no one is actively indicating to come over. How would you ever join a motorway for instance? You can't wait for the entire road to clear.

I actually waited for the inside lane to be completely clear. The fact that the other driver was speeding at 120mph plus and decided to swerve over to illegally undertake 'slower moving' (70mph traffic) while racing another puts the blame for the collision firmly at his door, it wouldn't have made us any less dead given the right circumstances, but there is nothing I could have done different.

But thank you for taking the time to give me your opinion.

Fightyouforthatpie · 07/07/2023 09:02

sandyhappypeople · 05/07/2023 23:33

insurance companies don't give a toss unfortunately, they just blame the person that doesn't 'give way'.

I had one a few years ago, pulling out onto a 70mph dual carriageway from a t junction, into an empty inside lane (great visibility, a few cars in outside lane, nothing in inside lane), as I went a car slammed into me and then flew off the road. He had been racing another car and they had been bullying people out the way for miles apparently, he was in the outside lane, but swerved to undertake the cars in front just as I pulled out, he had braked but he was still doing over 100mph when he hit me, it's very lucky we weren't both killed.

The insurance were horrific, he told them he was trundling along on the inside lane doing 70 and I just pulled out, so they immediately found against me without looking at any of the evidence I provided and they then 'lost' the three witness details I provided and said they never had them, they just said I was at a give way and should have given way. The was a police crash investigation, witnesses, a court case against the driver for dangerous driving, and all the while them fucktards from Hastings Direct wouldn't listen to any of it, they did eventually but good god it was an ordeal!

Insurance companies will always take the path of least resistance.

You pulled out onto a 70mph dual carriageway when you could clearly see vehicles approaching? You were 100% to blame, you can't just assume vehicles in one lane won't switch to the other, that's nuts.

SofiaSoFar · 07/07/2023 08:53

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/07/2023 15:19

You can't say that for certain as there are loads of different factors to consider.

I had a 50/50 accident in my first year of driving, claimed a 4-figure sum and my insurance still went down the following year.

Absolutely this. There are so many factors that determine the price of a policy that it's impossible to know what will happen.

People on MN love to post their opinion as if it's fact. It makes it a waste of time for people asking advice.

whynotwhatknot · 06/07/2023 15:28

noone can tell for sure thats the problem everyting is different with each crash and the insurance companies

she might aswell get some quote for her own damage though

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 06/07/2023 15:19

princesscaraboo · 06/07/2023 11:36

Yeah it will. Even if she doesn't claim, as soon as the insurance company find out about the accident then her premiums will rise. Also, if she doesn't contact the insurance company and the other party does then her insurance company may cancel the policy as you have to inform them.

You can't say that for certain as there are loads of different factors to consider.

I had a 50/50 accident in my first year of driving, claimed a 4-figure sum and my insurance still went down the following year.

BashfulClam · 06/07/2023 12:02

SofiaSoFar · 06/07/2023 11:00

Having a claim increases the premium even if not at fault.

I wish people would stop staying stuff like this as if it's fact. There is absolutely zero that's guaranteed about what will happen with the next policy.

DD was run into at a junction a couple of years ago and the next year her policy was cheaper.

No one can say for sure what will happen after a claim.

Ours went up after a no fault claim. An animal caused an accident as someone hit it and other cars swerved etc. We only had very minor damage but it cost £700 to fix (we paid £300 excess). Our premium went up and we still had £400 increase even switching companies via comparison sites.

princesscaraboo · 06/07/2023 11:36

dolol · 05/07/2023 21:25

She’s really worried the premiums will go up by hundreds of pounds.

Yeah it will. Even if she doesn't claim, as soon as the insurance company find out about the accident then her premiums will rise. Also, if she doesn't contact the insurance company and the other party does then her insurance company may cancel the policy as you have to inform them.

dolol · 06/07/2023 11:30

SofiaSoFar · 06/07/2023 11:00

Having a claim increases the premium even if not at fault.

I wish people would stop staying stuff like this as if it's fact. There is absolutely zero that's guaranteed about what will happen with the next policy.

DD was run into at a junction a couple of years ago and the next year her policy was cheaper.

No one can say for sure what will happen after a claim.

Thank you, I hope this is the case for my sister. I’ve tried to help as much as I can but not a financial stress she needs right now

OP posts:
Meeting · 06/07/2023 11:04

dolol · 05/07/2023 23:23

Having googled it looks like she will need scratches buffing out and a new lower splitter. I don’t think that would be £600. I don’t know why the insurer thinks she should pay a 600 excess to a garage literally miles away from where she lives, it’s in the next county for goodness sake! She said the other party had a company car so were wanting to go through the company insurance for it

With all due respect OP, you obviously know very little about cars and it's not possible to diagnose what needs to be done to the car with a Google search. You have to check the structural integrity of what's underneath.

I had a car written off in my teens and by looking at it you'd have thought it just needed a new bumper.

SofiaSoFar · 06/07/2023 11:00

Having a claim increases the premium even if not at fault.

I wish people would stop staying stuff like this as if it's fact. There is absolutely zero that's guaranteed about what will happen with the next policy.

DD was run into at a junction a couple of years ago and the next year her policy was cheaper.

No one can say for sure what will happen after a claim.

Shade17 · 06/07/2023 10:26

Car B can argue A was speeding

I think she’d struggle with that anyway as there’s no speed limit in a public car park. You might see 5mph signs but that’s a request and nothing more.

Nordicrain · 06/07/2023 09:37

Car B.

lou9393 · 06/07/2023 09:36

I'm in agreement with @BungleandGeorge, car repair costs can be massive for something that looks like it'll just "buff out". If a new splitter is needed, depending on the make of the car, this can genuinely be hundreds of pounds alone, it may even need a new door so repairs would easily go above the £600 excess (I've worked in car bodyshops for the past 10 years). Also if it's a company car it may likely be a newish car on lease so the third party (sounding like they are non-fault) are likely only to accept perfection otherwise they'll be penalised when the car goes back off lease, it's common place for this incident to go through insurance. Completely agree with PP's though to see if the third party are happy to take the car to a few garages for them to assess and advise. The insurer will push for the third party to go to their approved repairer as they will be on lower labour/paint rates meaning more money in the insurance companies pocket, however at the end of the day it sounds like your sis is at fault and no doubt the third party will go to nearest approved repairer to save them time and hassle.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 06/07/2023 08:18

SofiaSoFar · 05/07/2023 21:35

As usual on MN there's lots of guess work and incorrect assertions when it comes to anything vehicle related.

Your sister doesn't have pay the excess if she doesn't claim for her own damage, regardless of who's found at fault.

Anyone telling you differently is wrong.

If she only has minor scratches that she's either not bothered about or could repair very easily, it may make sense to not claim herself.

No one can say for sure what will happen to her premium next year. It may be loaded but there's no guarantee of that.

But she’ll have to put a claim in as the third party’s insurers will expect to be reimbursed by hers, given she’s almost certainly at blame. She can chose not to have her car fixed, and not pay the excess. But that’s unlikely to change the impact on her premium much as the bulk of the claim is, I suspect, third party costs.

BungleandGeorge · 06/07/2023 00:16

I think you’re totally underestimating the cost of car repairs! If she hit the side of the other vehicle she is unequivocally at fault. Having a claim increases the premium even if not at fault. Presuming the side is dented it will probably mean replacing the door and re spraying half the car and will be far more than the cost of her increased premium though

MrsRandom123 · 06/07/2023 00:11

Car B is at fault (your sister?) regardless of the speed A was going car b tried to come
out when the road wasn’t clear. Car A was already on the “main road” & the damage is to the side of Car A which aligns with B pulling out and hitting her.

Car B can argue A was speeding which A can deny as whether they were or weren’t speeding B shouldn’t have come out when it wasn’t clear to do so and i don’t think As insurance would accept 50/50 in that instance and will push for liability on Bs side so it’s B out of pocket on excess and potential no claims strike.

Maryandherlamb · 06/07/2023 00:02

In my experience, if both cars are moving it'll be a 50-50 fault (regardless of who was actually at fault). I've known of a few similar instances and they all had the same outcome.

Swipe left for the next trending thread